News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by jcranmer on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:49AM (#25299722)
I wonder where the stereotype of scantily-clad leather-fetish armor for barbarians actually comes from, given its extreme prevalence in modern culture and complete absence in actual historical cultures. Some other ahistorical stereotypes are easy to understand [1], but I don't see how both leather acquires an ahistorical importance and less armor becomes better-armored.

One point to call out that the author doesn't emphasize is that steppe cultures (both in North America and Eurasia) were integral parts of vast trading networks. One of the noted features of pre-Columbian North America [2] was the extent and speed with which trade goods moved all along it. So steppe cultures would absolutely have access to all the fine luxuries of the "civilized" world. Indeed, it should be noted that marrying off royalty to steppe elites was a common strategy for keeping steppe raiding at bay. This is fairly evident to anyone who does even a modicum of research on steppe peoples, or ancient people in general (people trade! all the time!), so the notion that steppe people are inherently austere is clearly the mark of someone who does not believe in research.

[1] e.g., colorless white Greco-Roman temples: all the paint faded away, leaving the underlying white stone. When the Renaissance kicks off a shift in Greco-Roman historiography to putting them at the pinnacle of human civilization, the extant white ruins were taken as reflective of what they actually looked liked and became the archetypes of modern attempts to re-summit civilization's pinnacle.

[2] Although it should be noted that the steppe cultures of the US--such as the Cheyenne, Apache, Sioux--don't exist in their modern form before the introduction of the horse around about the 18th century, with the Siouan peoples not even living on the plains until pushed out there during migrations in the 17th century.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by rishav_sharan on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:40AM (#25299967)
I think the art of Boris Vallejo and his compatriots was instrumental in 80s fantasy having a sexploitation theme. Their work was so influential that it shaped fantasy themes for decades and gave nerds like us an expression of the typical teenage male power fantasy
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by FranzFerdiNaN on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:54AM (#25300059)
This for sure reinforced it with a new wave, but i think that pulp characters like Conan the Barbarian, from the 1930’s, already did it.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by baud147258 on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:20AM (#25300483)
If I remember right, it was mostly the covers, because I don't think Conan is usually described as wearing scantily-clad leather-fetish armor in the books
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by Mauricebranagh on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:56AM (#25301725)
Margret Brundage was there before Vallejo and there is also Wonder Woman in the early 40's
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by howlgarnish on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:23AM (#25299875)
Same reason they put Princess Leia in a metal bikini: it's an excuse to look sexy. You wouldn't see Khan Drogo's bulging pecs and sculpted torso or Daenerys' neckline and toned midriff if they were covered by boring but historically accurate linen tunics.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by goto11 on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:23AM (#25300504)
Sure but they didn't have Jaime Lannister dressed as scantily as the Dothraki. Clearly the show is relying on the trope of barbarians which does not care about fancy clothes as a justification for the fan service.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by puranjay on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:56AM (#25302230)
I find the depiction of the "barbarians" in the Barbarians show on Netflix to be far more accurate. They are barbarians only because they are deemed to be so by the Romans. Otherwise they aren't roaming around topless in leather chaps - they wear regular clothes, just rougher and not as refined as the Romans.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by maxerickson on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:35AM (#25304280)
Leia is a captive in those scenes, so it's not really a comparable context.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by howlgarnish on Saturday December 05, 2020 @12:31AM (#25312057)
Leia is chained up in a skimpy metal bikini, while Han Solo & Chewy are thrown into the dungeon with their clothes on. Wonder why?
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by maxerickson on Saturday December 05, 2020 @10:05AM (#25315037)
Sure, from the filmmakers perspective, but it isn't narratively incoherent the way it is for someone headed into a battle. It's maybe strange that a giant slug would sexualize a humanoid, but maybe that's not what is being implied.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by chewz on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:47AM (#25304485)
Visiting a monastery in Italy I have seen the painting of Alaric burning Rome commissioned by Pope. The Goths were depicted more or less as barbarians in Hollywood movie.

