News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:27PM (#25573724)
Hi there! I'm the founder.

This is my "hobby project". I work at Google as an SRE.

One of the ideas here is to integrate the Agora with existing social networks:

https://twitter.com/flancian/status/1343979536434798598

The Agora is an overlay to the internet (semantic web) controlled by users. It is part of the open source ecosystem.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by corobo on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @04:12AM (#25580003)
If this takes off, who owns it? You or Google?
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:08AM (#25580711)
The community does :)

Google owns the copyright, as can be seen in the LICENSE file and headers, but the totality of the project is open source (Apache).

I own https://anagora.org in particular and plan to run it as a public service.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by ssakamoto on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:24AM (#25581069)
> Google owns the copyright

Giant Red Flag

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:28AM (#25581087)
Oh, interesting -- why do you think so?

I considered this for a while and I didn't find any downsides. It's open source; can be forked anytime by anyone.

I do this on my free time.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by pabs3 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:17AM (#25581384)
Software Freedom Conservancy's ContractPatch project has some exploration of this and other issues in employment contracts:

https://sfconservancy.org/contractpatch/

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by hansdieter1337 on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:34AM (#25581506)
Have you though about using a pseudonym instead of your real identity for this? My contract even forbids me to contribute to OSS. You can’t advertise with any of your OSS work on your CV though.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by alkonaut on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @10:15AM (#25582330)
> My contract even forbids me to contribute to OSS

What, in your spare time? That seems... restrictive

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by hollowcelery on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:49AM (#25583237)
The standard Google employee contract contains this restriction. It's easier for them to institute a blanket ban on open source contributions (including in one's spare time) and then consider exceptions on a case-by-case basis. They have a dedicated internal committee that fields employee requests to work on open source projects.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by alkonaut on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:38PM (#25583764)
Weird to even impose any restrictions at all outside of working hours. Can’t see how it’s any of my employers’ business?

How would they view working a second job? Does it matter in what field?

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by 3np on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:19PM (#25584324)
Depends on where. In many places this would be unenforceable and in some places illegal.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @02:33PM (#25585098)
I'm sorry to read. Mine doesn't, I'm lucky.

flancian is a pseudonym but many people know my real name, it's no secret.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by arbol on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:48AM (#25581209)
Why does Google own the copyright then?
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by thristian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:00AM (#25581268)
Because Google owns the copyright to everything their employees make during their employment, whether or not they do it on company time or use company resources.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:18AM (#25581386)
Exactly, thank you.

I understand there is often a reaction to seeing "copyright by Google"; but I researched it and it didn't seem to have any consequences of note.

The one thing I know of is that contributors to the project must sign a (one time only) CLA: https://cla.developers.google.com/about/google-individual

I hope this isn't an issue for you; if it is, please reach out -- or consider forking! :)

https://anagora.org/node/open-source

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by corobo on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:45AM (#25581593)
Because Google has killed every social play they've ever tried tbh. I can't get invested.

This isn't the same as the killedbygoogle complaint. I know they kill a lot because they try a lot but social is Google's Moby Dick. They'll jump on it and fuck it up if it takes off.

Fair disclosure I know it's distributed and as such I've got this link up my sleeve

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2013/05/google-abandons-open-s...

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:25AM (#25581926)
I won't try to dispel this notion; I think your opinion is valid. I'll just say that in my experience Google is made up from a majority of people with good intentions :)

I'm interested in discussing how precisely Google could negatively affect the project -- I currently don't think that's possible, but I might be missing something.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by corobo on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @09:30AM (#25581968)
Of course on the individual level Google hoovers up the smartest in the world! As a company though, social network shambles every time haha.

I don't know how they'd mess it up, gut feeling really. I do honestly wish you the best of luck outside of my cynicism!

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by indigochill on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @11:07AM (#25582824)
The difference here is that this is not formally a Google project the way Wave, G+, etc were. This is just someone's hobby that incidentally Google owns the copyright to because tech companies treat engineers like glorified slaves when it comes to intellectual property.

Google kills social projects they run, but since they don't run this one, I don't see them interfering. Their ownership is just a technicality because of stone age IP law.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by corobo on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:39PM (#25585810)
They don't take the copyright from you for a laugh.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by arbol on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @08:20AM (#25581402)
That's far too overreaching. I wouldn't work somewhere that had ownership over my free time like this.
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by amelius on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:32PM (#25583693)
Google != Oracle
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by rapnie on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:31AM (#25580806)
Ah yes. I had to do some searching (maybe I overlooked an easy link), but here are the sources:https://github.com/flancian/agora-server
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:47AM (#25580879)
Thanks for the feedback; sorry for the inconvenience. I'll probably add a 'github' chip somewhere on the page.

https://anagora.org/node/open-source lists all relevant repositories.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @02:59PM (#25574087)
http://anagora.org/node/agora for a high level view.

http://anagora.org/node/agora-plan for a development journal+plan.

http://anagora.org/node/agora-protocol for interactions with the wider landscape.

