News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Life in Cars by sandworm101 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:44PM (#25413295)
The vast majority of accidents are not linked to joyriding. It is alcohol, and to a lesser extent other drugs. Lethal accidents are the norm at 3am, not rush hour. And we have to be careful about causation statistics. A drunk will be speeding, but the accident is the result of the drunkenness rather than speed as there was no rational choice to speed. Nor was it reckless driving. Stop letting people get behind the wheel after drinking. Solve that problem. All the other sources of accidents are secondary at the moment.

And use seatbelts. I am constantly shocked by how many americans still refuse to do so. Seatbelt use in back seats was still not manditory when i lived in new england.

"Depending on which state a driver is in, not wearing a seat belt in the front seat is either a primary offense or a secondary offense, with the exception of New Hampshire, which does not have a law requiring people over age 18 to wear a seat belt. In the front seat, the driver and each passenger must wear a seat belt, one person per belt. In some states, such as New York, New Hampshire, and Michigan, belts in the rear seats are not mandatory for people over the age of 16."

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seat_belt_legislation

Re:My Life in Cars by adrianN on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:34PM (#25413588)
I think you need to distinguish accidents in cities, which are very frequent, but lethal "only" to cyclists and pedestrians, and accidents that kill drivers. The latter happen at high speeds and drugs are often involved, but the former happens all the time simply because people are in a hurry or inattentive.
Re:My Life in Cars by sandworm101 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:39PM (#25413623)
Bicycles and cars is a very specific probelem. Speed is almost irrelevant given the different masses involved. The only complete answer is not to play, to separate the vehicles. Separate road/paths for bikes, protected by actual barriers. And conversely, no bikes on the car paths. This has largely worked already for pedestrian safety (no driving on sidewalks, no people walking on road etc).
Re:My Life in Cars by dionidium on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:58AM (#25414291)
> Speed is almost irrelevant given the different masses involved.

A healthy 30-year-old pedestrian has a 97% chance of surviving a collision with a car traveling 20mph. At 45 mph that same 30-year-old's chances of survival are worse than 50/50.

https://gizmodo.com/how-likely-you-are-to-get-killed-by-a-ca...

Re:My Life in Cars by adrianN on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:18AM (#25413839)
Which is incidentally almost exactly what cyclists demand. Unfortunately this means taking away space from cars, which is met with vehement opposition.
Re:My Life in Cars by sandworm101 on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:47AM (#25413982)
And taking the roadways or sidewalks away from bicycles, confining them to bike lanes/routes, results in equally heated opposition.
Re:My Life in Cars by adrianN on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:52AM (#25414002)
I don't think that opposition would happen if you had a separated cycle lane along every street, but of course that the case exactly nowhere.
Re:My Life in Cars by sandworm101 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:24AM (#25418568)
Tell bikes they cannot ride through crosswalks, that they must walk as a pedestrian would. That is very common but universally ignored. Heck, tell bikes they have to obey stop signs, also universal but ignored. Bikes hate limitations exactly as much as any other vehicle.
Re:My Life in Cars by Symbiote on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:07AM (#25415287)
It's the case in the Netherlands, and to a lesser extent in Denmark.

I've not heard people complaining that they have to use the bike lane, though I'm sure there are some roads where a fast (maybe recreational) cyclist feels the bike lane isn't good enough.

Re:My Life in Cars by closeparen on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:54AM (#25414271)
People drive drunk because they drink to socialize, and access to other humans is almost always mediated by roads. This is not going to get solved separately from car dependence.
Re:My Life in Cars by bbarnett on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:06AM (#25414618)
We have anti-drunk-driving programs where I live, and they work. These comprise of surprise, out of the blue road blocks and spot checks. They work.

Ergo, at least some of this can indeed be solved.

https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/85-002-x/2016001/article...

That's a drop to 1/3, in 30 years.

Further, drunk driving used to be much more accepted. In the "old days", cops would often let people go if they were drunk, but seemed OK at driving.

Now there is absolutely zero tolerance for drunk driving, which also means that if there is an accident/death, and even the hint of alcohol, it is now labelled as 'drunk driving'. This is partially to reinforce the (needed) narrative, but also because cops hate to see this sort of thing, and therefore, it increases the penalties when someone dies.

This inflates the statistics, yet the rate is, as seen, extensively reduced.

Beyond spot checks, you now have a very low tolerance for any alcohol in the blood. Down to 0.05 where penalties start, meaning that even a full grown man worries about drinking a beer (recall, we have stronger alcohol content in beer in Canada) and driving.

These sorts of things, and more, can dramatically change the landscape... regardless of human nature.

I agree however, that there will always be outliers. Those that do not comply. However, you're trying to link "Driving cars", with "See all the ills they cause!", which I deem to be highly unfair and non-logical.

You could point to any other thing, knives, guns, chainsaws, ladders, and explain how due to human nature, these things will sometimes be used for ill. While this is true, it is a nasty trick, in order to get ones personal peeve resolved.

Re:My Life in Cars by clwk on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:01AM (#25414041)
> with the exception of New Hampshire, which does not have a law requiring people over age 18 to wear a seat belt

In fairness, the state motto is 'Live free or die.'

Re:My Life in Cars by Hamuko on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:12AM (#25414090)
"Live free and die" would be more appropriate in this case.
Re:My Life in Cars by tertius on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:18PM (#25413495)
I can't stop everyone else from driving drunk but I sure can exhibit self control and not speed or drive dangerously as to endanger others just because I want to have some fun.