Historic Alaric the Goth was born in Dacia (former Roman province abandoned already at the time), he spoke fluent Latin, was a Christian (however Arian so heretic for Pope) and before burning Rome had a career in Roman Army.

The book Alaric the Goth [1] by Douglas Boin published this year is quite interesting if little thin on historical facts.

Fun fact I have learned from the book - to keep its cultural cohesion late Roman Empire at one point banned trousers and shoes as barbarian and non-Roman. And look at European streets today.

> Though Boin doesn’t advance an explicit argument, a preoccupation lurks within his language. “Alaric’s actions,” he writes at one point, “forced a difficult, long-overdue conversation about acceptance, belonging, and the rights of immigrant communities.” That’s a very 21st-century formulation. Was there a Ravenna Ideas Festival? The collective term he uses for Goths, Vandals, Huns, and other groups is always “immigrants.” In his pages we encounter “border patrol,” “border separation,” “gated communities,” and “cultural warriors.” He refers to the Danube River as a “fence.” He describes a “new combustible mix of xenophobia and cultural supremacy” that encouraged public figures to work “populism and nationalism into their applause lines.” Alaric the Goth is not a polemic. [1]

[1] https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2020/07/douglas...

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by Ichthypresbyter on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:52AM (#25304571)
> to keep its cultural cohesion late Roman Empire at one point banned trousers and shoes as barbarian and non-Roman

Shoes? Really?

I know that trousers were seen (by both Greeks and Romans) as being barbarian, but the Romans definitely wore shoes. The most famous sort were the caligae, hobnailed sandals worn by legionaries- the pair worn by the young Gaius Caesar, son of Germanicus Julius Caesar, as part of his miniature military uniform gave him his better-known nickname of Caligula.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by chewz on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:53AM (#25304599)
Shoes not sandals...

> further legislation forbid residents of Rome from wearing two items of clothing, tzangae and bracchae, which sounded as strange in Latin as they looked foreign on people strolling the city's streets of volcanic cobblestones: "boots" and "pants"..

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by Olreich on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:08AM (#25301823)
I think it’s a fetish and a quickly readable way to indicate raw and unbridled strength. They are so strong and quick they don’t need armor, realistic weaponry or anything else, they’ll kill you anyway. I think it’s also supposed to indicate an inferior culture stemming from the more puritanical cultures of the western world. The west knows enough to cover themselves and use proper armor, the barbarians don’t. The barbarians are feared and mocked because of this in most media I’ve seen.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by _iyig on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:36AM (#25301570)
I wouldn’t say _complete_ absence. Greek Hoplites are thought to have fought semi-nude with e.g. linen or leather cuirasses, and were depicted as fighting fully nude in the art of their day.

https://history.stackexchange.com/questions/10260/is-it-true...

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by puranjay on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:59AM (#25302249)
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by watwut on Friday December 04, 2020 @10:19AM (#25303173)
They had helmets and armor. Their style of warfare involved tight formation with massive shield that worked as long as they were in formation with that massive shield.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by chromaton on Friday December 04, 2020 @11:38AM (#25304336)
In the Frank Frazetta documentary, it was pointed out that the original Conan book covers were done in a Greek/Roman style, but then sold much better with Frazetta's leather loving barbarians on the front.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by tecoholic on Friday December 04, 2020 @05:29AM (#25300880)
I wonder about the practicality of metal and leather heavy costumes of the Amazonians in Wonder Women as well. It's just made to make them look attractive more than realistic.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by mdorazio on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:34AM (#25301220)
In case you're unaware, Wonder Woman came out of Marston's repressed S&M fantasies and belief in feminine superiority. The costumes and weapons (a lasso/rope...) reflect that specifically.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by thatguy0900 on Friday December 04, 2020 @10:02AM (#25302947)
The weakness of the original wonder woman is even that she becomes completely powerless if tied up by a male
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by QuesnayJr on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:42AM (#25301617)
It's pretty common on old pulp sci-fi, like Edgar Rice Burroughs. (The Skylark books have a surprisingly large amount of nudity, as well.) The characters in Princess of Mars are basically naked, except for leather harnesses to carry weapons. It's plausible that ERB was drawing on pre-existing notions about Native Americans, though the commercial appeal of sexy nude aliens is perhaps clear.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by disown on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:31PM (#25305912)
> I wonder where the stereotype of scantily-clad leather-fetish armor for barbarians actually comes from

