News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by lacker on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:54PM (#25363715)
My interpretation is the opposite. MongoDB is clearly successful - they are a public company worth 16 billion dollars. And they proving the success of the open core business model.

For 99% of use cases, MongoDB is open source. You can see the code, you can make modifications, you can use it for free in your business, you can share your changes with others, you can integrate it into your products and services. Yeah, you can't use it if you're working at AWS, but for most people it's just fine.

For founders creating new open source companies, it's a great strategy to go the route of MongoDB. Start off open source and sell services. If you run into big enough problems with direct competitors using your own software, you can modify the license to exclude them.

This is far better than the status quo in, say, 2010, when the conventional wisdom was that if you're providing a service it shouldn't involve any open source at all.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by julianmarq on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:00PM (#25364878)
I'd replace mongo with redis in your comment. Redis truly is open core, but mongo no longer is. Now it's source available, and has been removed from the repos of many distros.

Calling mongo open source now just dilutes what "open source" actually means. The organization even removed the submission of its license for approval by the OSI.

It's source available, and it's up to each person to decide whether that's good or bad.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by aaron_m04 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:53PM (#25365769)
> Now it's source available, and has been removed from the repos of many distros.

I wasn't aware the licensing is more restrictive now.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by lacker on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:35PM (#25365475)
That’s true, but Redis and MongoDB are at different points in their growth. Redis is worth around 1 billion, and they are still private. I would not be surprised if Redis usage continues to grow, which attracts more competitors, and they eventually shift to a “99% open” model more similar to MongoDB.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by qchris on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:06PM (#25366661)
I know that there's a formal definition of capitalized "Open Source" by the OSI, but I'm also not enchanted by that being the only definition for lower-case "open source". I think that the lower case open source is really more about a general approach to software (or intellectual property in general, really). Some people want to use terms like "libre" to refer to projects that have most of the practical characteristics of open source projects, but not an OSI-approved license, but I kind of think that the lower-case version of the term is important because it's reached a point of basically a colloquialism.

There's room for a grey area, but I think that the parent's comment about how Mongo's license relates to the overwhelming majority of it's community to use it (in that, functionally, it doesn't) still pushes farther towards open source than it does proprietary with source-available.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:16PM (#25366825)
People forget that the OSI and the people behind it neither own, nor invented, the term 'open source.' They want to give you the impression that they do and they did, but they don't and they didn't.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by t0astbread on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @08:00PM (#25368043)
On the other hand, standards and consensus are important to know what's going on. See the endless meaningless "organic produce" label landscape.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by dredmorbius on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @09:59PM (#25369098)
False.

In the application to software, Bruce Perrens most definitely did define ther term, based on the Debian Free Software Guidelines, and the Free Software Foundation's Three Freedoms definition of Free Software, in June 1997:

https://opensource.org/docs/osd

https://www.debian.org/social_contract#guidelines

https://perens.com/2017/09/26/on-usage-of-the-phrase-open-so...

The term was not previously used with regard to software, though the intelligence community have used the phrase "open sources" to refer to unclassified information.b

Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Thursday December 10, 2020 @06:20AM (#25372466)
> The term was not previously used with regard to software

This is just not a true thing to say. See my other replies for examples from before 1997.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by andrewshadura on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:38AM (#25371302)
Indeed. But to be more precise: Christine invented the term and Bruce precisely defined it based on the DFSG.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by MaxBarraclough on Thursday December 10, 2020 @06:46AM (#25372630)
I don't see a good reason to view it as akin to a power-grab. It's profoundly unhelpful when terms are diluted and muddied. We should use the OSI's definition not because they say so, and not for legalistic reasons like trademarks, but because it's important to have meaningfully precise language.

It's right that when a thread is submitted of a project falsely claiming to be open source, the HN community unfailingly tears it to shreds. We don't want the term to be cheapened into becoming meaningless. I don't see that the origins of the term are relevant.

Personally I tend to capitalise, I typically use Free and Open Source software to be more clear that I'm referring to free software as defined by the FSF, and open source as defined by the OSI. It's unfortunate that I've found this to be necessary, to close the door on obtuse misuse of these terms.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Thursday December 10, 2020 @06:58AM (#25372730)
Ideally they would have picked a term that they could prove to have invented and could have trademarked, then there wouldn't be an issue.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by MaxBarraclough on Thursday December 10, 2020 @07:12AM (#25372826)
I suppose so, but the term is typically understood in the software community as a pretty precise term of art, and people shouldn't try to muddy it.

