News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by batch12 on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:29AM (#25822650)
I was a foster kid for 11 years. My social worker and foster parents were likely the only reason I am still here. My social worker would visit his children weekly-- even on weekends and did whatever it took for us. Still, he was just one man. I still talk to him regularly. During one discussion, I asked him about the other kids that I remembered. There were only two of us left. I think people forget about the trauma foster kids deal with. First, the reason kids went into care. Second, the separation of the kid from their families. My experiences showed me that this trauma, combined with an institutional care system does not equip most kids to function in society.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by duxup on Monday January 18, 2021 @12:01PM (#25823775)
Yeah the trauma is really hard to quantify. My mom was a 3rd grade teacher for years. One of the kids was a foster child. He was a good kids, a good heart, but had self control realated issues.

On the last day of the school they were drawing pictures of what they'd do that summer. His photo was of him being sad. He told her.

"Some of us are sad because of summer vacation because we don't want to be at home every day."

Just brutal to hear.... some kids have the deck stacked so far against them....

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by chasd00 on Monday January 18, 2021 @03:00PM (#25825903)
my wife is school teacher, when the pandemic hit and schools closed some of her kids were taken into CPS and some just flat out vanished. Elementary schools are basically social safety nets for some kids. I think that's why many governors were quick to re-open and very slow to close them down again.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by aksss on Monday January 18, 2021 @08:02PM (#25828750)
to some degree a social safety net, but surely also a daycare in the most literal sense for a single parent who can't take their kid to work. Having school closed can be disastrous for people who are barely hanging on with joe jobs, fickle employers, and a rent to pay. Tough problem, because it shifts a lot of burden onto teachers to proxy as parents/wardens as well, which must undermine the mission of education.
[dead]
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by jacobolus on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:36PM (#25829344)
> we realize that adults give COVID to kids but kids don't tend to give it to other kids or adults

This statement does not match available evidence. What can be accurately said is that children seldom have severe disease and often asymptomatic or have unremarkable symptoms, making the extent of Covid among children hard to measure (in general, asymptomatic people have their cases discovered and tracked at a dramatically lower rate than people with serious symptoms).

There was a nice Spiegel article summary a while ago https://www.spiegel.de/international/world/new-on-the-covid-...

There has been overall very poor data gathering (testing, contact tracing, symptom tracking, ...) among children in most parts of the world, and in particular in the USA. All other age groups are tested and tracked at much higher frequency.

Due to the combination of this lack of solid research plus extreme political/social pressure, many people have argued (some based more or less on wishful thinking / confirmation bias, others disingenuously) that kids are not a spread risk and should therefore be allowed to mingle.

In many places where this has been tried, it was followed by notable outbreaks in schools (which then spread to the broader community), leading to schools shutting back down. In analyses of the effects of various public health interventions, school closures had one of the largest effects on the reproductive number of the epidemic.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by treeman79 on Monday January 18, 2021 @07:18PM (#25828418)
My wife (teacher) got covid from small kids. Brought it home as a gift for the whole family. School closed again after maybe 5-10% had already been diagnosed.
[dead]
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by treeman79 on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:29PM (#25829681)
8 hours indoor with classroom with kids, vs 20 feet away for a few seconds outdoor.

Yes. We are quite sure.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by AndrewUnmuted on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:55PM (#25830149)
No, you are not - and you cannot - be sure.

You can tell yourself whatever you want, but this kind of thinking has become pervasive throughout the culture as of late and it is a very concerning development. You cannot see a virus and you cannot prove one way or the other where you acquired the viral load necessary to come down with an infection.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by Aeolun on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:48AM (#25832513)
> You cannot see a virus and you cannot prove one way or the other where you acquired the viral load necessary to come down with an infection.

Based on years of research, I think we can safely conclude that it’s generally not while walking outside by yourself.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by jacobolus on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:06AM (#25830519)
With genetic sequencing it is often possible to trace the infection chains with a bit more confidence.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by phkahler on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:34PM (#25829330)
>> Which makes COVID the opposite of diseases like the common cold or the flu where kids act like germ factories.

