News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pstack on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @06:50PM (#2538725)
Who is surprised?

The committee that granted a trillion dollar bail-out of a few companies including Goldman Sachs was staffed with plenty of current/former executives from Goldman Sachs.

The FDA and agencies involved for approving bovine growth hormone (later found to do freakishly hideous things to the poor cows and increase by incredible amounts the contamination of the milk we drink from infected utters), the Round-Up-ready patented corn seeds, and aspartame just happen to be largely staffed by current/former Monsanto executives.

The FDA and agencies involved in inspecting the food production in the states and making sure that it remains uncontaminated and safe and regularly inspected have reduced the number of inspections by something like 85% and the contamination rates increase, while under the watch of agencies staffed largely by current/former executives of the few main companies being overseen.

The US government is beyond corrupt and beyond any possible reform and nobody cares. Nobody gives a damn that almost every office and committee appointment in the country is a matter of the wolves guarding the sheep. It has been this way for decades and they are now so brazen about it that you can look at every single person in every single job and do a simple search to trace the truth of their position and appointment back and nobody gives a damn.

I mean, seriously, we let them give themselves a trillion dollars. We let them poison our food supply with largely untested and unproven chemicals. We let them cover up and manipulate right in front of our faces and we do nothing. After thirty years of looking the other way on all of these things, what on earth could possibly ever even remotely raise our eyebrows and make us do something other than participate in the attention-occupying busy-body bullshit of "durr durr republicans are stupid and evil" and "durr durr democrats are stupid and evil" my team versus yours bullshit?

Maybe if the government and corporations decided that it was just easier to require that all births be sponsored to make sure they can be cared for until adulthood and then those sponsored children become indentured servants for their sponsor company until the age of 40 . . . maybe . . . MAYBE we might possibly take our eyes off Dancing With the Stars and the football game long enough to do something other than pull the red or blue lever according to the team we've associated ourselves with and demand that we have choices that aren't part of the game and won't be part of the game and will radically change things.

It won't happen in my lifetime. I know that much.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by stephenjudkins on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:50PM (#2538924)

  The US government is beyond corrupt and beyond any possible reform and nobody cares.

  my team versus yours bullshit

  It won't happen in my lifetime. I know that much.
Have you ever volunteered for a local politician? Paid close attention to an particular issue? Gone to your state capitol to lobby for a particular bill? Took notice of any substantive differences between politicians of both major parties running against each other? Have you ever spent a substantial amount of your own time and effort to attempt to fix any of these issues?

Or do you just bitterly complain about the irredeemably corrupt nature of US government on online message boards?

Your cynicism, and those of people like you, is also a large contributor to our nation's innumerable problems. There exist honest, well-meaning, hard-working people working in government and politics to attempt to fix these issues. Unfortunately they're outnumbered by people like you, who tar all of them with same brush you use for the most corrupt business lobbyist. That's probably because it's much easier to complain than fix the problem.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pstack on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:44PM (#2539065)
Unfortunately, the system is setup to expediently counter attempts to change it. Why do you think we keep getting the same results after every election? If it was just a matter of "getting a democrat" in the office or "getting a republican" in office, then problems wouldn't exist, because we have one or the other in office every few years. It's a deeper problem in that the fingers that manipulate the puppetry and the machinery are so deeply embedded in the process that with very few outlying exceptions, little occurs which isn't vetted by the corrupt process. (Also reads: There aren't really many substantive differences between viable politicians.)

The few people with any power in politics are expelled by the system itself. They're either not viable to begin with or if they somehow absurdly get into the system, it marginalizes them. They're called crazy or otherwise derided and made irrelevant through all the modern mediums we have available to us and society itself is too pre-occupied with what church they go to or if they ever smoked pot.

I didn't say I have any meaningful way to contribute or improve the process. Nobody else really does, either. It's not merely as simple as "well, run for office and be the first honest person in the government!". Very few people can even stand up against a single company and fight injustices. What hope does anyone have against the corrupt government plus all of the companies - together?

