News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by kodah on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:59PM (#25853070)
The weird thing here is the consistent recommendation of corporate backed distributions. Debian has existed for quite some time without any need for a corporation. Are there problems? Yes, but Debian isn't going to suddenly announce that it's going to kill itself either. I would suggest getting involved in the Debian community (without trying to take it over), and making meaningful contributions.

If you don't like Debian, pick an open source distribution that is not backed by a business and begin sending the money you would've dumped into subscriptions as donations.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by tempfs on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:32PM (#25855040)
Honestly, I can't remember the last time I had Debian stable go wrong in any application[server,desktop,laptops or raspian]. I use it everywhere and it is pretty fantastic.

Despite Debian being phenomenal in many ways, it doesn't offer up a head for the chopping block to replace yours if things go wrong in a corporate application. Good luck getting IT folks to deploy anything that doesn't offer them an out.

Using CentOS knowing that it is downstream from RedHat but that RedHat would step up and fix things in a semi-timely manner was good enough for many enterprises....at least until IBM got involved.

Ubuntu is also a weird choice generally speaking because Ubuntu just uses Debian's testing repo as a base and really only significantly varies in the kernels that they roll for various products/services.[cloud,live patching,etc.] They used to maintain their own desktop[Unity] and service management[upstart] and a bunch more variances from Debian...but that ain't really the case today.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chaz6 on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:26AM (#25856718)
Debian was responsible for one of the, if not the, biggest security disasters in Linux distributions' history. A Debian developer thought they knew better than the OpenSSL developers and made a change that compromised every SSH and SSH private key you generated.

https://threatpost.com/how-debian-openssl-bug-almost-spawned...

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by kodah on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:14AM (#25857358)
I remember this bug. It was what made my interest in systems engineering soar. Unfortunately your characterization of it falls quite short.

Here's the mailing list email that inspired the bug:

https://marc.info/?l=openssl-dev&m=114651085826293&w=2

I kind of doubt that some guy that thinks he "knows better than the OpenSSL developers" is saying things like this on their mailing list:

> What I currently see as best option is to actually comment out those 2 lines of code. But I have no idea what effect this really has on the RNG. The only effect I see is that the pool might receive less entropy. But on the other hand, I'm not even sure how much entropy some unitialised data has.

The result was something like 32k sources of entropy which is not enough.

Here's the bug Kurt was trying to fix: https://bugs.debian.org/cgi-bin/bugreport.cgi?bug=363516

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by pabs3 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:46PM (#25855513)
Ubuntu is actually based on Debian unstable, they do their own QA rather than relying on the Debian's testing migration QA.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by JeremyNT on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:25PM (#25854990)
Debian is amazing, and sadly often overlooked.

I was always a little confused by how popular Ubuntu became. Canonical never did much to add value, often replacing more standard tools with strange canonical replacements that didn't survive the test of time.

If you use Ubuntu now, give Debian a try. The stability and community are really second to none. For all my personal use I run Arch, but I would not hesitate to run Debian in production instead of a commercial distribution.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by cstejerean on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:58PM (#25855224)
I’ve been using Ubuntu in some form since the first versions in 2004, and mostly sticking with LTS since 2006. What won me over in the early days was the clear versioning story with predictable cadence of releases and support intervals, pragmatic approach to proprietary drivers and video codecs, and the fact that server and desktop were the same distro.

By comparison I never fully understood the Debian versioning story. I have no idea when the next version will become stable, or how stale the versions are in stable, whether I could install it without driver issues on my desktop, etc.

With Ubuntu I could take a break for a few years and know there will be an LTS release in April or 2022, that the previous LTS release was 20.04, and 18.04 was the one before that, etc. That each will be supported for 5 years and so on.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by sjansen on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:24PM (#25855368)
In my opinion you've hit on Ubuntu's biggest contribution to Free and Open Source software.

When I started using Linux a couple decades ago, "we ship when it's ready" was the dominant FOSS approach, and I thought it was the most sensible approach.

Then I got my first job and experienced the realities of enterprise support and planning. Today I wish more projects were as predictable as Ubuntu, and I'm gratefully for every one that is.

Ubuntu is far from my favorite distro technically, but the predictability of its LTS releases makes it my recommendation for most uses.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by m463 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:53PM (#25855567)
I have to agree. The year.month scheme, and the predictability are things that make ubuntu easy to adopt for corporate users.

I think if debian augmented the toy story names with dates, that might help.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by krupan on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:40PM (#25855092)
When Ubuntu came out, Debian was notoriously difficult to install. The joke was that Ubuntu was the African word for, "can't install Debian."
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by jbverschoor on Thursday January 21, 2021 @12:22AM (#25855749)
I’ve never had any issues with installing Debian.

Before that I was on FreeBSD, and before that I was in Slackware. All were always fine

What does “difficult to install” even mean?