Hollywood and media. Most modern stereotypes around the world are created by hollywood and the media. Whether it is of the cowboy/indians, soviets, north koreans, french, the south, etc.

As for why they are scantily-clad, probably because we associated clothing with wealth/civilization?

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by BlueTemplar on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:52AM (#25302198)
> One point to call out that the author doesn't emphasize is that steppe cultures (both in North America and Eurasia) were integral parts of vast trading networks.

I expect that this will pop up in the next blogposts of this series...

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by vanderZwan on Friday December 04, 2020 @05:02AM (#25300721)
> I wonder where the stereotype of scantily-clad leather-fetish armor for barbarians actually comes from, given its extreme prevalence in modern culture and complete absence in actual historical cultures.

I think it developed roughly like this: it probably somehow is rooted the "othering" that is fundamental to the "scientific" racism that was used to justify slavery and colonialism[0]. Leathers, furs and plain nakedness would fit there as a convenient stereotype of primitive cultures, compared to woven cloth which implies the use of technology and being refined. That gives us the (inaccurate) rough leathers vs woven colorful clothes contrast, representing primitive savages vs sophisticated civilizations.

Caveat: that is the most speculative part - I might be projecting modern stereotypes to a time before they were established, but it sounds like a sensible starting point to me.

If that holds up, then after that stereotype is established we enter Romanticism. People longing back to imagined pre-industrial times when things were pure and good (note that thanks to Tolkien this is also deeply, deeply embedded into the DNA of fantasy - Sauron and his orcs represented industrialism). We get the stereotype of the noble savage[1], which endured all the way to a fairly recent movie about giant blue natives on other planets[2] (not to be confused with that other movie about savage planets and blue giants[3], but anyway).

This was and still is hugely problematic, btw. Even if you don't include the anti-industrial vibes, you still have the glorification of a mythological collective past. That was a big part of 19th century propaganda used to sell the idea of nation states to people who historically did not belong together at all. Same with justifying the use of military force to unite people into one country. You can probably guess where that ended up. Spoiler: Godwin's law applies - which I think also makes it clear why it's Tolkien's depiction of "Sauron = industrialization = bad, Elves = nature = good" is not quite so simplistic and easy to reject either, since the theme also is a reaction to WWI and WWII.

Anyway, this is probably also where revealing skin really started becoming a thing: nakedness has a long history of implying innocence in art, and as a contrast also emphasizes vulnerability being violated by civilization. So suddenly being simple, barely clothed and primitive is "good".

And then we get to what everyone else has pointed out: pulp stories and sexy fantasy.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_racism

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_savage

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Avatar_(2009_film)

[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fantastic_Planet

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by BlueTemplar on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:51AM (#25302187)
> colorless white Greco-Roman temples: all the paint faded away, leaving the underlying white stone

Wait, I get that the statues and the bas-reliefs were painted, but were the columns too ?

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by boudewijnrempt on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:45AM (#25302729)
Yes. Everything was painted, and to modern eyes, as gaudily as possible.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by goto11 on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:58AM (#25302909)
> as gaudily as possible.

