News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by iseanstevens on Saturday December 19, 2020 @09:38PM (#25483359)
I come away from this way more impressed by the M1 than I was going in. It's a comparison of a ~$700 stock, low end full computer Vs. $700 for high end CPU only. And the high end CPU has overclocking tweaks enabled, and overclocked memory.

The M1 generally keeps up quite well, which blows my mind. The power use difference Is pretty big as well.

Yeah, it would be great if Apple was totally open source.

But this is going to push the entire industry to do way better.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by kuschku on Saturday December 19, 2020 @09:47PM (#25483401)
The M1 also has overclocked memory (by spec, DDR4 only supports 3200MHz), and the 5800X isn't a 700$ CPU, actually it's at 450$ (and it will fall even further soon, I bought a 3900x recently for below 400$).
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by KSS42 on Saturday December 19, 2020 @10:59PM (#25483750)
M1 uses LPDDR4X at 4267MHz. It is not overclocked.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by fulafel on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:40AM (#25484862)
Nitpick: It's 4266 MT/s (at 2133 MHz). DDR is 2 transfers per clock.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by kuschku on Monday December 21, 2020 @05:44AM (#25493714)
If that's true, then it actually is entirely in-spec. I had read several articles claiming it was running at 4266MHz, which would definitely have been extremely out of JEDEC spec, but not unusual for current-gen DDR4 XMP profiles.

Some higher-end RAM even gets above 5100MHz / 10200MT/s https://www.crucial.de/memory/ddr4/blm2k8g51c19u4b, so I had expected Apple to get somewhere around 7600-8400MT/s at 16-19-19-36 or better timings.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by Scarbutt on Saturday December 19, 2020 @10:09PM (#25483499)
Still... $450 for the CPU only vs a $999 laptop, for most use cases the apple's MBA offers much more value and will have slower depreciation.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by Macha on Saturday December 19, 2020 @11:51PM (#25483958)
CPU: $450 (5800x)

GPU: $150 (1650 super)

Storage: $60 (samsung 970 evo 250gb)

PSU: $90 (silverstone sfx 500w 80 plus gold - there's probably cheaper options but most PSUs seem sold out on amazon)

RAM: $70 (16gb 3200mhz CL16, gskill or team group)

Case: $70 (Silverstone tek)

Motherboard: $120 (asrock b550-m itx)

There's your $1000 mac killer. I wouldn't call it a sensible build, but it should outperform the mac across the board. Notably the GPU is significantly better but the closest gpu the m1 is to trading blows with is the Radeon 560 which is only $30 cheaper. Also the mac comes with 8gb ram in the base model, and 16gb is a $200 upgrade but I could not find a decent speed 2x4gb ddr4 kit as nobody wants that little ram anymore in a custom build. I could save $40 by going with a 1x8gb kit for $30, but single channel will hurt performance.

I'd also consider $30 to go from the 250gb ssd to a 1tb variant, something apple charges $400 for.

The reason I wouldn't call it sensible is that the 1650 super is a budget gaming card while the 5800x a higher tier cpu. If you were actually planning to build this for gaming I'd suggest dropping down to the 5600x and putting the extra $100. actually for gaming I'd even suggest squeezing the budget for a 2060 (or even better wait for the standard 3060) by dropping to basic ddr4-2133, and going for standard sized case/psu rather than the small form factor to chase the mac.

On the other hand, if you're not gaming and just need a video output, save like 120 bucks and just get a gt 1030. Use that to buy some nicer RAM or more cores via a 5900x depending on what suits your workload better. Sadly you have to get _a gpu_ as Intel is falling behind and AMD won't give us high end APUs in the individual market.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by stickyricky on Sunday December 20, 2020 @12:13AM (#25484041)
Doesn't include monitor, keyboard, mouse, speakers, webcam, microphone, battery backup, and fingerprint scanner which would be necessary to make it "comparable" to a base model Macbook Air.

It also isn't a portable, fanless laptop which has its perks.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by CoolGuySteve on Sunday December 20, 2020 @01:04AM (#25484241)
There are plenty of 8 core/16 thread Ryzen 4750U laptops for around the same price that outclass the M1 in multicore benchmarks.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by agloeregrets on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:10AM (#25484751)
In most programming benchmarks, single core and RAM is the game. That’s why the machine in this post has overclocked ram and an undervolted CPU. In that area the 4750u loses badly. In Node for example you will see nearly 60% better performance on M1.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by agloeregrets on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:52AM (#25485645)
(I am wondering why that got downvoted, perhaps it upset someone.) the 4750u sits at around a 1050pt GB5 single threaded score while the 5800x (with tweaks detailed in the article) scores ~1800. The M1 is 1700 or so. The 4750U just isn’t there for things like Node and scores similarly to Intel’s best desktop CPUs which are real world 50% slower at these very tasks than the M1 (or I imagine, this 5800x)
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by rfoo on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:59AM (#25486233)
Dunno, maybe because compared to Node.js developers, C/C++/Rust developers have more time to burn on HN (due to their multithreaded build still takes ages), so they are more likely to show up and make a downvote?