Covid 19 is literally a cold virus. It just happens to have high mortality rate for a Corona virus.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by aminozuur on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:35AM (#25822710)
Thank you for sharing your experience. May I ask, how are you doing now? Did you find any ways to address or even overcome those past experiences?
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by batch12 on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:03AM (#25823068)
I am doing well for myself now. How I got here is pretty complicated. I can only attribute my ability to overcome these experiences to those who genuinely cared. These are the people who cared enough to help me succeed but also let me fail and deal with the consequences. In high school, I was a low C to D student. I slept in class. I refused to do homework. I thought the schools were only temporary, so therefore they did not matter. I only passed classes because I excelled at test taking and understood the material. I felt like it was all a game-- people, school, relationships. None of it mattered and all I had to do was find the right way to play. After foster care, I had a free ride (I was still in care), but failed out of college because I didn't see a point. I joined the military. This forced structure and discipline actually helped me. I understood this game and excelled. I used my experience in the military to get an entry level job in IT and continue to grow. There are residual effects that I will always deal with. I have huge gaps in memory from when I was a kid- I don't remember much before age 11. I compartmentalize things too easily. I can be impatient with people. I dislike and distrust bureaucracies. I don't have enough patience for incompetence. I could go on, but I'm sure that's not why you're here :)
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by aminozuur on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:09AM (#25823130)
Thanks again for sharing. I find your story very relatable, from the gaps in memory (which is common after trauma) to rebelling and failing in the school system.

I wish there was a community just for people in tech who've overcome messy childhoods.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by minitoar on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:18AM (#25823229)
In my book, disliking and distrusting bureaucracy is a hallmark of an intelligent and well-adjusted being.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:12PM (#25829185)
Hmm, you might want to refine your criteria. I'll grant you Ted Kaczynski was intelligent but well adjusted seems a stretch.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by FrankyHollywood on Saturday January 23, 2021 @04:43AM (#25881008)
> I can be impatient with people. I dislike and distrust bureaucracies. I don't have enough patience for incompetence.

I hire people with these qualities, most intelligent people I know are like this :)

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by exabrial on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:20PM (#25829251)
This is amazing insight actually, thanks for sharing your story. In civilian life, how are you giving yourself structure and holding yourself accountable? I ask because I find creating structure for myself as an adult really helps me do things I wouldn't make time for
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by jawzz on Monday January 18, 2021 @08:12PM (#25828810)
Not trying to be snarky, but no one remembers much before age 11 or likes bureaucracies or incompetence.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Monday January 18, 2021 @08:30PM (#25828912)
Kids who went through foster care frequently fail to remember entire years of their life, schools they attended, and families they lived with. There are multiple reasons for this, from trauma causing decreased working memory and formation of longterm memory during childhood to social factors such as lack of the same stability of and reminders of their life that a child who goes to one school for years and then has photos of themselves from that time to cement the memory will have. Most people do remember their life before 11 - the vast majority can name their school and neighborhood from back then without thinking, could tell you if they had a bike, if they liked school, etc. Some of these memories are indeed formed retroactively through stories, but they still exist.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by octodog on Monday January 18, 2021 @08:49PM (#25829037)
This is a terrible comment. Obviously the GP is speaking in a relative sense, based on their observations and experience with others.

Saying "not trying to be snarky" does little to minimise the snarky attitude.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by slothtrop on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:05AM (#25823085)
I believe this is very understated, and collectively we tend to throw up our hands at the issue as though nothing could be improved. Even children growing up without a father figure or having divorced parents can have some developmental issues, I can't imagine how being separated from family must be.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by candiodari on Monday January 18, 2021 @06:05PM (#25827814)
It results in what is referred to as "Attachment Disorder" and is generally considered the worst possible psychological state. Especially where it is "Reactive" (ie. the problem started because of CPS involvement, because of being separated from figures the child was attached to), the worst possible option.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reactive_attachment_disorder

Reality is that, certainly on average, CPS is worse than neglect, worse than abuse. Reality seems to be that what parent figures provide for children is simply a predictable, stable environment. It does not matter if said environment has violence (especially if it doesn't directly harm the child). If the child is well provided for (ie. even poverty or neglect to the point of irregular availability of food). The vast majority of cases, by the way, are neglect, which means in practice the child being left alone for longer periods of time (hours, not days). Needless to say, this is not going to seriously damage any child over the age of 3 or 4.

The same even with violence against a child. The not-so-common-but-considered-typical image of a father who gets drunk on fridays and then yells or even hits a child with flimsy excuses, but otherwise cares for them is just not going to do the damage even a single CPS placement does.

