News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by NiceWayToDoIT on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:18AM (#25503819)
Hacker news are for polite and rational an above intelligent conversation, but some things that are coming from politicians nowadays are so, in lack of more polite words, mindless, that sheer gravity of their actions leaves me speechless. It is like a constant stream of attack on freedom of speech by dictatorship and fascism 2.0 (better, stronger upgraded version, more sneaker and cunning). It begins to look like a rise of condition before second world war. Before you know it, we stand in line and exclaim 'Hail to Y'.

Sometimes, I think evil has a game called, attempts, if you try X number of times at the end something corrupt will pass.

Interesting enough in the same week in Serbia they want to pass law that will "Forbid people insulting high government official if that could cause deep emotional stress to their family members"

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by IfOnlyYouKnew on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:46AM (#25504594)
> are so, in lack of more polite words, mindless

The linked article as well as the criticism here aren't exactly mindful, either.

For a start, the article only ever says "Congress" did this or that. Such unspecific language only furthers cynicism and is damaging for democracy. There certainly are lots of members of congress that are against this, from both parties. But they'll get accused of this as well as any other real or imaginary ill.

As such, cynicism becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy: When people literally no longer care about the actual work you do, why bother trying? When they assume you are "corrupt" or "deep-state" or whatever, why shouldn't you start selling your vote to the highest bidder?

At least the "CARES Act" also does no such thing as "criminalising meme-sharing", as far as I can tell. It is a civil law establishing a small claims courts pathway for copyright infringement. Both sides need to opt-in to this process. If one side doesn't, exactly nothing changes.

Because this is about reducing overhead costs of litigation, it doesn't do much to help Disney. Its stated intend is to help smaller or one-off creators who see their works reused without their permission and do not have the means to pursue claims in federal courts. The merits here are debatable, and I believe some sort of collective rights managements system would be better. But imagine taking the single greatest photo of your life and seeing it used everywhere with people not even bothering to give you credit?

The criminalisation targets sites that knowingly and repeatedly stream copyrighted content. Unless you reject copyright altogether, I can't really find fault with that.

> fascism 2.0

Congress gets a lot wrong, but at at least they tend to stay clear of Godwin's law. Diminishing the industrial slaughter of millions of people by comparing it with some minor adjustments to copyright law is certainly not raising the level of debate.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by Mauricebranagh on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:26AM (#25505584)
Congress was caught adding non related items to a "supply bill" (I am using uk nomenclature)

This is highly undemocratic and should have be ruled out of order and never even gone onto the order paper.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by pmyteh on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:33AM (#25505633)
There's no requirement in Congress that amendments are germane to the purpose of the bill, unlike in the UK. This kind of 'Christmas tree' bill, where all kinds of personal favourite measures are added to some kind of must-pass legislation, is common.

Having briefly interned in both Parliament and Congress, I'm not entirely sure which is the better/worse system. Parliament certainly wouldn't allow this - but then, if the government wants giveaway bills its basically got the power to put them through Parliament with little-to-no oversight. Where Congress has independence, it also has this kind of legislative log-rolling and low-level corruption. I prefer the UK system, but it's not clear-cut.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by whatshisface on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:05AM (#25507637)
If the representatives were better, the pork mechanism could be used to escrow deals between parties with different interests. "I will pass this if you pass that" becomes a lot easier to organize when you can combine them together in a way that makes defection impossible. Unfortunately, this nice theoretical property is damaged in practice by the not-so-great behavior of the participants.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by whoopdedo on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:17AM (#25504774)
> Both sides need to opt-in to this process.

Meaning it'll be added as one of the hundred other things that you agree to in the TOS that is too long to read in less than an hour every time you register for a service that you "agree" to by clicking a button but if you want to opt-out requires postal mailing a written request.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by unix_fan on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:58AM (#25504653)
I agree. Reading the article, as well as the comments, it is clear to me that people are predisposed to despise "government overreach" even if it isn't really happening.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by spacemanmatt on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:19AM (#25504788)
But this is absolutely overreach
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by ant6n on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:27AM (#25504835)
> Diminishing the industrial slaughter of millions of people by comparing it with some minor adjustments to copyright law is certainly not raising the level of debate.

