News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by umvi on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:02PM (#25498879)
> Why do you think the default should be that it's your right of way in the car?

a) Because it's the law, b) because there's a power dynamic. I can accidentally kill a pedestrian, a pedestrian can't accidentally kill me unless they throw a brick off an overpass.

> Why should pedestrians keep out of your way and not cross your path?

So that they take responsibility for their own safety.

> Why don't we instead say you should keep out of the pedestrians way and not cross their path?

Because I disagree I should be liable if someone darts out into traffic and is struck by my car.

> Maybe we should reset the expectation that cars own the streets, and make them a guest there, deferring to human beings in the first instance.

In dense cities... sure, I agree. In car-heavy suburban areas where everything is super spread out? I don't think this is a necessarily a good idea.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by chrisseaton on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:04PM (#25498898)
All your arguments are about protecting yourself and limiting your liability at the expense of the pedestrian and you just slowing down and taking more care.

You even talk in the passive voice about people being struck by your car rather than you striking them with your car.

That's a shit attitude.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by nineplay on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:14PM (#25499035)
I would have to drive very far below the speed limit on any street in my vicinity to be able to safely stop before hitting a jaywalker.

I can do that, of course, but I then become a road hazard. I find it hard to believe that the overall safety would increase as a result. I'm open to being otherwise convinced.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by ck425 on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:57PM (#25500705)
The solution there is that you drop the speed limit for everyone and therefore you're not a road hazard. Anywhere that could have a reasonable number of pedestrians should have adopted limits such that the majority of traffic can safely stop before hitting someone in most cases. Drivers convenience should not trump people's lives.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by umvi on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:11PM (#25498992)
Why am I being villainized for a) going the speed limit, b) complaining about a legitimate safety issue?

I would never intentionally strike a pedestrian in my vehicle, but a situation where a) I am driving the speed limit, b) a pedestrian jaywalking forces me to reflexively brake is not safe. So either the speed limit needs to be lowered, or pedestrians need to behave more safely. I would not need to reflexively brake if pedestrians waited their turn at a designated crosswalk.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by francisofascii on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:50PM (#25499398)
In the effort to find common ground, maybe the villains are not the specific drivers, but the planners or collective culture who decided to built highway like roads next to shopping plazas. "The speed limit needs to be lowered" is a good compromise.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by watwut on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:50PM (#25499393)
You argue by Germany and in Germany jaywalking the way it exists in USA does not really exist. There are a lot more options for pedestrians to cross the street, the marked crossing is not necessary.

There are ways for pedestrian to get small fine, but generally cars are supposed to be in control and watch for pedestrians.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by chrisseaton on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:23PM (#25501467)
You are the safety issue. Without you there is no safety issue. And you should drive accordingly.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by umvi on Monday December 21, 2020 @09:02PM (#25502070)
It takes two to tango. Without the jaywalker there is no safety issue either. So jaywalkers should jaywalk accordingly.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by chrisseaton on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:05AM (#25504065)
> Without the jaywalker there is no safety issue either.

This isn’t true - a street of just cars will have lethal crashes amongst themselves even with no pedestrians. A street of just pedestrians will never lethally bump into each other. The only lethal thing in the situation is the cars.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by falcolas on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:22PM (#25499129)
> Why am I being villainized

Because cars bad, of course. Bicycles and pedestrians should always have the right of way in every situation, of course.

If a pedestrian is walking in the lane on the highway, it's obviously the car's legal responsibility to make way for them.

/s

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by watwut on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:47PM (#25499365)
> a) Because it's the law, b) because there's a power dynamic. I can accidentally kill a pedestrian, a pedestrian can't accidentally kill me unless they throw a brick off an overpass.

In Germany, car drivers must always be prepared to brake for pedestrians, including children and elderly people. Children as young as 6-7 walk the streets alone or in packs, so the kid dashing is real possibility. No one is gonna call CPS over it, schools literally recommend first graders to walk to school alone.

Pedestrian must use shortest path through street, but does not have to use crossing - you have to use crossing only if one is available within 40m or so.

The power dynamic does not really plays out. The cars are slow in cities, cross walks are everywhere.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by ck425 on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:03PM (#25500766)
> b) because there's a power dynamic. I can accidentally kill a pedestrian, a pedestrian can't accidentally kill me unless they throw a brick off an overpass.

I'd argue the opposite conclusion and say that as one operating dangerous machinery you should be given lower right of way for safety reasons. The burden should be on you to drive safely more than others to safely stay out of your way.

> So that they take responsibility for their own safety

And what about your responsibility as the person choosing to speed around in a ton of metal?

> In car-heavy suburban areas where everything is super spread out? I don't think this is a necessarily a good idea.