Just to be clear: none of those things are good for a child. But they do not prevent the formation of a stable adult. CPS and child placement (and especially re-placing them on average 14 times before they grow up) prevents the formation of a stable adult in something like 45-60% of cases.

I guess CPS just feels they "need to do something". The result of that need is tens of thousands of destroyed lives per year. But nobody can be blamed for doing nothing ...

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:36PM (#25829341)
Attachment disorders are a fairly controversial subject and many former foster youth and advocate groups believe that they are largely garbage diagnoses for kids who are understandably angry, distrustful and unwilling to for a relationship with strange new carers. Among other things, actually diagnosing RAD requires that it show up before five years old, because it is in those few early years that a child develops their ability to attach to a caregiver. As for experience in CPS care - 50% of kids return to their parents, and (not exactly the same) 50% are in care for a year or less. The average number of placements is maybe 2 - are you perhaps thinking of the average number among children who never leave care?

As for the idea that "even a single CPS placement" is worse than being left with violent parents - I've never seen anything supporting this but if you have some I'd love to read it.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by candiodari on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @06:17AM (#25832296)
There are a number of studies that point this out. This is the biggest by far:

https://sci-hub.se/10.1257/aer.97.5.1583

> As for the idea that "even a single CPS placement" is worse than being left with violent parents - I've never seen anything supporting this but if you have some I'd love to read it.

Well, reactive attachment syndrome is the expected outcome for something like 60% of placements, and 80%+ of kids that are placed more than once. These multiple replacements are not exactly rare. Apparently there is a small group where the first placement remains stable for a long time which has reasonable results, and there is a large group that keep getting placed again and again where the outcomes are terrible.

The vast majority of parents aren't violent but neglectful. And even then, our standards of neglect have moved quite a bit. These days some interventions are done because of "bad" food in lunch boxes (think: mars bars, not sandwiches).

The long term consequences of neglect and violence that isn't random are "parentification. TLDR: kids start acting like adults at a very young age, and obviously with less than ideal success. Think 7 year olds that make sure the rent is paid and their little sister sees a doctor once a year, or when she's ill. These kids will fight for their independence, for obvious reasons, at a very young age. This can, and does, lead to depression and less than ideal school results (because in that situation the kids don't consider school very important and of course caring for others takes time that can't be spent on homework or hobbies or even actually going to class when there's a crisis). The worst outcomes are observed where the kid takes total control of the home situation and the KID abuses this power. But even that is nothing compared to even mild attachment syndrome.

The worse cases of reactive attachment disorder, well, from Wikipedia: "Actions that otherwise would be classified as conduct disorder, such as mutilating animals, harming siblings or other family, or harming themselves intentionally"

And of course, it is anecdotal and probably lacks validity but if you look up mass murderers, whilst diagnosis is missing their family background is really quite common and are the sort of circumstances that you'd expect to generate RAD. Obviously, that outcome is very rare, but does exist.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Parentification

I would say, read both entries and judge for yourself which is the worse one. But I don't think there will be much disagreement.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @12:15AM (#25842814)
Studies that point what out?

> Well, reactive attachment syndrome is the expected outcome for something like 60% of placements,

Absolutely, completely false. Also nonsensically false that "mars bars instead of sandwiches" would get any intervention.

You are very misinformed on this topic. Almost everything you have said is directly, easily contradicted simply by looking at the widely available data on foster care. Children arrive in foster care with attachment disorders - the majority of children don't even enter foster care until they are too old to develop an attachment disorder, according to the diagnostic criteria. Almost 50% of children who are taken into foster care in the US have only one placement (1). (Unsurprisingly, being diagnosed with RAD correlates very highly with having more placements. There's likely causality in both directions there.)

I don't know why you have such a strong opinion here, but it's not based on reality.

(1) https://www.childtrends.org/blog/the-share-of-children-in-fo...

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by candiodari on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @04:49AM (#25844476)
Multiple placements are the result of 2 things:

Non-permanent placements (most obviously crisis care), which by itself happens to 20-30% of children in care. A placement in a youth institution is a per-6-month assignment by a judge and therefore obviously very unstable in essentially all cases. Even when they are stable, because of the 6 month time limit, after which a decision the child has zero possibility to influence might change their environment 100%, do you really think this will be experienced as stability and is correctly classified as "no change"?

