If you're talking specifically about urban cities, I still bet Japan/Germany have been urban planning for sidewalks which encourages "good behavior".
I think this reflects a lot of comments, "American's are lazy" and "Look at this german punks walking and respecting traffic laws!" Is the argument US is just inherently lazy? Could there be something else at play? I think it's just that when a use case isn't a main focus of design those users will be stuck trying to hack the system or having a poor experience. USA isn't designed for walkers most places, those people will behave "badly" because of it.
Also, yes there are strip malls that bad, I can show one but then we'll be having pedantic arguments over "hey if you walk an extra 600 feet you have a sidewalk!" or something. Like, even the idea of a strip mall inherently is car centric, with most square footage devoted to parking and who wants to walk (or even drive!) through a parking lot.
If the shoe fits... I've seen too many young slightly chubby people coasting around on mobility scooters at Walmart instead of walking a few hundred meters to think laziness isn't a strong component to this sort of behavior.
Exactly, which is why the decriminalization of jaywalking in those cities is a terrible idea. Orange County isn't going to be redesigned, so more jaywalkers means more pedestrian deaths.
No option is perfect, but it's layering unfairness on unfairness, ESPECIALLY considering that such laws are often selectively enforced.
Why should pedestrians keep out of your way and not cross your path? Why don't we instead say you should keep out of the pedestrians way and not cross their path?
Maybe we should reset the expectation that cars own the streets, and make them a guest there, deferring to human beings in the first instance.
I agree that the US infrastructure doesn't do enough to support pedestrian and bicycle transport. Expecting people cross only at intersections that are a half-mile apart is unrealistic. Expecting people to cross at a cross-walk that is 5 yards away is not. Crossing just beyond an intersection is the most dangerous possible place to cross due to inherently poor visibility, and all the competing demands for attention that drivers and pedestrians encounter around an intersection. This isn't a matter of rights or relative importance, its a matter of physics and human ability.
Wishing away all the cars is not practical solution, which is what your post essentially amounts to.
Look at this video's and others from this channel, to see how the netherlands builds infrastructure being more forgiving of mistakes, and find out how our cities turn out more livable:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ra_0DgnJ1uQ
(Yes, i'm aware the suburban culture is different, hence the relation with cars)
There are plenty of things that could be useful, yet aren't in the context of civilized society. For instance, shotguns are useful for killing squirrels. That alone doesn't grant someone the right to use them that way at any place or time.
"Wishing" people into crosswalks is also not a practical solution.
a) Because it's the law, b) because there's a power dynamic. I can accidentally kill a pedestrian, a pedestrian can't accidentally kill me unless they throw a brick off an overpass.
> Why should pedestrians keep out of your way and not cross your path?
So that they take responsibility for their own safety.
> Why don't we instead say you should keep out of the pedestrians way and not cross their path?
Because I disagree I should be liable if someone darts out into traffic and is struck by my car.
> Maybe we should reset the expectation that cars own the streets, and make them a guest there, deferring to human beings in the first instance.
In dense cities... sure, I agree. In car-heavy suburban areas where everything is super spread out? I don't think this is a necessarily a good idea.
You even talk in the passive voice about people being struck by your car rather than you striking them with your car.
That's a shit attitude.
I can do that, of course, but I then become a road hazard. I find it hard to believe that the overall safety would increase as a result. I'm open to being otherwise convinced.
I would never intentionally strike a pedestrian in my vehicle, but a situation where a) I am driving the speed limit, b) a pedestrian jaywalking forces me to reflexively brake is not safe. So either the speed limit needs to be lowered, or pedestrians need to behave more safely. I would not need to reflexively brake if pedestrians waited their turn at a designated crosswalk.
There are ways for pedestrian to get small fine, but generally cars are supposed to be in control and watch for pedestrians.
This isn’t true - a street of just cars will have lethal crashes amongst themselves even with no pedestrians. A street of just pedestrians will never lethally bump into each other. The only lethal thing in the situation is the cars.