Joining in with your writing if you already have it up somewhere and would like a new display platform helps a lot!

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by markdown on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @03:25AM (#25579740)
According to the Oxford dictionary:

> Agora: (in ancient Greece) a public open space used for assemblies and markets."

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by winrid on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @07:50PM (#25577016)
Hopefully without sounding rude - what's the experiment exactly?
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @06:26AM (#25580789)
You don't! I appreciate the question.

The quick and fuzzy answer is: whatever the community wants it to be :)

My current view follows. In a nutshell:

* The Agora is meant to be a goal-oriented social network specializing in problem solving.

* The first goal of the Agora is to build itself.

* The second goal of the Agora is whatever you (the community) want it to be.

* The Agora seeks to complement and enrich the internet and existing social networks instead of "taking over".

From https://flancia.org/agora:

"You can think of the Agora as a convention based social network; an optional, user-controlled annotation layer that can be applied over any internet platform which supports user-generated content.

I think one of the best possible uses for such a network would be to use it to pro-socially maintain a distributed knowledge graph tailored specifically to the goal of solving problems: those of its users and society at large.

Its users, as a cooperative group, could by default take a naive but rational approach to problem solving:

      For each problem in the set P of all problems:
          Describe it as thoroughly as possible.
          Maintain a set of known or argued possible solutions, S(P).
      For each solution in S(P):
          Describe it as thoroughly as possible.
          Maintain a set of resources (people, time, attention, money) needed to implement it, R(S).
Individual users could also declare their views on the state of the world explicitly: they define which subsets of P, S and R they agree with, in the sense that they believe they are feasible, true, interesting.

Users that agree on their defined subsets can then efficiently collaborate on solutions as they become available by pooling of resources.

We apply some good old recursivity and seed the Agora with the problem of how to build itself. That is, how to build a system that allows participating users and entities to collaborate optimally in the face of adversity (such as biases, irrationality and even actual ill intent)1.

The Agora should be built on a federated protocol to limit the harmfulness of diasporas. Groups might temporarily diverge in their views enough to want to run separate Agoras, but different Agoras should be able to cooperate on problems and solutions for which there is enough ideological alignment, and eventually merge."

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by selfhoster11 on Thursday December 31, 2020 @12:12AM (#25589814)
> You can think of the Agora as a convention based social network; an optional, user-controlled annotation layer that can be applied over any internet platform which supports user-generated content.

So should this be understood as a kind of a multi-user Memex? Annotation and linking over any site that supports user-editable fields seems similar to that, if one squints their eyes.

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by hobofan on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @05:26AM (#25580453)
Very interesting to see a project built on top of Underlay! I've worked in the space ~2 years ago when Underlay was still in stealth mode and haven't heard from them since. It looks like it has grown into possibly the solution for decentralized knowledge graphs that ticks most of the boxes we were aiming for back then.

Where there any other similar technologies that you considered instead of Underlay and what made you choose this one specifically?

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @12:58PM (#25584050)
Ahoy!

I have to clarify at this point the Agora is not based on [[underlay]]; they are just a reference I go back to often in the context of [[distributed knowledge graphs]].

I know Samuel Klein though and I'm looking forward to collaborating more with him and the Underlay project; it hasn't happened yet mostly because the Agora is still at a very early stage in its development :)

https://anagora.org/node/underlay https://anagora.org/node/distributed-knowledge-graph

Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by hobofan on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @01:27PM (#25584406)
Ah, seems I've not read that page carefully enough. I thought the link on that page implied that it was built on Underlay, but I guess that was just wishful thinking :D
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by ssivark on Tuesday December 29, 2020 @06:45PM (#25576516)
Haven’t looked into it well-enough to understand the details of how it works, but at first glance — would you say that this model for a distributed network might be a good/natural way to connect nodes/content on the p2p internet? (Say IPFS)
Re:Show HN: The Agora – an experimental social network by flancian on Wednesday December 30, 2020 @07:36AM (#25581127)
Yes, definitely!

The current architecture is the simplest distributed architecture I could come up with to get started: the Agora pulls from a series of git repositories that its users maintain, these repositories containing Markdown notes with [[wikilinks]].

[[IPFS]], [[solid]] are all natural directions to evolve in. I just started with something simple enough to be coded in a weekend :) And also something that most people in tech are already using (git+markdown).

https://anagora.org/node/ipfs

https://anagora.org/node/solid