We don't actually know that. We know more or less what pigments were used but not how artistically it was applied. The gaudy reconstructions are made by scientists, nor artists. Not many paintings have survived from antiquity, but the ones we have does not strike me as gaudy.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by watwut on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:14AM (#25299827)
80ties sexy fantasy tropes possibly?
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by kibwen on Friday December 04, 2020 @02:40AM (#25299974)
Much earlier than that, at least as early as the pulp novels and comic books of the 1930s. Frank Frazetta's covers for Conan The Barbarian were almost certainly what solidified the depiction in the popular consciousness.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by flohofwoe on Friday December 04, 2020 @04:23AM (#25300503)
Also look at Siegfried's attire in the 1924 "Ring der Nibelungen" movie, classic "barbarian in bear skin" style (and I think this goes back further to the romanticization of the Germanic tribes as "noble savages" in the 19th century).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=45-8eZViYOE

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by twic on Friday December 04, 2020 @05:12AM (#25300786)
My guess is that this is derived in turn from stereotypical caveman outfits - furs wrapped round the scandalous bits and not much else. Barbarians basically being modern-day cavemen.

So where did that idea of caveman dress come from?

Ötzi, from ~3000 BC, was much more smartly dressed, although he did live somewhere a bit cold for just a squirrel-skin posing pouch:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/%C3%96tzi#/media/File:Archeopa...

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by bluGill on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:46PM (#25306065)
Interestingly, most caves are too cold to dress like that, even if the climate itself is otherwise warm enough. (I'm not aware of any place where you could safely sleep naked every day, though some nights are that warm)
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by inglor_cz on Friday December 04, 2020 @03:08AM (#25300143)
"the notion that steppe people are inherently austere"

They are not inherently austere, but the very fact that they tend to move around limits how much they can own and carry with them. Plus, by living far inland, it is harder to reach them using ships, which were by far the most efficient transport means until the advent of railways.

Until railways, wealth made by long distance trade tended to concentrate in major seaports or in cities on important rivers that could be easily supplied by water (Vienna, Paris, Prague).

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by watwut on Friday December 04, 2020 @03:20AM (#25300213)
You ... did not read the article, did you?

Cause the thesis is exactly the opposite. The limited space just reinforces the need for single clothing to be good against both cold and warm weather. It does not remove the political need to flaunt wealth by elite either.

Edit: thesis is supported by photos and descriptions of real world stepped people.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by nemo44x on Friday December 04, 2020 @06:58AM (#25301361)
We don’t know much about the climate Dothraki lived in, much less the weather patterns they had to endure. I assume the Dothraki did though and they choose appropriate garb.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by watwut on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:20AM (#25301480)
The article goes into some detail here, it is worth reading.

> plains and steppes – that is large expanses of semi-arid grasslands. The very nature of that terrain configuration produces fairly extreme seasonal temperature variations (that is, very hot summers and very cold winters) as well as extreme daily temperature variations (that is, hot days and cold nights) because such places are far from the large bodies of water and also don’t have tree-cover, both of which serve to moderate rapid temperature changes. [...] There’s no reason to suppose the Dothraki Sea would be any different: it sits at about the same latitude as King’s Landing so there is little reason to assume it would be warm all-year-round.

There are more reasons then just weather patterns estimated based on location and terrain for cloth to be less practical tho.

The same blog applies the same pedantry to clothing of other groups and to military aspects of different groups too. It is not like Dothraki were singled out in a blog that otherwise ignores clothing and practicality.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by nemo44x on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:44AM (#25301633)
I read it. My point stands - assuming the land the Dothraki roamed is anything like somewhere on Earth is a leap. To suggest there are latitudes or that they are even on a spherical planet is a leap. They have what appears to be great seafaring cultures yet they always have to take what would appear to be the long way if they were in a spherical planet. Would their dragons fly in our physics? They cast steel in fires that couldn’t possibly be hot enough in our physics. There are innumerable examples to suggest their realm is quite unlike ours.

