News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by phtrivier on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:23AM (#25428856)
That's the beauty of it being an EU-level regulation: each national party can plausibly deny being "the party that got Facebook banned", and pretends it's "because of those technocrats in Brussels."

That being said, of course Google and FB are never going to be banned in the EU. They'll lobby to death to get the regulation to be "reasonable", and they'll mostly comply because they want their part of the advertising market, and they'll pay the fines when they get caught.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by piker on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:27AM (#25428887)
Ah, yes, the "beauty" of unaccountable government action.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by cataphract on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @10:50AM (#25431338)
Hardly. EU legislation generally needs a majority from the EU parliament (directly elected) and a qualified majority from the Council.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @09:43AM (#25430722)
The thing is that they're not actually unaccountable. You vote for them.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by AlphaSite on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @01:22PM (#25433172)
You only indirectly vote for the,
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by oblio on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @02:24PM (#25433950)
> indirectly vote

That's how representative democracy works, and it's the kind of democracy 95% of the world uses.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by AlphaSite on Monday December 28, 2020 @02:36PM (#25562421)
I think it’s more that there are more layers of indirection than are typical for a democratic system.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by throwaway2048 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:33AM (#25428928)
Ill take it over unaccountable private action, at least there is a chance of influencing government policy.

Good luck influencing Google or Facebook's policy.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by disabled on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:38AM (#25429322)
> That being said, of course Google and FB are never going to be banned in the EU. They'll lobby to death to get the regulation to be "reasonable", and they'll mostly comply because they want their part of the advertising market, and they'll pay the fines when they get caught.

Sure they can be banned EU-wide, although it can obviously be circumvented by the ambitious. Have you been paying attention to EU politics lately regarding the digital single market? Because the EU already has huge behind-the-scenes plans (generally unannounced) for EU based platforms and developments.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by Kbelicius on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @10:15AM (#25431023)
Do you have any resources that you could share on those behind-the-scene plans?
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:29AM (#25428901)
> each national party can plausibly deny being "the party that got Facebook banned", and pretends it's "because of those technocrats in Brussels."

Given that Brexit is looming, this doesn't sound very sustainable. If the people feel the EU's power is no longer legitimate, there may be consequences.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by CaptArmchair on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:16AM (#25429198)
I don't think that the legitimacy of the E.U. will be challenged overnight over a single decision regarding Google or Facebook.

Brexit is just the latest chapter in a long European history. The same is true for the Union and the Maastricht and Lisbon treaties. European history isn't finished as long as there are Europeans.

The U.K. wasn't a founding member of the E.U. nor has it ever been a stalwart partner of the E.U. ever since it joined the Union back in There has always been contention in the U.K. about being a E.U. member ever since it joined through the 1972 Treaty of Accession. The U.K. even held a referendum as early as 1975 about the question of remaining in the then E.C.C. (67.33% voted remain)

The same is true for many other E.U. members, notably newer members who joined the union in the wake of the fall of the Berlin Wall and the breakup of the Warsaw Pact after 1991. Their incentive to join the union was just as much geo-strategic as it was economic. That doesn't mean there weren't voices opposition within those countries as well as elsewhere in the union.

These two companies coming under scrutiny isn't just because they monopolize a consumer market. It's because they enable forces of contention - nationalism, identity politics - that have led to some very dark chapters in the recent European history.

The E.U. such as it is today, originates from ideas that gestated right after WWII under such proponents as Winston Churchill, and the primary incentive was... creating a stable structure for peace on the continent. The E.C.S.C. as founded by the original 6 founding members (Schumann) was about consolidating the coal and steel markets exactly because those were enabling factors during both wars. [1]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Union#Background

And so, if the E.U. moves against Google and Facebook, it's because it feels these companies are evolving into a threat against the first principles from which the Union has emerged.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by Lio on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @07:57AM (#25429828)
Worth remembering too that De Gaulle's France blocked the UK's attempts to join the EU 3 times before grudgingly allowing membership.

Right wing, often foreign owned, sections of the British media have been able to use that and other outright lies* to present the EU as against British interests whilst furthering their own agendas.

In a way, the UK tabloid press is like a precursor to the polemic fake news of social media. In the past politicians would suck up to foreign businessmen like Rupert Murdock and he would attack their rivals. The EU probably doesn't want to see that repeated elsewhere with Zuckerberg.

