News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by jamesbritt on Saturday May 14, 2011 @11:15AM (#2547774)
Well, why are you buying a house just to sell it a few years later?

Your post mentioned at least four different cities where you lived in an apartment. How would owning a house have changed your mobility? What would it have done to your overall cost of housing if you needed to sell one house and buy another?

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by pstack on Saturday May 14, 2011 @11:26AM (#2547812)
I agree that owning a home limits your mobility and that is one reason why I put it off. In retrospect, I should have bought a home earlier, anyway. In fact, when I first moved to Denver, I started looking at homes and decided against it. After all, I didn't plan to live here forever. Only awhile. Next thing I knew, I had been here for five years and spent that whole time giving money to someone else.

The cities I listed as having lived in were actually three (I realize that I was unclear about California, where I worked in SF but actually lived in San Jose). I can break it down to under a year in one place and at least six years in each of the other two places. Even there, I actually could have probably found a way to not move, so it wouldn't even have been an issue. (I've had the same employer for almost fifteen years).

So, in my case, it was only a perceived need for mobility and unwillingness to say "I'm here, for a long time" that kept me from owning a home and it was probably not the best financial decision, looking back. I sacrificed a lot of income over the years for something I thought I needed, but never did.

It is definitely a bigger concern, now, than ever before. I absolutely concede that point. My grandfather built his home and lived there for more than fifty years. I will be happy if I keep my home for ten or fifteen. Our lives and careers change too often, now. Buying a home now requires the added consideration of whether you'll still be here in five or ten years and how many times (especially in technology) has taking a new job also required moving? (By the way, I think they say it tends to require about five years of ownership to compensate for the costs of buying and selling a house - and that was back when houses were increasing in prices, instead of decreasing).

Of course, if home prices reached a naturally lower point instead of being artificially kept up, then the affordability may trump all the other concerns. Hell, if I could own a nice home for $100k, I'd buy one in all three of my favorite cities and never have to worry about uncertainties of live and mobility again!

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by mattmanser on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:16PM (#2547927)
I never get the mentality of renting being 'giving money to someone else'.

What do you think a mortgage is? The majority of your payments in the first 5 years go to interest, which is just giving money to a different person.

And on top of that you're paying more in hidden costs, stuff like estate agent fees, tax on any future house sale, home insurance, structural problems, boilers, plumbing, etc. which is giving money to more different people just not at a convenient monthly time.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by pstack on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:42PM (#2547991)
I think the point is long-term thinking. As you mentioned, over the life of a 30 year mortgage, I'm likely to have paid about double what I bought the house for. However, that's $900/mo today and that'll be $900/mo in 30 years. In 10 years, that'll be worth $675/mo, in 20 it'll be worth $495/mo and in 30 it'll be worth $270/mo. Meanwhile, the unit I was renting will probably be $1,500, $2,136, and $2,760.

So, I think even the expenses I've incurred (I replaced the power junction box and ugpraded it from 50amp to 200amp, installed several dedicated circuits, and did tons of other work to this place) will seem small in the long run, as will the interest included in my mortgage. Of course, I only have a 30yr mortgage as a failsafe. So that "if things go really bad, I only am obligated to a certain amount per month". Unless things go totally awry, I'm expecting to pay it off in half that time, which will be an enormous savings. (Also, payment on mortgage interest is tax deductible).

And best of all, in the end, I have a house and property to show for it. So even if it came out to be on par with renting for thirty years, I don't end up owning anything at the end of those three decades when I'm renting.

Of course, in the meantime, I'm keeping my fingers crossed that something doesn't arise that requires me to move and spoil the whole plan. That would suck. But the long term game will be beneficial. That's an admitted risk I have to take, since just about none of us can ever be absolutely sure that we'll still be where we are in five, ten, fifteen, or twenty years.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by mattmanser on Sunday May 15, 2011 @10:56AM (#2550036)
You can't compare apples with oranges, the rent on your old place is a different place, so you can't use those figures. You could be renting the home you're in now, that figure is the only figure you should be using in comparison.

You also don't seem to be taking into account that interest rates are very, very low at the moment, you definitely can't plan around those rates. Sometimes renting is cheaper than your mortgage payments, sometimes its more expensive. It depends on interest rates.

A lot of lenders also have heavy penalties for early payment. If you don't it probably means that the lender has given you an overall worse rate to compensate for the fact that you're probably going to pay early.

They always get their money. That's how banks work.

Buying a house has been a disaster for some people, causing some serious financial difficulty because they bought when they couldn't afford to, ending up with interest-only mortgages and are now in negative equity.

