And I'm not bitching, I'm discussing.
When it suit these platforms, they claim that the opinions are of their users and not their own, yet when it otherwise suit them, they claim ownership.
Why? Hacker News, or Twitter, can say things for itself, and it can also host other people's opinions. There is no collision there. Twitter has Free Speech rights, and is responsible for, whatever it says itself. Twitter also has the Free Speech right to support, or not, anything it likes since it is in no way quasi-governmental. It doesn't owe anyone a soap box. And there is no reason it should be held liable for what users say, the users who say those things should be held liable.
>When it suit these platforms, they claim that the opinions are of their users and not their own
The law, and common sense as well is clear. Words of their users are not, in fact, theirs. The only thing regular law gives them is protection from not being completely perfect in their attempts at exercising their own Free Speech vs other people on their own property, rather than having to use Common Carrier all-or-nothing. But they could ban whomever they liked regardless.
>yet when it otherwise suit them, they claim ownership.
Specify. They own their own words and their own resources, and necessarily users must offer them at least a limited non-exclusive license for reproduction due to copyright. That is a fair tradeoff offer for what their users gain, and everyone may accept, or not.
Which ones "claim ownership" of other people's words and how? They don't need any ownership for bans, because nobody is entitled to their support.
Try reading the whole paragraph (emphasis added):
>particularly if they in some way are significantly making use of government power themselves (limited spectrum allocation for cellular carriers for example
Come on.
>Why should they allow literal Nazis to communicate over their infrastructure?
Because they're making use of a government granted monopoly on a physically limited common. They should in turn operate as common carriers.
Hmm, not always though. I use WiFi 99% of the time, including for voice calling, which isn't using any government-allocated cellular spectrum. So in my case, T-Mobile should be able to filter packets going through their servers and censor undesirable speech, right? Their servers, their ToS, right?
Also their government allocated bands don't change if you use "WiFi 99% of the time" they still have the monopoly.
As for packet filtering, that's Net Neutrality issue, which last time I checked the right was against and successfully allowed it (except for states that brought their own laws to replace it).
Other things are limited too. People's time and attention are limited, and the app stores have a pretty strong duopoly on those.
In theory you could print pamphlets and drop them door to door, but come on.
Sorry dude. You don't believe in free speech. You are contradicting yourself.
Nobody is forced to make a wedding cake with a long stream of racist invective like one of the examples Amazon suggested might fall foul of its AUP a month before all the Capitol fallout (and Parler replied that they absolutely wouldn't take down) and I think that's for the best.
But forcing people to make cakes they feel morally icky about sounds like a guaranteed way to get some really ugly, half-assed cakes. Whether we like it or not that they feel that way doesn't seem to matter because an ugly cake that validates me is still an ugly cake.
I don't know the details of the case but I think there is a clear line between refusing to do usual service because somebody is from a protected group. Like a ordinary wedding cake only because the person ordering is gay.
vs
Refusing to create a wedding cake because it is offensive. Like customer asking for a cake in a shape of penis or something offending the artist.
Those seem like fundamentally different moral scenarios.
You know, in Masterpiece Cakeshop, people treating them as religious nuts was a factor in why they didn’t have to do that.
I'm sorry for the caps but you and a host of others are forgetting something repeatedly and it's getting fairly annoying:
AMAZON HAS FREE SPEECH RIGHTS TOO.
Just as Parler does, and you do, and I do, and Twitter does, and the various owners and employees of these organizations do, and on and on. It's Free Speech all the way down. And a fundamental aspect of Free Speech isn't just the right to say something, it's necessarily the right to NOT say something, and to NOT provide material support against your will to speech you disagree with. If you or I or anyone else or any general organization decides to NOT provide help to someone else's speech, be it our own direct voice or access to our private property, that's not censorship that is itself Free Speech. They in turn have the right to complain, and to exercise their own freedom of association, and we may change our minds, or not, and others can chime in, and on and on forever. Free Speech is a system not an end goal, a constant churning that hopefully over long enough timescales will give us a better grasp of Truth.
When government uses force, that halts the system, and speech becomes frozen. History and present indicates that the bar for that, though not infinite, should be quite high. Some companies that truly have natural monopolies or exercise quasi-governmental power may fall into that too, particularly if they in some way are significantly making use of government power themselves (limited spectrum allocation for cellular carriers for example, or physical infrastructure companies making use of public rights of way). But social and economic censure is a fundamental aspect of the process of Free Speech. 3rd parties aren't some disembodied Other, they're entities that have the same rights as anyone else by default.