* When Boris Johnson was a full-time journalist he often made up populist stories. One well know example is the EU attempting to ban prawn cocktail flavoured crisps. Completely untrue and only written to get the naive frothing at the mouth in anger and advance his career. He repeated that lie, amongst others like his famous NHS bus poster, during the Brexit campaign.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:32AM (#25429288)
> I don't think that the legitimacy of the E.U. will be challenged overnight over a single decision regarding Google or Facebook.

I figured from phtrivier's account of things that they were suggesting it's a political pattern for national leaders to blame the EU as unrepresentative. If it were a one-off I'd agree.

> if the E.U. moves against Google and Facebook, it's because it feels these companies are evolving into a threat against the first principles from which the Union has emerged

My point was about undermining perceived legitimacy. I've not commented on whether the regulations themselves are a good idea. Do you think phtrivier's account of things is mistaken?

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by CaptArmchair on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @07:39AM (#25429714)
> Do you think phtrivier's account of things is mistaken?

Well, he only points to a specific rhetorical device used in politics. What really matters are the incentives, interests, values, trade offs, tactics, available opportunities, risks,... that prompt a leader to use that device.

The E.U. is very much a representative body. Every 4 years, there are European elections and every European citizen does have a vote in those elections. And it's perfectly possible to start a so-called europarty. [1] The European Pirate Party - part of the Greens-European Free Alliance, is an example. [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_political_party [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/European_Pirate_Party

Moreover, a party could be nationally in the opposition, but be part of a political group holding a large chunk of seats in the E.U. parliament. Plus, as a party, you could be for and against particular policies at the same time.

The problem with phtrivier's account is that it surmises that politics must consistently operate from a particular, usually unmentioned or implied, moral high ground. The reality of democracy - and by extension any form of cooperation between individuals, groups, parties and nations - is that it can only function if one is willing to compromise and show pragmatism in which battles to pick, or where to draw lines in the sand.

The very real consequences of confusing rhetoric with pragmatism - and, ultimately, failing to display the latter - are clear in the second and third order effects as a result of Brexit on economic, political, geostrategic and social interests held by both the U.K. and the E.U.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by MaxBarraclough on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @08:24AM (#25430044)
> he only points to a specific rhetorical device used in politics

Right, but that's the topic I was responding to. If politicians are making a habit of blaming things on the EU and implying the EU is unaccountable, that strikes me as a problem worth taking seriously. Presumably it wouldn't work in the first place if the people had unshakeable confidence in the legitimacy of the EU.

> The E.U. is very much a representative body

Sure, but I wasn't commenting on this. My point was a specific one about perceived legitimacy, without which there can be no EU. Whether the EU is actually democratic, is another matter.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by phtrivier on Wednesday December 23, 2020 @11:09AM (#25519040)
> he only points to a specific rhetorical device used in politics

I have to clarify that I only witnessed the rethorical device being used in France, mostly in the late 90's / early 20s. It was mostly used "informally" (through dog whistle, if you want) , and usually simply by "ignoring" the debates in Brussels and hide behind the commission after decisions had been made. Only the most nationalist parties would blame almost anything on the EU. Maybe other countries behaved differently.

> The E.U. is very much a representative body

The fact that the Parliement is the most obviously elected body, and the one with the least amount of power always bothers me. Although it always makes me giggle to hear this complain from right-wingers in France, where we have a Parliement that has been de-facto powerless because of the way we elect our MPs and President. Anyway, another matter it is !

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by CaptArmchair on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @10:24AM (#25431101)
Those points are interconnected.

Yes, the rhetoric is problematic. But politicians can be held accountable by the people who give them a mandate based on election results. The public debate, journalism, education and the voting booth are instrumental in doing that.

These things aren't self-evident though.

They are really expressions of emerging collective behaviour. And that behaviour is always a function of a multitude of social, economical, political, cultural, religious, geographical,... factors.

Authoritarians don't necessarily take power through a violent revolution. It just as easily happens by simply exploiting weaknesses in the economy, society, financial system, the legal and the constitutional framework to a point where they arrive into power. Weaknesses such as economic and social inequality, widespread resentment, poverty,...

Many authoritarians and populist leaders derive their legitimacy from the same democratic processes that also lead to a lawful state which upholds moral values such as basic human rights.

"Democracy" in itself isn't a guarantee towards a net "good" or "bad" outcome. That's just value attribution. Democracy is just a form of governance which could just as well lead to less then desirable outcomes.