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by alrs on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:55AM (#25856555)
fighting with XF86Config, hoping not to fry your monitor.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by jbverschoor on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:35PM (#25863888)
Well, that was with any dist, and not really a Debian issue.

Besides, last time I ran a GUI on linux was probably over 20 years ago.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by alrs on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:31PM (#25865426)
What complicated it is that usually when you were coming to Debian you were coming from Slackware or a BSD, so everything you knew about init systems and software distribution went out the window. Where's rc.local? Why did ./configure && make && make install destroy my system? Also: we're talking about 20 years ago: everything was harder then.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by int_19h on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:49PM (#25865659)
If you came from a BSD, then you (were supposed to) already know why make install is not a good idea. Although Debian package management was not particularly similar to FreeBSD ports and packages, the fundamental idea was the same.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by zwaps on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:10AM (#25857322)
No gui
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by jbverschoor on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:39PM (#25863937)
I never wanted a GUI on servers.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by 3np on Thursday January 21, 2021 @01:01AM (#25855978)
I use Debian, a lot, I happily run it on most of my servers. But I can completely understand that it's not great for the majority of users.

Stable is too stable for the average desktop user - often kernel is missing drivers for newer hardware models, or system libraries are too old for newer applications.

Testing works most of the time but is not stable enough. Most recent example; zfs, which is on 0.8.x, is completely broken in testing since the kernel upgrade to 5.10 in December. zfs has not (and prob will not) backported 5.10 compatibility to 0.8.x. Last I heard, the Debian maintainers were still not decided on if they are going to backport the 5.10 fix to their own fork of zfs 0.8.x, or if they're going to do the upgrade to zfs 2.0 already.

I had a couple of servers where I had stupidly enabled unattended-upgrades, which broke the filesystems and required recovery to make services start again. Annoying, but it was my mistake.

This kind of situation is completely expected and there's really no one at fault. But it is a good example of why vanilla Debian is not suitable for many users and use-cases. Mint does seem like a better Ubuntu, though.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by happymellon on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:01AM (#25856296)
Backport frankenware is probably the biggest reason I wouldn't recommend Debian.

They do not have the time and resources to figure out every inevitable configuration, and they end up supporting a mishmash of unsupportable software.

Backported ZFS just brings fear in my eyes, these filesystems have to have many decades of testing before people are comfortable with it, and Debian finds it acceptable to make a custom patched version. Not cool.

If you want to store all your data on that configuration then by all means, but I'm afraid I won't run a distro that plays games to avoid changing a version number.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by 3np on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:02AM (#25856303)
Just to be clear, the backporting part was just hearsay that it was under debate, so don't take my word for that one.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by happymellon on Thursday January 21, 2021 @09:04AM (#25858874)
I'm sorry I misread this.

> the backporting part was just hearsay that it was under debate

I guess if it is just hearsay then thats something else. Does Debian have guidelines about what they wouldn't backport?

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by 3np on Thursday January 28, 2021 @07:30AM (#25941011)
I'm not certain about guidelines, but zfs 2.0.1 has landed in bullseye \o/

https://packages.debian.org/bullseye/zfs-dkms

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by happymellon on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:48AM (#25856841)
They backport all sorts of things, the fact that this is even a discussion point is bad enough.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by snicker7 on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:33AM (#25856756)
Solution: use a distro-agnostic package manager (Nix, Guix, Homebrew, FlatPak, ...) on top of Debian. Stable base + modern apps.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by geofft on Thursday January 21, 2021 @01:27AM (#25856120)
> Canonical never did much to add value

They employ a number of people who maintain core Debian packages to work on Debian packaging full time and generally to land improvements in Debian.

I do agree that Canonical never did much to add value to Ubuntu beyond what they added to Debian, but they certainly added value to Debian, and ironically you don't even need use their distro for that, let alone pay them!

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by derekp7 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:40PM (#25855460)
Two things that I would like to see in Debian. First, something more similar to Red Hat Kickstart. The Debian equivalent (Preseed) doesn't quite cut it (effectively it is an "answer" file for the Debian installation, so when the questions in the installation evolve you need to regenerate the preseed config (this is my understanding, everything I've read says that it would be really difficult to make a preseed configuration by hand).

Second, it would be nice if the package manager had an actual database behind it capturing everything that the rpmdb does. Instead you have a flat file with some of the data in it, and log files with other data (where the log files can be rotated out eventually). I want to be able to do things like "rpm -qa --last" on Debian. Or "yum history".

How difficult would it be to write a version of the apt suite of tools that uses an sqlite db? Would that break other items in Debian? It sounds like an interesting project to take on.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by pabs3 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:58PM (#25855598)
The dpkg roadmap mentions a metadata tracking proposal, which seems likely to provide something like the database that you want.

https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Dpkg/RoadMap https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Dpkg/Spec/MetadataTracking

Personally I vastly prefer the flat file version, it is much easier to inspect and modify and maybe less likely to get corrupted.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by m463 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:50PM (#25855548)
I think a database to speed things up would be ok, as long as the flat text files were the truth.