There’s simply no reason to assume Dothraki climate resembles ours.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by watwut on Friday December 04, 2020 @07:54AM (#25301710)
Have you read the book or seen the show? GoT is not crazy anything goes fantasy. Weather in GoT follows clear patterns that also happen to be super important for plot.

It is also big on maps and accurate timing of how long it takes to get from place to place. There was even massive complaining when last seasons written by different people failed in that aspect.

There are inaccurate things beyond Dothraki, as described on both this blog and half the internet. But arguing about GoT as if it was Alice in Wonderland crazy fantasy is absurd.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by nemo44x on Friday December 04, 2020 @08:07AM (#25301822)
Have read all the books to date and seen the show. There are dragons in it. There is magic in it. There are mystical people and what appears to be spirits and ghosts and witches.

People get badly wounded and yet no one dies of a bacterial infection. There are buildings constructed in ways that our physics wouldn’t support with the assumed materials and tolerances of the assumed period.

There are undead - in fact they are introduced in the prologue of the first book. There is a massive ice wall made by humans in an area that is, as described in the books in permanent winter but yet inhabited by people. And giants. And a few days ride to places that have warm summers. And oh yeah, the seasons last years instead of months and are irregular and unpredictable in length.

But yes, the lands the fictional Dothraki people roamed in should be similar to our grasslands in terms of climate and appropriate garb.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by kybernetikos on Saturday December 05, 2020 @05:24PM (#25318999)
> yet no one dies of a bacterial infection

I have read most of the books (a long time ago now) and I believe this happens at least twice. As well as that, there's a lot of talk about cleaning wounds too, even in field situations (typically with boiled wine - apparently similar to Hippocrates).

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by boudewijnrempt on Friday December 04, 2020 @09:47AM (#25302755)
"They cast steel in fires that couldn’t possibly be hot enough in our physics."

That's not because of fantasy elements; it's because the author didn't do his research, and instead just went with what he'd seen in countless movies.

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by gelert on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:23PM (#25305059)
The reason to assume that Dothraki climate resembles that of Earth steppe peoples is, as quoted in the essay, because Martin claimed to have based the Dothraki on them. Those Steppe peoples have adapted their clothing and cultures to the climate they live within. If the Dothraki are supposed to resemble these people culturally then their clothing should reflect the climate of Earth's steppe peoples.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by orthoxerox on Friday December 04, 2020 @01:35PM (#25305955)
We know it very well: steppes [0] require specific climate conditions to form.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Temperate_grasslands,_savannas...

Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by nemo44x on Friday December 04, 2020 @05:02PM (#25308769)
On earth of course. But in the fantasy world of GoT, how can we know? The books describe many natural things that are different. For instance, seasons last years instead of months.
Re:That Dothraki Horde, Part I: Barbarian Couture by doikor on Friday December 04, 2020 @12:33PM (#25305209)
> the very fact that they tend to move around limits how much they can own and carry with them

This is why they used horses/animals to carry their stuff (at least on the Eurasian steppe). If you can carry huge tents with floors risen from the ground etc you can carry some clothes if you want. Just check some pictures of the various tents and how they are constructed. Yes they are portable but by no means small or lightweight.

And as pointed out in the article they wanted really nice clothing as you have to layer and add/remove the layers during the seasons (and even night vs day)

> living far inland, it is harder to reach them using ships

And yet the precursor to the Silk Road (Steppe route) went straight through the Eurasian steppe. Around 10000km of it. That most likely gave them a better access to trade than the average European inland city had.

And even once the Silk Road replaced the Steppe route for the most part the actual horses used to transport stuff on the Silk Road came from the Eurasian Steppe. And the horse nomads on the steppe had horses to trade and the traders on the Silk Road had stuff they wanted in exchange.

Also the steppe nomads did not go around conquering huge amounts of area (see the Mongols and Huns for examples) just because they liked to kill and murder. They did it for mainly the same reason most other large empires did. They wanted the nice stuff (good food, nice clothing, gold/silver, art, etc)