Without defending the poster’s point about fascism 2.0 too much, I’d like to point out that Fascism isn’t equivalent to genocide or nazis. It’s a political ideology against a liberal democracy, characterized by ultra-nationalism, corporatism, forcible suppression of opposition and strong regimentation of society and of the economy. Some would argue that a government governing in close ties with corporations against the wishes and interests of the population at large is a form of fascism. Sort of like the society shown in the move Robocop.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by selimthegrim on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:30AM (#25505611)
I’m pretty sure Zappa would have hauled out the fascist label but more about a society that allows this not the government.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by drtillberg on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:54AM (#25505392)
To me a defining characteristic of 1930s Nazism was a perceived mortal struggle against Communists that excused or justified egregiously unethical and immoral means.

In the modern U.S. that has some similarity to the highly polarized debate the last decade along party lines.

This however? It's mortal political enemies coming together to elbow-bump over ... pork-barrel end-of-term politics. That, from a realist perspective, is America. It's not great, but it's not 1930s Nazism either.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by whatshisface on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:10AM (#25507693)
>It's mortal political enemies coming together to elbow-bump over ... pork-barrel end-of-term politics.

"Let's fix this rotten system by replacing it with our new system (which just so happens to be a dictatorship, but don't mind that...)," is a pretty common way for democratic governments to fail. It even happened to Rome.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by fouric on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:47AM (#25508219)
Huh, I haven't heard anybody say anything remotely like this, and I have friends from not only the two big parties, but also a few of the smaller ones, too...
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by whatshisface on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:13PM (#25508564)
The general perception of the incompetence or disingenuousness in the present system lays the groundwork for people to start saying that, at some point in the future, unless things improve.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by stjohnswarts on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @04:11PM (#25522275)
I think given Trump's actions so far he would clearly overthrow the democratically held election to keep him in power if the rest of government wasn't keeping him in check. Just because he's not had a night of the long knives yet doesn't mean it's not a serious, dangerous, and horrid usage of his position and power as President. He isn't Hitler but he is the worst President in the history of our country as far as sheer malfeasance.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by mariodiana on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:19PM (#25508651)
I'm not justifying unethical or immoral means, but was the perception of being in a mortal struggle against Communists incorrect?
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by chordalkeyboard on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:39AM (#25504904)
> Congress gets a lot wrong, but at at least they tend to stay clear of Godwin's law. Diminishing the industrial slaughter of millions of people by comparing it with some minor adjustments to copyright law is certainly not raising the level of debate.

Fascism is about an alliance between industry and government against the people. Genocide is neither necessary nor sufficient to label a system "fascist."

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by commandlinefan on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:50AM (#25505367)
Until everybody is willing to admit that both sides are to blame for this, I doubt we’ll see any improvement, either.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by trianglem on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:26AM (#25507088)
Except then people would be lying to themselves. It really, really isn’t both sides to the same extent.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by dvtrn on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:20AM (#25507828)
You should look into whose names are in the "Yea" column for this bill, and what party they belong to. It's publicly accessible.

Also should check out who the sponsoring Senator was for the last version of the amendment in question that failed to get yea votes a few years ago, and what party that person belongs to. That too is publicly accessible.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by zaroth on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @11:23AM (#25507869)
Narrator: Everyone wasn’t ready.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by x86_64Ubuntu on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:09PM (#25509243)
But both sides aren't to blame. The law at hand was proposed by Thom Tillis, a Republican from North Carolina.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by IG_Semmelweiss on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:11AM (#25506931)
congress is and always be inertia towards less freedom.

It is truly a bunch of chaos monkeys behind a keyboard. Given enough time, their random strokes will result messy code that , regardless of best efforts at bug work-arounds, it breaks the app.

Something as simple as forcing 2 full reads in the physical presence of all YEA votes could end this 6000 page monstrosity.

Simple rules like random switching of winning candidates between each other (senator for assemblyman, mayor for health commissioner , etc) would take giant lobby money off the table since it introduces risk to any lobby "investment". What a dream to see lobby money at a big risk ! Make them think twice.

