Just about everything we do has some component of persuasion or an appeal to biases. It's a huge can of worms.
Definitely not easy, but probably doable to a certain extent.
Clearly suppressing a truth is bad. But modern technology causes massive amplification of falsehoods in a way that just didn't exist in the past, and that's bad, too.
From a utilitarian perspective, fake news and persuasive technologies do real harm, and not just to the people who are persuaded. Unless something is done at the group level (i.e. by the state) the harm will continue. You might consider that an appropriate trade-off for liberty, but others can reasonably disagree without being weak.
The problem is that we are learning this is not true. Falsehoods can come so fast that the truth never becomes known. https://news.mit.edu/2018/study-twitter-false-news-travels-f...
A lot has changed since 1789, and there is no reason not to re-examine the assumptions that were made then in light of technological developments over the past two centuries plus.
2 Samuel 15:1-6
Now it came about after this that Absalom provided for himself a chariot and horses and fifty men as runners before him. Absalom used to rise early and stand beside the way to the gate; and when any man had a suit to come to the king for judgment, Absalom would call to him and say, “From what city are you?” And he would say, “Your servant is from one of the tribes of Israel.” Then Absalom would say to him, “See, your claims are good and right, but no man listens to you on the part of the king.” Moreover, Absalom would say, “Oh that one would appoint me judge in the land, then every man who has any suit or cause could come to me and I would give him justice.” And when a man came near to prostrate himself before him, he would put out his hand and take hold of him and kiss him. In this manner Absalom dealt with all Israel who came to the king for judgment; so Absalom stole away the hearts of the men of Israel.The latter exists and has been used by Google to offer jobs to users for whom they may have an opening. (Or perhaps a competitor has openings and Google wants to ensure the best candidates not work there, which is what I would do if I were Google.)
That several gargantuan companies have and use this kind of insight into widescale human behavior is more terrible than "grandpa shared some nonsense on facebook."
Edit: clarification
It'd be like saying that all car driving should be banned because high speed driving is extremely risky. Of course that makes no sense, because there's a huge difference between driving 100mph in a neighborhood and just doing 25mph, and it's also the reason we have speed limits, which draw a line in the sand, past which we say "this is unacceptable."
True enough. But are you implying (not saying you are, just asking) that ~"nothing can be done"?
"Banning emotional appeals....This way lies a dystopia..." is just one option - might there be other approaches that could improve the situation?
This problem space has barely been cracked open, and we're going to have to get big smart about it before it destroys us.
100% agree, but try getting any group of people to agree on this idea even in principle.
Most ideas become refined as they grow from very small open-minded spaces, towards mass appeal. So perhaps this idea can be refined as well... no sense in trying not trying.
> I cant think of any downside here.
I can imagine many people who may see a downside of a population who is broadly capable of skilful critical thinking. I don't think it's an accident that we only talk about the crucial need for it, but never talk about actually doing something about it.
In my experience, once you give people the basic toolkit for introspection, it can kick off a positive feedback loop. Not everyone will become a stoic, but they can make meaningful progress on their own.
> I can imagine many people who may see a downside of a population who is broadly capable of skilful critical thinking. I don't think it's an accident that we only talk about the crucial need for it, but never talk about actually doing something about it.
On the contrary I think those who see this as negative are few and far between. Democratic power in the western world has never been greater than today, so if this is something the people want, there is very little that can stand in their way
No doubt it is an improvement over baseline - but do you have any opinions on this specific notion that skills in abstract thinking mode may not successfully transfer to object level thinking, particularly when under pressure (ie: conversations)? I truly believe that this is a real phenomenon.
> On the contrary I think those who see this as negative are few and far between. Democratic power in the western world has never been greater than today, so if this is something the people want, there is very little that can stand in their way.
Oh, I think this is a very small group of people. I believe the general public has wanted a lot of things for a very long time (general welfare for all people, within reason, especially domestically), but improvements along these lines seem rather marginal, despite essentially unending productivity and GDP growth. Something seems rather imperfect here - the advertised benefits of democracy seem more impressive than the results, not unlike TV commercials for a Big Mac Meal versus what you actually get at the restaurant.
I think the lack of progress is due to a fundamental misunderstanding of how democracy functions and drives progress. Meaningful progress is only made when persuasion occurs. Living in political or philosophical silos then going to the voting booth only perpetuates the status quo. To drive forward, you have to change someone's mind. Just about anyone can double their political impact on an issue by going out and having a 1 hour conversation with someone who is indifferent on the topic. The biggest trick ever played on the public is telling them they are disenfranchised and that the system is rigged. If people spent 5% of the time and effort they spent lamenting corruption or political advertising on persuasion, change would advance at a rapid pace.
