News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Thursday January 14, 2021 @05:44PM (#25783931)
These massive websites/broadcast SMS cannot have it both ways.

They cannot seek the protections of being "critical infrastructure" of any sort, common carrier, public forum, etc. and then, at the same time, disable user accounts for any reason just like any other private website.

They have to pick one or the other. The arguments I am seeing online are folks who have chosen one or the other and are arguing from their chosen perspective. For example, I am content to see them as just another handful of private websites, no matter how large they have become.

Meanwhile, the companies themselves, like Twitter, are content to bask in this ambiguity instead of clarifying what they are or intend to be.

EDIT:

Once the number of users has grown past a manageable threshhold where violations of rules can be detected by administrators (instead of relying on others to report them), it may cause some to wonder what are the reasons absent any legal or other compusion when a user's account is suspended.

Looking at the Twitter rules, the possible reasons this account may have been suspended, e.g., copyright violations, are not obvious. What is their justifcation for suspension. Some sources, e.g., The Verge, are reporting that this Twitter account was being used to solicit statements of support from academics to be used in some litigation in India that seeks to block access Sci-Hub in that country. Apparently the Indian court denied the initial request from publishers for an immediate decision in order to allow time for the scientific community to weigh in on the issue.

I hope someone is setting up another means for the scientific community to weigh in on the non-monetary value of Sci-Hub.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:17PM (#25784389)
> These massive websites/broadcast SMS cannot have it both ways. They cannot seek the protections of being "critical infrastructure" of any sort, common carrier, public forum, etc. and then, at the same time, disable user accounts for any reason just like any other private website.

It's never been proposed that platforms like Twitter become common carriers. That designation was intended for the layer beneath them, ISPs.

I agree that allowing that layer, ISPs, to effectively monopolize content via regional monopolies and ever-growing media conglomerates is problematic. Now they're implementing zero rating in broadband and that means there's a high bar for starting the next Netflix, Twitter etc. If you're not already part of that club you'll have to be super wealthy or take on huge debt from existing tech/wealth dominance just to get your foot in the door.

We really need to encourage competition at the ISP level in order to allow for competition among services like Twitter.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by konjin on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:50PM (#25784808)
And ISPs were not common carriers until they were. It was only meant for the layer underneath them: telcos. The world changes and we should not be stuck with the technology of the 80s until the end of time.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by takeda on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:33PM (#25785260)
actually they were from the start, or more accurately telcos were required to provide their lines for ISPs.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by konjin on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:47PM (#25785396)
Actually isps weren't common carriers until 2015 and aren't again today: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2017/12/14...
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by takeda on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:03PM (#25785547)
They were until 2003 when they were classified as information services. The FCC then enforced net neutrality rules by penalizing ISPs whenever they broke them until 2014 when court ruled that if ISPs are under Title I, the FCC has no control over them. In 2015 FCC reclassified them back as Title II, in 2017/2018 Pai reclassified back to Title I, but multiple states (I know that at least California and Washington) implemented their own net neutrality laws.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:52PM (#25785441)
And since 2015 social media platforms have had no real competition.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by takeda on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:10PM (#25785604)
I used Facebook in 2006 and it already was taking over MySpace. I don't know where you got 2015 from, because how ISPs are treated has no impact on social media.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:40PM (#25785824)
2015 came from the parent comment. I'm saying the current tech platform powers got a lot stronger in the last 4 years.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by root_axis on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:09PM (#25785020)
Websites are not common carriers.

>What is their justifcation for suspension.

I don't see why they should need a justification. Just because something is popular doesn't mean people should be entitled to it. It makes no sense that an arbitrary MAU count suddenly rescinds the property rights of the people who pay money to keep the servers running, as well as to develop and maintain the software. Further, I don't see any benefit to society in policies that might encourage social media use, and speaking economically when these large platforms boot people off it actually increases competition and decreases their dominance because it creates a market opportunity for competitors, exactly like what happened with Parler. Suddenly, nobody seems to care that a conservative competitor to AWS is getting a huge account, shouldn't that be pereceived as a good thing? Why are the people who get banned so insistent on using services they claim are inherently unfair to them? Why not support companies that share your values?

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by FillardMillmore on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:24PM (#25786191)
> Suddenly, nobody seems to care that a conservative competitor to AWS is getting a huge account, shouldn't that be pereceived as a good thing? Why are the people who get banned so insistent on using services they claim are inherently unfair to them? Why not support companies that share your values?