It's still better than free software, which invariably makes the uninitiated think of freeware.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by lowdose on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:34PM (#25367080)
Who did?
Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:37PM (#25367131)
I don't know - not sure anyone does.

Christine Peterson claims to have invented the term in 1998.

https://opensource.com/article/18/2/coining-term-open-source...

But at least this much is not true - we can see it being used, in context, at least as far back as 1996. I think people involved in this project at the time say it was a common term back then as well, but I can't find a reference for that now.

http://www.xent.com/FoRK-archive/fall96/0269.html

And they certainly don't own it - they wrote a whole article on their own website still available about how they don't own it!

https://opensource.org/pressreleases/certified-open-source.p...

Re:Death of an open-source business model by andrewshadura on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:36AM (#25371285)
The Caldera announcement you’re referring to does not use "open source" as a term. They write "open (source code) model", not "(open source) (code model)". It’s an important distinction.

And yes, Christine indeed invented the term, and folks from OSI gave it the current meaning by clearly defining it.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Thursday December 10, 2020 @04:55AM (#25371871)
I'm afraid this just isn't true. Ask other people around at the time:

> I joined Caldera in November of 1995, and we certainly used "open source" broadly at that time. We were building software. I can't imagine a world where we did not use the specific phrase "open source software". And we were not alone. The term "Open Source" was used broadly by Linus Torvalds (who at the time was a student...I had dinner with Linus and his then-girlfriend Ute in Germany while he was still a student), John "Mad Dog" Hall who was a major voice in the community (he worked at COMPAQ at the time), and many, many others.

https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:-i7au3...

Re:Death of an open-source business model by phaemon on Thursday December 10, 2020 @05:22AM (#25372061)
So where are all the examples on public mailing lists and Usenet of them using this? I'm afraid I simply don't trust people's hazy memories of conversations from years ago.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Thursday December 10, 2020 @06:20AM (#25372473)
> So where are all the examples on public mailing lists and Usenet of them using this?

Here's one

http://www.xent.com/FoRK-archive/fall96/0269.html

Also - even the USPTO rejected their claim as a trademark.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by phaemon on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:01PM (#25375728)
One. The same one you already posted. Where are the thousands of examples of this common usage?

Rejected after they'd made the term popular.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by chrisseaton on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:49PM (#25376300)
How many examples do you need to prove that something existed? Isn't one enough? When you see a fossil of a dinosaur skeleton in a museum do you say 'well hang on are there any more or just one?'

And it was rejected because it was a simple descriptive term. You can't take ownership of a simple descriptive term.

Bottom line facts are: OSDI don't own it - that's a fact - and they didn't use it first - that's a fact.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by phaemon on Thursday December 10, 2020 @01:33PM (#25376782)
I didn't claim it didn't exist so your strawman is irrelevant. If there was only a single dinosaur skeleton in existence I certainly wouldn't be claiming they were common animals.

The fact is it was barely used until the OSI introduced it as a term at which point it became popular. You seem to have a personal problem with that.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by phaemon on Thursday December 10, 2020 @05:08AM (#25371963)
> But at least this much is not true

Yes it is. Just because a phrase was used once or twice in some obscure post in the past, doesn't mean that someone can't come up with it independantly.

> a common term back then as well, but I can't find a reference for that now.

Because it wasn't a common term at all. If it was, you'd be able to find thousands of examples of usage, from all over the early web and (especially) Usenet. How many examples do you actually have. Two or three?

Re:Death of an open-source business model by vosper on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @04:11PM (#25365061)
Mongo is also proving the success of vendor lock-in: you (or the engineers before you, and the engineers before them) make a mess in Mongo, because there are no relations and no schemas [0], and it becomes really difficult to get off it.

The effort required just to get your data in a state that's clean enough to consider moving to the RDBMS you should have started with can be overwhelming.

Then you have to rewrite your queries out of their custom query language.

Is it Mongo's fault you made a mess in your database? No, of course not. And their dashboard is actually pretty nice. But you are massively locked-in.