All because they believed that renting is throwing money away. I just wanted to clarify that it's definitely not.

I also want to point out that the tax-break you're currently getting is by no means guaranteed to remain for the lifetime of your mortgage. Governments use that to encourage home ownership. After the recent disaster it's only going to be a matter of time before someone starts questioning why this amazing tax break exists. Abolishing it is also a politically easier way to raise tax revenues without actually raising the tax rate, which allows politicians to say they stuck to their promise of not raising the tax rate. Here in the UK it was got rid of long ago. This also applies to any capital gains tax relief you think you'll be getting in the future.

Buying a house can be just as expensive, if not more and in fact carries far more risk as you can lose all your initial investment if you end up in negative equity or suddenly find yourself at flood risk due to rising sea levels or whatever it may be.

All you can lose renting is your deposit.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by jeffdavis on Sunday May 15, 2011 @02:13PM (#2550410)
"You also don't seem to be taking into account that interest rates are very, very low at the moment, you definitely can't plan around those rates."

That's what 30-year fixed means: you can plan around those rates for the life of the mortgage.

"A lot of lenders also have heavy penalties for early payment. If you don't it probably means that the lender has given you an overall worse rate to compensate..."

I think that's fairly rare now. There are plenty of reasons that buying a house might be bad; but in this environment, bad loan terms are not one of them as long as you shop around.

"All you can lose renting is your deposit."

It's more complicated than that. Rising rents can be a risk, too, because you need to live somewhere. Also, there are costs (financial and otherwise) if you are forced to move by the landlord.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by nostrademons on Monday May 16, 2011 @02:17AM (#2551826)
The interest rate risk on a house isn't just the mortgage payment. It's also the value of the house itself.

House prices tend to move inversely to interest rates. When interest rates are low, then new home buyers can afford a bigger principal values on a loan of a given monthly payment. The market adjusts to accomodate this, and house prices rise to take up that principal value. When interest rates fall, new home buyers can't afford to take out as big a mortgage, so the supply of cash available in the market declines, and prices fall accordingly.

In 2006, when interest rates were at historic lows and home prices were at historic highs, I worked out who was making the profit from all of this. Obviously, existing homeowners who sold into that market were making a killing; where was the money coming from? It wasn't coming from the people who bought the house: they were paying the same monthly payment, for the same loan terms, as people who bought in the not-so-bubble years before. It might've been coming from the banks, but ultimately their profits were indifferent too, because they were just passing along their low borrowing costs. Trace the money all the way back, and it was being injected directly into the economy by the Fed, through low discount rates. That reduced the banks' borrowing costs, which reduced their mortgage rates, which increased the size of the loan that could be written for a given monthly payment, which increased the amount of cash in the housing market, which made housing prices go up.

And then I wondered what would happen when this system went into reverse, interest rates started to rise, and cash came out of the system. This started to happen in 2007, but then the system froze up, the Fed panicked, and the floodgates opened again. It will probably happen again at some point in the future, unless we get full-on hyperinflation.

Anyway, the obvious losers are people who bought houses with inflated mortgages for inflated prices. With high interest rates, new home buyers can't afford as big a mortgage for the same monthly payment, so house prices must come down for anyone to be able to buy. But who are the winners? Not (really) banks, who're just passing along the borrowing costs from the deposits they have. It's actually people who are holding cash right now and looking to buy in the near future. They're acting as a mini-bank in their own right: if you can buy a house with cash (or put down an absurd down payment like 50+%), then you're effectively acting as your own bank, but without any borrowing costs. Any rise in interest rates goes straight to your pocket.

tl;dr: Falling interest rates are good for homeowners, ambivalent for mortgaged buyers, and bad for people with cash savings. Rising interest rates a bad for homeowners, ambivalent for mortgaged buyers, and good for people with cash savings.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by anamax on Monday May 16, 2011 @01:36AM (#2551767)
> A lot of lenders also have heavy penalties for early payment.

I've had at least 5 mortages (in the US) and have never seen a prepayment penalty. That's not to say that they don't exist, but I'd like to see some evidence for "a lot of lenders". More specifics please.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by nasmorn on Monday May 16, 2011 @07:28AM (#2552216)
The parent is from the UK and for Europe he is certainly right. Im from Austria and here it is seriously expensive to prepay.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by nhangen on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:26PM (#2547946)
Yes, but when you pay off the home, it's yours. Sure, you still have to pay maintenance, taxes, and insurance, but a home warranty can solve many of the problems associated with the first, and you have to pay insurance anyway (renters).