Just spitballing here, but doesn't it seem that with the way things are going, Twitter/Facebook will become a silo for those who hold more left-leaning views and Parler/Gab will become a silo for those with more right-leaning views? I understand that there are some who only want to see their preconceived notions reinforced, but for those who are actually interested in an open dialogue and open discussion, aren't we losing something important if this is the result? It would certainly cause an already polarized populace to become more polarized, would it not?

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by dagw on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:39AM (#25790230)
Twitter/Facebook will become a silo for those who hold more left-leaning views and Parler/Gab will become a silo for those with more right-leaning views

Most right leaning politicians have no problem at all being active on Twitter and Facebook and the vast majority of people who describe themselves as "more right-leaning" want absolutely nothing to do with the sort of people or ideologies that where prevalent on Parler.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by root_axis on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:54PM (#25786419)
Politics is just a small part of twitter, the overwhelming majority of twitter content is music, sports, entertainment etc, so a potential silo effect isn't much to be concerned about. Most people just don't engage in politics on social media because it's a soul draining exercise and generally not time well spent unless you're a political junkie that enjoys exchanging barbs with friends and strangers online. So is it possible some of the conservative political content on twitter might wane? Sure, but that's just a fact of life, some communities online just lean a certain direction. Finally, conservatives are not in exile from social media, just about every prominent conservative has an active twitter account with millions of followers and there are millions of conservatives posting all over twitter right now and this is something that can be trivially verified. The bottom line is that none of this is a big deal, it's politics flavored tabloid gossip.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:41PM (#25785841)
100%. By the same token, however, despite how Section 230 has come to be interpreted, I think these companies should be held responsible for the user-generated content they publish. They should be publishing their own content not acting as middlemen, providing a so-called "platform". All in the interests of surveillance and selling advertising services.

Telcos and cable providers provide access to the medium, i.e. the internet, whereas the web is just one protocol that allows internet users to publish. Having websites with 100s of millions of people posting to them is no substitute for peer-to-peer protocols (private communication) or websites owned by news organisations that employ journalists (publication).

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by root_axis on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:17PM (#25786140)
In my view we should leave Section 230 alone, instead we should target the true incentive of bad behavior: the ad model. If it were illegal for companies that collect PII and track users across 3rd party sites to sell ad space on their platforms, all these companies would have to switch to a subscription model like Netflix, shifting the economic incentives to favor user retention rather than advertiser appetites. This means companies lose money when they ban people rather than make money by cutting their losses on viral bandwidth that's too toxic to monetize through ads.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Thursday January 14, 2021 @09:48PM (#25786363)
Sounds good to me. And what is the gratuitously complex instrumentation by which all of these companies collect personal data and track users: the so-called "modern" web browser. Authored by, you guessed it, companies who rely on advertisers. They purport to do many other things, wonderfully idealistic and technically impressive things, besides supporting web advertising. Those alleged pursuits seem to keep everyone distracted from their raison d'etre: Make money from advertising.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by curryst on Friday January 15, 2021 @01:17PM (#25794086)
> Just because something is popular doesn't mean people should be entitled to it.

We have generally acknowledged that things that are important to everyone and are monopolized need to be regulated.

Social media is practically the only effective way to participate in the global community. The same is true, although with decreasing necessity, in more localized communities.

Facebook and Twitter have massively altered the way that people engage with other people, businesses, even the government. They took public discourse and monetized it. That's fine, but they now have to deal with the implications of being the keepers of public discourse, and I think a reasonable stipulation for allowing them to monetize that is that they cannot bar someone from participating without a very good justification that isn't "lol our ToS allows us to cut you off whenever we want, and take your first born child".

> speaking economically when these large platforms boot people off it actually increases competition and decreases their dominance because it creates a market opportunity for competitors, exactly like what happened with Parler. Suddenly, nobody seems to care that a conservative competitor to AWS is getting a huge account, shouldn't that be pereceived as a good thing?

Sure, and what happened to them? It's a little ironic to argue that booting people off of their platform increases competition and then mention their new competitor that was immediately wiped off the face of the internet.

I think Parler attracted a lot of extremists. That's partially their own fault with their poor moderation, but it's also a reflection that Twitter has so dominated the marketplace that your only customers as a new social media site are going to be nutjobs. It has strong anti-competitive effects. The community is a huge part of a social media site. Crazy users poison the community, ensuring that the brand is tainted and not a threat to Twitter.

> Why are the people who get banned so insistent on using services they claim are inherently unfair to them? Why not support companies that share your values?

Because you'd be better off writing it on bathroom stalls.

