When I was a stats major, Peter Donnelly's TED Talk was required viewing on the matter: https://www.ted.com/talks/peter_donnelly_how_juries_are_fool...
I don't know. I'm vividly aware that if the matching isn't accurate, innocents will go to prison. But the truth seems less simple than that.
Thoughts?
[1] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2019/09/why-forensic-science-...
[2] https://www.chicagotribune.com/news/ct-xpm-2009-08-25-chi-09...
If the finger is pointed at you with a deep fake, you can then counter with proof from large corporations which presumably haven’t all been compromised.
You might also be able to use proof of your location in other settings, such as civil suits or domestic disputes.
Lots of people are using dash cams in a similar fashion. Proof to protect themselves from being named the liable party in a collision.
Same with forcing communications over email so you can prove what was actually communicated in the event a legal or public relations matter arises.
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/google-tracked-his-bike...
> Even then, Kenyon wanted to make sure police didn’t have lingering doubts about McCoy, whom they still knew only as “John Doe.” So he met with the detective again and showed him screenshots of his client’s Google location history, including data recorded by RunKeeper. The maps showed months of bike rides past the burglarized home.
I’m posting kind of tongue in cheek, because it’s almost a foregone conclusion that people have their mobile device on them, which means the mobile networks know where you are at all times. In that event, it’s more advantageous for you to have access to your location history (via Google/Facebook/Instagram) when the full force or the law starts coming down on you.
Each item isn’t meant to be foolproof, just to assist in creating third party verifiable data when combined with things like credit card transaction data or road toll timestamps to make it improbably for anything else to have happened.
Privacy laws tend to focus on corporation's being tasked with protecting it but as stated before they already are handcuffed by the sheer fact government can get the records when it wants them. Worse sycophants within government and these companies will turn it over to prying eyes for financial and political benefit or just self determined moral justification
So in the end only protection we have is making it too costly for anyone to use the information they obtain illegally. This means going not just after the people who leaked/stole/etc the data but anyone with it.
People vastly over estimate how much privacy they have when in fact anything you do outside your home pretty much can be observed and any government agency will be able to get that information through the courts
It's not the relationship I expected, clearance rates are steadily dropping despite these advancements.
The following piece considers a few possible reasons why:
https://digitalcommons.newhaven.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?arti...
Some of this may be a corrective effect, DNA is more likely to exonerate and prevent false arrests than it is to identify criminals. Other situations, well, new technology doesn't guarantee that you have enough detectives to clear crimes, or that those detectives are well trained.
Then there's the whole class of violent crimes that happen on high traffic streets where DNA is not likely to be abundant or well preserved.
We may not able to stop the first murder, but we can stop the abuse on the first hit.
I censor myself on Wechat and expect to be able to go to the next pool party in Wuhan. Not everything is about whats happening on the other side of the Gobi desert, also obligatory "Chinese territorial sovereignty and unity shall not be questioned". You'll catch on (or be indefinitely detained, or at least unable to board a plane lol.) I find this tolerable.
The people or the likely-genocidal government?
Besides that, the two ancestry database sites said it was a breach of privacy.
So you tell me if justice was served.
He also has form for faking medical issues. He was caught shoplifting while still a police officer and tried to fake a heart attack in the hope that they would let him go/it would enable him to escape.
To be sure there will always be human ineptitude and bungling of cases but it does seem that DNA forensics, security cameras, the prevalence of cell phones, digital messaging surveillance, etc. have brought to justice many killers very quickly that might have gone on to kill again were this 50 years ago.
While there are a lot of nuances to privacy in the 21s Century, I am not so stalwart of a privacy advocate to disregard the utility of finding killers by means that are somewhat privacy invasive.