2. From the article:
> Note added 2020.12.07: ... Each item in the list looked like a flush-left paragraph, like the paragraphs in this blog post, adjacent to the left margin.
They were numbering paragraphs, not line items, and lines that wrapped were supposed to be left-justified. I don't think this is a strawman.
3. MS Word would have a fit with skipping a number before "They" in the sentence above, and assigning number 3 and not 1 to this paragraph.
4. There are other cases when you need to separately label Article 1/Section A/Clause I etc. in a hierarchy; the numbered list tabulation and hopefully semantic Heading 1/Heading 2/Heading 3 styles and tables of contents in Word can handle this for your use case, but be prepared for frustration if you want something a little different than what the UI is designed to help you build.
Word allows you to adjust the indentation on numbered lists so that the text in a paragraph is flush with the left margin. In Word 365 there are at least two ways to do this:
1. View -> Show -> [check Ruler] -> [Adjust the indentation on the ruler]
2. Layout -> Paragraph -> [click lower right arrow] Paragraph Settings -> Indentation -> change Special from (hanging) to (none), or change the "By:" value to 0
So the author's motivating example doesn't seem to be a particularly fair criticism of Word.
For me, Word and LaTeX are on par. Styles, referencing, formula, macros, auto-layout are possible in both. However real-world use is different because Word is the lowest common denominator and thus mostly only the basic features actually get used. Because everybody experienced the horror of automatic features at least once.
In using Word with long documents, I'm reminded of pilots' early criticism of Airbus software, "What's it doing now?"
"Geeks that have read 2000 man pages about LaTex and have never bothered to browse Word docs complain about missing feature in Word that is actually in Word since the last millenium" :-))
LaTeX seems much more predictable. I have a file with my custom commands and styles that I `\input` and use always use consistent style. Nothing too crazy. But I also never try to do anything too crazy in Word, either.
Regardless, Bernstein does in fact address this criticism in the note added yesterday. Yes, it has automatic list numbering, but in order to achieve the desired formatting, the users had, instead of altering the formatting appropriately, removed this automatic numbering, because Microsoft Word doesn't make these sorts of distinctions clear and explicit.
If we want to compare tools, we should not compare expert users of one tool with novices of another tool.
That would explain it :-)
But I guess it’s not easy to save work in latex when in macro mode?
You can get into much worse situations than this once you leave the "happy path" in LaTeX.
Microsoft Word has automatic numbering. Just to be sure, I opened Word, and entered a numbered list. When I inserted a new numbered item, it automatically renumbered the list. Also, converting from a numbered list to bullet points is as simple as selecting the list and clicking the bullets icon instead of the numbered list icon.
This opening anecdote makes me think the author is completely unfamiliar with Word, and is strawmanning it.