Finally, make a hard rule of 99% tax rate on every penny earned above the historical average for any public office holder (pre-election), and you stop the rags-to-riches path by using govt as the path.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by minusSeven on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:53PM (#25509749)
We probably need to remove conflict of interest in the laws they want to be passed, but how we do that is anyone's guess. A good place to start will be to add regulations on the process of lobbying, but the whole thing can get pretty complicated pretty fast.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by roenxi on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:04AM (#25504384)
There are parallels, but mainly in the political institutions becoming so worm-ridden and disinterested in prosperity that they are at risk of toppling.

The conditions right before WWII was a party going from 2% of the vote to plurality in 4 years [0], against a backdrop of economic catastrophe. There is little risk of slow creeping dictatorship - the risk is institutions weakening to the point there is a sudden reform to dictatorship when a large group of people decide to do something different quickly without anyone stopping to design some safeguards against human nature.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nazi_Party#Rise_to_power:_1925...

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by mtgx on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:42AM (#25504268)
If the US had a Constitutional Court (like some European countries do) that verified bills for constitutionality after being signed by the President, 90%-95% of these obviously unconstitutional bills Congress passes these days would get rejected. They wouldn't take 10-40 years to reach the Supreme Court and finally be verified for constitutionality.

And before anyone says "but the US only has adversarial courts" - well, the US had a secret spy court for more than a decade that rubberstamped anything the NSA/FBI requested, and it didn't seem to be an issue until the Snowden documents leaked and there was major backlash against it.

But honestly, a Constitutional Court is what the US needs right now. Something to stop the insanity of politicians in the mid-term.

Long-term, you stop their insanity by actually preventing them from getting elected in the first place. You do that by getting rid of money in politics, the FPTP voting system that promotes party a 2-party system and extreme polarization, and gerrymandering (a proportional representation voting system would fix both of the last 2 issues).

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by rasz on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:24AM (#25505186)
That would be hailed as a huge waste of time and money. What US has instead is an Office of Legal Counsel full of lawyers at the Justice Department. Their role is to polish turds until shine blinds you. OLC are the ones responsible for Bush Administration legalization of torture.

https://www.nytimes.com/2020/12/20/opinion/trump-justice-dep...

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by postingpals on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:05AM (#25504392)
You cannot get rid of money or imbalanced voting structures in politics because people aren't going to write in laws that cut out their own financial and popular gain.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by curiousgal on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:24AM (#25504815)
For a country that was literally founded by a revolution, y'all really seem to be tiptoeing around that concept.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by CuriouslyC on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @08:32AM (#25506040)
We'll probably see mass secession, and reformation into a number of smaller nations, rather than an armed revolution.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:56AM (#25505404)
The result of many decades of anti-Communist brainwashing. It's telling that stuff that's considered basic quality of living in Europe like government-provided affordable healthcare is considered "socialism" in the US.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by rpz on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:01AM (#25506322)
Anti communist brainwashing? Are the schools, universities, and media in the States not liberal enough for your tastes?
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by Andrex on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:14AM (#25506423)
Are these the same schools that not even a decade ago were humoring intelligent design and climate change denial?
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by hnthrowaway923 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:51PM (#25509735)
Not sure what schools you're referring to but that wasn't a thing when I was in school 15 years ago..
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by alwayseasy on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @10:29AM (#25507129)
Forcing kids to say the Pledge of Allegiance every morning isn't very liberal though.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by hnthrowaway923 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:57PM (#25509776)
I didn't have to say the pledge or stand for it although there was social pressure, most students would.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by matwood on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:25AM (#25506505)
US liberal is far the to the right of the majority of Western Europe.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @09:06AM (#25506361)
I'm European, so can't comment on your schools - but I can definitely comment on what I'm reading on every single thread no matter if here on HN, or Reddit, or Twitter, or Facebook... and that is people crying "socialism" for everything.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by tacocataco on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @12:02PM (#25508424)
Liberals are center left at best, and that's people like AOC and Bernie Sanders.

The overton window in the USA has shifted so far right it's almost falling off the house.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by postingpals on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:29AM (#25504849)
I am trying to get people to come to that realisation themselves, that way they're more open to it.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by marmaduke on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:56AM (#25504333)
> do that by getting rid of money in politics

You forgot how to explain to do that ;)

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by sofixa on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:36AM (#25504540)
It's not that hard to achieve, but the people with the power to do so have no interest.