I wish Linus had veto'd the binary logfiles of systemd.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by derekp7 on Thursday January 21, 2021 @12:50AM (#25855919)
I think the best of both worlds would be an sqlite DB (which is extremely reliable) along with a rotated export to a flat file whenever there are modifications.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by pabs3 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:53PM (#25855571)
There is something called kickseed, which is documented on the Ubuntu wiki and seems to be available in Debian too, possibly in the Debian installer as well.

https://help.ubuntu.com/community/KickstartCompatibility

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by TylerE on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:41PM (#25855470)
They made it so that when the system booted you got a graphical login prompt, and not just a stock xdm config, either.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by eloff on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:26PM (#25853771)
> If you don't like Debian, pick an open source distribution that is not backed by a business and begin sending the money you would've dumped into subscriptions as donations.

How is that as useful to you personally as a support subscription? You can't replace a support contract with wishful thinking and a donation.

It's great to support open source projects, but lets not mix concerns here.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by TylerE on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @09:09PM (#25854488)
Debian is in fact incorporated.

"Software in the Public Interest, Inc. is a tax-exempt non-profit corporation based in the United States of America, founded by Debian people in 1997 to help free software/hardware organisations."

It owns the various Debian trademarks, etc.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by kodah on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @09:42PM (#25854687)
There is a massive difference between a company that manages trademarks and a for-profit business that depends entirely on gatekeeping behind a subscription and support contract. Before someone brings up Fedora, RHEL exercises ultimate control over that too. Think about that, RHEL owns the trademark to Fedora. Feel free to browse their board too.

You can argue that Ubuntu provides a counter model to RHEL where only services and select products require a subscription but the OS is otherwise free.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by pabs3 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:42PM (#25855478)
There are actually several non-profits holding Debian assets, in years with a physical DebConf usually a new or existing organisation is enlisted to hold funds for that conference.

https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/Treasurer/Organizations https://wiki.debian.org/Teams/DPL/TrustedOrganizationCriteri...

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by erichocean on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:11PM (#25853167)
> The weird thing here is the consistent recommendation of corporate backed distributions.

If you pay for software, like we do in VFX/Animation, then RHEL is basically the standard and what's supported best.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by csdreamer7 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:20PM (#25853720)
Would you write out more about that? I would assume Windows is the standard for workstations.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by mroche on Thursday January 21, 2021 @12:43AM (#25855867)
In addition to the other responses, the VFX community has strong roots coming in the SGI/IRIX days. When those platforms started to decline due to competition from modern commodity hardware among other reasons, Linux offered the best path of migration from both a hardware support perspective and reasonable compatibility with existing pipelines and tools (the latter being very important). Red Hat became a sort of de facto at that point.

^ This is what I have been told by my older colleagues; I wasn’t around for this. My current employer danced around with RHL and Fedora Core before moving to CentOS 6 (now 7, and looking at what to do with 8). Pretty much all studios using Linux in this industry are running RHEL/CentOS, with a very small handful operating on Ubuntu. Home users will do whatever they want and deal with whatever incompatibilities arise ;)

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by alrs on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:32PM (#25853810)
Standard? Someone in vfx would have to answer that, but my understanding is: not really. There is a lot of vfx work that happens on Linux workstations.

https://vfxplatform.com/about/

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by PowerBar on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @08:19PM (#25854179)
In the VFX environments I've seen (100+ artists), most artist workstations and servers are Linux (usually RHEL or CentOS due to much higher rpm than deb support in the industry). Macs are common for editors (who use the Adobe suite to make timelines for dailies) and producers (because shiny), while Windows is mainly used by admin staff (accounting, hr, etc) because they use the same terrible accounting software as every other company out there (note: this may be less so now with the move to web based solutions).

While most hobby level video software is targeted at windows or Mac, the truly powerful stuff (houdini, maya, nuke, blender) are first class citizens on Linux. Currently one of the few artist programs that aren't available for Linux is the adobe suite which is mostly used by editors (for timelines) and photo editing (for promotional material) and most of that happens on Macs, usually in the editing department.

Something to keep in mind is that many VFX shops are kind of specialized and will work on very specific portions of a movie or TV show. For example, the company that owns the final product (Disney, Fox, MGM, etc) will pay company A to shoot the movie, then company A will send the footage for a 30 second scene to company B to rotoscope everything, then it gets sent to company C for VFX elements, then to company D for 3d conversion, then to company E for lighting and finally to company F for audio and final stitching. This is repeated (often with different companies A-F) for each scene since different scenes required different levels of expertise in different areas such as crowd generation, fire simulation, raindrop removal (yes, it's as painful as it sounds), background replacement, CG helicopters, etc. Because of this, the few steps that require windows are typically handled by 1 or 2 companies so the rest only need enough Mac/Windows machines for their local editors to stick timelines together for daily reviews.

