Go scorched earth - what do you have to lose? Know the other guy is hostile and don't trust them to do the right thing. Consider your options outside of that and talk it over with the other investor.
If you're the technical cofounder here you're probably in a stronger position to negotiate.
If you can get the other investor to see what's happening here (your cofounder pushing you out one month before the cliff after you've helped to build things up) you may be able to get them on your side.
As I see it without knowing details:
- Either your contributions are real and your cofounder is a miserable person trying to screw you out of it and risking the company in order to do that.
- Or you haven't done anything substantial and the cofounder wants you out. Even in this case it's still wrong of them to do this one month before vesting (and the way they're approaching it sounds dishonest, they should be direct).
If it's truly the former I think getting the third investor to understand this is key, if the non-technical cofounder is risking the entire business at this stage they're going to be bad going forward - you probably need to get rid of them.
If it's the latter (which seems unlikely since the other cofounder is non-technical) you'll still want to negotiate a reasonable exit, but it may be harder to do so (and you'll probably need a lawyer).
If they're reasonably secure they have more ability to fight for a better outcome, risking the 3%.
I would do that myself because having a cofounder tell me 1 month before vesting that they want me to leave with less than half of our deal is unjust and wrong. I'd do what I could to avoid that outcome, if the company blows up as a result it's the cofounder's fault - I'd sleep fine.
I would never do what the non-technical cofounder is doing to someone I partnered with.
Instead, I would have an open, honest conversation, listen from a place of empathy and generosity and seek a compromise.
The truth is, unless your cofounder has the right to terminate your employment, then continue working and try to create as much harmony as possible.
Co-founder disputes are awful and usually result in the death of the company. But being aggressive will only speed up the Demise not prevent it, and if the company implodes that equity is worth nothing anyway.
You don't move the needle back by being kind and compassionate with those sorts of people. You move it back by using whatever leverage you have. We don't know what leverage the OP has, but his only defense is to use it to either trigger a real buyout, to get the other investor on his side, to risk tanking the company, to say "no" in the belief the co-founder won't tank the company in response, or some other option we're unaware of.
In the same way you won't make headway trying to explain to that lowballer at the yard sale why $5 is more than fair, you won't make any headway trying to explain to someone who has come out of the gate with something so starkly unfair as the OP presents why their proposal is unfair. They know.
"Helping the other co-founder get to the decision" is only going to be achieved with leverage given that it's clear they're not looking to find an equitable (hah!) solution. They're trying to get as much control and equity as possible. It may be the OP has no option but to accept it (keeping 3% and moving on). Or it may be the OP has better options. But the point is that the other party has made their intentions known. They haven't come to the negotiating table saying "This is what I want, how can I get you to agree", they've come to it with "This is what I want; accept it", and when provided what the OP wants in return, turned it down, rather than seeking some middle ground or otherwise budging.
Who's at fault matters here, if the cofounder is truly acting in the way suggested and is not willing to compromise then it's critical to get the other investor to see what they're doing. If that leads to the cofounder blowing up and the death of the company happening sooner rather than later so be it.
If it turns out OP is actually not contributing anything then yeah, better to seek some sort of clean exit compromise. The details matter and how much leverage OP has matters. It's impossible to give good advice without knowing that in either direction.
At a minimum the OP should get the one year cliff on exit.
Which seems like a valid concern.
As a pretty well- studied gambler, and given the limited information we have, I think you're right-- there a worse possible outcome. But it's 100% worth the shot.
Point being, as others have said, it’s essentially a negotiation. Not a war.
Plus, I guess if the guy really could fuck the cake that gives him leverage and a negotiating position. If he can’t, then it’s moot.
And as other folks also pointed out further down, OP needs good legal advice and, to determine when the cost in time and money ends up being high enough and the probability of a lucrative outcome being low enough that it’s time to walk away.
Knowing those things can help make good decisions.
I think of this like this: OP created the cake of value being in a near equal partnership, thinking it would be cut equally when it is done. However when the work of OP is done and cake is baked, they want to have the full cake. This is not negotiation. This is breach of trust...it is morally, ethically dishonest on part of their co-founder.
If it’s not a negotiation, what is it?
And, how does OP assess their position, possible outcomes, and decide what cost is worth it?
How many months of ones life or tens of thousands of bucks is it worth? Depends on what’s likely to be at the end of the tunnel, no?
Point is - it’s a calculation, of just how badly one desires justice/vengeance, if nothing else. Which, when contracts are involved, for stuff like this means getting advice from a lawyer, unless you want to get your ass handed to you.
IIRC most court cases resolve with some kind of settlement - which is a negotiation.
Even if the process does become adversarial, how do you think wars end? Even when one side is the clear victor there is still negotiation. Consider the U.S. post-WWII occupation of Germany. Even there negotiation was involved at the end. We struck deals with the (now former) Nazis because they could help us against the Soviets in various ways.
There’s a third investor, who it sounds like has the power. So agin, potential for negotiation with the investor.