Because there is no meaningful competitor. Even Parler was tiny by social media standards, and it's probably dead now.

Because your friends and family want to use Twitter, and probably won't switch, so you have to use Twitter and Facebook.

Because Facebook and Twitter have spent so long maximizing engagement that people barely bother looking for other sources of news and information.

I'm not a huge fan of Parler or the way it was run. It does seem damning that the only app that threatened to take some of Twitter's market share was immediately scrubbed off the internet. I don't think ISIS material gets completely wiped off the face of the internet that fast.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by root_axis on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:56PM (#25796337)
> We have generally acknowledged that things that are important to everyone and are monopolized need to be regulated.

Social media is not important, it's an entertainment triviality on par with online gaming. Further, big tech does not monopolize online communication by any definition of the word, twitter and facebook are one of many thousands of ways to communicate online, and most internet users use a variety of platforms as using one does not preclude the ability to use another. Additionally, I'm not saying these companies shouldn't be regulated, check my reply in the sibling thread, what I'm opposed to is the violation of property and first amendment rights by forcing these companies to pay for hosting content they disagree with.

>Social media is practically the only effective way to participate in the global community

Totally false. The "global community" such that it exists on the internet is spread across many hundreds of thousands of applications, sites, and communities.

> they now have to deal with the implications of being the keepers of public discourse,

No, your reasoning here is completely backwards. The fraction of people who willingly choose to participate in public discourse on these sites have to deal with the implications of choosing to use such sites. There are many alternative options available.

> It's a little ironic to argue that booting people off of their platform increases competition and then mention their new competitor that was immediately wiped off the face of the internet.

No. Parler moved to a new hosting platform called Epik the same one that hosts Gab and others, this is a business opportunity for Epik created by the fact that AWS did not want to do business with Parler, this reduces AWS's dominance in the market.

> it's also a reflection that Twitter has so dominated the marketplace that your only customers as a new social media site are going to be nutjobs.

Not true. The reason that Parler attracts extremists is because it was designed to attract them. There are many other platforms that don't have this issue

> The community is a huge part of a social media site

Social media sites do not own the community, they can visit as few or as many different social media sites as they want and its trivial for them to do so.

> Because there is no meaningful competitor.

Totally false. Discord, tiktok, mastadon, pinterest, twitch, vimeo, tumblr, irc, medium, soundcloud, wordpress, blogger ete and that's just off the top of my head.

> Because your friends and family want to use Twitter, and probably won't switch, so you have to use Twitter and Facebook.

That doesn't matter. If your friends use a platform that you want to use then follow the rules of the platform and you'll have no problem. A lot of my friends communicate over Steam chat, that doesn't mean Valve owes me anything - it's an entertainment triviality.

> Because Facebook and Twitter have spent so long maximizing engagement that people barely bother looking for other sources of news and information.

This is false, but even if it were true, anyone who gets their information exclusively from social media is to blame for their own media consumption habits.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by takeda on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:30PM (#25785235)
you are mixing up net neutrality and a platform.

Net Neutrality ensures that ISP do what the name says, providing Internet service without interfering with it, like restricting which sites you can visit.

A platform like twitter, facebook, parler. Is something that was created from scratch and is owned by these companies. As of now it's not their duty to allow everyone in. And enforcing it is stepping on their freedom.

Someone here or on reddit, suggested that perhaps the government supposed to provide such public platform. That's an interesting thought, because at that point I would agree that if such things would happen there such complaints would be justified.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:26PM (#25785725)
If U.S. government provided a platform, then these "free speech" claims might have a basis in law. IMO, the issues would be easier to grapple with.

Instead these enourmous websites are filling what is now an obvious void in public services for communication.

Perhaps I should not have used the term "common carrier" as that term has very specific meaning, and only in certain jurisdictions. What I mean is common carrier-like treatment by the public. People talk about these websites as if they are public services. Messenger apps are treated like they are interchangeable with telephone service.

Practically speaking (i.e., how they are being used in practice), maybe, but beyond that I refuse to see them that way. These are not anywhere close to public services, IMO.

Even the trend of websites that we would otherwise see as "public websites" containing "public information" that urge visitors to create "accounts" or "profiles" and "log in" is a disturbing evolution to me, blurring the line between public and private websites. Traditionally, a website that is protected by a password is not "open to the public". If "accounts" are required then disabling the account can disable "public access". Accounts can be disabled for any reason.

Of course, that trend is probably driven by the commercialisation of the web as an advertiser's wet dream.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:55PM (#25786826)
> If U.S. government provided a platform, then these "free speech" claims might have a basis in law. IMO, the issues would be easier to grapple with.