I moved to FL and we're renting out our NC home while paying rent in Florida, and I loathe being a renter again.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by illumin8 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @06:47PM (#2548760)
You should realize that it's not really yours. The government can and will take it for many various reasons. You merely have a "right to use" it.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by CamperBob on Sunday May 15, 2011 @01:34AM (#2549395)
Would be curious to hear why you were modded down. The fact is, cash-strapped states and municipalities are going to see property owners as sheep primed for the shearing over the next several years.

As a homeowner you may be able to avoid paying rent, and you may even be able to avoid paying interest, but good luck avoiding the property-tax increases that are probably coming your way.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by salemh on Sunday May 15, 2011 @04:45AM (#2549611)
You need sources, as does the down-voted comment. Cash-strapped states does not equal "eminent domain" on random suburbs. Some tax-levels on property taxes are going down or neutral (Utah) while others remain the same (California, both () examples are personal experience) and can't be used as a broad paint-brush stroke.

Interest is a tax write off, many states are suing for home-owner protection, the very large fraud lawsuits against mortgage lenders, etc.

http://www.google.com/#sclient=psy&hl=en&source=hp&#...

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by billswift on Sunday May 15, 2011 @05:42AM (#2549666)
Property tax increases will hit renters just as hard, since they pay them as part of their rent. Maybe even harder, since rents are often calculated as a percentage above fixed costs.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by gills on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:37PM (#2547981)
By definition, as a renter, you pay those same costs plus a small proft margin plus a premium to cover the times it's not occupied. Unless your landlord is a moron.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by beagle3 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:00PM (#2548028)
If you're staying in the same place for ~10 years, that is right. However, if you are NOT staying long term, you pay that + a profit margin to your landlord, but avoid the (usually 6%-8% all things considered) friction that goes to real estate agents, etc.

If you live in NYC, and your studio apartment is worth $500K, that's $40K in friction costs -- rent for 16-18 months for the same unit. Ammortized over 10 years, it is not a big deal. However, if you move after 3 years, that brings your "owner equivalent rent" up by 50%.

Circumstance is everything.

In a city like NYC or SF where most people can't afford a house larger than they need at the moment, the introduction of kids forces you to move -- thus, if you're planning kids in the next few years, you're better off renting even if you know you'll stay in SF for the next 20 years.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by mrgordon on Saturday May 14, 2011 @02:43PM (#2548268)
False. Your landlord could have purchased the place at an advantageous time many years or decades before you would have been ready to purchase a home. Thus the landlord could charge less than a current or recent homebuyer could charge while still profiting or at least covering costs.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by anamax on Monday May 16, 2011 @01:39AM (#2551775)
> Thus the landlord could charge less than a current or recent homebuyer could charge while still profiting or at least covering costs.

That landlord would be better off selling.

Folks don't charge based on their costs. They charge what the market will bear above their costs.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by herdrick on Saturday May 14, 2011 @03:41PM (#2548396)
No, your rent is a function of the supply and demand of rentals.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Saturday May 14, 2011 @11:39AM (#2547847)
I'd probably just rent my house out. Over the years I've purchased enough of the principle (by overpaying on the mortgage, the difference buys down the principle) that my monthly payment is about the same as the rental rate for a home this size in my area. Even if I lose a little bit every month, I'm just buying more of my own place with somebody else's money.

Something the parent mismentioned is not that he'll be paying $1000/mo 5 years from now while rental rates will simply go up, but you can actually reduce that rate now and free up more of your income for later. It's actually the sole reason I've been able to fund my co-founder to work on our startup full-time while I work a regular boring old day job, I've paid down so much of the principle the past few years that, along with pay raises from my day job, I have enough cash on hand to float another person for the foreseeable future.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by notauser on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:49PM (#2548007)
"I'm just buying more of my own place with somebody else's money."

At the cost of incurring risks including but not limited to:

  - Property damage by renters and others.
  - Property damage by acts of god (flooding/fire/subsidence).
  - Default on payments & long eviction periods.
  - Low occupancy/months without rent.
  - Downward price movements in the market as a whole.
  - Downward price movements in your location due to ghettoization, tax increases, service/school decline, structural unemployment or other factors.
Could be worth it for the gain in equity, but it's something to think about - especially as some of these risks can't be insured against.

You are also forgoing returns on your existing equity if you invested it elsewhere. Risk free interest rates for retail deposits here in the UK are currently above 3% for example.

