News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by ehayes on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @11:49AM (#25848645)
I manage a "tiny company", but we have 10-ish production CentOS 7/8 servers and this sounds interesting. Although my web-app use case is probably fine with Stream, I don't know why everyone is assuming Stream will be completely broken and useless.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by ziml77 on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @12:09PM (#25848899)
It's not that the expectation is that it will be broken and useless. It's that the reason to choose CentOS was for the fact that it has slow release cycles which allow for long support periods.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @12:13PM (#25848957)
> I don't know why everyone is assuming Stream will be completely broken and useless.

It probably wont be completely broken and useless, but they replaced a stable OS with a beta, which is particularly galling to many users who picked that OS specifically because it was so stable.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by freedomben on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @12:26PM (#25849112)
Curious, do you consider Fedora to be an alpha? Did you consider RHEL to be a beta for CentOS previously?

Just trying to see how you define "beta"

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by yjftsjthsd-h on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @02:50PM (#25851074)
> Curious, do you consider Fedora to be an alpha?

Slightly detached because of their processing/release process (Fedora X never quite matched to RHEL Y even if there was some derivation), but yes, Fedora is absolutely the alpha for RHEL. It gets changes, including breaking changes, on a fast track (IIRC, Fedora frequently goes toe-to-toe with Arch for having the most recent packages), has a 13-month lifecycle with a strong expectation that you'll `dnf system-upgrade` regularly, and doesn't shy away from pushing on tech that they believe to be desirable even if it's not (yet) widely used (Wayland, BTRFS, CGroupsV2).

> Did you consider RHEL to be a beta for CentOS previously?

Now that's an interesting point that actually makes me stop and consider:) It is true that previously CentOS could legitimately claim to be even more stable/slow-moving than RHEL. I think the distinction that I would make is that RHEL had its own betas that were called betas, and that each point release was frozen/stable until the next one came along, while Stream is explicitly unfrozen all the time. So yes, I suppose a person could have described RHEL as CentOS's beta, although probably only jokingly because it still had Red Hat supporting it and feature freezes to control changes.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by bluedays on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:28PM (#25855012)
Funny to read this because Fedora is definitely beta, because their distribution doesn't seem very stable. I switched away from Fedora because it seemed to break more than my Arch installation. There are a lot of things they are doing that no other distros are doing right now. Cgroups v2, for instance.

The benefit of Fedora was that they handled a lot of things that were a pain to configure. The biggest culprit being fonts. But now that TrueType patents have expired, and it's included in Arch automatically it's one less reason to use Fedora.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by awill on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:35PM (#25850109)
I think you're digging in the wrong place, and focusing on the label. This shouldn't be kicking fedora down. It has a place, as does stream.

The point is that with CentOS you expect a super stable release. Red Hat replaced that with what is clearly a less stable project. And as was said before, if you used CentOS, it's probably precisely because you want something super stable with long term support. Those are not the sorts of users who'll want to use Stream.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by eropple on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:45PM (#25850238)
To me, Fedora is a desktop environment (my preferred one!) and absolutely an alpha/early-beta server option at best.

CentOS Stream seems like "Fedora, again" and does not do what CentOS did. And now, the willingness to blow up CentOS with so little warning means there is a massive trust deficit here.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by ghaff on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:44PM (#25853420)
There's a pretty big difference. While I'm very much not an expert on the RHEL QE process, my understanding is that Fedora is pretty much its own thing that is used to rebase RHEL on major revs. Whereas Stream is RHEL builds that have passed CI testing in the RHEL dev/test process.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by bombcar on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:29PM (#25850028)
Many people use CentOS to run "Enterprise" software that expects to be run on RHEL.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by alexhutcheson on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @01:56PM (#25850390)
Those are probably the users that RedHat is trying to nudge onto RHEL. "Enterprise" software is normally quite expensive, so the marginal cost of some RHEL Server licenses is probably a small fraction of the total cost of deploying the software in most cases.

More generally, orgs that are running "Enterprise" software are already set up to pay for software. Going from spending $X to spending $X+Y is often not a big deal ("Ok, I'll run that through the same process I used to get approval for buying FooSoftWorks"), while going from $0 to $Y can be very hard ("I don't even know who I'd need to ask to get purchase approval for that").

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by oarsinsync on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @05:12PM (#25852662)
> Going from spending $X to spending $X+Y is often not a big deal

Except when $Y == $1000X. Then it really is a big deal.

