News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by raziel2701 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @05:52PM (#25598126)
I mean, the 21 million cap is just a line of code no? No reason why if enough people agree to it they could just print more. Or they could fork and print more no? I find it strange that people speak of bitcoin's scarcity as if it were a physical thing.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by sunshinerag on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:06PM (#25598274)
It isn't as simple as that. Not only have you got to change that line of code, you need to convince all users of bitcoin to run that version of the code including miners. Otherwise you have forked the coin and you might be the only user of it (your version is incompatible with the rest).
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by glitchc on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:14PM (#25598350)
You don’t need most to agree. Just the basic majority (50%+).

And of course that’s exactly what the major mining consortiums will do: Collude to increase the limit when it’s reached. After all, the rewards are in the mining, not the transaction fee.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by gruez on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:09PM (#25598888)
The miners aren't the only ones enforcing the limit, so is every other bitcoin node out there. Just because you have 51% of the mining capacity doesn't mean everyone else (merchants, users, exchanges)[1] will agree. If they decide to unilaterally change the block reward all that would do is cause them to mine worthless blocks.

[1] https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Economic_majority

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by corty on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:02PM (#25600036)
No, miners are far more powerful than all the other stakeholders. While acceptance by merchants is a relevant factor, miners also have to facilitate any transaction. Any fork without miners is instantly unable to transact, making the coins useless and therefore worthless.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by gruez on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:04AM (#25601009)
>Any fork without miners is instantly unable to transact, making the coins useless and therefore worthless.

The incentive structure discourages this. If half the hash power goes off to mine Bitcoin Infinite (the fork with uncapped Bitcoin generation), then mining the original Bitcoin would be twice as lucrative because there's half the competition. This gets better the more miners leave. If 95% of miners leave for Bitcoin Infinite, then mining Bitcoin becomes 20x more lucrative. There's the matter of the difficulty adjustment, but that has been historically dealt with using emergency difficulty adjustments.

Meanwhile, the miners who are mining the fork have real expenses (electricity, equipment), which need to be paid, and if there isn't sufficient demand for their Bitcoin Infinite coins, they'll quickly go bankrupt. Some napkin math:

* If the hash and economic power are both split 50-50, then there will be little impact in profitability, but also little impact on Bitcoin

* If 90% of the mining power goes to Bitcoin Infinite and only 25% of the economic power follows them, then the miners can expect to see a 72% drop in revenue. If their original profit margins were 20%, they can expect their profit margins to drop to -66%. If we use the price/generation rate of just prior to the last halving (May 2020), then that would represent a loss of $9.9M per day (not including opportunity costs/lost profits).

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by glitchc on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:23PM (#25604798)
The incentive structure falls apart once Bitcoin original runs out of blocks to mine. That’s the starting point for this discussion.

The only incentive to mine then is to earn the transaction fee. These fees ($8) are currently orders of magnitude smaller than the mining reward of 6.25 coins ($125,000 at $20,000/coin). Either fees have to dramatically compensate by rising stratospherically or miners will depart for greener pastures. Yes, difficulty level drops eventually, but by then a large number of users have also followed miners off the network, in which case the price will drop too. As the price collapses, there will be a selling frenzy, further reducing the price. In this scenario, Bitcoin may settle to something as low as $10 per token.

Once miners depart en masse, network resilience will drop precipitously. That makes it an attractive target for someone to stage a coordinated attack, which would destroy remaining residual trust in the network and bringing about the end of Bitcoin original.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by rafaelero on Thursday December 31, 2020 @11:30PM (#25600866)
This is not true. Bitcoin can proceed with half its miners or with 3/4 its miners with no consequence aside a decrease in its resilience to attacks.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by everfree on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:16PM (#25599632)
> You don’t need most to agree. Just the basic majority (50%+).

This is a common misconception about how consensus works. Everyone on the network has to agree, anyone who doesn't agree by definition won't be on the same network. They won't be able to receive the same fork of bitcoin that everyone else is sending.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by glitchc on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:14PM (#25604729)
On the contrary: Consensus is defined precisely at 50%+, not 100% as you imply. In Bitcoin, the longest chain wins, therefore any chain with 50%+ support of the total mining power will inevitably end up with the longest chain.

