News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by jimnotgym on Sunday January 17, 2021 @10:21AM (#25811367)
Since 2015 we have had all this clutter in the meeting rooms with different chargers, adaptors for monitors, projectors etc. In fact every mac user I know has a little hub to run everything! I'm currently using a Thinkpad and I have never felt that I had too many ports! I don't carry any adaptors.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by Daneel_ on Sunday January 17, 2021 @10:29AM (#25811436)
Exactly. I have a Lenovo P51 and I’m in the same boat. I have usb-a, usb-c, mini display port, hdmi and Ethernet on my laptop and don’t need to carry any adaptors. It’s glorious. I use all of them regularly.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @10:46AM (#25811605)
on site at a client fresh after they started upgrading people to USB-C/thunderbolt MBPs/Airs...

Very quickly meetings started with question of "who has a laptop with real HDMI/DisplayPort? We would like to start in 15s instead of 15 minutes of fighting with dongles..."

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by BlackFingolfin on Sunday January 17, 2021 @11:04AM (#25811784)
Anecdotes are not data. I can easily counter yours with mine:

I use such a dongle a lot whenever I am presenting on conferences etc, and have been doing so for many years (even before the all-out for USB-C/Thunderbolt on MacBooks, there were no VGA ports, while many projectors still were; now I see a lot of HDMI, but still need the adaptor).

And I habe yet to have a single issue caused by that! Sure, damaged VGA cables and other weirdness, but never ever anything tracing back to the dongle.

In the same time I helped lots of people who struggled with their laptops with builtin VGA/HDMI Granted, usually not the laptops fault but rather PEBKAC / or people not knowing how to control Windows / Linux. Doesn't really matter: my point is that I see zero correlation between dongle usage and projector troubles.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by phkahler on Sunday January 17, 2021 @11:39AM (#25812134)
>> Anecdotes are not data.

Yes they are. The singular form of data is datum, not anecdote.

A personal experience is a data point. A 2nd hand story may well be an anecdote. "I have this and use it for that" is very much data in this case.

Is it enough to make product design decisions? No. Should Apple throw it out as an outlier? I would argue no - to think one person is a special snowflake with a unique problem is a mistake too.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:40PM (#25812809)
HDMI to VGA conversion, even through displayport connector, is much simpler topic than properly handling USB-C feature negotiation, and as I mentioned in another comment, it was common for USB-C dongles to exhibit problems, especially on macOS (non-Apple branded dongles tended to have better success rate on non-mac systems, Apple-branded dongles were consistently problematic on everything).

Usual case was that with dongles, the display wasn't detected, at all, and having spent quite a bit of time fiddling with it, it didn't seem fixable.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by Godel_unicode on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#25813467)
My org has an entire batch of OEM USB-C to HDMI dongles which work great on Dell, Lenovo, and Microsoft laptops but will reliably cause Macs to crash and reboot within 5 minutes.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by JohnBooty on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:19PM (#25812562)

    Very quickly meetings started with question of 
    "who has a laptop with real HDMI/DisplayPort? 
    We would like to start in 15s instead of 15 
    minutes of fighting with dongles..."
I don't understand this.

There are plenty of arguments against against going all-in on USB-C and forcing people to buy/carry multiple dongles. I don't like dongles myself! I still use a (pre-USB C) 2015 MacBook Pro, partially for that reason. I greatly prefer common ports such as HDMI to be built right into the laptop.

But "15 minutes of fighting with dongles?" Even if there's some comic exaggeration here, I don't understand.

Of all my gripes with Mac laptop dongles, "fighting" with them is not on the list. They are as plug and play as it gets. No drivers, etc... I hate carrying them but they're not exactly difficult to use.

The only way I can imagine people "fighting" with dongles is if they were nontechnical users who had difficulties simply plugging a cable in.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:36PM (#25812769)
The reality was that quite often the dongles did not work properly. Using official Apple USB-C AV dongle (with USB-C, USB-A and HDMI) had people scrambling for "oh, maybe this one will work", screens randomly not displaying, etc.

I personally strongly suspect that they had a broken batch of dongles, seeing as how trying to use them on other systems often resulted in display detection issues too.

Then there was of course "oh, I forgot the HDMI dongle"/"Someone took the one that was in the meeting room" and so on.

The end result was that it soon become normal for people to push against updating the laptops.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by Godel_unicode on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:43PM (#25813515)
Apple dongles normally work really well, which combines with the RDF to make people not believe stories like this until it happens to them.

Paraphrasing what I said in another comment, dongles are flaky. If yours aren't, congratulations, but that doesn't mean other people are lying or that they don't know how things work.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:52PM (#25813633)
That's why I suspected they had a whole flaky batch - the dongles were too reliably not working for different case.