In addition to that you also have the costs (in time and money) of:

  - Management time/effort.
  - Time to deal with renters and searches.
  - Organizing maintenance.
  - Costs of credit scoring etc.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:23PM (#2548091)
All good points. You have to figure in costs of use when renting. As it turns out in my locale, you can reduce your taxes when renting under the assumption that renters are beating your place up and thus reducing the property value.

I'm fortunate enough to live in an area where finding renters will never be a problem should I end up that route, but you make an excellent point about that.

Also, eviction periods are not too bad in most parts of the U.S., you can write terms into the lease that also help short fuse eviction on non-payment if many places.

The biggest concern I have above all others is just managing the renters. There are services you can hire to handle all that and maintenance, but they consume some not insignificant part of the rent as payment.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by nhangen on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:46PM (#2548148)
I pay 10%/month to a rental company to handle most of that for me. As to the first - this is why you take a deposit, and why you have money in the bank just in case something goes wrong.

The first list is full of what if's...

As a renter:

What if the landlord gets foreclosed on and you are forced out What if they don't pay to fix anything What if the building burns down and you lose everything etc

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by pstack on Saturday May 14, 2011 @11:48AM (#2547869)
In the year that I've owned my home, I've toyed with the idea of renting out a room or two. I have three bedrooms and I don't use any of them. I live in my basement. I know, I know. That sounds stupid. I have a basement that is the size of all but the largest apartment I've rented and it is where my sweet home theater is as well as my home office (I telecommute). Since it's where I spend so much time, I threw a sofa and a futon and an enormous bean bag down there (and a fridge and microwave). Now, I never even go to the top floor where the bedrooms are.

I could rent out all the bedrooms, including the master bedroom (with its own bathroom). I don't even know what the right price would be and I've heard plenty of horror stories about renting to people, but if I renteded even two of the rooms at only $350/mo, I'd have two thirds of my housing costs covered!

And, if I ever need to move, I could buy a house somewhere else and keep this one to rent it out. Again, I hear being a landlord sucks - but I have a handyman nearby who could do on-site work for me and once the house is paid off, the renters would basically be paying the mortgage on my second home.

Also, I plan to pay down the principal, too. I'm not making any extra payments just yet, but I am putting money in a savings account. If I have an emergency, I have access to that money today. If I don't have an emergency, then once I have enough saved up, I can pay off a hell of a lot of my house at once.

Owning a home can be a hassle. God damn, I sure as hell learned that right out of the gate. (I did a lot of remodeling to fit my lifestyle and my electrical needs, among other things). One thing it gives you, however, is more options. More choices, even if not mobility.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by dedward on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:37PM (#2548130)
Just seconding - being a landlord can REALLY suck, and is full of hidden obstacles. You need to be committed to it, get proper legal advice and do everything by the book. In principle (though I don't know specific state laws in the US) - tennants have a lot of rights. It's their HOME - even though you own the structure. You may not be able to evict them because you want to move back in. You may be liable for all kinds of things.

And that handyman close by? That's great - until he has a family emergency and isn't available - then it's 100% on you to fix.

I'm not saying the renting-to-pay-other-mortgage is bad idea - it's not, it's a valid strategy - but it's something to be taken really seriously, not something you should try to just pull out of a hat.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by nhangen on Saturday May 14, 2011 @05:57PM (#2548646)
Take a look at CL, there are no shortages of handymen.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by cookiecaper on Saturday May 14, 2011 @08:41PM (#2548980)
Let me say that we just moved into a rental unit and the landlord is pretty dang carpy. He is too cheap to pay a qualified person to fix anything. Stuff is falling apart all over. He resents us for asking for simple repairs that cost less than a tenth of what we paid to move in. He calls the neighbors to try and get them to do it for free, and if they won't do it, he comes over on the weekend to try and fix it himself (usually failing, always doing a "ghetto fabulous" job).

We are on the verge of asserting my state's statutory process to compel the landlord to fix things because he is too cheap to use a qualified repair person, even on complex or potentially dangerous tasks like the gas stove, and even when there will be a long lag time on repairs if he doesn't.

My advice is that if you're going to be a landlord, get familiar with some of the maintenance companies in your area and don't be too cheap to call them out. I have been following this discussion with some interest, but I really believe any position, renter, owner, or landlord, can make sense in the correct set of circumstances. You just have to think things through and do it the right way, and it will save everyone involved a lot of headache.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by chopsueyar on Saturday May 14, 2011 @12:40PM (#2547989)
You should really convert the basement to a seperate residence, so you can independently live there, while also providing the same conveniences to the renter upstairs.