I know, this is all very anti-American. We're raised to believe that there's always hope and "we the people" and "power to the people" and all. Just check the right box in the voting booth or volunteer your time to support the right magic politician that we've been waiting a couple centuries for.

There is a critical point past which an organism is so consumed with cancerous tissue that nothing can be done to save it.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by 18pfsmt on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:33PM (#2539285)
They seem to be making progress at massive change in the middle east (Libya, Eqypt, Syria, etc.). It's pretty inspiring how much strength there is in numbers. I'm not much of a leader, but I would always participate.

Maybe one of the talented designers around HN could spin up a nice site to pledge to march on DC if/when 10 million people sign up? I'd write the copy and donate some hosting $.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by beagle3 on Thursday May 12, 2011 @01:38AM (#2539573)
> They seem to be making progress at massive change in the middle east (Libya, Eqypt, Syria, etc.). It's pretty inspiring how much strength there is in numbers. I'm not much of a leader, but I would always participate.

This is after 40 or so years of dictatorship in every single one of those countries; and peaceful previous attempts did not work (were mostly met with deadly force)

In the US, most people have the illusion that they are actually voting for THEIR representative, and thus it will take 400 years (not 40) until something will happen. Douglas Adams described this very well:

"Ford Prefect, of course, had an explanation for this, as he sat with Arthur and watched the nonstop frenetic news reports on television, none of which had anything to say other than to record that the thing had done this amount of damage which was valued at that amount of billions of pounds and had killed this totally other number of people, and then say it again, because the robot was doing nothing more than standing there, swaying very slightly, and emitting short incomprehensible error messages.

"It comes from a very ancient democracy, you see..."

"You mean, it comes from a world of lizards?"

"No," said Ford, who by this time was a little more rational and coherent than he had been, having finally had the coffee forced down him, "nothing so simple. Nothing anything like so straightforward. On its world, the people are people. The leaders are lizards. The people hate the lizards and the lizards rule the people."

"Odd," said Arthur, "I thought you said it was a democracy."

"I did," said Ford. "It is."

"So," said Arthur, hoping he wasn't sounding ridiculously obtuse, "why don't the people get rid of the lizards?"

"It honestly doesn't occur to them," said Ford. "They've all got the vote, so they all pretty much assume that the government they've voted in more or less approximates to the government they want."

"You mean they actually vote for the lizards?"

"Oh yes," said Ford with a shrug, "of course."

"But," said Arthur, going for the big one again, "why?"

"Because if they didn't vote for a lizard," said Ford, "the wrong lizard might get in. Got any gin?"

(copied&pasted from http://www.virtualeconomics.co.uk/2008/05/keeping-the-liz.ht... )

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by mceachen on Thursday May 12, 2011 @12:51AM (#2539499)
No need to code anything up -- it's already been done. Set it up on http://www.thepoint.com/ (which is the predecessor of Groupon, btw)
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by __david__ on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:59PM (#2539101)
You know, it's not my job to fix the problem. I have my place in society and I'm not about to start over in life and become a politician just to fix my perceived problem with the system. No more than I would start over and become a doctor because I thought that, say, doctors had bad attitudes. I'll vote the appropriate way but that's really my only recourse. I still have the right to bitterly complain about rampant corruption in politics and even be pessimistic about reform happening.

> There exist honest, well-meaning, hard-working people working in government and politics to attempt to fix these issues. Unfortunately they're outnumbered by people like you, who tar all of them with same brush you use for the most corrupt business lobbyist.