Additionally, in clinic or some forms of foster care one might even say that given the rate of changes in the group (and personnel) even if the child remains in the same location, everyone around them changes in something like 8 months, every 8 months (because 10 children per group, every one has 6 month placement, so you can expect some change every 2 weeks). On top of that, personnel changes are very common in all youth institutions. So even in the case of a stable placement a youth institution will not be experienced as anything remotely resembling stability by a child living there.

The viewpoint of the child is obviously what matters here.

Breakdowns of placements (ie. foster parents/institution requiring child to be removed immediately, without waiting for placement to end): 20% to 65% of children, depending on age and gender.

https://www.researchgate.net/figure/Rate-of-breakdown-by-age...

Is it really so controversial for you that multiple changes of caregivers and environment are experienced by almost all children in state care? And that constant large changes of environment are experienced by a large subset of these children?

I did not say the worst possible form of reactive attachment disorder is the expected outcome in 60% of cases, some form of attachment disorder is expected in 60% of cases. And granted, you can certainly make a valid argument that this is at least partially because every DSM revision loosens the definition of attachment disorder, which is also seen in other diagnoses and results in absurd levels of comorbidity.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6097443/

The real problem that everyone does agree on is that reactive attachment disorder sharply rises when social services intervene in the lives of children, irrespective of the reason. Even abused children have sharply lower incidence of attachment problems than children in clinic or foster care.

This is controversial, that's certainly true. Why? Hmmm, let's ask ourselves ... why might a very good reason to avoid interference in families by social services that has historically been used to deny almost all interference (and with that came the consequence that it robbed many social workers of a job and greatly limited the size of the sector) be controversial? I wonder why that might happen...

> Also nonsensically false that "mars bars instead of sandwiches" would get any intervention.

This is seen as neglect and will most definitely cause intervention by social services. Hopefully placement is rare, but the issue is that if you attract the attention of social services, a child getting an out-of-home placement is greatly dependent on the child services investigator as the first linked study pointed out, not on the child, the parent, or what is actually going on. Just for that reason alone it will happen.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Wednesday January 20, 2021 @07:51PM (#25853957)
Actually, the major driver of pushback against these diagnoses in foster care in my experience is former foster children, who object to having been diagnosed with these conditions for what they feel was perfectly reasonable behavior. But yes, let's jump to a conspiracy theory about bad social workers instead.

It seems that you are attempting to argue something completely different to your original claims, and I'm not interested in trying to follow you and your goalposts.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by candiodari on Thursday January 21, 2021 @04:43AM (#25857155)
> Actually, the major driver of pushback against these diagnoses in foster care in my experience is former foster children

I don't get it, you accuse me of conspiracy and then claim this is all because of a conspiracy by the children, the victims. And victims is the correct word because VERY few foster children had any hand in or possibility to influence their placement at all, and the vast majority, as the paper says too, are "marginal", meaning their placement was the choice of the social services investigator. I'm sure it's nevertheless all their fault and they deserve it, and the social workers who are totally financially dependent on robbing them of their home just don't have .

Besides, those are children have experienced firsthand the consequences of social workers' help, and really didn't want that help, don't want it now, and will never want it.

Who would know better than they do? Nobody would.

> let's jump to a conspiracy theory about bad social workers instead

You have met some social workers, right? Bad is the standard there. Even outright malevolence is not rare. Hidden agendas and lies are the norm in youth protection social workers, because if they told the truth to children, it'd be comical: "do you want my help? We can take everything from you, friends, parents, school, ... everything, declare you sick with 20 diagnoses and if we start now we can have you in prison before you're 20. Yes almost all foster children become criminals. So do you want our help?". Children will be running in tears to abusers begging them to take them back ...

The system for helping children is a bad joke.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by flyinglizard on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:37PM (#25829349)
I don’t have the means to judge what you were saying but I found this reasoning fascinating nonetheless.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by omginternets on Monday January 18, 2021 @12:13PM (#25823919)
>My experiences showed me that this trauma, combined with an institutional care system does not equip most kids to function in society.

Can you elaborate on this? It abstractly makes sense, but what does this look like in practice? What kinds of situations come up whereupon a foster-kid-turned-adult wouldn't be "equipped"? What is it they wouldn't know to do? Or, what would they mistakenly think was an appropriate response?