I assume you mean people's perception of the lack of progress. Actual physical progress is independent of the public's perception of it, I would think.
> Meaningful progress is only made when persuasion occurs.
Makes sense. I pay fairly close attention to the variety and nature of political persuasion, and I find it rather....interesting. I think a fair argument can be made that it is often exerted in directions that seem inconsistent with the general well being of the population.
> The biggest trick ever played on the public is telling them they are disenfranchised and that the system is rigged.
I agree that that is "a" trick, but I don't agree that it is the biggest one, by a long shot. Actually, I think there's more than a little evidence that suggests there's a fair amount of truth to it.
> If people spent 5% of the time and effort they spent lamenting corruption or political advertising on persuasion, change would advance at a rapid pace.
I can't imagine how this could be true. Who would be the parties being persuaded in this scenario, and how would that exert influence on the amount of change?
And then looking at it from another perspective: compare the change in well being of the average person in China versus the USA over the last 10 to 20 years - does the above explain the entirety of the differential? Or, might there be some other variables in play here?
>I assume you mean people's perception of the lack of progress. Actual physical progress is independent of the public's perception of it, I would think.
I totally agree.
>> Meaningful progress is only made when persuasion occurs.
>Makes sense. I pay fairly close attention to the variety and nature of political persuasion, and I find it rather....interesting. I think a fair argument can be made that it is often exerted in directions that seem inconsistent with the general well being of the population.
I think it depends on what you count as political persuasion. I think it is more than adds and media. It includes conversations at dinner tables and in lunchrooms. It includes school curriculum, protesters, and door to door political canvasing. I would agree that political advertising and media is often inconsistent with general well being. I think that it is disingenuous and often exerted to benefit a small subset of the population, either corporate shareholders or individual politicians. That said, in my opinion, the influence of advertising and media is relatively small in comparison to the other factors. Sometimes, like a swing voter, it might sway the public a critical 1%, but collectively, the other forces are far more influential.
>> The biggest trick ever played on the public is telling them they are disenfranchised and that the system is rigged.
>I agree that that is "a" trick, but I don't agree that it is the biggest one, by a long shot. Actually, I think there's more than a little evidence that suggests there's a fair amount of truth to it.
See above
>> If people spent 5% of the time and effort they spent lamenting corruption or political advertising on persuasion, change would advance at a rapid pace.
>I can't imagine how this could be true. Who would be the parties being persuaded in this scenario, and how would that exert influence on the amount of change?
The ideal parties to persuade are those with weakly held views. 40% of Americans don't vote. Most of those who do vote have very little information and opinion on down ballot positions and propositions. If someone wanted to, I think they could persuade an indifferent or marginal neighbor or coworker to vote on a topic with an hour of face-to-face conversation. For context, the average american spends 4,000 hours a year consuming TV and digital media. Anecdotally, I too am part of the problem because I easily spend dozens of hours a year listening or complaining about politics, or reading articles to "stay informed".
>And then looking at it from another perspective: compare the change in well being of the average person in China versus the USA over the last 10 to 20 years - does the above explain the entirety of the differential? Or, might there be some other variables in play here?
This is a such a huge an interesting question, I'm not sure we could even define the scope or definitions on HN. I would be happy to follow up via email if you are interested.
This is all true, but my concern is that which seems to go unnoticed, and that is: the nature of "conversations at dinner tables and in lunchrooms", or in internet social media, forums, etc, seems to be highly influenced by the initial framing of the stories by politicians, journalists, thought leaders, etc. These topics do indeed get discussed, but are these discussions comprehensive of all dimensions and perspectives? Or, is it something more along the lines of: an event occurs, and various entities "get out in front of it", establishing specific narratives and perspectives for the public to argue over, and exerting ongoing maintenance of these narratives, discrediting or redirecting discussions that go off script, and amplifying those that are on script? If one pays very close attention to stories from a meta-perspective, I propose that these techniques can be seen clear as day (and this theory is far from novel- it's as old as the hills).
> The ideal parties to persuade are those with weakly held views. 40% of Americans don't vote. Most of those who do vote have very little information and opinion on down ballot positions and propositions. If someone wanted to, I think they could persuade an indifferent or marginal neighbor or coworker to vote on a topic with an hour of face-to-face conversation.