Just because you're not a drunk doesn't mean your actions are justifiable.

* I really like driving.

Re:My Life in Cars by sandworm101 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:28PM (#25413560)
Does "for fun" include trips taken for leasure activities? If i am driving to the waterpark, and cause an accident, was i not driving for fun, for no other purpose than my own pleasure? If we crack dowm on driving "for fun" we should really look into all forms of unnecesary driving. Or shall we admit that many trips are unnecessary and adress the accidents rather than the motivation for why the person took to the road in the first place?
Re:My Life in Cars by paulryanrogers on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:37PM (#25413609)
My interpretation of "driving for fun" is doing entertaining maneuvers, usually putting myself or others at risk when on public roads. Not driving to get somewhere fun.
Re:My Life in Cars by tertius on Monday December 14, 2020 @07:55AM (#25416906)
You can go anywhere safely.

You can also go anywhere recklessly, or what reckless people call "having some fun".

Does that clear up your misunderstanding?

Re:My Life in Cars by neolog on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:12AM (#25414088)
Nice one.
Re:My Life in Cars by ablekh on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:52PM (#25413695)
> Stop letting people get behind the wheel after drinking. Solve that problem.

The solution to this problem seems quite trivial to me: to equip all cars with alcohol (and, perhaps, some drug) sensors [not breathalyzers, but rather some more sophisticated remote-sensing devices], strategically located throughout interior to prevent cheating / gaming the system, and integrate them with ignition and engine. As long as the system determines that a driver is drunk or under influence of drugs, it prevents the car from starting or (in case someone starting drinking or using drugs after stopping a car, but leaving it idling) moving.

Re:My Life in Cars by tachyonbeam on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:52AM (#25414264)
Trivial, eh? I would argue that the solution is not some imaginary set of sensors that could somehow flawlessly detect every class of psychoactive drugs that could somehow impair a person, including but not limited to: xanax, PCP, ketamine, cocaine, alcohol, GHB, LSD, mushrooms, marijuana, 2C-I, MDMA, MDA, meth, heroin, fentanyl, etc. Not to mention a myriad more prescription drugs, including sleep medication and antipsychotics which are perfectly legal to drive on, but can also be equally impairing.

... But actually to continue the work that we're already doing to implement self-driving cars. I mean, it's not just drugs, it's also tiredness, distractions, and simple mistakes. We can make cars safer by removing human drivers and replacing them with extensively tested machines. It will take a bit more time, but we'll get there.

Re:My Life in Cars by ablekh on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:20AM (#25414380)
I didn't say trivial implementation, but rather a trivial solution (i.e., a general approach). Regarding the issue that, in addition to alcohol, there exist a large number of drugs potentially diminishing one's ability to drive: it could be approached using Pareto principle. Either focus just on alcohol (which most likely is responsible for 80% of road accidents) and ignore the other 20% (distractions, lack of attention, drugs, etc.), or apply Pareto principle again, now to the drugs class, and identify most frequently used ones and/or most potentially impairing ones and design relevant sensors to cover the 20% that causes 80% of issues.

While I certainly recognize potential benefits of autonomous driving (and automation, in general), relevant global or nationwide deployments are still a very long way to go; it's not "a bit more time", but most likely decades. Imagine how many lives could be saved with simpler sensor-based solutions (which, by the way, could very much help with the problems of "tiredness, distractions, and simple mistakes") in the meantime ...

Re:My Life in Cars by tachyonbeam on Monday December 14, 2020 @02:00PM (#25421633)
I think it's very realistic to have driver-assist solution that can provide advanced collision warnings, collision assistance and watch the driver's face to see if they are paying attention.

With respect to self-driving, search YouTube for FSD beta. You can see what Tesla has been up to. It's not perfect but it keeps getting better. It's not going to take several decades.

Re:My Life in Cars by ablekh on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:09PM (#25422562)
The sensor-based driver assist solutions is what I meant as a secondary aid in my comment above. However, these solutions are reactive and quite partial as opposed to strong preventative measures like alcohol detection-based car immobilization solutions. Some would say that it is a radical measure, but so is electronic speed limiter/governor in all modern cars.

I'm well aware of the progress in autonomous driving space (including Tesla's - though, I would argue that Tesla is not the leader in this space; I think that it's Waymo). However, more generally, my point was not about limited fleet use cases, but rather global-scale deployments and massive adoption. That, I believe, is certainly not going to happen soon.

Re:My Life in Cars by voltagex_ on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:04AM (#25413767)
Love for my engine not to start after I've used mouthwash in the morning.
Re:My Life in Cars by megablast on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:14AM (#25414095)
A small price to pay for safety. Maybe one day you will figure it out, and do the mouthwash later?? No. Oh well.
Re:My Life in Cars by gambiting on Monday December 14, 2020 @03:12AM (#25414643)
Also I don't get it - alcohol free mouthwash exists.
Re:My Life in Cars by ablekh on Monday December 14, 2020 @01:14AM (#25414098)
Well ... Firstly, human lives are much more important than a preference to use an alcohol-based mouthwash (considering that non-alcohol alternatives exist). Secondly, it very well might be possible to design and/or calibrate sensors to distinguish between both cases based on chemical components or relevant concentration ratios that are specific to mouthwash formula.