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by whoknew1122 on Monday January 18, 2021 @07:00PM (#25828272)
Depends largely on how stable the foster family is, and how much effort the kid's social worker can (or wants) to put in.

I've known children who left unstructured, chaotic situations and were placed in... unstructured, chaotic foster homes. Many foster homes are like warehouses with upward of 6-8 children at a time. Fostering children is a paycheck for some foster parents.

I've also known a foster child who was placed in a home wherein the foster family had biological children in the house. The biological children were treated better and more lovingly than the foster child. The foster child left an abusive situation, only to find inequitable treatment. The foster child never had anyone model a loving, supportive relationship. So they bounced around from abusive, drug-addicted partner to abusive, drug-addicted partner until they got tired of being around abusive people and drugs.

Without a role model, it's hard to be equipped once you're legally an adult and don't have someone making decisions for you. Being an adult is a big responsibility, and a lot of these children weren't prepared to make healthy decisions. And they don't have health coping mechanisms.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by omginternets on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:15PM (#25829203)
Hmm. This is definitely interesting, and I appreciate the details, but I don't feel like I have a better understanding of what the maladaptive behavior looks like. I think you're describing the causes of being "not equipped", but I'm interested in how "not equipped" manifests itself in practice. That is: what is the actual behavior we see on the outside?

The story about the foster kid who gravitates towards abusive relationships is closest to the level of analysis I was hoping for. In that specific case, what is still unclear to me is exactly how -- in the details -- a lack of a stable/loving home pushes one towards abusive relationships

Do you perhaps have some anecdotes about specific people behaving in ways that well-adjusted people wouldn't? Speaking for the rest of us, I think it's hard to grok this kind of stuff without a lot of detail.

I recognize that this is a hard question to answer, of course. It effectively asks you to become a novelist. I'm grateful for anything you can provide, but also don't want you to feel obligated.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by whoknew1122 on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:44PM (#25829764)
What is the actual behavior we see? Higher incidence of domestic violence, drug abuse/dependency/violence. And much more.

It's hard to say definitive, concrete examples because trauma is so personal. The same things can cause two divergent reactions in other people. As a random example from a single friend, I had a friend whose dad died via suicide by cop after he became addicted to drugs he prescribed as a small town's ER doctor. She saw her dad murdered by her friend's father from her living room window. This friend said I had it worse than she. While I definitely have my own scars, I don't think they're anywhere close to what she experienced.

I'll share how I was ill-equipped for life. Please note that while I was never put in foster care myself, I likely should have been; the only thing that stopped me going into foster care is a terribly overburdened and underfunded Child Protective Services department. Every single one of the complaints alleged against my family (of which there were several) were true. The social workers and CPS department as a whole simply has too high a caseload and I fell through the cracks. For better or worse.

I never had anyone around me that modeled how to successfully handle stress and anger. So I constantly walked around in fight or flight mode for all of my teen years and most of my twenties. It led to more than a few of assaults (both as a profession--I bounced a bit--and otherwise). I also made many other impulsive decisions, because I only knew how to solve interpersonal problems one way.

It literally took me until I was in my early thirties and hospitalized with what I thought was a heart attack to figure out I had problems with anxiety, ultra-vigalence, and a hair-trigger temper with associated anti-social behaviors. That's how I was ill-equipped for life in normal society. And again I wasn't even in foster care like some of my closest friends and loved ones.

Just one of those times I let my fists do the talking for me could've led to someone geting knocked out, falling the wrong way, and dying after landing with their head against a curb. That's manslaughter (at best). It's blind, stupid luck that I eventually got my shit together and work at a FAANG rather than shooting you a kite from behind bars.

I have someone very close to me who did go into the foster care system, and was placed in what amounted to a juvenile jail. She had a 'bunkmate' who burned their entire house down in an attempt to kill her family. And then the bunkmate tried to burn others while in the foster care facility. Now my friend has troubles sleeping; especially in areas around which she's unfamiliar (e.g. hotels) or around people she doesn't know well (e.g. B&Bs, friend's houses, etc.).

