News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mikem170 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:17PM (#25653645)
Aren't buses better then subways for most places, given their lower costs and greater flexibility? Isn't this true for most of Europe, also? Or does the typical mid-sized city in Europe have subways like London, Paris, and NYC?
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by corty on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:00PM (#25653933)
Busses are very slow compared to any subway. Even with dedicated lanes (which is costly and unpopular) they still need to go around obstacles like buildings, follow the roads, yield to pedestrians, pull into stops, etc. Speed limits need to be obeyed as well.

Compare that to a subway that just goes below most obstacles in a straight line, travels at >80km/h and usually has no places to yield whatsoever. Fast travel in a predictable way, independent of traffic, weather, whatever. Maybe rush hour will make getting into the subway a little slower, but that's about it.

Subway is far superior to everything, including trams and trains for urban environments. It is expensive to build however, which is why in Europe it is usually supplemented with trams and busses for outlying routes or to fill the gaps between tunnels. Flexibility is rather a minus actually, because it leads to bus routes being subject to "snaking" through neighborhoods to satisfy the occasional political whim. Planted 5 trees and a bench? Call it "Mayour Mueller Park", add a bus stop with a 5min detour. Lather, rinse, repeat. Subways are somewhat immune to that.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by vmarsy on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:20PM (#25654032)
> Even with dedicated lanes (which is costly and unpopular) they still need to go around obstacles like buildings, follow the roads, yield to pedestrians, pull into stops, etc. Speed limits need to be obeyed as well.

In this case, Buses can drive in the underground tunnels that were built for this subway, can't they? Seattle did it for many years until they replaced it with trains: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=etT_wVuKy_I

In that case, the only thing slowing down the bus is speed limits, which are probably a bit lower than a train, since train would be safe on rails, but still I wonder why they didn't use that given that the tunnels are here and in good condition

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by munk-a on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:37PM (#25654128)
I'm a bit confused what benefits buses have at that point - you would need to dig a dedicated subway tunnel (and maybe spend additional to widen the tunnel so that buses can navigate it more easily) so you're out all the construction costs - you're just using a vehicle that has the ability (which you've now restricted) to more freely change routes... one that probably suffers higher maintenance costs over subway cars... and one that might be more difficult to electrify.

I think running buses in subway tunnels is just someone's creative idea to attempt to sabotage having reliable mass transit so that ridership doesn't get too high and they can argue that the whole program should be cut a few years down the line.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by vmarsy on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:05PM (#25654284)
> you would need to dig a dedicated subway tunnel

The tunnels and their exits next to interstate highway already exist per the article, so at this point the construction costs are assumed to be negligible (compared to a "$2.6 billion and take thirty years to build" system quoted in [1])

it would be used exactly like it was in Seattle: as a shortcut through the city for some routes. The bus retains all its advantages outside the tunnel, it's basically an underground dedicated bus lane.

If really popular then it can get upgraded to a real train, like it was done in Seattle.

[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cincinnati_Subway

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by supertrope on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:16PM (#25654017)
An interesting in-between is a transitway (bus only road). Very nearly as fast as a subway due also only stopping at stations and only being delayed by other mass transit vehicles. Obviously cheaper than tunneling or elevated railways if the land is available.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by corty on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:53PM (#25654216)
That would be a no-go in most of Europe. Cities are too dense, so there is just no land available for that. And even if it were, land prices are high enough that tunneling costs start to look cheap.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by ginko on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @03:32AM (#25655764)
>That would be a no-go in most of Europe. Cities are too dense, so there is just no land available for that

Bus/Taxi-only lanes are pretty common actually.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by xxpor on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:35PM (#25653770)
>greater flexibility

This is actually a negative. Build a train, and it's really hard to move. This actually spurs investment. A bus line can be taken away with the stroke of a pen.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by kube-system on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:54PM (#25653896)
Train lines can be discontinued quite easily as well. And it's more wasteful when it happens.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by howlgarnish on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @09:32PM (#25654091)
Abandoning subway lines is virtually unheard of, which is why this article exists in the first place.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by kube-system on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:49PM (#25654483)
Many light rail systems discontinue or change portions of their system. It doesn't happen often in underground sections because those are usually built only in the densest portions of a city which would tend to have high ridership.

I think it's more the tunnel that makes these lines less likely to be discontinued, rather than the train. Tunnels are just expensive to move whether they're for trains or for busses.

For example:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Defunct_New_York_City...

