News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by quasse on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:19PM (#25619389)
Meanwhile the backwards state of Wisconsin has a special extra tax for hybrid vehicles, and then an even larger extra tax for electric vehicles [1]. The justification was that hybrids don't pay their "fair share" of fuel taxes - but it's not like I see the state government putting a huge tax on diesel fuel to tax the heavy trucks that actually are causing road wear. [2]

[1] https://wisconsindot.gov/Pages/dmv/vehicles/title-plates/fue...

[2] https://streets.mn/2016/07/07/chart-of-the-day-vehicle-weigh...

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by tbihl on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:22AM (#25619720)
Road maintenance has to be funded, and will be done in a way that avoids change and angering people who actually care (when change becomes necessary) while being at least a hypothetically good faith effort at fairness. So you shouldn't expect to get tolls (people who drive a lot will care more, plus wealthy suburbanites are more likely to fight this) or weight-based registration (no one drives more than truckers...)

So "hey, those guys stopped paying their share" can be passed,and that's what happens.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by dawnerd on Sunday January 03, 2021 @01:59AM (#25620114)
Oregon is doing the same too, but based on fuel economy. It's ridiculous that someone with a gas guzzler will pay less. It's the wrong move to transition us to alternative fuels.
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by kortilla on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:34AM (#25620249)
That only sounds ridiculous if you don’t realize that fuel is being taxed to pay for roads and not for its externalities.

Up until the last 10 years, it wasn’t feasible to use the road with a heavy vehicle without burning fuel so it was a shortcut to put road tax on the fuel instead of tolls everywhere.

This is why farmers use red dyed diesel that has the tax excluded. They are still emitting just as much but aren’t wearing down the road.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by estaseuropano on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:21AM (#25620893)
Money is fungible. Don't confuse a narrative/explanation with actual use of funds. Cars cause a lot of externalities and likely the tax is still too low, but it would be naive to think the funds collected one way are exactly used for an earmarked purpose.
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by throwaway201103 on Sunday January 03, 2021 @01:58AM (#25620105)
Trucks pay a lot of taxes, both in fuel and otherwise. True everyone who uses diesel pays those fuel taxes, but the number of diesel passenger cars in the USA is so small that it can be ignored.

In 2016 commercial trucks paid $18.4 billion in federal highway user taxes and $21.6 billion in state highway user taxes[1]

[1] https://www.ccjdigital.com/heres-how-much-trucking-paid-in-h...

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by ProfessorLayton on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:50AM (#25620322)
Commercial trucks may be paying more taxes nominally but they are not paying for the road wear that they cause. A commercial long-hauler causes 1,408 times more damage than a passenger vehicle. Even something like a garbage truck is 1,279x worse [1].

What can’t be ignored is the level of subsidies being offered to heavy vehicles.

[1] https://www.lrrb.org/pdf/201432.pdf

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by lazylizard on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:27PM (#25619443)
that implies that electricity is unfairly undertaxed.

solution is to tax electricity not 1 of the uses of electricity?

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by quasse on Saturday January 02, 2021 @11:35PM (#25619484)
I guess I'm not quite following, especially since any electricity used by a non-plugin hybrid vehicle is generated directly from gasoline.

If the goal was truly to "fairly" tax road use, registration fees should be based on vehicle weight and not fuel type.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by overscore on Sunday January 03, 2021 @04:27AM (#25620699)
Axle weight and mileage, surely?
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by pengaru on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:02AM (#25619614)
Not that I'm anti-EV, but it's probably worth noting that EVs like Tesla's are both heavier and more torquey than the average ICE econobox. They might be causing more than their fair share of road wear. Especially considering you can treat every stop as a drag race in relative silence.
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by brianwawok on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:16AM (#25619683)
Road wear is like cubic? With vehicle weight. Would take 10000 Tesla’s to wear the road the same as one truck.

https://streets.mn/2016/07/07/chart-of-the-day-vehicle-weigh...

If you want to EV tax me for road wear fine. Please tax trucks at least 1000x, and please tax all gas burning cars for the lung cancer and other negative externalities they cause.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by akira2501 on Sunday January 03, 2021 @01:02AM (#25619878)
> Would take 10000 Tesla’s to wear the road the same as one truck.

Did you consider the weight for the full vehicle, or per-axle? The per-axle figure is the relevant one and would probably flatten that figure out quite a bit.

They are also much more stringently enforced on commercial transportation vehicles, which require annual inspections and serious preventative maintenance to pass which does already add to the cost of operating these vehicles.

Their per-mile consumption is higher as well, which aside from being bad for the environment, already means they are consuming much more fuel and paying a higher tax as it is.

> tax all gas burning cars for the lung cancer and other negative externalities they cause.

Transportation, on the whole, accounts for 28% of greenhouse gasses... but it also enables the society that we live in and our own personal mobility within it. Electricity is nearly the same at 27%. You can shift the source, but you cant eliminate greenhouse gas from our way of life.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by ByteJockey on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:25AM (#25619728)
Yeah trucks are subsidized because without them most populated areas wouldn't have food, and people tend to like food.

Also basically every every other material good.

I think people would probably scream pretty loud if food suddenly jumped in price 10x, but maybe we could handle it like most places handle sales tax? Exempt trucks carrying food/necessities and tax everything else.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by Wowfunhappy on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:15AM (#25620179)
> Yeah trucks are subsidized because without them most populated areas wouldn't have food, and people tend to like food.

The cost of transportation should just be included in the good. That way, if someone comes up with an ingenious new method of urban farming or something, they'll get rewarded in the market for cost savings.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by vkou on Sunday January 03, 2021 @01:45AM (#25620059)
Most trucks don't deliver food.

And if that sort of tax policy would severely impact the cost of food, we'd be better off with direct subsidies for groceries.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by guerby on Sunday January 03, 2021 @03:22AM (#25620435)
A Volkswagen PASSAT is pretty similar in size with a Model 3 SR+ and weights ... the same.

https://www.lacentrale.fr/fiche-technique-voiture-volkswagen...

=> length 4.78m, weight 1635kg

https://www.lacentrale.fr/fiche-technique-voiture-tesla-mode...

=> length 4.69m weight 1612kg

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by pengaru on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:06AM (#25620834)
Comparing AWD to RWD seems hardly fair, but you have a point; all modern cars are heavy pigs.

The dual-motor AWD variant Model 3 comes in at 1847kg (4072lbs), which is pretty damn heavy for a car in my NA Miata-driving book.

Also no PASSAT is going to rip sub-4s 0-60 launches from every stop.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by guerby on Sunday January 03, 2021 @05:28AM (#25620922)
Note on the weight comparison: AWD EV do have two or more motors (I've not seen models with only one motor but may be I missed one). AWD petrol cars only have one motor, just more transmission axes/gearboxes, so little impact on weight.

AWD model 3 does have a 50% bigger battery though.

Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by adrianN on Sunday January 03, 2021 @12:13AM (#25619665)
If you want to tax according to wear, almost every car is pretty much free and trucks become insanely expensive. Road wear is something like axle weight to the fourth power.
Re:France Hits Record 19.2% EV Share in December – Up Almost... by dawnerd on Sunday January 03, 2021 @02:00AM (#25620121)
At least here, those tiny cars are also the ones running studded tires in Portland when we rarely get snow let alone ice where studs are needed. That absolutely is destroying our roads but we don't seem to care to tax them more.