News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by 18pfsmt on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:28PM (#2538847)
I agree with you, but here's my attempt at devil's advocate:

These industries require domain expertise gained over years in order to understand the fundamentals of these industries at macro and micro levels, So, who better to help regulate them then people directly from the industry with that expertise. Career politicians and bureaucrats simply have no real world experience, so we must get industry insiders to provide insight.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by Duff on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:01PM (#2538961)
Regulation and control is by its nature an adversarial relationship. You cannot be an effective adversary if that will compromise your ability to be an advocate or employee of whomever you're regulating.

Just as an auditor doesn't need to be a domain expert to audit a companies books, a regulator doesn't need to be one, at least from an industry POV.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by pstack on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @08:28PM (#2539022)
The "employ a hacker to catch a hacker" methodology of hiring is fine, if your hacker is going to catch other hackers. If you're actually just hiring thieves to help themselves to all they can carry in their pockets, then their expertise really isn't relevant beyond their own self-serving exploitation of that knowledge domain.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by bennysaurus on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @07:56PM (#2538948)
Absolutely agreed, but the industry insiders have to be impartial and use their knowledge and experience to come up with a decision.

The question you have to ask is what's the motivation to approve (or deny) a given application or law? If it's because it's the 'right thing to do' (broad term I know) then fantastic. If it's to 'help out a mate' or 'it may be the right thing to do, but meanwhile there's incentives for me to vote this way' then that's where integrity has to be questioned.

Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by onedognight on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @10:37PM (#2539290)
I would counter that anti-trust decisions are not industry decisions, but population wide decisions and hence they should be made not by industry focused bureaucrats but by more accountable general politicians.
Re:After approving NBC buyout, FCC Commissioner becomes Comc... by ams6110 on Wednesday May 11, 2011 @11:46PM (#2539402)
I'd argue that in general there is far more regulation than is really necessary, and this is what creates the opportunity for corruption.