News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by offtop5 on Friday January 08, 2021 @12:32PM (#25687203)
As long as I can Bill my hours, I don't care all that much.

I find smaller or more experimental companies to be much more unstable, and in my thirties I just want something stable and nice so I can save money and retire with a bit over a million in the bank at 40.

Just want to be done with it

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by xienze on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:52PM (#25689430)
> in my thirties I just want something stable and nice so I can save money

Shoot, the article yesterday had me searching for how I can apply to Gumroad on top of my day job. They were claiming $50-250 per hour with as little as 10 hours a week. You want to save money? Have a stable day job and work at Gumroad for 10 hours a week. With such a short work week I can't imagine you'd be doing much more than simple bug fixes. I can swing 2 hours of that a day.

> retire with a bit over a million in the bank at 40.

You might have to set your sights a little higher. That's not gonna carry you to potentially 85 years old.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by bravura on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:05PM (#25687640)
If you retire at forty with a million in the bank, how do you make it if you live till 80?
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by CleverLikeAnOx on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:14PM (#25687752)
There is an idea called FIRE (Financial Independence / Retire Early). The first half is having enough money to not need to earn again, so you are not dependent on work or others. Once this is achieved, then you can retire early if you would like.

The conventional wisdom in this community is that if you invest a sum of money in equities, you can withdraw a certain percentage annually without ever running out of money. That is, you mostly live off of the growth of your investments. Generally, 4% (inflation adjusted) is considered a safe withdraw rate. So if you have a million dollars, and you can live off of 40K a year or less indefinitely, then you can retire.

Obviously this is a simplification and there are more considerations. Let me know if you have any questions. This is a topic I am passionate about and happy to give my 2 cents on.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by war1025 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:26PM (#25687902)
I'm pretty well versed in the whole FIRE thing, and find myself more or less on that path.

One conclusion I've come to is that after people "retire early", they almost never actually stop making money. It just tends to end up being more entrepreneurial stuff that they make money off.

You don't "have to" work, but you "might as well", and all the sudden you may even find yourself in a more lucrative gig than you started with because you changed your focus and found a niche you can fill nicely.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by offtop5 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:37PM (#25688074)
I'd love to have free time to pursue other hobbies like working on video games, and making music. If I had the million dollar cushion, and then maybe I only made like $500 or $600 a month with my hobbies that would be awesome.

Life is too short to do anything else in my opinion. unless I guess I end up with a family but that's not really in my plans

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by hinkley on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:46PM (#25689335)
Wooing a client isn't so different than pursuing a romantic partner in this way. When you don't 'need' something from someone, you are easier to be around. Your personal qualities aren't being overshadowed by your agendas.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by stocknoob on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:50PM (#25688361)
Yep. The type of person who gets a high-paying enough job (and has the discipline) to save $1M usually doesn't have trouble getting extra work if they want. But now there's no pressure, they can take "fun" gigs that couldn't have supported them previously (musician, librarian, teacher, etc.).
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by jandrewrogers on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:42PM (#25689285)
A reasonable investment portfolio (in the US) will reliably generate enough inflation-adjusted growth on average that this will afford a modest lifestyle in most parts of the US. $35-50k/year (today's dollars) without much risk, which is a fairly average wage. It is only unrealistic if you live in an expensive city with a lavish lifestyle.

Anecdotally and ironically, many tech people that do this end up making a loads of money after they "retire". They don't sit on a beach and do nothing. The ability to be highly selective about what they work on, and to defer any compensation, often leads them to invest all their time on software projects they are passionate about, which not infrequently ends up throwing off a large amount of incidental income even though that wasn't the objective per se. I like the term "recreationally employed" to describe this lifestyle. I know many engineers who ended here and some of them make more money "retired" than they did work the 9-to-5 grind at a big company.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by offtop5 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:29PM (#25687951)
Move to a country where I can live off the 40k -> 60k a year an interest or whatnot.

This basically means either Southeast Asia, or some parts of Latin America. Asian languages tend to be extremely hard, and it might be a lot easier to sort of blend in with the populace in Latin America. The last thing I want to do in my retirement is draw needless attention to myself.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by war1025 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:38PM (#25688102)
> Move to a country where I can live off the 40k -> 60k a year an interest or whatnot.

You realize the median US household income is like $40k/ year right?

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by pvarangot on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:49PM (#25689384)
With $40k a year you can live with the rich in some Latin American countries, if you can also spend 250k/350k on buying your own place in a high rise with private security or a gated community. You won't have access to Amazon and be able to buy all the top notch gear for your new hobbies in a week like as a tech worker in the US, but you can have a nice house with cleaning staff, a nice car or just take Uber or private cars everywhere, and do fancy dining two or three times per week.