Set fixed spending caps on candidates and parties, or maybe even make their budgets government provided ( so that everyone is on an equal footing), criminalise spending over it and gifts to politicians and family members, and you're decently covered.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by tertius on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @07:34AM (#25505640)
So, impossible?
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by AdrianB1 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @06:14AM (#25505128)
Some of the European Constitutional Courts are restricted to check the laws only when challenged by the president of the country, a High Court or a large number of members of the Parliament (same people who voted it), ordinary people cannot do that and the check is not automatic. It solves maybe 5% of the problems with the laws that and non-constitutional because nobody can effectively challenge the rest.
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by LordDragonfang on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:42AM (#25503941)
>fascism 2.0 (better, stronger upgraded version, more sneaker and cunning)

I think you're both giving too little credit to the original fascists, and to much credit to the people falling for it a second time. Fascism was plenty good at deception and bending of truths the first time around, and at this point in the second go around, they've stopped being subtle about it.

Remember that a) plenty of people supported the Nazis, and that Hitler's party was voted into power, and

b) people on the left have been pointing out the proto-fascist rhetoric since Trump's first campaign, and moderate liberals are all acting surprised that the neo-fascists are suggesting fascist things (like subverting a democratic election with military force)

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by NiceWayToDoIT on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:00AM (#25504043)
I agree, for now community is vigilant, but I am afraid does'n need much for those same forces to flip a coin. My issue is that I perceive world as accumulation of knowledge and acting upon what is learned for the benefit of all. Then, when what should be considered a serious group of people, proposes a law that is just like introduction of malicious code withing OS, I am left dumbfounded with question "Why?!"
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by nightcracker on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:05AM (#25504067)
> Hitler's party was voted into power

This is a misrepresentation of what happened. They first tried a coup in 1920. When that failed they tried gathering votes.

They won a plurality, not a majority. After that this guy is responsible for the transformation into a dictatorship: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paul_von_Hindenburg

> In 1925, Hindenburg returned to public life to become the second elected President of the German Weimar Republic. Despite being personally opposed to Hitler and his Nazi party, he was nonetheless a major player in the political instability that resulted in their rise to power. Upon twice dissolving the Reichstag in 1932, Hindenburg ultimately agreed to appoint Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in January 1933 when the Nazis won a plurality in the November elections. In response to the Reichstag Fire allegedly committed by a communist arsonist, he approved the Reichstag Fire Decree in February 1933 which suspended various civil liberties. Later in March, he signed the Enabling Act of 1933 which gave Hitler's regime emergency powers. After Hindenburg died the following year, Hitler combined the Presidency with his office as Chancellor before proceeding to declare himself Führer und Reichskanzler des deutschen Volkes (i.e. "Leader and Reich Chancellor of the German People") and transform Germany into a totalitarian state.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by postingpals on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:37AM (#25504244)
> They won a plurality, not a majority

You speak of this as if it's not a legitimate electoral structure in place in many countries today, especially America. When OP says they voted fascists into power it carries the same weight whether it was by majority or plurality, in the former case it means most people 'wanted' it, in the latter it means enough people were okay with letting it happen.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by brodie on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:41AM (#25504565)
I wish the governments of America were more consensus-oriented. Less “enough people were okay with [it]” and more “most interested and affected parties can agree to it and be okay with it.”
Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by gwd on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @04:47AM (#25504598)
> Hindenburg ultimately agreed to appoint Hitler as Chancellor of Germany in January 1933 when the Nazis won a plurality in the November elections.

This is a misrepresentation of what happened too. The democratically-elected Nazis formed a coalition government with the democratically-elected German National People's Party (DNVP); it was this coalition government which was approved by the democratically-elected Hindenberg. The Enabling Act was also first passed by the democratically-elected Reichstag.

So yes, Hindenberg failed to fulfill his role as the "check and balance" against the rise of someone like Hitler; but it's not like what he was doing was strange or unusual.

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by SnowProblem on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:31AM (#25504209)
PBS released a great 3-part documentary last month on exactly this called Rise of the Nazis. It focuses on the years 1930-1933.

https://www.pbs.org/show/rise-nazis

Re:Congress Crams Language to Criminalize Streaming, Meme-Sh... by TurkishPoptart on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @02:42PM (#25510254)
Good to know. I love PBS docs!