Having the government provide the platform would create a huge burden on one entity to moderate content. Any mistake would be magnified 1000x what they are now. It would end free speech as we know it and would be very expensive.

Instead we encourage businesses to moderate their own content and compete for a userbase. That allows platforms to evolve on their own dime with incremental changes that satisfy their respective userbases.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by catlifeonmars on Friday January 15, 2021 @01:14AM (#25787603)
That would work if the interests of social media platforms are aligned with the interests of its users, but that is not the case. Rather, social media platform interests are aligned with their monetization vectors. This is a classic agent problem.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Friday January 15, 2021 @02:56AM (#25788161)
The point here is to expand the number of social media sites from the handful we have to several more rather than collapsing them into a single state-owned entity.

And, we can't just snap our fingers to make that happen. True competition comes from separately owned, competing services.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:23AM (#25788330)
A superior outcome would be OTT peer-to-peer communication, with small groups of peers forming their own mini-networks potentially linking with others if there is mutual interest. The massive groups that form via today's internet do not reflect human nature in the real world. People usually are only part of small groups, family, friends, colleagues, teammates, etc. People usually keep the groups isolated from one another, for the most part. The internet has been hijacked to become primarily a broadcast medium that serves the interests of advertisers, marketers, promoters, etc., those who deal in hype, and a relatively small number of companies (middlemen) that enable them. The hijackers all want internet users to join large groups that can be targeted through a central point with commercial/political mesaging.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Friday January 15, 2021 @04:28AM (#25788751)
Maybe. Make it happen and let's see but I wouldn't put money on that. Everyone can't hold the ledger like btc

It's not a conspiracy that a handful of platforms dominate it's simply flawed regulation targeting the wrong incentives.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by nathias on Friday January 15, 2021 @02:36AM (#25788070)
Platforms have been exempted from being sued for content as they were claiming neutrality and now that they are monopolies bigger than most countries they are starting to employ their own moderation and censorship. We should either break them up and make competition possible or enforce their neutrality.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:01PM (#25785525)
> perhaps the government supposed to provide such public platform.

Nah, inviting the government to moderate these platforms is the last thing we want. It's bad enough there are only a handful of them, we definitely don't want all that power under one person's control.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by takeda on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:12PM (#25785616)
I agree, personally I think POTUS and other government officials should even be banned (not by twitter but by law) to officially uses such private forums.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:37PM (#25785802)
Nah that would put incumbents at a disadvantage against their competition.

And, forcing them to use more official accounts like @POTUS might give existing office-holders undue advantage.

I think drawing the line at inciting violence is proper. We do need more competition at the platform level and I think this comes when we establish a competitive environment among ISPs and content conglomerates by reinstating net neutrality and discouraging regional broadband monopolies.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by raxxorrax on Friday January 15, 2021 @03:29AM (#25788369)
Twitter wants to be relevant infrastructure and ironically Trump gave most way to that.

Personal opinion is that the best solution would be to dumb Twitter for any discussions, but especially political ones.

Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by fuzzfactor on Saturday January 16, 2021 @11:28PM (#25808127)
If the headline read Twister Shuts Down Twitter I wouldn't miss it.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by stjohnswarts on Thursday January 14, 2021 @06:52PM (#25784833)
I can't agree. It's their platform and they can leave up what they like. When someone starts advocating violence, treason, assassination then they can shut down that account. Also in national emergencies (like our current one with right wing extremists) it is also justified. I don't want section 230 undone, it will do far more damage than good.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by Mountain_Skies on Thursday January 14, 2021 @07:12PM (#25785056)
Who did Sci-Hub advocate for assassination? What violence did they try to incite? What treasonous act did they commit? This conversation is about twitter nuking Sci-Hub. I understand the events you are referring to but you cannot use them as justification for actions like suspending Sci-Hub.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by unityByFreedom on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:04PM (#25785552)
There probably is some Twitter-backed research on sci-hub but that's not the point. They can lawfully ban whoever they want as long as the basis is not race, sex etc.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by ssakamoto on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:11PM (#25785609)
Sci-Hub Is a PRIVATE Company. They can ban who they like. Period.
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by apple_innocent on Thursday January 14, 2021 @08:47PM (#25785889)
Sci-Hub is a company?
Re:Twitter shuts down account of Sci-Hub by colejohnson66 on Friday January 15, 2021 @07:19AM (#25790069)
Probably meant Twitter. Sci-Hub is not a company.