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by eropple on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:36PM (#25654700)
Most subways are heavy rail, not light rail. And, as you note, underground subways rarely go away--particularly after the age of multiple competing lines, often redundant.

All save one of the defunct lines in NYC went defunct because they were demolished for other stuff--because they were elevated or at-grade lines. (The one underground line that went defunct was split into three lines in active use today.) Putting it underground definitely increases political and budget survivability.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by supertrope on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:44PM (#25653827)
Lower upfront capital costs. At a higher level of passengers per hour labor costs of needing one driver per bus start to dominate. 70% of mass transit operating cost in developed countries is staff. A train can have many cars but only one operator. Buses use existing roads and the increased wear of a 35,000 lb vehicle on roads is part of another organization's budget (notice bus stops use concrete instead of asphalt). Methods of improving bus service like more drivers and buses to reduce wait time, and dedicated lanes bring up the cost.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mikem170 on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:49PM (#25653860)
That makes sense. And above-ground tracks also make sense as some other replies mentioned, less capital costs.

Maybe driver-less buses would be a new sweet spot? Maintain detailed road maps for the driving software instead of tracks?

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by vagrantJin on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @10:01PM (#25654260)
> Maybe driver-less buses would be a new sweet spot? Maintain detailed road maps for the driving software instead of tracks?

Would be a political nightmare. One of these autonomous busses hit a passenger and it becomes a policy nightmare. Public control center gets hacked, its a technical nightmare.

To problems like this, sometimes the solution isn't tech.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by lazyasciiart on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:56PM (#25654783)
No - bus routes are ephemeral. People won't build businesses and apartment buildings near them, or arrange their lives around them unless the city is blanketed in frequent bus lines (which is a huge investment itself). Because a bus route can be changed in a day, they don't have the attraction of a subway station that is going to be there no matter what the budget looks like.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by chrismcb on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:23PM (#25653686)
Pretty much every city in Europe has some sort of train service. Maybe a tram system, or a metro/subway, or just regional train service.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by kumarsw on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @08:51AM (#25657695)
A lot of people are disagreeing with you, but subways are extremely expensive compared buses and only make sense for capitols or very large cities. Public transit must match the city. Mid-sized cities like Nice or Denver will have light rail systems. Smaller cities like Boulder will have buses. Buses get a stigma in North America but they are good because the initial cost is low so it's easy to get routes with the magical <= 15 minutes between buses which is needed to attract "casual" riders.

Something no one brought up is the recent-ish idea of bus rapid transit (BRT), which solves the problem of not having exact change, because who does these days? BRT gives some of the advantages of rail like fare machines and dedicated right-of-ways. Albuquerque (which is far too small for a subway) just put in its first line.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by mikem170 on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @05:57PM (#25663864)
Buses are also stigmatized by many in the U.S. as being for poor people, aka losers who can't afford cars.
Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by p_l on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @11:12PM (#25654598)
Honestly? At least in Poland, I get the feeling that most cities would jump on having a subway, the problem is getting it started (as for various reasons Poland isn't exactly flush with investment capacity)

Some built other alternatives to buses or shared-grade trams, for example by putting fast local trains under same ticket system (train-based local transit was very popular in UK till Beeching Axe, too), others experiment with things like separate-grade trams - cheaper than proper train-line, but still achieve separation from car traffic.

Because the same thing that gives buses flexibility and cheap start, is the thing that makes the biggest problem - sharing space with car traffic.

If there's a traffic jam, buses stop too. If something takes out part of car infrastructure, the dedicated lanes might be lost for a time, too. When Lazienkowski Bridge burned down in 2015 in Warsaw, figuring a connection that allowed one to take train or subway became crucial, as previously very fast buses (bus/taxi lanes!) would give me a commute longer than commuting from Amsterdam to London by train.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by graeme on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @08:27PM (#25653709)
They often have above ground trams that go down the middle of the street and/or share space with cars.

Buses too but they’re not as dominant as in north america. Trams are generally quieter, prettier and less obtrusive. And with quite frequent service. Also easy to know your way around without knowing the routes as they’ll have lines on a map.

Re:Cincinnati is home to the largest unused subway system in... by adrianN on Wednesday January 06, 2021 @12:57AM (#25655002)
The transport capacity of busses isn't even in the same ballpark as the capacity of a subway. Subways (and surface rail) are the most capable mass transport system we have by a very wide margin. Busses only make sense to close gaps in the train network.