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by omginternets on Monday January 18, 2021 @11:51PM (#25830123)
Thanks for this, it really helps give some perspective. It's incredibly difficult for those of us blessed with stable homes and happy childhoods to fully grasp the degree to which such things make us who we are. We can kind of intuit it, and it makes rational sense some of the time, but it's often hard to see the connection between e.g. "I had to pull my alcoholic mom out of a ditch" and "I'm fighting with people all the time". These two things feel disconnected, but it's clear from the literature and from stories like this one that they are not.

>It literally took me until I was in my early thirties and hospitalized with what I thought was a heart attack to figure out I had problems with anxiety, ultra-vigalence, and a hair-trigger temper with associated anti-social behaviors.

Out of curiosity, how does one get from this place to gainful employment in a FAANG company? I realize much of it has to do with luck, but surely there were a number of "stages" during this recovery/relearning process. Did you go to some sort of therapy? What were the major steps in becoming well-adjusted? For example, do you remember the first time you noticed your hair-trigger temper rising, and managed to get it under control?

>I bounced a bit

I actually did too! In my 20's I was very involved in my local MMA gym, and bouncing seemed like a 'cool' way to make some beer money.

All in all it was a pretty good gig for me because I actually had very little exposure to violence before then, and this was a way for me to confront a pretty severe aversion to conflict that I'd been carrying with me for some time. As a matter of fact, this was very much the reason I'd gotten into MMA to begin with, and bouncing was a way to move from an environment with highly-controlled violence (the ring) to a less controlled one (a bar where I had backup, and a technical advantage in a fight). I ultimately ended up in the military doing MOUT operations, but that's a different story, and I digress. My reason for bringing this up is that I remember being quite shocked and horrified at the unbridled violence in some of my colleagues. You basically had three types of bouncers:

1. Calm professionals looking to get the job done and go home

2. Cocky assholes looking to be the protagonist of a badass story, but nevertheless with some self-control

3. Tough-as-nails guys with zero self-control or ability to direct their violence usefully

I think I was mostly in the first category (though shamefully with about 30% of the second category ... I did have something to prove...). It was the third category that horrified me because it seemed like these people weren't even fixing to get into fights; they just couldn't prevent themselves from falling into a blind wrath at the slightest provocation. There's this idea in evolutionary psychology that the emotion of disgust relates to things that should be inside the body (blood, vomit, feces, saliva, etc) finding themselves outside the body. In that specific sense, I think I was disgusted by the third category of colleague -- this terrible, ugly rage that should have stayed inside was somehow spilling out. Quite a few of those guys ended up getting charged with battery over stuff they did on the job, and it all seemed so damn preventable and absurd.

I realize that I'm speaking with someone who may have been this third type of person, and I sincerely hope you don't feel judged. My reason for bringing it up is that I've never fully understood what was going on when these (otherwise super nice!) guys went off the rails. I always suspected there was something like what you described, but never managed to figure out when -- let alone why -- the switch would flip. It was truly terrifying stuff, even for someone who knows their way around a fight, because it all seemed so random and bestial. As an MMA fighter, I was used to clear rules about when the fight started and ended, but with these guys, I would worry that I'd gotten on their nerves without realizing it, and that I'd have a bottle broken over my head before I even knew the fight had begun.

In any case, I'm truly, honestly happy that you seem to be doing well, and I really appreciate this conversation.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by whoknew1122 on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @08:56AM (#25833410)
> "Out of curiosity, how does one get from this place to gainful employment in a FAANG company"

I was blessed with an above average intelligence. But I didn't have any role models. So it was really about figuring out how intelligent I am and comparing myself to people.

One of my more stable jobs was working as a gas station clerk. The gas station I worked at was one of the few in a more affluent, medical-oriented district. Lots of doctors, nurses etc. Most of them treated me like crap. And just listening to the way they talked to me I was like... these people really aren't that smarter than me.

So I was like what do smart people do? I have 0 family connections--I was the first person in my family to graduate high school--so I figured I'd go to college. That's what smart people do, right?

Went to community college (my high school GPA wouldn't have gotten me into any school with any sort of selection), and succeeded. Graduated with honors, etc. Then transferred to my state's flagship university. Studied something not related to computers.

Got out of school during the Great Recession. Struggled to find a job. Had a couple of other shitty, albiet generally better-paying jobs. Met someone who worked at a FAANG. We were talking and having a reasonably intellectual conversation about what they do, networking and the like. Asked them where they went to school. They said they never went to college; they just taught themselves.

