News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by whiddershins on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:23AM (#25791231)
> It is caused by peoples' jobs not paying a living wage, coupled with high housing prices, making them one unexpected expense from being on the street.

I agree with much of your post but let’s be clear, leading with this can be misleading.

Fundamentally, homelessness centers around being unable, for whatever reason, to work.

Not around specific wages and rents, which I think makes this part a red herring.

We can’t solve homelessness by attacking several ‘root causes’ at once. The key here is to be absolutely candid about what the root cause actually is right now.

Edit: Your comment is using homelessness to critique capitalism, and is not actually about homelessness at all.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by elliekelly on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:27AM (#25791268)
There are many people in the US who are gainfully employed in fulltime jobs and homeless: https://youtube.com/watch?v=JHDkALRz5Rk
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by adamcstephens on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:46AM (#25791511)
This is a great video with some much needed outside perspective. Highly recommended.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by ModernMech on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:38AM (#25791410)
> Fundamentally, homelessness centers around being unable, for whatever reason, to work.

No, as the parent said, homelessness centers around the fact that homes cost money. There are all kinds of people in this country who have homes, sometimes many homes, and they don't do any work at all. Conversely, are you aware that many homeless people have jobs and they do actually work? “about 30% of … homeless people have a job” https://theconversation.com/factcheck-qanda-do-about-30-of-h...

As a society, we have the resources to say "Everyone should have a home, no matter what." We have enough homes. There are more empty homes in the US than there are homeless. So it's not even a case that we don't have the resources to end homelessness. We, as a society, choose not to.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by scott_s on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:44AM (#25791490)
Fundamentally, homelessness centers around being unable to maintain a home.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by quickthrower2 on Friday January 15, 2021 @10:23AM (#25791943)
The last homeless person I spoke to said it was because he couldn’t afford rents, they were too high.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by ahelwer on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:29AM (#25791292)
There will always be reasons, often outside of peoples' control, why they cannot make enough money to afford housing. Your solution to this is - what?

I believe that the fundamental necessities of life - shelter, healthcare, education (food, sure, but it is still relatively inexpensive) - should all be socialized to some degree. This can easily coexist with capitalism. Denmark has these things and is still a fervently capitalist country.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by whiddershins on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:34AM (#25791361)
Let’s say, for the sake of argument, the is some ‘socialization’ of housing, whatever that means ... but somehow everyone always has a place to live no matter what.

In that situation should we still be angry about minimum wage?

See, we are conflating things here.

Some people really can’t work and need help. At that point, as I said above, specific rent amounts and wage amounts become irrelevant.

You need to focus on: what will genuinely help them? Drug treatment? Mental Health treatment. A lifetime of free food and housing etc and the removal of any obligation to contribute to society forever?

I say none of this ironically. When someone simply can’t work, and no one else voluntarily want to take care of them, we have to figure out what to do. And how to distinguish between fakers and real. And between temporary and permanent. Partial and complete.

At that point there are so many issues, putting high rents and low wages in is literally a distraction.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by ahelwer on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:39AM (#25791426)
Why care so much about fakers vs. real? Just provide a solid base for living for everybody, regardless of economic standing. Stop making people jump through all these hoops to prove they really need help. This is the same animating principle underlying UBI, but I think UBI fundamentally won't be effective as long as it can be eaten up by rent, healthcare, and education costs which will rise to meet what is available.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by jakelazaroff on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:53AM (#25791599)
I think you and the others in this thread disagree on the actual problem, and as long as that is the case this will just be a debate of people talking past each other.

The problem you see is: something prevents some people from contributing enough to society to afford housing.

The problem others see is: some people do not have housing.

I am with the second group. In an era of unparalleled abundance, is it so crazy to provide for everyone’s basic needs without expecting anything in return? What is even the point of “society”, and our contributions to it, if not to make life better for everyone?

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by whiddershins on Friday January 15, 2021 @06:35PM (#25798104)
This mischaracterizes my point.

We agree on the problem: some people don’t have housing.

Second point: if some subset, which I say is the majority, of people who can’t afford housing are in this situation because they literally can’t work ...

Decreasing rent or raising wages does nothing to address this.

Since these are the most vulnerable people, I feel that bringing concepts like the imbalance between rents and wages actually muddies the waters.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by jakelazaroff on Friday January 15, 2021 @08:56PM (#25799166)
Aren’t you arguing against a straw man? No one is making the case that the ultimate solution is lowering rent or raising wages.

If we agree that’s the problem, can we then agree on the simplest solution? Give everyone housing, with no conditions or strings attached.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by whiddershins on Saturday January 16, 2021 @07:27AM (#25801811)
No. I’m replying to a comment purporting to be about helping the homeless that is in fact a critique of capitalism.

It isn’t smart or effective to mix the two. Pick one, and maybe something can get accomplished.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by jakelazaroff on Saturday January 16, 2021 @12:17PM (#25803615)
That doesn’t make any sense. You can’t discuss a socioeconomic problem without also critiquing the society and economic system within which it exists. Any discussion about homelessness within a capitalist society is necessarily also a discussion about capitalism.
Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by whiddershins on Sunday January 17, 2021 @01:12PM (#25813162)
No. It’s not. Because homelessness is primarily a health problem not a monetary one.

And also, every were the problem primary economic, it doesn’t necessarily follow that capitalism is the problem, it could be bad or corrupt policy that is straightforward to change without diving in on reforming capitalism.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by SamoyedFurFluff on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:51AM (#25791574)
Every test you have between “fake” and “real” candidates for a program introduces waste and reduced participation by “real” people.

See: every single means tested program in America like disability benefits or SNAP. Hell, my state is throwing out vaccines right now because of this.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by ModernMech on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:53AM (#25791600)
> A lifetime of free food and housing etc and the removal of any obligation to contribute to society forever?

I don't understand this point you made? Are you saying that if someone was receiving food and housing they would no longer be obligated to contribute to society? I think that would make them more obligated to contribute, seeing as they are getting food and housing out of the deal.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by s5300 on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:41AM (#25791464)
Nations that claim to be civilized are mostly judged by how they care for their most vulnerable citizens/inhabitants.

If you feel otherwise, feel free to campaign for that throughout your life... don't be surprised if most people think you're a dick for it though.

Re:Books helped South African man overcome homelessness by stallman_is_ok on Friday January 15, 2021 @09:47AM (#25791522)
Homelessness and other poverties is consequence of capitalism. 'Winner takes all' system causes many of loser to have nothing.