News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by nrmitchi on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:28AM (#25347432)
There is a huge difference between "FedEx and UPS are limiting the number of items we are allowed to ship", and "Fedex and UPS are limiting the number of items that they will pick up and scan for us but we can still drop everything off at a depot ourselves with no limit".

The article is using the terms "shipping limits" and "pickup limits" interchangeably, which is very misleading.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by jgjr on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:17PM (#25349239)
I'm the source. And yes, we are also being turned away at the depot. "Shipping limits" and "pickup limits" are used interchangeably because they're one and the same limitation currently. I even offered to drive our packages in a UHAUL to Las Vegas or Denver hubs to insert them myself and was told a hold would be placed on our account.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by SilasX on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:53PM (#25349736)
I hate to be the one to ask, but ... why can’t they throttle demand and increase capacity by raising prices?
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by lumost on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @03:17PM (#25350760)
Throttling a spike using price forces everyone to pay the marginal rate, and to use price as a "good" throttle requires the logistics companies to have perfect knowledge of the demand/price curve.

Given that shipping can be a significant price component for multiple types of e-commerce, transparency on when they can issue their final "get it by Christmas" sales with their standard/deterministic pricing structure.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by sieabahlpark on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @06:21PM (#25352960)
> Throttling a spike using price forces everyone to pay the marginal rate, and to use price as a "good" throttle requires the logistics companies to have perfect knowledge of the demand/price curve.

Not really, you just keep raising prices per day until it gets to the rate you want. If you want more packages lower the price.

I have no idea why you think something that has been done since the foundation of capitalism is somehow completely foreign or impossible to compute or experiment with. Unlike in an economics class companies will never solve the two equations to perfectly maximize the profit, it's more of a range and they're hoping to get close enough. That's a much more realistic approach that has historically worked.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by sokoloff on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @07:37PM (#25353719)
High-volume shippers have contracts with carriers, often more than one year in length. Some of them are referenced to the retail rate. Many though are defined price (including surcharges) with annual escalations. Parcel carriers have been disrupted to some extent by Amazon building out their own logistics capability both line-haul and last-mile and have been signing contracts with non-Amazon shippers to ensure they could cover their costs and make a profit.

Now, pandemic hits and drives a lot of unexpected, probably just this year, traffic into parcel shipping that would have otherwise been freight to stores and passenger car to homes and there's not enough capacity.

There's not as much price shaping they can do without being in violation of their contract. In a lot of cases, they know they need these big shippers next year as well, so they can't entirely burn them this year even if they were willing to litigate the contract.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by jessaustin on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @10:36PM (#25355026)
It's an interesting contract, that locks in a price for a service but not whether the service will even be available.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by lumost on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @08:29PM (#25354223)
This works if you don't care about churn, or necessarily moving a certain number of units/preserving capacity on a given day. As there are only 17 days until the theoretical peak delivery date there isn't much room to adjust. A miss-price on December 20th may cause you to sell out remaining capacity or worse favor one customer over others.

A second price auction market for available capacity could allow the market to adapt fast and transparently to available capacity.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by bfieidhbrjr on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:53PM (#25355500)
The real answer is it’s politically incorrect to do that. Refusing service is cheaper than raising prices. Raising prices introduces all kinds of media and government scrutiny with unquantifiable downside. It’s the right thing to do but not the political thing to do.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by shanecleveland on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:08PM (#25349922)
I believe they had been, and perhaps still are, charging per-shipment fees to "high-volume" shippers. And that is good in that it is leveling the charge on the culprit (the ones benefiting from e-commerce the most). Retail shippers already pay more and that wouldn't hit the source of the problem. And most shippers have contracts that may prevent sudden price increases based on volume (typically volume is rewarded).
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Retric on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:03PM (#25349866)
They did as everyone can just pay over the counter rates without issue, because you can ship anonymously.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by ghshephard on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:12PM (#25349962)
Nobody is shipping 500 packages/day over the counter.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Consultant32452 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:18PM (#25350018)
I would love to try this one day as long as the Benny Hill song can play in the background as I make trips from my van into a retail UPS store.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by jjjjoe on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @06:20PM (#25352947)
I helped a friend pack and ship a successful Kickstarter campaign. The first time we showed up at the UPS store with a minivan full of boxes they made us set up an account. They had no interest in an "anonymous" transaction for more than a couple packages.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:20AM (#25355629)
Don't be a slacker. You have to bring in one at a time. If they kick you out you gotta move on to the next UPS store.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by CaliforniaKarl on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:37PM (#25350252)
I have a friend who works in a UPS Store. He has been working 10+-hour days for the last two weeks, on top of a bicycle commute (which will sometimes turn into an hour-long walk if the winds are bad), picking up groceries, etc.. They have as many employees as they are allowed to have (given the store size), and right now the work is never-ending.