The median American household doesn't have all this luxuries.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by offtop5 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:41PM (#25688151)
Yeah but I'm not trying to struggle in America, so cómo estás ¿
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by kingnothing on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:48PM (#25688306)
You can also live just fine off that amount in most American cities. $40k is basically $2,500 / mo after tax.

In the Atlanta area for example, there are plenty of nice 2-3 bedroom houses for $200,000 or even less, which puts your mortgage at $1,000 / mo. That leaves $1,500 / mo for a car, utilities, and food, which is plenty doable. Rent out a room if you want to for more income.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by citizenpaul on Saturday January 09, 2021 @12:11PM (#25702139)
1k a month? Good luck with that.

https://www.zillow.com/mortgage-calculator/

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by kingnothing on Sunday January 10, 2021 @01:24AM (#25711360)
You aren't making any sense.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by citizenpaul on Thursday January 14, 2021 @10:16AM (#25777258)
Put in the numbers you suggested to the calculator. The only way you are getting under 1k month mortgage is if you have 20% of your down payment. I think the stats are something like 90% of homebuyers don't even put down 10% of the cost in down payment.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by gnicholas on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:08PM (#25688714)
How does this work if you have kids that will be going to college when you’re ~50? That is, how do you know at 40 how much you’ll want to spend on your children’s college education?
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by mooreds on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:52PM (#25689427)
> That is, how do you know at 40 how much you’ll want to spend on your children’s college education?

It's hard to figure how much to save for kids college, because the spectrum is so wide. For example, do you plan for the worst case scenario (ivy league, no scholarship or out of state state school, no scholarship) -- $250k and climbing.

Or the best case scenario (they take tons of ap courses and courses at local cc until transferring their jr year to in state school with full tuition scholarship) -- ~$20k?

Maybe try to aim for the midpoint? It's a hard problem.

What I've read that mad sense to me, though, is that kids can borrow for college and you can't borrow for retirement (reverse mortgage notwithstanding).

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by offtop5 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:25PM (#25689021)
At least my plan assumes I won't have a family. Kids make this nearly impossible. While I can up and move to Costa Rica tomorrow( assuming their wasn't a pandemic ) , you can't exactly just tell your wife and kids to pack it up( and expect to remained married).
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by kingnothing on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:28PM (#25690000)
Either you keep working to pay for their education, or you tell them to take out loans like most families, or you live in a state that pays for education. Georgia, for example, has the HOPE scholarship which pays for kids with good grades to attend public colleges at low or no cost as long as they keep their grades up.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by Bedon292 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:35PM (#25689181)
If you have kids, and want to help pay for their college education, a 529 plan or other custodial type account (UTMA/UGMA) would be a good choice. I would not want to take that out of the funds you are trying to live on.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by watermelon59 on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:04PM (#25688649)
Health and dental insurance can be a huge cost though.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by kingnothing on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:31PM (#25690046)
Healthcare can definitely be expensive and you'll need a plan for that until Medicare kicks in.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by sgerenser on Friday January 08, 2021 @11:28PM (#25696984)
ACA actually makes health insurance very cheap if you can control your income (I.e. retired and living off investments). My in laws were paying a couple bucks a month for a Silver plan, I think it’s up to $100-$200 now. ACA subsidies do not take into account wealth, only adjusted gross income.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by war1025 on Friday January 08, 2021 @03:44PM (#25690213)
I have a dream that someday America will get its head out of its ass and decouple health insurance from employer benefits.

That would change the employment calculus for a ton of people.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by hinkley on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:50PM (#25689399)
Most people who get rich get that way by saving money. That means living on less money than you can make. Indefinitely.

If you want to get sucked into every ad campaign that comes along, you'll end up broke even if you get a huge windfall. Which is in fact exactly what happens to many lottery winners, sports stars, musicians, child actors...

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by Viliam1234 on Saturday January 09, 2021 @04:14PM (#25704827)
> Which is in fact exactly what happens to many lottery winners, sports stars, musicians, child actors...

I suspect the problem of sport stars et cetera is that they have to focus most of their time on their career, thus most don't have time to learn about finance (and not being from rich families means they can't simply copy the strategy of their parents), but it is publicly known that they are rich, and there are scammers who specialize on exactly this kind of victim. That is, I suspect that many sport stars will at some moment of their life meet a "financial advisor" with references from fellow sport stars, who offers to take care of their finance, and they go "lucky me, now I can focus 100% on my training", only to find out later that the money is gone.

To get rich, you need two different skills -- one to make money, and one to keep it -- and they both compete for your time. If you only focus on being good at what you do professionally, you may see lot of money flowing through your hands, but the part that you don't spend will somehow disappear anyway.

> Most people who get rich get that way by saving money. That means living on less money than you can make. Indefinitely.

That's true, but it is much easier to save money if you already started with a large amount. With enough starting money, it simply means not spending more than the interest you get (after adjusting for inflation).

