News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:30AM (#25406426)
It's not really a ponzi scheme. You're not investing (uploading) your images with an expected return on that investment.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by colde on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:51AM (#25406527)
Yeah, it seems closer to a "tragedy of the commons" kind of situation. Where a few users deplete a shared resource affecting everyone else.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by iamacyborg on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:57AM (#25406564)
Unsurprising really, there's some fun example on Reddit's Data Hoarder sub. And stuff like this https://www.vice.com/en/article/a33j5a/a-redditor-archived-n...
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by ghaff on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:12AM (#25407060)
If it were, hypothetically, come percentage of new users who were consuming most of the resources, it would still be just as big a problem. (In fact, maybe more so if a changing pattern of use suggests that your pricing model is no longer profitable.)
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by anoncake on Sunday December 13, 2020 @09:49AM (#25406898)
Except that they did not pay for their fair share of a limited resource but for an unlimited amount of it.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by Spivak on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:00AM (#25406985)
Can we please dispel this notion that “unlimited” means literally unbounded to the point of absurdity. Seemingly everyone understands that bottomless breadsticks doesn’t mean that Olive Garden literally has infinite breadsticks and that you’re not allow to show up with a semi and tell them to fill it up.

Unlimited means that you don’t have a set quota and as long as your usage doesn’t cross over into genuine abuse of the service that you don’t have to worry about it. If you cat /dev/random into your unlimited storage provider 24/7/365 you can’t really be surprised when they ban you.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by ghaff on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:39AM (#25407246)
Personally, I'd prefer that companies not use terms that can't be literally true and that obviously must have some limitations to guard against someone who wants to upload data--e.g. high res video--to the cloud constantly.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by salawat on Sunday December 13, 2020 @02:18PM (#25409242)
No... Because that isn't unlimited. Period. The limit in your case is when you decide "usage crosses into abuse of the service". Which means there is no communication ahead of time to the user what behavior to avoid.

Just admit all people want is to be able to ride the gullibility of people who aren't as picky about language as the people who actually give a crap about clear communication. What businesses want to sell is a conditionally vague statistically multiplexed service level, and I'm willing to bet most don't even go out of the way to let the User know what they're overall footprint within the scope of the entire system is, which is info they'd need to manage usage patterns themselves. It's the hallmark of manipulative language.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by im3w1l on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:35PM (#25410523)
The difference is that there is a common understanding of what unlimited breadsticks means. If you asked people what a "reasonable" amount of unlimited data storage meant, you'd get answers all over the place.
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by anoncake on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:23AM (#25407138)
Unlimited literally does mean unbounded, not "we don't tell you the limit". You cannot abuse a service by using it for its intended purpose. Storing data for possible later retrieval, even exabytes of data, is the purpose of a data storage service.

Storing large amounts of random data merely to waste space might qualify as abuse. But that is a) a strawman as far as I can tell and b) it isn't always possible to tell apart random and encrypted/compressed data apart anyway.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by tomhoward on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:58AM (#25406576)
Sure - the title is crafted for rhetorical effect not literal accuracy.

But it's comparable, in the sense that the "returns" for earlier customers (ongoing provision of storage service) are funded out of the contributions of later new customers, and when the supply of new customers runs out, the returns can no longer be funded and the system collapses.

Edit: Also not that the phrase "is a Ponzi scheme" is often used in opinion pieces to describe all kinds of business and economic models that are not literal Ponzi schemes: https://www.google.com/search?q=%22is+a+ponzi+scheme%22+-wha...

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @09:21AM (#25406711)
I think accuracy is important. If an author isn't trustworthy or correct on this, then why should we listen to their other information in good faith?

I think it's not just new users. It's also new content/files. Existing users uploading more pictures can also generate revenue, right?

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by foolmeonce on Sunday December 13, 2020 @09:57AM (#25406960)
It fits the flow model of a ponzi scheme:

At each future stage a growth of fresh input is required to make up for a growing backlog of past transactions. Since the world is finite, the available growth must come to an end while the back log does not. (A possible disagreement with this is if expected media quality/size is growing in size similar to Moore's law.)