But your random non-technical person only faced the fact that the chances of quickly setting up a meeting went down if the presenter needed a dongle.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by pilsetnieks on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:47PM (#25812886)
Unless you happen to have a cheap 3rd party dongle, use 2.4GHz wifi, and have to have internet access while doing your presentation or whatever. (3rd party dongles often have bad shielding and it interferes with 2.4GHz signal, it's a pretty widespread issue. You cannot really "fight it," though, you need to get another dongle.)
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:50PM (#25812928)
Oh, I forgot the interference issues - those are very "fun" even for deeply experienced technical people.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by ricardobayes on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:52PM (#25812941)
Only companies with disfunctional IT departments who didn't bother to install streaming devices to the big screens.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by OkGoDoIt on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:38PM (#25813465)
I worked in multiple companies that used streaming rather than physical connections for meeting presentations, and they were always so much worse and less reliable than just using a cable, dongle or not. Best case scenario it worked but there was a several second lag. There were a few meeting rooms that had the old fashioned physical hookups and those were always fought after because at least they worked reliably.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by p_l on Sunday January 17, 2021 @02:06PM (#25813788)
The last reliably streamable setup I've seen involved Plan B, a system built on top of Plan 9, and it was far on the weird side of the universe.

Many "streamable" options often end up actually using HDMI dongles, if working at all. Or work with very limited set of systems (the weird apparently undocumented reverse-RDP for projectors in Windows, intel-proprietary streaming, etc.)

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by megablast on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:43PM (#25812840)
So it took you 4 hours to connect the projector to the hdmi port on your p51. My MacBook worked in seconds.

See what fun we have when we lie and exaggerate.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by csomar on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:36PM (#25812763)
Isn't this the reason to push for no more ports than the USB-C. After the Macbook become USB-C only, manufacturers started to move to USB-C instead of USB-A and some of them include an adapter.

The quicker we move, the better. It'll be a little painful at first, but then we'll have only USB-C for everything.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by OkGoDoIt on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:40PM (#25813489)
I’ve been hearing this argument for years now. Years of pain, and I still don’t feel like we’re any closer to this supposed future. Maybe it was a mistake?
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by totalZero on Sunday January 17, 2021 @09:42PM (#25817559)
I charge my phone on my laptop charger, and charge my laptop on my dock. When I want to undock my laptop, I disconnect a single cable. I have two monitors that can run off a phone or a laptop using just a USB cable (no power supply). I can even charge my MBP off a Lenovo charger without a second thought.

None of this was possible prior to those "years of pain." I personally welcome our USB-C overlords.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by llampx on Tuesday January 19, 2021 @03:20AM (#25831114)
Charging standardization is only a small part of what was promised via USB-C though.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by csomar on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:46PM (#25815324)
I think we just started. I was shipping for an external hard-drive recently and USB-C seems to be the new standard.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by xirbeosbwo1234 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:45PM (#25812869)
When I buy a computer, I want something that makes my life better. I do not want something that deliberately makes my life worse to achieve a strategic goal for Apple Computer.

We saw the same thing with Flash. Apple didn't like Flash and wanted it dead. They couldn't manage to kill it off through negotiation or outreach or by offering a better alternative, so they instead decided to weaponize the iPhone by refusing to support Flash at all. Their angry customers then killed Flash for them.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by numbsafari on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:05PM (#25813073)
They did offer something better: HTML5.

Don’t blame Apple for Flash’s demise. Blame Adobe. They allowed it to become the inefficient, security rats nest that it was.

The web is amazingly better now that Flash has been relegated to its best use: historical animations and games.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by behnamoh on Sunday January 17, 2021 @02:01PM (#25813726)
> web is amazingly better now that Flash has been relegated to its best use: historical animations and games

Is it though? All I see is millions of bloated websites that all look the same thanks to lack of Flash, and not much success with html5 to really replace Flash.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by xirbeosbwo1234 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:30PM (#25813387)
And HTML5 did not kill off Flash. People kept right on using Flash until Apple sicced millions of angry iPhone users on them.

I thank Apple for Flash's demise. I had no love for Flash. What I blame Apple for is treating their customers as pawns in a game. They sold their customers a broken product so they could gain leverage.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by csomar on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:45PM (#25815313)
Which was a net positive for the Internet? But this is not a companies' war, but rather a specs war (USB vs A bunch). Apple is not pushing for its own interests only on this one, but for the interest of everyone.
Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by xirbeosbwo1234 on Sunday January 17, 2021 @10:04PM (#25817675)
That is entirely irrelevant to my point. Apple used its monopoly power to make its users buy an inferior product so that others would have no choice but to adapt. How many of those users, given the option, would choose to buy a machine with no Flash support or with only one type of port?

It is, by the way, absolutely not a clear advantage to get rid of old ports. USB C is about five years old. It is absolutely ludicrous to claim that any peripheral older than USB C is obsolete. That goes double for audio equipment. I have decades-old equipment that is still excellent by modern standards, but Apple has decided it's got to go because the 3.5mm headphone jack is unfashionable. If I were an Apple customer I would have no choice but to throw out all my electronics every few years or carry around a suitcase of adapters.

Re:Apple's MacBook revival plan: Bring back old features by behnamoh on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:59PM (#25813713)
My thoughts exactly. I don’t want to sacrifice my own convenience for the sake of a company, which by the way, doesn’t even bother including a freaking adapter in their other product, the iphone.