Because cars bad, of course. Bicycles and pedestrians should always have the right of way in every situation, of course.
If a pedestrian is walking in the lane on the highway, it's obviously the car's legal responsibility to make way for them.
/s
In Germany, car drivers must always be prepared to brake for pedestrians, including children and elderly people. Children as young as 6-7 walk the streets alone or in packs, so the kid dashing is real possibility. No one is gonna call CPS over it, schools literally recommend first graders to walk to school alone.
Pedestrian must use shortest path through street, but does not have to use crossing - you have to use crossing only if one is available within 40m or so.
The power dynamic does not really plays out. The cars are slow in cities, cross walks are everywhere.
I'd argue the opposite conclusion and say that as one operating dangerous machinery you should be given lower right of way for safety reasons. The burden should be on you to drive safely more than others to safely stay out of your way.
> So that they take responsibility for their own safety
And what about your responsibility as the person choosing to speed around in a ton of metal?
> In car-heavy suburban areas where everything is super spread out? I don't think this is a necessarily a good idea.
There's a chicken and the egg problem here. Such cities came about because of monopolization of streets by drivers. We can't change that over night but given the vast benefits of people centric urban design we should be tilting the balance away from cars and towards people.
If somebody can dart out in front of my car, isn't that the fault of the person who darted? Or, the civil engineer who designed the road? How can you possibly say that I let myself get into this situation?
(Even if you don't care about hitting somebody, maybe at least consider that it's equivalent to having a 75 kg lump of meat fired at your car at, say, 35 mph.)
I would be pissed off if maximum speed of a train (a 20000+ bhp murder machine, by your standard) that I use to commute was lowered to some 10 kph in order to keep those candidates of the Darwin Award alive.
Being weaker (pedestrian) does not absolve you of all guilt if you decide to hazard with your life.
I think this point supports the other side of the argument. The pedestrian already has a very strong incentive to be careful: they might die otherwise. Of course most car drivers would be horrified to hit a pedestrian, but most care much less about a stranger's safety than their own (and some are complete psychos who won't care unless it materially costs them). So placing the main legal burden on the driver will do more to deter risky behaviour than would placing it on the pedestrian.
I can't imagine how a "commercial center" could have a road with a 45 MPH speed limit. Lowering that to 20 would solve most of the problem.
https://www.google.com/maps/@39.17947,-77.2383268,3a,75y,359...
And here is proof the speed limit is 45:
https://www.google.com/maps/@39.1826157,-77.2383985,3a,75y,1...
Sounds like it is residential. That lady who has to risk death to get her groceries probably doesn't appreciate people going 45+ in her neighborhood.
I think I understand the intent of the law but I guess my own philosophy of "cross where you're far less likely to die" isn't the legal one.
Much more info on the car free city center concept at this wikipedia page: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carfree_city
It really feels like you're trying to make this an "us vs. them" situation negatively, rather than understanding that it's people wanting safer, healthier, more enjoyable places to live by means of reducing car dependence.
Calling someone "anti-something" makes them sound one-sided and hostile.
But based on some comments in this discussion there are absolutely anti-automobile people here and they are vocal. I just responded to someone calling a car a "murder machine".
Knives. Belts. Ropes. Electrical cords. Hammers. Chairs. Frying pans. Scissors. Etc., Etc., Etc., as nauseum, ad infinitum.
knives would be the obvious answer, though they probably don't cause as much accidental carnage as cars.
> Insisting that drivers are careful in any areas where pedestrians might be and being strict about that isn't unreasonable.
sure, but this is a vague statement that has no real teeth. everyone agrees that drivers ought to try not to hit pedestrians. what gets fiercely debated is how civil (and possibly criminal) liability ought to be apportioned.
These aren't slow residential roads either, but roads around commercial centers with speed limits around 45 MPH.
> In the Netherlands, for example, traffic engineers and urban planners have actually worked to lower the country’s curbs so as to encourage people to cross wherever they like.
This I don't understand at all unless it's in low/slow traffic areas.