There's a chicken and the egg problem here. Such cities came about because of monopolization of streets by drivers. We can't change that over night but given the vast benefits of people centric urban design we should be tilting the balance away from cars and towards people.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by tom_ on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:14PM (#25499026)
Why can't you take some responsibility for their safety? You're the one in a 200+ bhp murder machine, not them. If somebody can dart out into the path of your car, you should be asking yourself why you let yourself get into that situation.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by BitwiseFool on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:18PM (#25499083)
>"You're the one in a 200+ bhp murder machine, not them. If somebody can dart out into the path of your car, you should be asking yourself why you let yourself get into that situation."

If somebody can dart out in front of my car, isn't that the fault of the person who darted? Or, the civil engineer who designed the road? How can you possibly say that I let myself get into this situation?

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by tom_ on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:25PM (#25499160)
My point is: why were you not more carefully assessing the situation, to ensure that you were driving at an appropriate speed, given the risk of having somebody leap into the path of your car? That is after all a situation you presumably want to avoid.

(Even if you don't care about hitting somebody, maybe at least consider that it's equivalent to having a 75 kg lump of meat fired at your car at, say, 35 mph.)

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by BitwiseFool on Monday December 21, 2020 @03:35PM (#25499251)
I've had pedestrians dart out in front of my path on three separate occasion in my life. Thankfully, I was aware enough to prevent hitting them. A combination of a slow enough speed, good brakes, enough distance, and luck (to be honest). It was a jarring experience each time, and each time it was completely unexpected. Of course I care about the life of the people who almost got hit - and I'm glad they didn't get maimed. But I absolutely did do a lot of cursing and wondering why they didn't look both ways.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by inglor_cz on Monday December 21, 2020 @04:36PM (#25499893)
From a city that has a lot of public transport (Prague): some people will dart in front of fully loaded buses, trams, or even trains at a railway crossing. That is humanity at its finest. (/s)

I would be pissed off if maximum speed of a train (a 20000+ bhp murder machine, by your standard) that I use to commute was lowered to some 10 kph in order to keep those candidates of the Darwin Award alive.

Being weaker (pedestrian) does not absolve you of all guilt if you decide to hazard with your life.

Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by ck425 on Monday December 21, 2020 @06:33PM (#25501050)
But a train is on specific tracks where a pedestrian has little need to be. That's not the case with cars, which intermingle heavily with pedestrian areas. In those cases I think it's perfectly fair to restrict their speed for safety and to put the onus on the driver to prioritise safety. The alternative is we either ban cars from pedestrian areas completely or we just accept the deaths or heavy inconvenience of pedestrians (which seems to be the current US model).
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by yw3410 on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:44PM (#25502614)
Please think a little about what you've said; that you'd rather a fellow human would be killed for less than 5 minutes of convenience for you.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by Noumenon72 on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @01:59AM (#25503722)
That's exactly what the jaywalker said about their own life when they decided to jump out into traffic to get across sooner. And it's a rational calculation: the five minutes saved is concretely useful and the chance of a death is low. When you do the math and present value calculation, you get more of your life to enjoy if you risk it sometimes.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by anigbrowl on Monday December 21, 2020 @04:38PM (#25499908)
You have more power, therefore a greater burden should fall on the pedestrian than you? Hmm.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by umvi on Monday December 21, 2020 @08:58PM (#25502049)
Yes. If you disagree, jump in front of an oncoming train at the last second. After all the train has much more power than you and therefore the burden falls on the train operator to keep an eye out for you and save your life.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by chrisseaton on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @03:07AM (#25504079)
Train lines rarely run through shared space with pedestrians in the West. Cars want to run through shared space all over the place.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by recursive on Monday December 21, 2020 @10:35PM (#25502558)
And in fact, train operators, do in fact make significant efforts to avoid killing people. It doesn't prevent all deaths. I believe it's reasonable to hold motorists to the same standard. "Make significant effort to avoid killing people". It's not a guarantee, if that's what you wanted to hear.
Re:Jaywalking decriminalization, 100 years after the auto in... by retsibsi on Tuesday December 22, 2020 @05:42AM (#25504924)
> because there's a power dynamic. I can accidentally kill a pedestrian, a pedestrian can't accidentally kill me unless they throw a brick off an overpass.

I think this point supports the other side of the argument. The pedestrian already has a very strong incentive to be careful: they might die otherwise. Of course most car drivers would be horrified to hit a pedestrian, but most care much less about a stranger's safety than their own (and some are complete psychos who won't care unless it materially costs them). So placing the main legal burden on the driver will do more to deter risky behaviour than would placing it on the pedestrian.