Joke aside, claiming "In most programming benchmarks, single core and RAM is the game" is far from truth.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by fulafel on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:50AM (#25484900)
Also benchmarks are biased towards multicore use cases, probably because slow things that feel like heavy computation are more commonly had parallelization efforts put into them, and are fun to benchmark.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by tastyminerals on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:06AM (#25484516)
It may outclass it in performance. However, all my life I've been waiting for something that runs over 10h on a single charge. I am naturally surprised that this is not something that ppl truly appreciate in a laptop. Hell, I even bought a cheap Atom laptop once just to have more battery time. So as of now, there's literally no decent competitor to M1 laptops. One must be living under a rock to buy anything but Apple and this is coming from someone who doesn't have Apple products and always hated their walled off ecosystem. I am reconsidering my life choices :)
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by db48x on Sunday December 20, 2020 @02:20AM (#25484576)
Using a laptop screen for 10 hours a day is a waste of a day, and if you're at your desk with multiple monitors then you don't need a laptop.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by Toutouxc on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:43AM (#25485601)
What if I want to use the same machine both at my desk and at work? The ability to use the machine on-the-go is one thing, but the actual portability is second. But you already knew that, didn't you.

Not saying I agree with the "One must be living under a rock to buy anything but Apple" part, that's nonsense.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by db48x on Sunday December 20, 2020 @10:11AM (#25486715)
Sure, having a laptop in that case is unavoidable, but you won't _require_ 10 hours of battery life either.

In the long term I don't think laptops are exactly the right answer for portability. I think the ideal would be that when we get up from our desks, all of our running programs (even the whole OS) would migrate to our phones. As soon as we open our laptop, they would all migrate there.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by woah on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:08AM (#25487180)
That’s just your opinion. You don’t need large monitors to code (lines of code are 80-100 characters), and moving around and changing positions (desk to couch etc) every couple hours while working is generally better for health and concentration. Not having to hunt around for a power adapter makes it that much easier and better.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by kuschku on Monday December 21, 2020 @07:00AM (#25494100)
Using a laptop for 10h is super useful for days where you have to travel somewhere, have an appointment, and travel another 5h by train back. Avoids having to constantly have it plugged in in the train, and allows using it even in trains without power sockets
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by Xevi on Sunday December 20, 2020 @09:11AM (#25486285)
Neither does the Mac Mini, what's your point? If you're building your own desktop PC, then you're clearly not comparing it to a laptop.

On top of that, Apple charges $300 (in Sweden) for every 8GB of RAM, and $300 for every 500GB of SSD storage you add. The costs quickly even out. Unless you buy the absolute cheapest Mac Mini version, a self-built PC will be cheaper, at least according to the PCs I've built.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by eertami on Sunday December 20, 2020 @06:51AM (#25485637)
>Doesn't include monitor, keyboard, mouse, speakers, webcam, microphone, battery backup, and fingerprint scanner which would be necessary to make it "comparable" to a base model Macbook Air.

Let us not pretend that you don't need to also buy a keyboard, monitor, speakers, and mouse for the Macbook Air to be in anyway usable.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by zimpenfish on Sunday December 20, 2020 @07:45AM (#25485880)
> Let us not pretend that you don't need to also buy a keyboard, monitor, speakers, and mouse for the Macbook Air to be in anyway usable.

Having worked on Mac laptops for the last 8 years without external keyboard, monitor, speakers or mouse, I beg to differ.

[dead]
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by tonyhb on Sunday December 20, 2020 @07:46AM (#25485884)
You also have to unbox each component vs' just the macbook air, am I right?

Sarcasm aside, I don't think assembling a PC has any factor in performance/price here...

