News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by mattnewton on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:57PM (#25721196)
Assuming you are referring to the current wave of private censorship in the wake of the storming of the US capitol, I think it’s a false equivalence.

Here people are arguing this looks like monopolistic behavior (that the law attempts to make illegal); and there people were arguing for allowing de-platforming (that the law could be read as encouraging to limit the liability of the platform). This analogy erases the nuance that might make one desirable to society and the other undesirable.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by WindyLakeReturn on Sunday January 10, 2021 @09:14PM (#25723455)
>This analogy erases the nuance that might make one desirable to society and the other undesirable.

Could you explain the nuance then? In recent days I've found this explanation often used and generally in ways that I am not convinced of. In many cases, the arguments being presented are done so without any concern for nuance, so I find it hard to expect someone to understand nuance that wasn't originally included in the argument. I get this is largely a result of people only presenting a summary of their argument (as I find any writing to be a summary as words convey less than thoughts contain).

Especially since we are not talking about legal action the government is taking to ban something dangerous enough to society to be illegal, but a private business choosing to ban something because they choose to do so.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by mattnewton on Monday January 11, 2021 @12:04AM (#25724769)
It’s possible the other people were implicitly saying private companies should be free [to not publish someone’s speech]; I can’t argue on behalf of all the other people you have talked to.

But I can say that to me these are just different situations. It’s not contradictory to think that companies should be free to not associate with individuals for their brand, but should not be free to buy ads impersonating a competitor, or blocking links to a competitors products. The phrasing of companies should be free to do X doesn’t carry over to a different issue.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by MikusR on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:09PM (#25721324)
Signal is used for unmoderated encrypted communication. Facebook is just removing a link to service that allows hate speech and calls to violence. :)
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by SuoDuanDao on Sunday January 10, 2021 @09:00PM (#25723316)
Seems some people don't like what they see in the mirror.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by mattnewton on Monday January 11, 2021 @12:27AM (#25724941)
Or they don’t appreciate flippant replies.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by folli on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:45PM (#25721032)
Copying my comment from another thread:

I'm getting slightly fatigued with this point of view ("X is a private company and can do what it wants").

If a company reaches a certain size and has a quasi-monopolistic position so that other people or companies depend on it, it starts to have some degree of responsibility towards society that's beyond value maximization for shareholders.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by tomc1985 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @09:14PM (#25723449)
As an idealists who repeats the "private companies can do what they want" perspective, I agree fully. But this is the legal situation, and asking companies to take any kind of moral stance is going to be an uphill battle.

Whatever future we want, we are going to have to push for it legally. Because right now management can be replaced if shareholders don't like what they're doing, given that shareholders are their only legal obligation here.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by quadrangle on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:19PM (#25720710)
Your comment could be read as suggesting that private companies are above the law.

I assume you mean just "this particular sort of anti-competitive behavior is legal because it's all within their private service".

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by godelski on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:57PM (#25721191)
More importantly it would mean the link previews aren't e2ee. ,,BUT'' I cannot reproduce the error.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by fsflover on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:06PM (#25720563)
Not if they are a monopoly.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by mhh__ on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:28PM (#25720817)
Unfortunately they operate in the US so they can't

https://youtu.be/gRelVFm7iJE

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by newbie578 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @05:59PM (#25721214)
Well played. It is their platform, I don't see a problem in what they are doing. If someone doesn't like it, then use a different one.. (that is the narrative, right?)
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by vlovich123 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:51PM (#25721848)
By that logic WhatsApp itself offers the same feature set and should be deplatformed.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday January 10, 2021 @07:37PM (#25722431)
I think this is the point. Going after, not the people actually making a call to violence, but some service three degrees upstream from them -- along with all of its other legitimate users -- is madness.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by WindyLakeReturn on Sunday January 10, 2021 @09:17PM (#25723487)
Yes, but a private company does not have to be consistent in how it applies it standard. One could even argue the standard is consistent but more complex, something of a difference between 'ban app that allows bad things' and 'ban app that allows bad things which we don't own', though this gets into the nature of what is consistency, arbitrariness, and hypocriticalness.
Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by vlovich123 on Sunday January 10, 2021 @10:38PM (#25724121)
It's muddled by the fact that the largest tech companies have been known to enter into secret (sometimes anti-trust violating) agreements. For all we know the other companies have an agreement to deplatform apps like Parler in the name of "free speech" but just to make sure that one of the big tech companies is dominant in a given space.

I'm not saying I think such an agreement exists in this latest spat of deplatforming. I am suggesting that that's the kind of conspiracy theories such capricious & unprincipled stances take (& yes - they are unprincipled given how much it depends on which political party is dominant when they go to do something).

A more benign framing of the conspiracy is that the tech companies desperately want to avoid any trust-busting activities by Congress so when the right is in power they don't do anything about right-wing extremism letting it grow & conveniently when the left is in power they deplatform right wing extremism that has grown, making legislators more anxious to enact any kind of regulation (just like the BS that MPAA played with ratings to avoid getting regulating).

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by WindyLakeReturn on Sunday January 10, 2021 @11:24PM (#25724492)
>A more benign framing of the conspiracy is that the tech companies desperately want to avoid any trust-busting activities by Congress so when the right is in power they don't do anything about right-wing extremism letting it grow & conveniently when the left is in power they deplatform right wing extremism that has grown, making legislators more anxious to enact any kind of regulation (just like the BS that MPAA played with ratings to avoid getting regulating).

If we accept the 'private company' argument as it has been recently presented, then even this falls under it as an acceptable outcome. I am not making an argument saying we should either reject or accept it was presented, only that if we were to accept it, this is a conclusion of the argument.

Re:Facebook buying ads for Messenger to be top result when y... by Ekaros on Sunday January 10, 2021 @06:04PM (#25721269)
Or build your own... I wonder have we entered in new standard. How long will any new competitor last? Will the Signal soon also see it's end?