Democracy doesn't protect society from bad actors who spout populist rhetoric. Nope, society can only protect itself as long as enough individuals are willing to call that rhetoric out for what it is: damaging and hurtful. Your "democratic" rights are only worth anything to the extent that each member of society is willing to back them.

And that requires believing in the value - the legitimacy - of the E.U. as a shared project.

> Whether the EU is actually democratic, is another matter.

Well, during last year's election cycle, I did get presented a voting ballot that allowed me to directly elect members to the European Parliament. The candidate I voted for, did got elected.

... which leads me to believe that, yes indeed, the E.U. is "actually democratic".

And as far as I can tell, the fact that the E.U. provides a legal framework that allows me to enact my individual rights. Such as the GDPR. Not just from Facebook or Google. But also from public authorities itself.

I perceive that as a good thing.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by adrianN on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:39AM (#25428957)
Losing the EU-skeptic members could in the end be a good thing for the EU.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by ChuckNorris89 on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:53AM (#25429050)
Not when that EU skeptic member that left was also huge contributor to the EU budget, housed the second biggest financial center in the world, was the EU's biggest tech hub and is a five-eye nuclear military power with worldwide influence.

I'm not from the UK but let's face it, the EU cannot afford to lose another big member like Germany or France. Smaller members can be Euro skeptics all they want as they'll just talk the talk but can't afford to walk the walk as they benefit the most from the EU.

Sure, the UK never did like to play ball with the rest of the EU and had to be let go but that doesn't mean it's a win for either side. A weak and divided EU only benefits China and Russia and to a lesser degree, the US.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by raverbashing on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:21AM (#25429229)
While it's true that the UK departure is certainly impactful to the EU, it is not going to be as simple for the UK as the EU-antagonists (I hate the word "euroskeptic") make it believe

As a reminder, Montreal was the biggest and most influential city in Canada before the independence movement and it lost a big chunk of influence even when the referendum went for No.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by sudosysgen on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @09:47AM (#25430760)
Actually, the biggest issue with Montréal really was the Loi 101, that enforced French in the workplace. Montréal becoming smaller wasn't exactly an unexpected change from that.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by Zenst on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @06:17AM (#25429205)
That's akin to turning a blind eye for the money - kinda like political lobbying by large companies that we see play out in many countries.

Leaner is meaner and the UK leaving - sure if it was just for the money then that wasn't a relationship and the children have already grown up so to speak.

What does worry me a bit is that tech/large companies have become in effect their own political parties with the amount of influence and impact they have had over the years. So any move by the EU now to rein them in, is a good thing and honestly, good to see that political lobbying by companies has some limits.

2021 is going to be a whole better year for all.

Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by Vespasian on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @05:35AM (#25428937)
Brexit happened on 31.01.2020.
Re:EU to unveil landmark law curbing power of tech giants by jlokier on Tuesday December 15, 2020 @09:49AM (#25430779)
It did, technically.

But the transition arrangements mean everything of importance changes at the end of 31.12.2020.

So far it's just a lot of government adverts telling us how things are going to be worse and to prepare for it. How much extra paperwork, tariffs, expenses, licenses, applications-for-permission etc there will be come 31st December, how we can no longer conduct some kinds of business, how professional qualifications cease to be valid in Britain after 31st December, and how some people who are currently employed can no longer be employed from 1st January.

All the adverts and policy effects that actually affect people are focused on 31.12.2020.

(Reading between the lines it also means some people will no longer be permitted a bank account or the ability to rent a roof starting in the middle of next year, though the government prefers not to headline that unpalatable truth.)

On 31.12.2020 things will change in a way that affects some of us harshly indeed.

I'm British.

As far as I'm concerned, Brexit proper happens for me on 31.12.2020 because that's the day I'm deprived of my previous life-long right to work, study and move my life to the other EU countries, which I have previously used, and hoped to use again :'(

I absolutely hate that such a major freedom, and my family's freedom, and my EU citizenship, is being taken away so forcefully against my consent and without me breaking any laws.

I was considering leaving Britain and emigrating to another EU country this year under EU-citizenship-grandfathering terms, but Covid made it infeasible. If the Brexit transition period had been extended I might have been able to do it next year, but it will cease to be possible after 31.12.2020.

What a Christmas present.

On 31st this year, around midnight, many of us will mark a day of darkness and sadness, as doors close on our life choices, and the Britain some of us had some sort of love and pride in some years ago finally ceases to exist.