> I would love to try this one day as long as the Benny Hill song can play in the background as I make trips from my van into a retail UPS store.

Please don't do this, or even joke about it.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by pmiller2 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:42PM (#25350308)
Seriously. The UPS store I go to always has a line, usually extending out the door due to 6' distancing, and it probably would not literally hold 500 average-sized packages. I know it certainly would not hold 500 additional, average-sized packages.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Consultant32452 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:47PM (#25350371)
The UPS store I go to sometimes has one other customer.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by ethbr0 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @03:26PM (#25350863)
Can I ship you a package to ship from your UPS store?
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Consultant32452 on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @12:21AM (#25355632)
Sure bro, fedex it to me.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by irrational on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @06:23PM (#25352981)
This was my thought. I was just at a UPS store and there was nobody else there. I assume some are just busier than others.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Retric on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @03:00PM (#25350563)
FedEx would only pick up 110 Letterfolk packages per day ... Galbraith had a queue of 3,000 orders waiting to go out.

There are 26 UPS stores in San Francisco for example. 10 packages at each location per person is hardly going to raise red flags. Use multiple people and add in FedEx and you could probably cover their 3k package backlog in one day. It's not going to cheap or scalable, but you can bet some people are going that route.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by jjjjoe on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @06:22PM (#25352971)
I commented similarly elsewhere, but in my experience UPS won't ship more than one or two packages without an account. Red flags will definitely be raised if you try to smurf package shipments.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Retric on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @06:53PM (#25353338)
Interesting, that's not been my experience.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by SilasX on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @02:19PM (#25350039)
So ... this “limit” is really just a “limit on how much you can send with a discount”? Well, there goes the newsworthiness...

Edit: Can someone please explain my error here? This comment [1] (as well as the immediately surrounding thread) indicates the limit applies to a business account that pays lower rates, and you have the unlimited right to ship on a non-business account that pays higher rates. Thus, the limit is really just a limit on the discounted rate. Which is equivalent to a price increase. Which is totally unsurprising and dog-bites-man for a case of high demand and difficulty increasing capacity. Thus, no longer newsworthy.

So where's my error, really?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25348485

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by reificator on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @05:44PM (#25352529)
To start with, the business account is not only about paying a better rate. It's relevant for your internal accounting, taxes, etc...

You can't just start handing out business credit cards to everyone you send to the store, the alternative is to ask employees to pay out of pocket and pinky swear to reimburse them.

Then there's the question of liability. If your business account shipped something, any questions of liability are clear cut and easy to deal with. If a random employee shipped something, who's liable for any issues?

And how about efficiency? Not only are you paying a reduced rate with a business account, but the provider comes and picks up your packages from you on a regular basis. If instead of putting things in the right place and answering the door when the UPS driver comes by, now you're paying however many employees to pick up a bunch of packages, drive over to the closest location, and wait in line. I don't know what the lines are like at UPS right now, but I do know that the USPS lines around me are about 45-60 minutes depending on the time of day. Not to mention that line starts outside in the cold.

And that's all assuming your employee brings 20 packages to the clerk and has no problems shipping them all in the same transaction.

Which means it's possible that your employee(s) didn't do their normal job, got frustrated and cold and risked infection standing in line instead, you paid a premium to do so, and some of your packages didn't get shipped regardless.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by fennecfoxen on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:32PM (#25355385)
> the alternative is to ask employees to pay out of pocket and pinky swear to reimburse them.

Uhh, fwiw, if you tell an employee you'll reimburse them for something they do for your business, it's got a little bit more heft in a court than a "pinky swear."

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by reificator on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:53PM (#25355499)
Thanks, I hadn't considered that. What about if you cross your fingers?

My post was to point out the absurdity of the claim that a business account with UPS/FedEx is nothing more than a discount. The part you quoted is a joke, and is not to be taken as legal advice. I am not a lawyer, and also IANAL.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by fennecfoxen on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:08AM (#25360087)
You're not giving legal advice, you're just... casting aspersions on the process of a business asking for you to file an expense report, for some reason, when it's a perfectly normal thing at many businesses (and one that I have performed hundreds of times myself, because ugh consulting.)

Like, you could complain that the reimbursement process is a tedious paperwork-generator, maybe, if you think your other objections aren't enough already?

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by reificator on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @02:37PM (#25363391)
I really don't understand your position at all, but it seems like you're more upset than I would expect given the context.

In good faith I will refrain from joking about expense reports in the future.

