MST isn't necessarily great because over an HBR2 link it doesn't have the bandwidth for dual 4k60, and there's still a lot of stuff that doesn't support HBR3 links. And MST + hotplug is still a mess. So you're just trading for a different set of confusion.
I just started with this configuration two days ago, so we'll see. It's not completely glitch-free yet: I noticed the mouse (also plugged into the TS3+) glitched a bit yesterday, and once one of the monitors couldn't be detected from the XPS once and required reboot. XPS also shows a low-power charger warning in tray when plugged into it, which I wish I could disable but oh well. Still, it's worked way better than I'd expected so far with no hassle. Completely replaces my desktop setup and hot-swaps are generally seamless.
I haven't noticed any major CPU or power spikes. Fan isn't doing anything weird. But I'll look out for it.
[1] https://www.amazon.com/OWC-Thunderbolt-3-Dual-DisplayPort-Ad...
Just my experience. Hope other haven’t had those issues.
I also tested an HP G2 Dock [1], because its dual-DP ports gave me more options, only to find that macOS can only use those two ports as Mirrored to each other.
Apparently [2], this is because the HP G2 implements its two DP ports as DP1.4 MST (Multi-Stream) on a single link, and in that mode macOS will only support a Mirrored configuration. It cannot (as of Big Sur 11.1) use them as separate displays.
I'm told you can also use the HP G2 with separate displays by plugging one monitor into one of its USB-C outputs, kind of like how I'm using the CalDigit TS3. I tried the one labeled USB-C (DP), and that stayed mirrored, but apparently I should've tried the Thunderbolt downstream port instead. I returned the dock before I knew or could try this.
All this to say, I'm disappointed by the mess of an ecosystem that Apple has built around Thunderbolt 3. But I can't say I'm surprised.
[1] https://store.hp.com/us/en/pdp/hp-thunderbolt-dock-120w-g2
[2] https://medium.com/@sebvance/everything-you-need-to-know-abo...