Source: own a production Mongo DB with years of accumulated mess in it. Desperate to get off it. Paying customer of Mongo's hosting (it's one less Mongo thing to deal with, at least).

[0] There is schema support now, but it's only JSON schema and it's relatively new in the scheme [sorry] of things

Re:Death of an open-source business model by bonestormii_ on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:07PM (#25365932)
This isn't really vendor lock-in, though. It's simply a technical/design lock-in. Going from unstructured to structured data presents problems, and if you do that, it's rightfully up to you to fix.

It is different from the vendor lock-in that prevents one from migrating from AWS to Google Cloud because all of your code uses their APIs and libraries specifically.

However, the effect is the same, of course. You are locked in! It's not necessarily a bad thing, but this is why you must choose your poison carefully.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by vosper on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:36PM (#25366278)
> This isn't really vendor lock-in, though. It's simply a technical/design lock-in. Going from unstructured to structured data presents problems, and if you do that, it's rightfully up to you to fix.

This is true, but it's also kind of vendor lock-in because there's a whole query language and aggregation pipeline for Mongo that's completely different to other databases. If I was using an RDBMS and was switching from MySQL to Postgres I think I would likely have a much easier time, because fundamentally it's all SQL (I know, there are differences between Postgres and MySQL, but it's a lot less, and a good ORM will smooth some of it out for you - at least initially)

I think this is basically equivalent to your example of not being able to easily move from AWS to Google Cloud because of their different APIs.

It doesn't seem like SQL-to-Mongo is impossible to implement, because there is third-party tooling for that (which I haven't tried): https://studio3t.com/knowledge-base/articles/sql-query/

Re:Death of an open-source business model by bonestormii_ on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:24AM (#25371222)
Yeah you are right. There is no standardization to the way you interact with such things.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by nradov on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:55AM (#25371409)
RDBMS doesn't work for some of the complex hierarchical data I have to deal with. Shredding it out into a 3NF relational schema would require joining 20+ tables in every query to do anything useful. No thanks. Use the right database type for the job.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by breakfastduck on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:06PM (#25365920)
Agreed. MongoDB makes it far too easy to make terrible decisions in regard to data design.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by zozbot234 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:10PM (#25369595)
Postgresql supports JSON-in-db out of the box, so I'm not sure that there's any real lockin wrt. Mongo. It's just that those who care about not being tied to a single vendor are less likely to use something like Mongo in the first place.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by FpUser on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:45PM (#25366391)
I very much prefer to use RDBMS first and the rest as the last resort. Still I do not believe that quality of data design could be enforced just by the fact of using RDBMS. I sometimes encountered RDBMS schemas that look like they were designed by lunatics.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by joshspankit on Friday December 11, 2020 @04:42PM (#25391465)
Genuinely curious: Have you looked at moving to a graph database?

I can’t conceptualize a dataset that could survive(/be performant) in a document store, but not a graph.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by jfengel on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @05:36PM (#25366283)
I took the opposite route in 2010, and it didn't work out well for me. We sold it as a premium product, and it was hard to get adoption. Which made it hard to actually prove the benefits we claimed should exist.

That's not proof that we'd have fared better if we had open-sourced it. We took exactly the opposite route of MongoDB, with very stringent schemas to ensure data quality. That required a large up-front investment in time, and that was a hard sell too. The whole world went in the opposite direction, of schemaless databases and machine learning for "eh, good enough" answers.

Still, I'll always wonder if we wouldn't have failed so spectacularly if we'd open sourced it. The idea was a pretty good one, and we wrote some remarkable software to make it happen.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by 3np on Thursday December 10, 2020 @03:22AM (#25371209)
What is the "it" you're referring to here?
Re:Death of an open-source business model by jfengel on Thursday December 10, 2020 @11:45AM (#25375538)
The company was called Highfleet. We built ontology-based databases. Not OWL ontologies; we were actually doing ontologies before OWL. We were briefly and tangentially involved, but we thought they had picked the wrong level of ontology. We had a full-featured logic language for really strong definitions, so that you have strong guarantees about data quality and good ways to reason about data integration between databases.

