When I use (for example) Vultr cloud compute (https://www.vultr.com/), I load my Vultr account with $10 via credit card. Once the money enters the account it remains there until it is spent
Then I pay 1 or 2 cents each hour for a cloud instance. At the end of each month, Vultr tells we what's due if I exceed what remains in the account. If necessary I load more money in
This kind of simple micropayment scheme (with a trusted entity holding upfront credit card payments) is widely implemented
If you are willing to trust an intermediary (and most people are) then distributed ledgers (blockchains) are unnecessary
The benefit of Bitcoin (or blockchains generally) is that you don't need to trust anyone. In 2009 this was considered important, but today, does anyone care?
No
Micro transactions to a range of different independent businesses requires using existing payment networks (visa / MasterCard / etc: relatively expensive; crypto: lack of widespread adoption) or building a new payment network.
> If you are willing to trust an intermediary (and most people are)
We already do. It’s called the bank. We also have regulation that helps. How many people keep real money in their personal PayPal accounts? How many people can even afford to?
EDIT: I retract my Vultr / Starbucks equivalence.
> At the end of each month, Vultr tells we what's due if I exceed what remains in the account. If necessary I load more money in
Starbucks will not let your spend exceed your deposits on your card. Your statement suggests Vultr will. Credit accounts are a whole other risk. What happens if you don’t pay off your balance after you’ve already consumed the service?
The difference is due at the end of the month. If I didn't pay, they would simply charge the last credit card I used to load the account (I suppose)
Another example: Linode (https://www.linode.com/) charges my credit card at the end of each month, to cover my usage. So a $5 cloud instance isn't paid for until the month ends. The point is to aggregate a whole month of spending into a single credit card payment
I dont see how this is any less relevant today than it was 12 years ago.
Compare a tangible market situation: remember the old Bazooka gum that used to say "3 cents" on each piece? Few customers are going to walk into a store and buy a single piece, no matter how cheap and frictionless payment is. At that level, the burden of thinking "I have to actually go and buy it" exceeds both the financial cost and likely the perceived upside of a single bite of gum. You can successfully sell a handful alongside another transaction, or a bag of them for a dollar, though, because you've raised the stakes of the total transaction high enough that it's worth thinking it through.
Maybe the classic micropayment story-- the individual news article/video view/song play-- is a single piece of Bazooka. Since it's likely to be ephemeral and competing with a nearly-as-good free alternative (the same content on an ad-based site), you don't have much room to make the case that it's worth going through a purchase process.
The challenge is probably mostly that a lot of publishers would need to get together and create a unified account that could be charged.
Hilariously BTC had this problem solved from day one, then Blockstream hijacked the GitHub repo, kicked out all the original devs and artificially limited the block size to try and push people onto their own "second layer" products.
Why anyone would use LN rather than just real Bitcoin (now called Bitcoin Cash) is beyond me. They have lots of trolls (Adam Back) and social engineers (Greg Maxwell) pushing a false narrative but how real people fall for it is still just bizarre.
The problem is that Lightning essentially is a subscription service. The user has to lock much more Bitcoin in a channel in order use Lightning for micro transactions, which defeats the purpose. The minimum fee to get a Bitcoin transaction confirmed in a reasonable amount of time is often over $20 USD at this point. That's a very large deposit for a $20 fee to be worth the effort.
They could deposit a smaller amount of Bitcoin in a custodial wallet, but at that point you might as well use a credit card or Paypal. It defeats the underlying appeal of Bitcoin, which is controlling your own money.
More people would have, and more importantly use, Bitcoin if it was allowed to scale on-chain. Why that hasn't happened yet is a different rabbit hole.
To give you an example, the withdraw fee for BTC on Kraken is 0.0005 BTC, which is currently about 17.50 USD.
Here is the current mempool: https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,24h
To get your transaction confirmed in the next few blocks, you have to be in the "yellow" of the chart, and use a fee of around 120 satoshi's per byte.
The average transaction is around 200 bytes, so you need to pay 24000 satoshis, which is 0.00024 BTC.
That's 8.40 USD right now. The problem is that it's a double blind auction, so to have a very high likelihood of getting into the next block, you often have to pay 200-400 satoshi's per byte, which puts you right up at the $20 level. If your transaction is larger, it can be significantly more.
Also, if the mempool gets even more backed up than it is right now, the fees can literally go as high as people are willing to pay when fighting over the restricted block space.
>You don't usually need a priority transaction when funding LN channel, so ~$1 fee will be enough.
If you try sending a Bitcoin transaction with a $1 fee right now it may not confirm for days and might confirm at all! That isn't a user experience that's going to create mass adoption. It needs to be an improvement on the existing options.
How, exactly, is my statement that the fees are often over $20 a lie?
You should stop accusing people of being liars without data to back it up. This forum is supposed to be for intelligent discussion, not trolling. This isn't twitter.
Why is a little bit of data exchange so expensive? (Ok because they can, so why aren't the competitors to drive that fee structure down? What's the barrier to entry?)
Any real users and devs moved to other project like Ethereum and Bitcoin Cash, now only trolls and bag holders keep pushing BTC as a "store of value", a totally meaningless concept.
The technical challenges of doing it with credit cards are overwhelming (in CC parlance, a "microtransaction" is anything under $10) due to fee structure.
You can simplify this by using a different payment rail (in my case, Lightning over Bitcoin), but now you have a different problem: nobody has Bitcoin.
You also need to add the lack of convincing incentive: since microtransactions don't yet exist, there's no proof that that's a market for them. That leap of faith is a significant barrier.