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by groby_b on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:47PM (#25688292)
You assume that a million generates $40k to $60k, inflation-adjusted, for the next 40 years?

I suppose that's one assumption to make. You know that the last time the US GDP grew more than 4% was back in 2000, right? And 2010 worldwide? Both with a continued downward trend since at least the 60's?

(This obviously doesn't preclude >4% ROI, but that in turn means increasing income inequality, and at some point, there's a price to be paid for that)

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by edoceo on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:06PM (#25688670)
It's not about GDP, it's about Equities - eg: SPX which averages like 10% growth over last 30 years or something. Getting 4% off $1M isn't that hard at all. And with $1M you may be able to get some portion to work higher yields.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by groby_b on Friday January 08, 2021 @08:16PM (#25694394)
Equities don't keep growing indefinitely without underlying economic growth, and GDP represents that economic growth. There is no immutable law that SPX needs to keep growing 10%.

It has been outpacing GDP because increasingly, production is being concentrated in fewer, larger companies. So right now, they are growing. There are limits to that growth if GDP isn't growing as well - there are only so many smaller companies you can put out of business.

This - investing into SPX, or VFIAX, or any other market aggregate - is a viable strategy in the face of unlimited growth. It's a reasonable mid-term strategy. It's entirely unclear that there will be unchecked economic growth for 40 years. In fact, there's very good reason to assume there won't.

As for "get some portion to work higher yields" - those yields carry risk. They're not just making you more money, you stand a better chance to lose money, too. Which in turn means much less return, even if you manage to maintain 4%.

And to make matters worse, you're timing dependent - if you'd invested $1M in 1999, you would've been back to $1M in 2012. Except, if you'd lived off it for those 13 years, you'd be down to half your initial investment, ~$480K.

FIRE is a high-risk strategy. I'm not saying it can't work out, but over 40 years, there are a lot of things that can happen, and most FIRE proponents have very small safety margins. The crux is that that doesn't seem particularly problematic in your 20s and 30s - worst case, you start again, right? Except "start again" in your 50s, 60s, 70s is a really sucky proposition.

Ultimately, everybody takes their own risks, but let's not underplay those risks.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by edoceo on Friday January 08, 2021 @09:12PM (#25695422)
Folks keep saying lots of logical things like this (for decades). And yet TSLA p/e is 1800.

And there are a dozen TSLA on the horizon.

And the market keeps making new ones.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by bawolff on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:08PM (#25687678)
A million in bank is like $35,000 a year in interest. Not an extravagant lifestyle, but certainly possible to live comfortably on that in a low cost of living area if you have low expenses.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by atwebb on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:10PM (#25687710)
Where are you getting low risk 3.5% interest these days?
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by ptmcc on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:42PM (#25688182)
It's an average inflation-adjusted expected rate of return over time of a balanced portfolio, not a guaranteed rate every year. Some years might be 10%, some years might be -10%.

Historically, about 4% is the safe drawdown rate. FIRE folks tend to be a little more conservative than that, though, because of the even longer time horizon involved with retiring earlier.

Check out a tool like https://www.firecalc.com/ that is designed to run backtested simulations to see if your drawdown rate from your starting assets would historically be safe for your time horizon. The UI is clunky but the math is good.

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by atwebb on Friday January 08, 2021 @02:17PM (#25688859)
That's fair, I'm pretty familiar with FireCalc and the withdraw rates, I wasn't in the right frame of mind (are any of us?) but that makes sense.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by CleverLikeAnOx on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:15PM (#25687770)
I think the 3.5% number is not for low risk investing. Additionally, you would need to make something more like 5.5% to account for inflation. Still a fairly conservative number for investments in equities.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by ptmcc on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:44PM (#25688226)
The oft-quoted 4% figure is accounting for inflation. The nominal average return of a balanced portfolio over time is more like 7-8%.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by dbjacobs on Friday January 08, 2021 @06:30PM (#25692069)
FYI, the oft-quoted 4% figure was derived using a 30 year retirement time horizon [1]. Using longer time horizons will lower that number. [1] - https://financiallyfinanced.com/posts/will-bengen
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by Mauricebranagh on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:56PM (#25688491)
In the UK My ISA portfolio is yielding at 3.2 from when I last did the sums - this is ignoring any capital gains.

Its a mix of some big Investment Trusts some wealth protection like Personal Assets RIT and Capital Gearing and a few more speculative bets

Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by CabSauce on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:08PM (#25687676)
Interest and live on <$50k/yr?
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by spurdoman77 on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:04PM (#25687631)
This is sane way to think. There are awesome workplaces out there. Whether you have a shot getting employed there is another question.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by fcardinaux on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:00PM (#25687584)
I wish I had thought it that way when I was in my thirties.
Re:Ask HN: Which companies work like Gumroad? by mmkos on Friday January 08, 2021 @01:08PM (#25687688)
How did you think in your thirties?