When you only have a tiny minority of RHEL hosts that you have full support contracts on, and an overwhelming majority of CentOS hosts that you administer in-house, it really isn't trivial.

It's almost certainly cheaper to migrate to Oracle or Rocky. Migrations aren't cheap either.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by JeremyNT on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @10:32PM (#25855041)
> More generally, orgs that are running "Enterprise" software are already set up to pay for software.

Crucially, though, most entities who are running their own "enterprise" software deployments will need way more than 16 servers.

Small shops do use "enterprise" software, of course, but they usually just pay somebody else to run it for them.

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by 1337shadow on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @04:04PM (#25851964)
Okay but I can't help but think about the social security in my country which I know runs likely to be more than hundreds of CentOS servers ... It's not like social security is a company making any profits, it's even the opposite, and now they are in such situation.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by paul_f on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @06:48PM (#25853458)
We are a smallish company with six CentOS 8 servers. Seems we fit into the profile of this new Developer program. To be honest, I can see us paying for full RHEL subscriptions before we would change distributions.
Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:07PM (#25853617)
Go ahead and buy licenses as a show of support, but I strongly suggest that you exercise the converter scripts in both directions, partially to know what will cause them to fail, and partially to have an option when the vendor misbehaves.

Red Hat offers a "no support" server license for $350/year, which is the lowest licensing tier. Tiers with more capability and support are available for $800, and $1300.

https://www.redhat.com/en/store/red-hat-enterprise-linux-ser...

Oracle has a larger range of tiers. The "no support" license is $120/year. Tiers with more capability and support are available for $500, $1200, $1400, and $2300.

https://www.oracle.com/linux/

Oracle Linux can be used in production without a paid license of any kind; Red Hat Linux cannot be used in this way for large deployments (excepting the new 16-seat license for a developer account).

Red Hat is aggressive with software audits; I have seen one.

Both Oracle and Red Hat now have complete toolsets to convert support between an installed CentOS/RedHat/Oracle OS.

Red Hat can now convert an installed CentOS or Oracle Linux to RHEL; previously a wipe and reinstall was required ("have fun reinstalling your system" is still on Oracle's CentOS site). The description looks much more thorough in replacing all possible packages with Red Hat versions:

https://access.redhat.com/articles/2360841

Oracle does not replace CentOS or RedHat RPMs in their conversion (AFAIK), so it is much less violent on the platform changes.

https://github.com/oracle/centos2ol

https://linux.oracle.com/switch/centos/

https://blogs.oracle.com/linux/reasons-for-switching-centos-...

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by paul_f on Thursday January 21, 2021 @08:20AM (#25858510)
"Red Hat can now convert an installed CentOS or Oracle Linux to RHEL"

Apologies if a dumb question, but I assumed CentOS 8 was a clone of RHEL 8. What would change?

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by jlgaddis on Thursday January 21, 2021 @06:48PM (#25866333)
Take a look at Oracle's "CentOS to Oracle Linux" (and other similar) scripts to see how they work and what they do (sorry, I don't have a link handy as I'm on a mobile device at the moment).

If memory serves, the process consists of, basically, installing the <distro>-release package for the "new" distro (which includes the files in the /etc/yum.repos.d/ (or whatever) directory that defines the package repositories), enabling the repositories it just added, disabling the "old" distribution's repositories, then running a "yum update" to replace the "old" distributions packages (including the kernel) with the (nearly identical) ones from the "new" distribution. After all that is done, you reboot the host so that the new kernel is loaded and that's pretty much it.

Mostly out of curiosity, I tried out Oracle's "centos2ol.sh" (or something like that) script ~8 years ago on a new CentOS 6 VM I had set up for just that purpose and it was as easy as they claim that it is. I don't recall encountering any issues and I suspect that, by now, they've ran into most of the potential issues and have devised ways to resolve them automatically.

Note that while CentOS 8 is a clone of RHEL 8, the CentOS packages are rebuilt versions of the RHEL ones. Most of them are built from the exact same source code but some packages do have minor changes made to them before they are rebuilt (for trademarks, etc.).

Re:Red Hat announces no-cost RHEL for small production envir... by chasil on Thursday January 21, 2021 @01:10PM (#25862017)
When running "yum update" the packages are pulled from the registered repository, found in the /etc/yum.repos.d directory.

When switching the provider of package updates, the old repository must be disabled, and a new one substituted, among other changes that the new provider requires to switch support.

Oracle makes (by default) modest changes for such a switch. Red Hat essentially rewrites your whole operating system, and has added a warning that consultants should be retained for such conversions in case of trouble.