I did not intend to cause offense, I just saw room for a joke I thought would lighten the mood of the post a bit by making it seem more childish. I'm not trying to demean people who file expense reports or something.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by fennecfoxen on Thursday December 10, 2020 @09:10AM (#25373843)
I was just taken aback by what seemed to be a vague and completely unnecessary “employers can never be trusted and employees are suckers” sentiment in the middle of coherent words. If it was a joke it undermined the serious points.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by kaitai on Wednesday December 09, 2020 @11:10PM (#25369598)
If you have low-wage workers, it simply isn't practical to ask them to float you hundreds of dollars in shipping costs. It's great that as a consultant you can do that. It might be useful to realize that most Americans are in a very different financial position.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by EricE on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @05:54PM (#25352658)
Yeah do that and they detect it (you better believe UPS and FedEX have EXCELLENT analytics) and they put a hold on your account and if you rely on shipping you are screwed.

You don't play stupid games with a critical part of your business operations.

If anything it just stresses the need for businesses to have more contingency plans and supplier/partner depth. Yup, it's not as cheap as winging it with a sole provider for the best deal you can get but you also won't be in a situation where you are screwed at a critical point in your business calendar.

Business operations - so much fun!

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by frogpelt on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:55PM (#25355515)
One reason may be that they are already at capacity for shipping and they simply cannot pick up any more packages.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by sokoloff on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @12:30PM (#25348485)
We are a high-volume shipper. Our limits were per-account, not per-location nor would drop-offs be accepted and treated in any way differently.

I suppose that we could ship as much as we wanted paying over-the-counter full-retail rates, just like anyone else could.

In contrast to the retailers stories in the article, these limits were not a surprise to us. We’ve been planning for months to accommodate this and I think our main carrier (UPS) did a great job of communicating, even as things were somewhat being defined.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @12:40PM (#25348641)
That changes things. I know that DHL express is doing this all the time during Q4. Until now I thought it to be a pickup issue. Now that is more like a general capacity issue. Do these limits impact your overall shipping capacity or do you manage regardless?
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by sokoloff on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:04PM (#25349048)
That's treading towards company confidential data, so I'll just say that it did represent a serious threat to overall capacity but that we have been able to navigate well enough by using a variety of tactics (including demand shaping, negotiating with carriers, and tweaking some of our fitness functions for fulfillment scheduling [to ensure we never/rarely wasted our carrier parcel allocation, even if it might be slightly cheaper to fulfill an order a different way if we had infinite outbound parcel capacity]).
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by hef19898 on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:46PM (#25349642)
Thanks for answering anyway! And already kudos for a nice job. I just hope I didn't jinx your Q4 now... Part of me wished to have an ops role in 2020, another part is happy I don't. Not sure which one is stronger, so!
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by danpalmer on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @12:23PM (#25348343)
For a retailer of any scale these might as well be the same thing.

Dropping off at a depot is not really how this bit of the industry works – the courier collects from the distribution centre in almost every case.

The issues with doing your own drop offs include: finding a new courier, booking, figuring out a collection time which then impacts your shipping estimate cut-off time, and paying for this whole service.

In terms of price, you're going from a high volume commodity service at typically a crazy low price for courier shipping (for what it is), to adding a new additional short-term, lower volume or unproven volume, from one of the smaller providers who aren't operating at Fedex/UPS scale. I could imagine this doubling shipping costs, which might be untenable for many ecommerce businesses.

In terms of the actual logistics, it's a challenge, plus typically this would be automated – your software will do this all for you. Now your software needs to book and pre-advise a new provider? And track through them? But also track through the original one?

For most businesses it's probably impractical to implement this, and for most that could they probably have contracts with the couriers that mean they won't be hit by this or they do their own deliveries. I think the space in the middle is a pretty small subset of companies.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by nrmitchi on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @12:38PM (#25348616)
> Dropping off at a depot is not really how this bit of the industry works – the courier collects from the distribution centre in almost every case.

I am aware of this. The posted article is referencing merchants with 3000 shipments to send out, which is not insane scale. If FedEx wouldn't pick those up at your door, it is possible to get those shipped out still. Obviously, yes, you may need some new logistics coordination, and it will be more expensive, and yes, it could make a lot of business margin's no longer work. I am definitely not saying that I agree with any action that FedEx/UPS is alleged to be taking here (especially without reasonable notice).

But that is not the same thing as "FedEx is refusing to let us ship more than X boxes per day". And it's a distinction that the article should get right.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by _jal on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @12:47PM (#25348746)
I would like to propose someone create a new emoji symbol for "I'm mad at the journalist".

It would save so much time.

Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by EsotericAlgo on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @01:10PM (#25349135)
There has been a big shift to ship-from-store to make up for limited warehouse capacity to meet increased demand. The options for delays for store picks up are much the same: employees drop off at depot, third party courier, or wait.
Re:FedEx and UPS hit companies with unexpected holiday shipp... by Hizonner on Tuesday December 08, 2020 @11:53AM (#25347840)
If everybody starts bringing tons of stuff into the depots, there may very well be a limit on that too, soon. Or maybe there'll just be the natural limit that you'll wait in line all day and not get to drop off before closing.

You'll have a madhouse at those depots if every shipper starts individually hauling in all of their (unusually high number of) packages.