News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sci-Hub: Scientists, Academics, Teachers and Students Pro... by silexia on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:38PM (#25648217)
I agree with everything you said here pretty much. The way I would address the problem is to perhaps outright get rid of patents, limit copyright to 5 years, eliminate any ability to copyright software, and allow for trademarks as that is just the identifier for a specific brand.
Re:Sci-Hub: Scientists, Academics, Teachers and Students Pro... by namibj on Tuesday January 05, 2021 @12:48PM (#25648391)
Yes, patents stopped fulfilling their societal contract decades ago. I do no think anything critical necessarily relies on them being a thing.

As for copyright, though.... a large part of the downsides lie with having to do bookkeeping and such. I'd argue for a total elimination of copyright, only keeping some very basic anti-plagiarism clauses (don't copy and then claim it was you who did it). They have to rely on intent, however. Accidentally reciting a joke and thinking you came up with it has to be very far from the grey zone.

Trademarks are a vehicle for reputation and trust in a market, see e.g. how you can't buy poor quality tools branded "Knipex", or how Samsung is know to not employ overly deceptive branding/advertising for their portable flash media, along with being known for at least decent reliability.