I don't see how the OP's attitude affects the good people working to fix the issues. They clearly want the same thing the OP does. If they think he's wrong--prove him wrong! Get things reformed in his lifetime.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by rooshdi on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:34PM (#2539039)
Yes, there are honest, well-meaning, hard-working people working in government, but there are also lying, corrupt, self-interested politicians lobbied heavily by corporations. When news like this comes out, it just adds to the suspicion and paranoia that all the war lies and government bailouts have already brought upon the American people. It doesn't help.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by VladRussian on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:38PM (#2539051)
nice logic. According to you the GP is guilty of having the trillion dollars taken from him.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by 18pfsmt on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:28PM (#2538847)
I agree with you, but here's my attempt at devil's advocate:

These industries require domain expertise gained over years in order to understand the fundamentals of these industries at macro and micro levels, So, who better to help regulate them then people directly from the industry with that expertise. Career politicians and bureaucrats simply have no real world experience, so we must get industry insiders to provide insight.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by Duff on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:01PM (#2538961)
Regulation and control is by its nature an adversarial relationship. You cannot be an effective adversary if that will compromise your ability to be an advocate or employee of whomever you're regulating.

Just as an auditor doesn't need to be a domain expert to audit a companies books, a regulator doesn't need to be one, at least from an industry POV.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pstack on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:28PM (#2539022)
The "employ a hacker to catch a hacker" methodology of hiring is fine, if your hacker is going to catch other hackers. If you're actually just hiring thieves to help themselves to all they can carry in their pockets, then their expertise really isn't relevant beyond their own self-serving exploitation of that knowledge domain.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by bennysaurus on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:56PM (#2538948)
Absolutely agreed, but the industry insiders have to be impartial and use their knowledge and experience to come up with a decision.

The question you have to ask is what's the motivation to approve (or deny) a given application or law? If it's because it's the 'right thing to do' (broad term I know) then fantastic. If it's to 'help out a mate' or 'it may be the right thing to do, but meanwhile there's incentives for me to vote this way' then that's where integrity has to be questioned.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by onedognight on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:37PM (#2539290)
I would counter that anti-trust decisions are not industry decisions, but population wide decisions and hence they should be made not by industry focused bureaucrats but by more accountable general politicians.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by ams6110 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @11:46PM (#2539402)
I'd argue that in general there is far more regulation than is really necessary, and this is what creates the opportunity for corruption.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by _b8r0 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:19PM (#2538814)
So, in the spirit of HN I'd like to foster a challenge. I challenge the people of HN to come up with a startup to challenge the status quo. How about a startup that could expose this in an easily consumable way by the public? What about a startup that makes government corruption irrelevant? Lets put our money where our mouth is.

Is there money to be made from benefiting the social good? Is there a way we can bring people together with an app or service that can bring about an end to all of this? On HN I see some of the most intelligent people that have ever lived. If we can't come up with a solution, then who can?

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pstack on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:55PM (#2539090)
I know it's not quite the same thing, but wasn't there a "startup" of sorts awhile back that focused on exposing documented evidence of different levels of corporate and government corruption? I can't remember what it was called, but I'm pretty sure the guy behind it had to flee the country and was charged with several counts of rape and a lot of the people he was trying to expose the information to about their own government said that they wanted him executed.

Anyway, there are certainly already-existing entities that serve the public good, but government corruption isn't irrelevant as long as there is government corruption. You can benefit social good all you like, but how exactly is it going to wholly displace the existence, expense, and function of a government office or committee?

The FDA example. Or the Goldman Sachs example. How are you going to displace the need for the FDA to exist or for the SEC and the Treasury to exist? Or the need for the military industrial complex? These are all functions that seemingly need to exist and be performed for the good of the people. The problem is that they require oversight. The public needs to be aware of the corruption and given the power to do something about it and it seems we either don't or won't. (And I'm part of that group, because if I knew how to change it, I would).

It is so massive. So complex. So layered. And so corrupt. I really almost can't expect someone busy trying to keep a roof over their head and their children clothed and educated to somehow be aware of many of these corruptions, much less have a way to change it (beyond the trivialities of voting, which mostly seems to just serve us as a way to make us feel better about ourselves).

When we have lots of regulation, we're told that the solution is to deregulate and then industries are singularly corrupt. When we don't have enough regulation, we're told the solution is to regulate. Then the regulator positions are staffed with people from the companies being regulated and corruption is there.

If there are some great solutions, I'm all ears. :)

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by eru on Thursday May 12, 2011 @05:49AM (#2539989)
> How are you going to displace the need for the FDA to exist or for the SEC and the Treasury to exist?