In the end we never found the right use case for it. The advantages were all in maintenance rather than development, and even people who could be talked around to it wouldn't see the payoff. There were a trillion other problems, and maybe better management than me could have made it work.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by infinity0 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @06:18PM (#25366850)
I wish there was a FOSS license with a clause along the lines of:

- if your company makes >X revenue a year, give us some of it.

Ofc, they (FSF/OSI/DFSG) would have to relax their FOSS definition(s), but with more projects dying in this way hopefully more FOSS organisations will take heed and think about this.

Ofc, the wording of the license has to be precise enough to avoid something like fobbing off the servers to technically be controlled by subsidiaries with 0 revenue.

Ofc, the license would have to figure out how to share revenue with major contributors too.

Contributors already contribute to for-profit open source projects without themselves getting paid, so this license would make the situation strictly better for them.

Laws and definitions have to change with the changing times - the technological economy is different today than it was 20 years ago when tech companies weren't so big or able to throw their weight around. Staying true to the original spirit of FOSS and sharing, means that we have to find ways to support independent FOSS business.

The loudest arguments I hear at forcing the FOSS definition to remain static and blind to revenue, is from big tech companies or wealthy people being paid by big tech companies, because it benefits them. People working for a small FOSS companies understand the realities of competing in today's tech environment, and understand that revenue-sharing far from stifling FOSS, will allow it to flourish properly.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by willvarfar on Thursday December 10, 2020 @01:16AM (#25370402)
> - if your company makes >X revenue a year, give us some of it.

This would just lead to Hollywood-accounting, where a AWS-Tools subsidiary does all the software at a loss, and AWS-Cloud is just a user etc.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by infinity0 on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:56AM (#25415631)
Whatever scenario you imagine where some $bigtech benefits from using the software, there is some identifiable chain of events from where the software was produced, which can, with some effort, be defined and specified in a general way in the license, in terms of a contract that allows each party in the chain to supply to the next party in the chain.

From that perspective they will never be an independent third party, and therefore you can specify that in a contract. So I don't see a theoretical problem to this, just a practical one of specifying this both precisely enough to be enforceable, and general enough to cover all real cases.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by joshspankit on Friday December 11, 2020 @04:48PM (#25391593)
Is there a way to structure a license so that this kind of accounting is much harder?

In Hollywood’s case, it’s pretty clear when movies are making money (same with games to a large degree), but I don’t know if there’s a way for “tool” companies to leverage that.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by langitbiru on Thursday December 10, 2020 @04:38AM (#25371732)
So can we cheat Unreal with Hollywood-accounting because they offer this kind of license (although it's not open source)?

https://www.unrealengine.com/en-US/download

Re:Death of an open-source business model by willvarfar on Thursday December 10, 2020 @04:50AM (#25371838)
Yes, game projects absolutely use Hollywood accounting. Dev studios pop up for one project, and often close at launch, and some other legal entity gets all the subs after that. And so on. Game dev financing is infamously horrid.

Unreal, though, is in a different negotiating position with the game publishers than, say, an open-source software with a new pay-us-if-you-make-money clause. Its the distinction between source-available (like Unreal Engine) and open-source which the article tries to make?

Timescale's new license is an interesting move in this direction.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by orlandohill on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @07:09PM (#25367520)
You can achieve something similar by dual-licensing under a paid license and the source-available license, Polyform Small Business.

https://polyformproject.org/licenses/small-business/1.0.0

Re:Death of an open-source business model by infinity0 on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:45AM (#25415544)
That license is specifically targeted in favour of small businesses for some reason, omitting individuals etc. This potential FOSS license I am talking about would only target against big tech companies.
Re:Death of an open-source business model by theamk on Thursday December 10, 2020 @12:59AM (#25370317)
Is this going to be fixed/known price? then you are describing "source available" model. I don't think we need another word for it -- it exists, and it works pretty well (even Microsoft uses it sometimes)

Or are you describing some sort of system where the authors get the fixed share (%) of user's company revenue? I think this is not going to work very well... just imagine a big company which is not focused on computers. Or a computer startup which wants to be bought by FAANG for billions of dollars.

Re:Death of an open-source business model by infinity0 on Monday December 14, 2020 @05:55AM (#25415624)
No, "source available" does not generally allow one to distribute and sell your own modifications.

This license would be exactly like today's FOSS, except to force large tech companies to the negotiating table to share revenue.