Forks are occurring all the time at the apex of the chain. They wither and die slowly as 50%+ miners accept successive blocks as the next block. That’s why most exchanges and users wait for six blocks on average to deem the transaction settled.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by yunesj on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:33PM (#25598537)
> You don’t need most to agree. Just the basic majority (50%+). And of course that’s exactly what the major mining consortiums will do

You don't need anyone else to agree to start mining your own fork / altcoin. However, even if most of the miners change the protocol, it doesn't mean that the users will.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by glitchc on Friday January 01, 2021 @12:24PM (#25604818)
Sure, but my coin isn’t worth $20,000. Or even $2.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by latchkey on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:25PM (#25598449)
The transaction fees are extremely relevant to miners, it is currently the icing on the cake, but will become more relevant over time.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ve55 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:06PM (#25598269)
Getting most people to agree to such a fork is likely impossible
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by guidovranken on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:29PM (#25598488)
It has happened before. Ethereum Classic is the "original" version of Ethereum, but it's a nondescript altcoin, while the one that reversed transactions is the number #2 in the world.

I don't see why that can't happen to Bitcoin if the network participants (ideally normal users but practically the miners) and major stakeholders can benefit from it.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by scotty79 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:37PM (#25599180)
They won't benefit because that will tank the price like nothing else.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by ve55 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @08:47PM (#25599905)
That's a good point and example, but I just don't imagine them thinking they would benefit from it is all. The future holds many mysteries, so it's at least possible, but I definitely would not bet on it, knowing what I do now.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by mindcandy on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:20PM (#25598402)
Agreed. There have been 21 million forks of Bitcoin with all manner of modifications. You don't hear about them because practically no one agrees with them enough to mine/trade/use them. You could make your own fork in an afternoon. The hard part is convincing anyone else to care.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by steeve on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:24PM (#25600199)
Why would they agree to that? Deflation is what guarantees the investment for most users.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by deadbunny on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:16PM (#25598370)
Sure it's a line of code but if you fork and change that line of code you need to find consensus on the network to accept your fork as the "true" Bitcoin. See Bitcoin cash for an example.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by rjurney on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:12PM (#25598333)
Isn’t this what Bitcoin Cash is? I’m really asking, but I thought so.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by mindcandy on Thursday December 31, 2020 @06:28PM (#25598476)
Bitcoin Cash is about trying to make transactions faster and cheaper by increasing the block size (and rate?). Upside: Might be able to use it directly to buy coffee with a reasonable UX. Downside: would likely lead to a small number of huge machines managing the world's blockchain. The Bitcoin Core group really wants people in poor nations to be able to run their own Bitcoin nodes on their cell phones eventually. They value decentralization above UX.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by almostdigital on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:18PM (#25598975)
No, they want Bitcoin to be a "store of value", whatever that means. Poor people being able to run a full node on a low-end phone is pointless when a transaction fee due to the artificial block size limit is more than a months wages.
Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by gruez on Thursday December 31, 2020 @07:45PM (#25599264)
>Poor people being able to run a full node on a low-end phone is pointless when a transaction fee due to the artificial block size limit is more than a months wages.

or just wait for a lull in the transaction volume and pay pennies per tx? eg https://blockstream.info/tx/3b9ce26a827b014e5f6cda461f5fa112... from last block only paid 14 cents.

Re:Bitcoin is a disaster by dane-pgp on Thursday December 31, 2020 @09:57PM (#25600384)
I'm not sure why every user needs to run a full node. Satoshi himself said that SPV clients would be enough for most users:

"Simplified Payment Verification is for lightweight client-only users who only do transactions and don't generate and don't participate in the node network. They wouldn't need to download blocks, just the hash chain, which is currently about 2MB and very quick to verify (less than a second to verify the whole chain)."[0]

It's not clear what benefit the user or the currency gains from having 90% of users running full nodes instead of, say, 50% or 10% doing so. In any case, when people in poor nations have phones that can manage uninterrupted 24/7 connections to the bitcoin network, they'll probably also be able to afford 2 TB of storage (currently costing about $50) which would be enough to store 10 years of 4 MB blocks.

[0] https://blockchain.news/wiki/satoshi-quote-on-trust