An interesting side effect of the above is that almost every company you see in the credits of a movie had no idea what the dialog was because audio is one of the last things that gets added and completely bypasses 90% of the VFX houses involved.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by krupan on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:51PM (#25855179)
Apples and oranges. Corporations that feel they need Enterprise Support, either for the OS itself, or for software that runs on the OS (commercial databases, engineering tools, etc.), pay for Red Hat Enterprise Linux. Or, if they were small just feeling like throwing caution to the wind, they would use Centos (and not tell anyone that it wasn't actually Red Hat). These are businesses and software that used to run only on commercial UNIX operating systems.

People tried selling Enterprise Support for Debian back even before Red Hat went commercial, if I remember correctly, but somehow Red Hat timed their effort right and became the defacto replacement for UNIX in these environments.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by vultour on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:19PM (#25853226)
So companies should expect OSS maintainers to provide the same level of service that a RedHat subscription does if they donate?
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by bityard on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:38PM (#25853369)
Who is suggesting that?
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by nvr219 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @09:30PM (#25854610)
I am
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by pabs3 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:44PM (#25855493)
It may not be to the level of support that RedHat provides, but Debian does provide gratis support and there are consultancies providing paid support:

https://www.debian.org/support https://www.debian.org/consultants/

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:51PM (#25853475)
The Linux kernel itself is corporate backed.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by emilsedgh on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @08:51PM (#25854366)
There is a difference between corporate backed and being owned and operated by a corporation.

Ubuntu, Red Hat and SUSE are owned by companies. That ownership is more than just trademarks. The own the trademark and are the sole decision makers.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by tootie on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:25PM (#25853268)
I don't see a lot of production workloads running debian unless it's a Ubuntu which is backed by canonical.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by tomc1985 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:55PM (#25854000)
Considering that Ubuntu is a superset of Debian, then yes you do see lots of debian production workloads

Personally, I used to support a $25m/yr business on a cluster of Debian servers, which itself supported about 1000 remote field installations, also running Debian.

Let me tell you, Debian was the least of my troubles in that job. It really did just work

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by blabitty on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @09:03PM (#25854445)
I wish I could use Debian at work, I run it at home on the same server for 8+ years through multiple full version upgrades with very little hassle or trouble. With RedHat I'm fighting satellite server and subscription nonsense and have to rebuild from scratch to upgrade, I've never understood that requirement.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by eloff on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:24PM (#25853750)
I see you've been downvoted, but this statement is true. Ubuntu on both servers and desktop is far more popular than debian. Popular is not always a good proxy for better, but in this case following a well tread path is advantageous when you run into trouble.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by int_19h on Thursday January 21, 2021 @05:51PM (#25865691)
Is there anything Ubuntu-specific in Ubuntu these days (other than process stuff, like release cycle)? Or is it just Debian with commercial support and branding?
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by GordonS on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:01PM (#25853562)
I know you mean in terms of host OS, but as an aside, loads of Docker images are based on the "slim" Debian images.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by curt15 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:48PM (#25853451)
Google's production servers run a customised version of Debian https://www.usenix.org/conference/lisa13/technical-sessions/...
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by erik_seaberg on Thursday January 21, 2021 @02:30AM (#25856451)
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by BigGreenTurtle on Thursday January 21, 2021 @11:56AM (#25861047)
I usually choose debian for docker images if alpine isn't the right solution. Their slim images are pretty nice.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by sjansen on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:15PM (#25855312)
From a business perspective, the biggest problem I've experienced with community-based distributions is the limited support cycle. Debian averages about 3 years with LTS, which is really good for for a community distro but really short for a commercial distro.

Updating a personal server every 6 months may be easy, but in a mature business it often makes sense to wait 5 years or more before upgrading certain infrastructure so that time and effort can be invested in other areas instead.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by derekp7 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:28PM (#25855395)
Is that still the case with cloud-first, software-defined infrastructure, and IAAS? Even in non-cloud environments you have pets vs. cattle, with the cattle hopefully out-numbering pets. So your data sits off in a storage device, and gets attached to containers running on an OS that is built from a kickstart or similar install. In that case you can spin up VMs running any OS version, make sure you can deploy your containers on it, test it, and off you go.

The days of having a fleet of servers that were carefully hand-crafted and evolved over the years are hopefully coming to a close.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by snicker7 on Thursday January 21, 2021 @03:30AM (#25856739)
You might be thinking as a technologist rather than as a business person. Debian is great, but there is no accountability if things go wrong. Accountability and QA may be worth the licensing costs, even if 100% of the software is "free".