I was like, really? You can do that? If they can, I can. I have a degree from very selective public university. Graduated with multiple sorts of honors. If I learned one thing, it's how to learn.

So I just started teaching myself Linux. Then networking. Then a bit of coding. Got a job helping a start-up-ish company migrate onto AWS. I was underpaid, but underpaid in that world is twice the salary (at least) than either of my parents made in a year collectively. Learned every day. A year later, a recruiter from AWS reached out. That was a couple of years ago now.

---

Your description of bouncing is spot-in. I was a mixture of 2&3. I learned to fight because I had no self-control. I had to learn it, eventually, out of self preservation. But my form of self-control was 'shut off your emotions until you feel dead inside. Then at least you're not a wrathful rage monster.' Not the most healthy strategy, but it's kept me out of trouble. I've gotten better, but still haven't shed a single tear in over 15 years.

---

> '"I had to pull my alcoholic mom out of a ditch" and "I'm fighting with people all the time". These two things feel disconnected...'

Yeah. They're really, really not disconnected. Someone who grows up in that life has no stabilizing influence. They never learn how to deal with problems or actually plan.

Also, a neglectful parent means that you probably got abused. By your parent, an associate of your parent, or both. Predators are really effective at looking at a family and finding a situation into which they can insert you. Then you got to deal with that trauma.

You're also more than likely to grow up in poverty, which comes with it a whole different set of bad habits and impulses.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by ashtonkem on Monday January 18, 2021 @10:44AM (#25822824)
Some of the amateur research we’ve done points to the idea that it takes a surprisingly small number of emotionally stable adults to help kids get through chaotic circumstances. If you read the testimonies from children from the foster system like you, or from children with mentally unwell parents, the ones that made it out ok always have some sort of story about how one adult in their life took an interest and helped them get through it. From what I’ve seen, teachers and coaches are the most common adult to help. Not peer reviewed stuff obviously, but the pattern is striking.

Anyways, glad you made it out of such a tough spot doing ok.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by robocat on Monday January 18, 2021 @03:16PM (#25826089)
> the ones that made it out ok always have some sort of story about how one adult in their life took an interest and helped them get through it.

How much time does that take of the person who is helping?

Also, from article, “Most of the $30 billion spent on child welfare annually is funneled into foster care or adoption services”, “Roughly 23,000 kids across the country are churned out of the system every year”.

That averages $100000 per child per year, assuming 300000 kids in care and all $30G spent on them.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by lazyasciiart on Monday January 18, 2021 @09:43PM (#25829399)
On any given day there are over 400,000 kids in foster care, and each year more than 600,000 kids will be in care for some amount of time. https://www.acf.hhs.gov/sites/default/files/documents/cb/afc... But when kids are adopted out of foster care, the majority will continue receiving some form of subsidy, including health insurance and often a monthly payment, so those kids are being covered by this spending as well.
Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by ashtonkem on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @01:24AM (#25830602)
> How much time does that take of the person who is helping?

It doesn't appear to be hours, although they help, but rather consistency over large periods of the child's life. In happier cases this is provided by parents and close family friends; teachers come and go and the family might move, but the parents provide emotional stability in the child's life. In less happy circumstances the issue is that some teachers and some foster parents might be great at what they do, but they only exist inside the child's life for a very short period of time.

Again, I am far from an expert here.

Re:We are sending more foster kids to prison than to college by candiodari on Monday January 18, 2021 @07:15PM (#25828398)
> That averages $100000 per child per year, assuming 300000 kids in care and all $30G spent on them.

Yes, and you'll find nearly all of that money is spent on employees and organisations, mostly for locating abused (and "abused") children, with most services paid per-child (and of course ALL services have to catch a minimum amount of children or cease to exist).

In the best of countries (not the US) in 60% of foster placements something bad enough happens that the foster family requests their immediate removal (this is called a "break-down"). The US is much worse. Foster care does not offer stability, so every kid has to be found a new foster home on average every 8 months.

https://wehavekids.com/adoption-fostering/What-does-being-a-...

$800 per month per kid is very well paid for foster care. All the other money goes to government services. The child receives, at most, $250 per month (in cases where they care for themselves).

Studies point out that if you take outcomes, it would literally be better (children helped vs children harmed) if these services just outright did not exist. But I guess the problem would be much more visible.

https://sci-hub.se/10.1257/aer.97.5.1583