Talk to some minimal-government libertarians for some ideas.

A (quite conservative) method to get rid of the FDA would be outsourcing that function to the EU, or perhaps push it down to the states.

> Or the need for the military industrial complex?

You can make it much smaller, if your government follows an isolationist foreign policy.

I'm not saying those are good ideas---just that it's possible.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by 18pfsmt on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:41PM (#2538892)
I've banged my head over a similar idea for a while, and I have failed to figure out a viable monetization strategy that won't compromise such a service eventually. The best I've come up with is that it must start at bottom and move up. From local communities and the governments that manage them, the power could be slowly drained away from the federal level (and even the state) eventually leading to a more decentralized system that is less susceptible to corruption (which obviously requires constant vigilance on the part of the local communities).
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by _b8r0 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:57PM (#2538950)
So what about a site that allows local communities to organise and co-ordinate? Your big problem would be astroturfing, but if you did it right, it would be as simple for them to arrange for 'Lets get rid of taxes on oil firms" as "Lets get the garbage taken out properly in the xth district in y area", then to link them together.

I think the key thing is to disrupt the lobby structure. If we can do that as well as MP3 downloads disrupted the RIAA then we win.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pyre on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:35PM (#2539043)
What about a social-network-like site where people communicate directly with their elected officials?

This would need someway to make sure that the politician was actually looking at the site and not just the delegating it to subordinates. Having a direct line to these politicians (that cuts past all of the subordinates that answer email, snail mail, etc) is one of the strengths of lobby groups.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by 18pfsmt on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:15PM (#2539252)
There is one, but I can't remember the name of it right now. I spent a week going through lots of it to see what kind of activity, but there was very little. On top of that, there were lots of people just barking non-nonsensical and/ or derisive remarks at the various federal politicians; and, absolutely zero participation from any of the politicians themselves.

This is why I suggested to start in a small community first. In order to keep it relevant to people that live in that community, the only thing that made sense was to authenticate users via post cards (with OTP passcodes) sent to an address within a zipcode (In my town they send out a community news page with my water bill). My thought was to keep it to short messages realted to only municipal maintenance issues and try to build from there. Funding it would be the biggest obstacle in my mind, so if anyone has specific ideas there, that'd be great.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by _b8r0 on Thursday May 12, 2011 @03:23AM (#2539714)
You might want to look at http://www.theyworkforyou.com and the other mysociety tools as a starting point.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by eli on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:14PM (#2538986)
I don't think it's a problem of awareness. NPR just now aired a brief story on the Comcast lobbyist.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by KevBurnsJr on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:17PM (#2538808)
Well not with that attitude!
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by geoffw8 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:36PM (#2538873)
Very well said. IMO anyone who disagrees either doesn't know enough of "the situation" or has simply scanned over your words, not actually digested them.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by awj on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:47PM (#2538911)
> IMO anyone who disagrees either doesn't know enough of "the situation" or has simply scanned over your words, not actually digested them.

That's not a useful stance to take on things. "Anyone who disagrees with this is ignorant or didn't understand" is a recipe for never having a useful conversation.

You want people to change their minds? Spend at least a little time listening to them. Not "I'm waiting for you to shut up" fake listening, actual listening. Learn why they think what they do. You have to counter their biases/ignorance/arguments on their own terms, anything else is more self-important posturing on your part than useful debate.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by geoffw8 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @09:00PM (#2539103)
I dont at all disagree with what your saying, that is how I would usually approach things. In the context of some things mentioned on the thread I feel my sentence is appropriate.

Nobody on this thread could say/articulate a single point or argument that could possibly counteract the sheer amount of corruption that is occurring not only in the US, but everywhere. Hence my ears are essentially closed for business.

What I was saying was that the OP is absolutely right, and anybody who even considers disagreeing hasn't done their research or has not registered the seriousness of the situation when reading the comment. I was hoping to add weight to an already very good point, hence the seriousness of my tone.