The author makes their own distinctions in the article, but I don't see how you could choose a more appropriate title without assuming a lot of pre-existing knowledge in the audience.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:43PM (#25410597)
Perhaps you can correct the definition on wikipedia then.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ponzi_scheme

A more appropriate title could be "Unlimited Data Storage is Dependent on New User Adoption". No reason to use a title that doesn't fit and is just sensationalized marketing.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by foolmeonce on Monday December 14, 2020 @06:29AM (#25415835)
Wikipedia's definition is great but is naturally focused on the social details rather than its nature as an inherently devolving system of resource management. Still it's coverage of how they fall apart is good AFA the system problems.

I suppose I should update more wikipedia entries, for example:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binary_tree

References an early example of such a problem article: "Binary Tree". An outrageous use of metaphor that should clearly have been named "Data is in no way an oak".

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:46AM (#25418829)
Nice strawman argument.

The word "binary" is a modifier of the word "tree". Anyone with a basic understanding of English knows that a binary tree is different from an oak tree. The modifier in "ponzi scheme" is "ponzi". The very definition stated that it is a scheme related to financial investment and returns, which doesn't fit the situation in the article.

If you compare the binary tree and ponzi scheme examples, you will find them quite similar. You have base word (tree/scheme) and a modifier word (binary/ponzi). So your tree example is actually a great point supporting my argument - this may be a scheme, but it's not a ponzi scheme.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by foolmeonce on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:39PM (#25420450)
The ponzi scheme was not a scheme to defraud investors it was a scheme to profit from mail regulations that ultimately defrauded investors since there were few consumers of the actual postage stamps. As such the fuller name of what seems to offend you is an intentional ponzi scheme-like fraud. The important modifier would be like, as in simile. Binary tree does not use simile so it is apparently more strongly a tree than something tree-like.

The ponzi scheme was very similar to offering unlimited plans despite most users having very little interest in storing much or having the constant but moderate usage pattern that would need to accompany that for it to run on ads. AFA schemes both are marketing gimmicks misrepresenting the market to sell an unlikely profit system as viable, and when it collapses the people sold the system's superiority to reasonable offers end up upset. Both of these gimmicks can be done intentionally or accidentally as described in the wiki entry.

Unlimited plans are in fact very similar to THE ponzi scheme, more so than an intentional ponzi-scheme-like fraud. Many even argue that the ponzi scheme is not a good representative of ponzi scheme frauds, rather many are based on fraudsters understanding the original ponzi scheme (ponzi himself probably did not initially understand he was getting into fraud of investors until the scheme already had investors.)

At any rate, you seem to understand that there's a lot of room for discussion on how unlimited media is like the ponzi scheme itself or a ponzi scheme fraud. Semantic arguments over who is defrauded and who expects what are pretty pointless as in modern finance the users and investors are all in the mix that is the public and is being uniformly addressed by the company whether in casual media or SEC filings.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by tomhoward on Sunday December 13, 2020 @09:43AM (#25406859)
It's a metaphor or analogy, which is a perfectly commonplace and legitimate form of argumentation.

> I think it's not just new users. It's also new content/files. Existing users uploading more pictures can also generate revenue, right?

Well, no; if it's an unlimited usage plan, then there's no more revenue from existing users, but they become more costly to support as time goes on, making the system ever more unsustainable and destined for collapse.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:52PM (#25410703)
It's only legitimate if it's accurate and presented as an analogy. The title of "Unlimited is a Ponzi Scheme" is not worded to be an analogy and isn't accurate.

"there's no more revenue from existing users"

That's not what the article says. Existing users can create revenue. The cost could outweigh the revenue depending on the amount stored. If it were solely about new user adoption, then it wasn't presented properly in the article:

"They make money inversely proportional to how recent you stored the thing."

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by imtringued on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:19AM (#25407103)
The problem is that there is no overarching word that describes this class of "scheme". There are pyramid schemes, ponzi schemes, matrix schemes, unlimited schemes and so on. Everyone uses an example of this class of scheme and then say that X is "ponzi scheme like" instead of saying that X is an instance of "circular fraud" where "circular fraud" is a term for this class of scheme I just made up on the spot. Just invent a word for this instead of complaining.

>f an author isn't trustworthy or correct on this, then why should we listen to their other information in good faith?

The author is correct because of the word "like" in the title.

Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by colejohnson66 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:40PM (#25408337)
Others here have suggested “bait and switch” which, IMO, is a more apt descriptor
Re:Unlimited is like a Ponzi Scheme by giantg2 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:36PM (#25410539)
The word "like" was not there previously, nor is it on the title of the article.