News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by musicale on Saturday January 16, 2021 @10:40PM (#25807872)
Who knew that Apple would decide to use its DRM? /s

> Apple moving to block the unauthorized app installs isn’t necessarily surprising

> Apple has given [iOS] developers power to block their apps from running on the Mac — a power that is undermined by sideloading

Presumably it's a response to a) piracy/unlicensed use of iOS apps, b) developers who don't want to support macOS, and c) developers who want to charge higher prices to macOS users.

Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by rgovostes on Sunday January 17, 2021 @12:06AM (#25808314)
(d) Apple is trying to spare developers who haven't yet addressed the bugs that arise when running their apps, written for a different platform with a completely different user interface idiom, from being inundated with support requests and unhappy reviews.

I think the answer is a little from each column, but (c) has the strongest weight: some apps, say Cultured Code's Things and The Omni Group's OmniGraffle, are sold as separate Mac and iOS SKUs. Apple would damage their businesses if they allowed the iPad app run on the Mac without the developer approving it. I hope it becomes the norm soon, but we're in an early stage of the transition.

It wouldn't surprise me if someone figures out that they simply need to re-sign the binaries to run them, though.

Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by musicale on Monday January 18, 2021 @01:35AM (#25818876)
> d) Apple is trying to spare developers who haven't yet addressed the bugs that arise when running their apps, written for a different platform with a completely different user interface idiom, from being inundated with support requests and unhappy reviews.

That's an elaboration of what I meant by (b) and I think it's on target.

Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by thefounder on Sunday January 17, 2021 @04:22AM (#25809377)
>> Apple would damage their businesses if they allowed the iPad app run on the Mac without the developer approving it. I hope it becomes the norm soon, but we're in an early stage of the transition.

What about the end user who paid good money to own a computer and run whatever he wants on it?

Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by _qulr on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:35AM (#25809660)
> What about the end user who paid good money to own a computer and run whatever he wants on it?

You paid good money to Apple. You didn't pay good money to the app developer.

iOS app prices are ridiculously low because of the crap store "race to the bottom", which fortunately didn't affect the Mac as much. This is one big reason why Things for iOS is so cheap: the market demands it, not because it's magically cheaper for a dev to make an iOS app. If you take away the Mac-level prices for Mac apps, developers like Cultured Code might go out of business, and then you won't get either version of the app.

If Mac app prices start to go as low as iOS app prices, you're going to see almost all developers completely abandon writing native Mac apps, and then Macs might as well just run iOS instead. To forestall that possibility, Mac devs might abandon their much cheaper (or even free) iOS versions to avoid getting undercut by their own products.

Paying money to Apple for a Mac doesn't automatically license you to use third-party apps. That's not how it works legally.

Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by thefounder on Sunday January 17, 2021 @10:42AM (#25811566)
Yeah, sounds familiar..remember the DVD region codes?
Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by rgovostes on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:20PM (#25815731)
Those don’t bear any similarity to this situation. Region codes allow effectively the same DVDs to be sold at different prices in different markets. iOS and Mac apps are different products altogether; it takes twice as much effort to design the UI for mouse vs touch, write code to use both AppKit and UIKit APIs, etc.
Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by thefounder on Sunday January 17, 2021 @06:13PM (#25816251)
It's just DRM. Cut the bullshit!
Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by beowulfey on Sunday January 17, 2021 @06:49AM (#25809993)
If a developer didn’t write the application with the intention of supporting your expensive computer, then I think they have the right to block it from working on it if it can be done.
Re:Apple is blocking Apple Silicon Mac users from sideloadin... by rusticpenn on Sunday January 17, 2021 @05:21AM (#25809610)
As long as the developers are fine with it, it should be fine I guess.