No doubt. And if executed skilfully, one may actually achieve the watered down proposals tabled by politicians, as opposed to the true democratic desires of the population (see: single-payer Medicare for All). And even when someone is on to this and tries to beat them at their own game?
"Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez rejects left-wing calls to force Pelosi to hold a 'Medicare for All' vote in exchange for her vote for the speaker"
https://www.businessinsider.com/aoc-rejects-left-wing-calls-...
Pay attention to the language and assertions in that article, as well as AOC's hypocrisy (prior complaints vs current stance):
"Gray and Dore pointed out that Ocasio-Cortez had previously suggested she supported holding a House vote on Medicare for All." "We can't even get a floor vote on Medicare for All," the congresswoman said in January. "Not even a floor vote that gets voted down. We can't even get a vote on it."
This is what I would call professional lying (or, Public Relations, Mass Perception Management, etc).
Is no one able to see the amount of persuasion that exists in "the news"? Am I imagining this? Do politicians not have a history of sticking to talking points?
Why does this abstract aspect of the situation so rarely get discussed on an intellectual site like HN? Why do we fight with each other over the same old object level nitpicks that one finds on Reddit? Are we not capable of more than that?
> This is a such a huge an interesting question, I'm not sure we could even define the scope or definitions on HN. I would be happy to follow up via email if you are interested.
I believe that this community should put some genuine honest effort into realizing that abstract perspectives and discussions on these matters is "the" path to eventual resolution, rather than succumbing to our intuitive Pavlovian behavior of reacting to the latest outrage ju dour that the media pushes into people brains. The underlying situations are not this dynamic, they are largely static across time...so, why do we not analyze and discuss them accordingly?
Is the way we undertake system analysis of Project Planet Earth (emotional, tribal, chaotic and disorganized, no documentation or tasks or timelines) similar to how we do the same for the complex (but far simpler) systems most of us work on at our days jobs?
EDIT: This "fresh daily news for the proletariat to argue about" approach to journalism reminds me of an old Joel Spolsky post:
https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2002/01/06/fire-and-motion/
>> When I was an Israeli paratrooper a general stopped by to give us a little speech about strategy. In infantry battles, he told us, there is only one strategy: Fire and Motion. You move towards the enemy while firing your weapon. The firing forces him to keep his head down so he can’t fire at you. (That’s what the soldiers mean when they shout “cover me.” It means, “fire at our enemy so he has to duck and can’t fire at me while I run across this street, here.” It works.) The motion allows you to conquer territory and get closer to your enemy, where your shots are much more likely to hit their target. If you’re not moving, the enemy gets to decide what happens, which is not a good thing. If you’re not firing, the enemy will fire at you, pinning you down.
>> I remembered this for a long time. I noticed how almost every kind of military strategy, from air force dogfights to large scale naval maneuvers, is based on the idea of Fire and Motion. It took me another fifteen years to realize that the principle of Fire and Motion is how you get things done in life. You have to move forward a little bit, every day. It doesn’t matter if your code is lame and buggy and nobody wants it. If you are moving forward, writing code and fixing bugs constantly, time is on your side. Watch out when your competition fires at you. Do they just want to force you to keep busy reacting to their volleys, so you can’t move forward?
>> Think of the history of data access strategies to come out of Microsoft. ODBC, RDO, DAO, ADO, OLEDB, now ADO.NET – All New! Are these technological imperatives? The result of an incompetent design group that needs to reinvent data access every goddamn year? (That’s probably it, actually.) But the end result is just cover fire. The competition has no choice but to spend all their time porting and keeping up, time that they can’t spend writing new features. Look closely at the software landscape. The companies that do well are the ones who rely least on big companies and don’t have to spend all their cycles catching up and reimplementing and fixing bugs that crop up only on Windows XP. The companies who stumble are the ones who spend too much time reading tea leaves to figure out the future direction of Microsoft.
Sound familiar? Why can we only achieve the smallest of accomplishments on matters that have (or would have, ex-propaganda) widespread public support, often for years if not decades, often bi-partisan? Might it be because the public is always reacting to the latest outrageous development, always in a state of confusion, never spending significant amounts of time focusing on one issue until it is fixed?
Human beings are not computers. No aspect of human behavior is perfectly logical or rational. You simply cannot ban emotional appeals in principle, because all appeals have an emotional component. This way lies a dystopia far more terrible than "grandpa shared some nonsense on facebook".