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by speedgoose on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:27AM (#25487350)
@dang Someone flagged my comments. I think they were very normal, about the value of a MacBook air M1 compared to buying parts and assembling a PC, but perhaps they were against the rules.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by jbverschoor on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:34AM (#25484842)
Then at least compare it to a macmini, which starts at $679

Don't forget to include your windows license ;-)

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by ykl on Sunday December 20, 2020 @12:10AM (#25484026)
The parent post appears to be discussing a MacBook Air though. The specified machine doesn’t do much good for someone looking for a laptop; I’d be very surprised if the average customer compares a MacBook Air type device with a PC desktop when shopping for a new computer.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by agloeregrets on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:07AM (#25484736)
By the point you get the Mobo CPU and PSU you already are over the price of an M1 Mac Mini and even then, to get the results seen in this you need to overclock ram and under volt the CPU in a big way, putting you at risk of a good bin vs bad situation. Personally the fact that they had to start with some serious tweaking on a desktop to even compete with a laptop CPU seems messy.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by pojzon on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:26AM (#25485020)
It would be a miracle to buy 1650 Super for 150 bucks where I live. They rose twice in price aleast. It would be more like 250-300$ for that card.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by africanboy on Sunday December 20, 2020 @07:20PM (#25490898)
Actually if you buy the 16gb model with the 512GB SSD you'll spend € 1.659,00 in Europe.
[dead]
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by Ar-Curunir on Sunday December 20, 2020 @12:34AM (#25484107)
? What part of “M1 outclasses every similar laptop” indicates to you that the MBA is a machine targeted at people who don’t do serious computer work

(Whatever “serious” means)

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by coldtea on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:49AM (#25485085)
Parent probably associates some value in dishing Apple, the reverse-fan-boy phenomenon.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by superkuh on Sunday December 20, 2020 @11:15AM (#25487229)
First, the article is about performance benchmarks and how the M1 is not some magical entity like the Apple hype train has been screaming. Second, the comment I'm replying to is:

>for most use cases the apple's MBA offers much more value and will have slower depreciation.

You can build a fine computer with a $400 CPU and $500 left for the rest. One that will absolutely dominate any laptop over a long time span because laptops cannot dissipate heat forever (it's simple a matter of mass and shape).

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by matwood on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:59AM (#25486232)
I got an M1 MBA to use until the real pro machines come out. It's much faster than the 2017 MBP it replaced, and does it while staying completely silent. The no fan noise is uncanny...sort of like a 'is this thing working?'.

Not scientific at all, but one of my large java app test suites takes ~7 minutes to run on my 2017 MPB and ~3 minutes to run on the M1 MBA using the Azul ARM build.

I can't wait for the 16" MBP with Apple Silicon.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by eyelidlessness on Sunday December 20, 2020 @08:16PM (#25491165)
Worth noting that the M1 MBA doesn’t have a fan at all, noise-making or otherwise. But the M1 MBP has been similarly described as fan silent, even with its fans running.
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by fvv on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:14AM (#25484763)
Why ? Comparison on single core bench is at disadvantage of the bigger cpu not the opposite , the m1 would have seemed even better against a 128 core epic of 7k$.. Wait some weeks and see how it compares to a 5x00u , also consider that apple is 'cheaper' now because are trying to bring more people fast to help transition to arm .. then everyone will be locked in in the ecosystem happy to pay the 30% apple tax for the entire life of the hw
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by socialdemocrat on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:47AM (#25484893)
That is kind of conspiratorial sounding. Apple has to charge more than a PC maker which spends almost nothing on build, quality, design, developing and maintaining their own OS and software.

Charging more in the premium segment is normal in any industry because you a smaller volume to spread fixed costs over.

Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by fvv on Sunday December 20, 2020 @03:51AM (#25484907)
I was saying the opposite.. apple could charge even more imo but then leave the hardware free like others do , if you solder everything, firmware lock everything , sell upgrades at 5x the price (and compare the price of the baseline to say.. wow it's cheap ) then apply a tax on all software, now when we compare prices we should account for that also
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by fvv on Sunday December 20, 2020 @04:00AM (#25484928)
The entry level is cheap so apple can win some price bench comparison ..also in general I can understand what is marketed like that but I don't have appreciate that btw. why we don't compare the 16gb ram 1tb ssd Mac 2.5kusd against a 700usd 4800u with same spec ? If you are comparing programmers productivity.. or for a better monitor monitor .. ok let's use a 900usd 4800u then.. ok 80% of perf in single core and 140% on multi for less than half the price.. and wait the 5800u and see.. when you compare you have to be fair between the components.. single core bench from 12core 24th vs 4core it's the start of every biased bench
Re:Ryzen 5800X vs. M1: Programming benchmarks by PaulBGD_ on Sunday December 20, 2020 @12:11AM (#25484031)
Well, $700 for the CPU + mobo and maybe a cooler. But it really is impressive still.