If new buildings being added to the building stock are built with gas, then people will still be reliant on gas to cook. If they are added with electric/induction stoves, then everyone will benefit from the grid's shift away from natural gas.
Requiring a 240V drop in the kitchen I could see. Makes the replacement of a gas oven with electric easier, if the homeowner wishes and an easy requirement for builders to meet.
Banning an NG connection limits choice today and is based upon a forecast for the future that may not occur in the timeframe you are expecting.
California will be burning gas 10 to 20 years from now.
Without nuclear or dramatic battery innovations, we will always burn natural gas for night time energy.
How sure of that are you? I’m not so sure but quick google says maybe not as true as you imply: https://slate.com/business/2015/09/texas-electricity-goes-ne.... Maybe région dépendant? Is that a deal breaker given power can be transported between regions?
> Battery tech
I see part of the point of this legislation is to drive innovation. We’ll never get change if we just say “it’s impossible so we have to burn fossils.” I don’t dispute any of your points really except if the policy is gradual enough it will force us to adapt and that is a good thing IMO.
Burning natural gas to produce electricity to power electric heaters at home is actually worse from a CO2 perspective than burning natural gas directly for home heating.
Using daytime solar excess to pump water uphill lets you get double duty out of the hydro and looks to be about the right amount of after hours energy use.
You need energy storage at scale at night. The only solution at night after batteries (chemical, stored water, gravity, etc.) are quickly depleted is natural gas.
Modern nuclear reactor designs could easily fill the gap. Public sentiment and the risk of building in earthquake prone geography has prevented investment in nuclear.
If the rate of new construction is low, then hopefully renewables plus batteries will be able to keep up with increased nighttime demand.
http://www.caiso.com/todaysoutlook/pages/supply.aspx
With renewables making up 32.7%.
When the sun drops by late afternoon, CA will be making electricity on natural gas.
Heating at night will almost be entirely natural gas. Even if you have an electric heater, the electricity will be generated using natural gas.
So what is exactly the benefit of ripping out natural gas from homes?