"By occupation, flu vaccination coverage was highest among physicians (98.0%), nurses (92.0%), pharmacists (90.6%), and nurse practitioners and physician assistants (88.8%) Flu vaccination coverage was lowest among other clinical health care personnel (81.7%), assistants and aides (72.4%), and nonclinical health care personnel (76.7%)."
I hear this argument a lot and it doesn't make sense to me. If the CDC predicts strain A will be dominant and vacinates against it, shouldn't we expect strain A to be supressed?
> And 2 articles from a quick Google search coincidentally show the same ~60% skip flu shots for both USA and UK:
You've said "healthcare workers", but your link about the UK (it's about Scotland only) talks about all NHS workers. That's cleaners, accountants, cooks, etc. People who don't necessarily have any patient contact and it's not what we'd normally call a healthcare worker.
For England, for frontline healthcare workers, the number was 78% for sept 2019 to feb 2020.
Some NHS trusts do better than others. One got a rate as high as 94%.
https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/...
The data cited in that ABC article, published in 2008, is taken from the 2006-2007 flu season. Over the last 14 years, much has changed.
For example, in 2019-2020, over 80% of healthcare workers received the flu vaccine, including over 90% of those who work in hospitals.
Source: CDC https://www.cdc.gov/flu/professionals/healthcareworkers.htm
https://www.cdc.gov/flu/vaccines-work/effectiveness-studies....
I always get it because even 10% is better than zero and it doesn't seem to cause me any serious side effects.
Most vaccines have amazing effectiveness. If you take something like measles, it's basically "take 2 shots and you have a more than 90% chance of being protected for a lifetime". This is a much easier win than "you need to have a shot every year and the effectiveness is varying somewhere between 40-60%".
Luckily it seems Covid vaccines are more like measles vaccines than like flu vaccines - at least in terms of effectiveness.
The average efficacy isn't necessarily high, but I don't see how that is enough to call it really bad. That gets balanced against the benefit it does have, the cost, the safety, etc.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4521706/
(the study evaluates medical costs and productivity, it's not doing a sentimental analysis to get to the savings)
Of course there is lots of room to improve a vaccine that is sometimes only 10% effective, but a reduction in costs to society by operating a vaccination program is a pretty good place to be starting from.
As most/all flu shots don’t contain weakened virus (FluMist, the nasal spray, does contain weakened virus, but the shot uses either inactivated virus or viral proteins), this doctor seems a bit out to lunch?
Moreover, it’s possible to get sick from another strain of flu or because the vaccine hasn’t yet become effective - it takes a week or two to be useful so an anecdote of getting sick before then doesn’t indicate anything about the flu shot.
As personal anecdote, I get flu shot from Costco every year but this year was the first time I got nasal FluMist because they ran out of the needle version. This was also the only time I've gotten sick from it. Immediate runny nose and headache even before I left the store.
Those side effects are apparently listed as normal, though it’s interesting to learn they can come on that quickly! I would have thought the immune system would take some hours to respond.
They got tested and quarantined anyway... and came up negative, but are still changing PCP.
Med school requires good analytical smarts and an excellent ability to retain information, but I'm quite convinced at this point that raw analyical ability has almost nothing to do with the ability to think critically to avoid insane beliefs. It's just not something that humans come built-in with.
Somehow you can make the same answer without denigration.
I don't believe in "anti-vaccine market penetration".
My model I use is that ALL people are ignorant of most things that happen around them and only SOME people are knowledgeable about SOME of the things.
And 2 articles from a quick Google search coincidentally show the same ~60% skip flu shots for both USA and UK:
https://abcnews.go.com/Health/ColdandFluNews/story?id=641897...
https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-scotland-42634781
If I didn't see the above, my intuition would have made me guess that 90%+ of medical professionals get flu shots. It turns out I was way off.
However, the reasons don't appear to be safety like this thread's article. One doctor said he doesn't get flu shots because the CDC makes a guess for what goes into the next season's flu shot and they're only ~50% correct. Since he got sick from the flu shot (even with the weakened virus) many years ago, he now avoids them. He still believes in the science of flu shot and not anti-vaxx but he personally chooses to not take it.
EDIT: Apologize for posting bad statistic. Is the UK NHS statistic accurate? If so, why do most UK health workers avoid it?