Negotiation does not equal weakness. It could very much mean negotiating an outcome in your favor from a position of strength. But if all you’ve got on your mind is cake-fucking then you may miss that opportunity.
This person created this valuable asset, giving his time and effort. The other person's effort to create it might be non zero but so are OP's and therefore, there is no reason why OP should walk away from it.
It’s a calculation. And it’s not a binary fight-or-flight situation. There’s room to maneuver - legal maneuvers, speaking with the investor, etc.
These comments here merely suggest that the goal should be to fight for what the OP rightfully earned, and that hostile actions and a threat for war should not be left unanswered if you have the capability to answer, both in order to retain the value the OP has at this moment and in order not to hinder their reputation in future endeavours - and, also very important, to have peace of mind (sleep at night). Feeling like a piece of sh!t guarantees lifelong bad sleep nights, incomparable to having to wake up early to go to the court.
What kind of compromise do you think is available that treats OP fairly that can be gained by performing empathy, compassion, generosity, and active listening?
From the story told, it sounds like the poster might have tried that already.
Cit. "Never Split the difference".
Something important I learned over time. Sure, listen, but don't take a deal that doesn't make you happy.
If things roll your way, maybe you resurrect the business later buying its assets out of bankruptcy. Either way, think lazy; this looks like a scam for your time; the more you put into it at any price, the worse off you are.
One quibble. That is typically not how it works, since his shares are likely common stock and investors get preferred stock. In my experience, the range of value for common stock in private firms varies widely, but it is never one to one with preferred stock (the golden rule being, of course, "who has the money makes the rules").
I have seen values ranging from 10% to 30% of the preferred stock price. Now, of course, I only have a few data points, so ymmv, but founders shouldn't delude themselves that their sweat equity is valued the same as preferred stock.
Honestly, if non-technical thought he could fire this guy, he probably would have already. That's why TCF is being bullied into resigning.
What is non-technical going to tell the investors when he fires the guy who keeps everything running, built everything, and did all the SEO?
Think of it this way, take the deal and you get 3% of nothing because it'll get driven into the ground.
Don't take the deal and either you keep working on it, and get 40+% of something decent, or you get N% of nothing because other guy drives it into the ground but you got a better buyout.
There's very little downside for TCF in actually sticking to his guns, and it's not like he's going to look like the asshole here.
It's possible that TCF can hang on until the cliff, but I doubt that'll happen, and it's not going to be pretty if they do. There are all kinds of ways NTF can reduce/destroy TCF's equity; I'd take 3% and move on with my life.
What are those ways? The only sane thing is to go and talk to lawyers. In what world is it going to be the best option to let yourself be used and abused?
Every ongoing business arrangement relies on goodwill and intent to survive, like any other relationship. Consulting a lawyer with expertise in the area may be a good idea, but the best solution is probably the cleanest and easiest one.
Note the “reverse vesting” bit, this caught me out too. This is not the standard employee “you have zero until your 1yr cliff” deal, it’s the opposite in some sense, the founders own their shares unless they leave, in which case they are clawed back, and the clawed back amount goes by the 4yr period.
In this case if the investor has voting rights, neither founder has a controlling share, and the investor is the tiebreaker. So OP can fire the other founder with the investor’s vote.
In any case, this is not going to end nicely, and I would recommend walking away with whatever equity can be had without setting the counter-parties against TCF. If NTF and investor get really mad, they can easily dilute or destroy TCF's equity, so I'd try to avoid that.
IANAL so interested to know how folks with more experience have seen this fact pattern play out.
It's not explicit this was done, so it's assumed it wasn't. If the TCF hasn't spoken to the investor directly, it's relatively easy to assume the investor will vote in the NTF's direction.
Lots of assumptions, but we don't have that much to go on.
I would request OP to assume good intent and ask the following question.
> What are you giving me in return of my 40% of the stock ? Why is that a fair price ?
I do not know, but it is perfectly possible that the other person might have a good answer. If you have already made up your plan you guys can agree on some kind of plan where you divest your stock over a period in one way to another.
I have a suspicion that the other co-founder probably does not want OP around for whatever reason. But OP can help him by simply taking a break while keeping the stock.
You said it yourself, you've grown hugely, you're dominating SEO since you joined, and built loads of products. This is your 'partner' getting greedy after you've done a lot of hard work. It wouldn't have happened without you. Don't undersell yourself.
Your 40% is worth $400k based on that initial funding valuation, right? Assuming it's as successful as you seem to be implying, it is almost certainly worth more now.
Everyone is telling you to roll over but seriously, fuck them. This other toxic guy is the one who should be getting pushed out, not you.
The other investor ultimately has power in this situation, not you or him, so whoever convinces them that they are the person to go with gets the seat and gets to continue with the project.
If he has a good relationship there you're probably fucked, but results matter... and if you can prove you've done great stuff since joining and and have great plans for the future, he can be replaced.
To be clear: this guy has decided to blow up the project so he can get a bigger share, if it all fails now he can only blame himself.