Rent to a family.

Being a landlord does suck. I have worked closely with a real estate investor managing 30 residential rental properties.

I would say the two biggest issues are the quality of tenants and the quality of homes.

Central A/Cs die. Whole homes need to be repiped. Roof leaks.

Tenants do not pay or will have 5 people in a 2 bedroom home. Eviction is costly and time-consuming.

The only real estate I would consider as an investment right now is something commercial/industrial, like a group of warehouses or office suites, something with multiple renters.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Saturday May 14, 2011 @01:18PM (#2548078)
One pretty much has to assume that your property is going to need a repainting/recarpeting/other repairs when the tenants move out and price accordingly. Most renters (not all mind you) will do all sorts of bad things to your property. Taking that into account is important when renting out.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by pstack on Saturday May 14, 2011 @07:52PM (#2548883)
Unless I moved out of my home, I'd actually be more likely to just rent out rooms. I think there's far less risk and legal complication if you're essentially renting out a room to a "roommate" versus giving over your entire home to another person or family.
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by illumin8 on Saturday May 14, 2011 @06:56PM (#2548772)
I feel compelled to reply. You're basically saying that by paying extra money for years you now pay about the same money as a renter next door. What a terrible way to invest your money. You could have been taking that extra money you were paying in principle payments for years and investing it in conservative investments and making 6-7%. Instead you've wasted it on a depreciating asset that only requires repairs, costs taxes every year, and isn't likely to appreciate in value for the next 3-4 years.

Take all of the extra principle payments you have made - calculate what they would have made at a 5, 6, or 7% interest rate. Then, look at your home equity, subtract the amounts you have paid in repairs and taxes, and ask yourself which number is larger. Chances are you have been foolish with your money.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Saturday May 14, 2011 @08:34PM (#2548966)
Instead you've wasted it on a depreciating asset that only requires repairs, costs taxes every year, and isn't likely to appreciate in value for the next 3-4 years.

I'm not sure you understand the difference between a depreciating asset and an appreciating asset. With very few exceptions, a car is a depreciating asset. It's worth less tomorrow than it is today. A house (with few exceptions) is not a depreciating asset. With the singular exception of 2007-2010, home prices tend to rise.

Also, I'm sorry to say, unless your definition of "conservative instement" includes a money printing machine, no conservative investment vehicle since the end of 2008 has broken even 3%, and 5% since 2007 let alone 6%.

http://www.fhlbdm.com/rg_history.htm

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by wonnage on Sunday May 15, 2011 @04:33AM (#2549602)
I don't know where you're getting your numbers from, but even Treasury I bonds were returning 5.93% (according to the calculator at http://www.treasurydirect.gov/BC/SBCPrice).

In any case, "home prices tend to rise" doesn't make sense if you're trying to justify buying one as an investment. Borrow ten times your net worth and buy a house hoping it'll appreciate. Not exactly a brilliant investment scheme.

Also, you could argue that a house is a depreciating asset. Shit breaks and you have to maintain it. If you were a business you'd actually have to account for depreciation on buildings.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Sunday May 15, 2011 @12:33PM (#2550215)
Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by wonnage on Sunday May 15, 2011 @06:14PM (#2550920)
"In the United States, residential rental buildings are depreciable over a 27.5 year or 40 year life, other buildings over a 39 or 40 year life, and land improvements over a 15 or 20 year life, all using the straight line method."

Basically the only thing that will appreciate when owning a house is the land it sits on. A really nice house in a crappy area is going to lose value until the demand for the location starts going up again.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by westicle on Saturday May 14, 2011 @10:41PM (#2549160)
"A house (with few exceptions) is not a depreciating asset. With the singular exception of 2007-2010, home prices tend to rise."

In the words of Shaun Micallef: "All cats are brown, as this exception to the rule proves".

http://www.infochoice.com.au/banking/savings-account/term-de...

If you compare 5-year term deposits most are in the 6.8% - 7.1% range.

Re:Maybe Americans aren't dumb enough to keep buying houses? by bane on Saturday May 14, 2011 @11:46PM (#2549250)
Sorry, we don't have those in the U.S. Our equivalent is called a Certificate of Deposit (CD) and those have just finally climbed above the 1% range after a few years sporting near 0% ROI. Put another way, they weren't even worth the time it took to go down to the bank to buy one.

Now...if you have something over $100,000 USD burning a hole in your pocket that you won't need to touch for a while, you can purchase something called a jumbo CD, and the 5-year instruments will just break 2.3%.