News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by heckerhut on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:46AM (#25881025)
Read Debt by Graeber so you can stop believing in the myth of barter. Then think again.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by gorgoiler on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:52AM (#25881060)
Thank you for the reference, and I look forward to understanding what you mean by myth.

Barter is literally my life. I teach other people’s children about life and Computer Science in order to buy potatoes. The children’s parents make medicine and build houses to pay for their children’s education. Is your point that barter is about goods, whereas most people provide services (time, labour?)

Or perhaps you mean that the majority of the economy in terms of wealth is engaged in the investment of capital, and we potato eaters are but a percentage of a percentage?

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 317070 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:00AM (#25881106)
With barter is meant (in the context of Graeber's book) trading tit for tat, without having a currency to go between. E.g. a farmer buying a book and paying with apples.

The book says that this barter method is almost never used, and instead people tend to keep track of favors and things they owe in a more vague way. And every now and then, these debts are settled in a communal fashion. But barter is not used.

So the farmer just asks for the book and gets it. And when autumn comes, and the bookstore owner feels like having an apple, he just goes to the farmer and asks for some. But the two transactions are not really linked.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by gorgoiler on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:21AM (#25881214)
Right. I feel like that’s nit picking (your parent; not you.)

Of course I (teacher) don’t buy potatoes by teaching the farmer’s children Dijkstra.

Instead of bartering we chooses to track our debts. Using Bitcoin as a cryptographically secure distributed debt tracker sounds great.

But Bitcoin right now feels like a bunch of technology enthusiasts have blessed the world with such a debt tracker while also saying ”btw you collectively owe us $630,000,000,000 worth of stuff”.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 317070 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:37AM (#25881281)
Also, this digital debt tracker uses numbers, which most of these communal debt systems do not do. Because different people put different value to things, tracking debt in numbers is not how it is done (the book goes in a lot of detail how this works). This is what makes bitcoin a currency, a way to track debts rather than having them implicit.

I'm not sure where on the globe you are at, but where I am from, groups of friends buy rounds of beers at the bar. You do not keep track of whose turn it is to pay the round or whether someone is buying more expensive stuff, but since you are friends you make sure things are fair over time. But implicitly, not tracking numbers and accounts.

And Graeber argues that that is actually the method that predates currency. Not barter.

I fully agree on the hilariously large "primordial" debt we somehow owe the early miners.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by pharmakom on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:41AM (#25881302)
Bitcoin does not track debt, it tracks Bitcoin assets.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by Kinrany on Saturday January 23, 2021 @05:01AM (#25881118)
I'm not sure it's relevant, although the book is fantastic.

The first few chapters show that historically money predates barter, not the other way around. And that money was born as "I owe you" notes issued by the government.

I know of only one comment [1] Graeber made about bitcoin, and it's too late to ask him now.

[1]: https://twitter.com/davidgraeber/status/990857460176089088

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by heckerhut on Saturday January 30, 2021 @07:58AM (#25968688)
Thanks you expressed it much better than I did.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by forgotmypw77 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:49AM (#25881039)
i don,t think it is a myth, i do it all the time, living almost entirely without currency.

digital technology only makes barter more easy and accessible.

converting every trade into numbers and back is an outmoded method, which i think will become less used with time.

Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 317070 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:56AM (#25881086)
That is basically what the book is telling. You are probably not tit-for-tat bartering, but taking on debts and returning things you owe in some more vague approach. History went through multiple cycles where currency went in disuse in favor of just tracking and settling debts.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by forgotmypw77 on Saturday January 23, 2021 @07:57PM (#25887705)
actually, i,m gifting without asking for anything in return. when i need something, it is offered or i ask.
Re:Bitcoin Core Lead Maintainer Steps Back, Encourages Decen... by 317070 on Monday January 25, 2021 @11:44AM (#25905278)
Exactly, that is the alternative system which was the default. It has gone through a number of cycles in history and is not always thought of the same way across different cultures (which is why there is a whole book on the topic).

But it is a recurring theme in history, and most (all?) monetary systems were traded for this alternative within 1000 years. For me, in Western Europe, this was 500 years ago between roughly 1000-1500. The churches were fitted with gold roofs, and because of the lack of coinage and currency, most people lived their lives with this alternative approach, only rarely coming across money, currency, accounting and debt.