Yes. Ultimately we have no choice but to trust trust itself.[a] That said, if the OP were a non-technical friend asking me the same question, I would respond more or less like this:
"Of all the widely used messaging services, Signal is the only one known to be designed to minimize the amount of user data needed to operate, and all indications are that they are operating as designed[b], so Signal is likely your best choice today if privacy is your main concern."
[a] http://users.ece.cmu.edu/~ganger/712.fall02/papers/p761-thom...
edit: after a quick algolia search, it has indeed been posted much more this year than years before.
Does that help in any way to verify that they do not store data on their servers?
Someone please correct me if I'm wrong.
Edit: That being said, I believe they could still record IPs, as well as the destination and timestamps of each message.
It protects signal from hackers or a malicious datacenter provider at best.
> SGX enclaves also support a feature called remote attestation. Remote attestation provides a cryptographic guarantee of the code that is running in a remote enclave over a network.
> Originally designed for DRM applications, most SGX examples imagine an SGX enclave running on a client. This would allow a server to stream media content to a client enclave with the assurance that the client software requesting the media is the “authentic” software that will play the media only once, instead of custom software that reverse engineered the network API call and will publish the media as a torrent instead.
On the contrary, if you answer the same to WhatsApp, it plain refuses to work. But it actually created an account on their servers, and from that on you appear on your contacts who do use WhatsApp as another user of WhatsApp, which invites them to write to you there although you cannot receive their messages. To fix this, you have to find the option in WhatsApp to delete your account.
Tally:
Signal 1 WhatsApp 0
Is (b) achievable by all users who have this concern?
What we do know is that programs like Telegram have to store data about users on their servers, by design. A big difference between the two projects is that Signal is carefully designed to minimize the amount of data the service needs to operate; it's why identifiers are phone numbers --- so it can piggyback on your already-existing contact lists, which are kept on your phone.
By contrast, other services store, in effect, a durable list of every person you communicate with, usually indexed in a plaintext database.