The net result is probably safer software for all.
Did the .gov pwn TPB and put their exploit up there?
I don't think that follows. Clearly there are folks in some governments who would fund finding zero day exploits so that they can use them to conduct cyber-warfare operations. Stuxnet comes to mind and the HBGary emails were telling in this regard. It seems there is a market for 0 day attacks that are not known to the manufacturer. So while Google would clearly give them $13,373 for the bug report but that is no doubt mouse nuts compared to what the someone would pay them while it's not in the 'known' state.
So I find Vupen's business model not unlike the business of creating munitions. No doubt profitable but not something I'd personally want to participate in.
Safer software for all, because it's a better thing that VUPEN discover the bug than if it's discovered by some criminals who keep it secret and scam/hack
I suppose it depends on the point of view, but having it exclusively in the hands of governments can easily mean it's limited to criminals who keep it secret and hack.
Why would a entity as big as "the government" would invest in breaking one browser used by a minority (~10%) of users in the web? Wouldn't it be much easier to just compromise their Internet connections?
Hell, they don't even provide prices on their website, you can request quotes.
According to Wikipedia it is technically not extortion because the obtained information that is of value to google is not obtained "unlawfully" and doesn't seem to fall under the category "money, property or services". There seem to be some similarities though.
Erm... it's a traditional business model of security firms on the internets...
> If a security firm can "extort" google, what stops a lone hacker to put up a video of a chrome exploit on youtube and demand some arbitrary amount of money as compensation?
They're not extorting anything. They're not menacing google or anything like that, they have not obtained this information illegally, they've done security research and are releasing their findings to their clients because that's how they make their money. That's it.
http://www.vupen.com/english/services/
"offensive security", yep. The guys are dirty like the Gary. Why a racket and government always means a happy marriage?
To profit? I believe most people would get into bed with the government if offered the correct incentives. I probably would, too. It's unfortunate, but that's how things work. Is it immoral not to relax your morals to, e.g., secure a better life for yourself and your family?
(Apologies for being meta, but I've recently begun studying morality/ethics so I'm exploring ideas for which I currently do not have answers. Suggestions/directions are appreciated.)
http://www.amazon.com/Lifes-Philosophy-Reason-Feeling-Deeper... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arne_N%C3%A6ss
relaxing more standards on par to being incompetent. only a little more damaging.
!)(@#*$!# cellphone keyboard.
They're an actual security company.
It's pretty easy to argue that police only protect those who pay them.
If the police fail to respond to calls in the ghetto then the crime in the ghetto increases, for instance.
A big part of it was how the LAPD would only enforce laws in certain neighborhoods. The gangs were literally trained by the police that if they commit crimes on one side of a particular street, the laws will be enforced, but if they commit crimes on the ghetto side of the street, they will not be.
Sure they do, they discourage crime by finding and jailing criminals. Prevention is protection.
These things should not in my opinion be disclosed to (the idiot skript kiddie segment of) the public before the vendors have been given a good long window to fix them.
I prefer what VUPEN does when compared to irresponsible discoveries by black hats who do not give a shit about the integrity of the installed product and privacy / safety / security of how many millions of users, who can then be screwed over by every skript kiddie and his dog because they released the info straight to the public.
Sure, if the vendor has absolutely ignored you and your loud demos of the bug, and won't respond to threats to release, you might release the exploit to a small segment of the IRREPROACHABLE VANILLA WHITE HAT security community with the intention that they might help persuade the vendor to take it seriously. That's about as far as I'd want go with releasing serious exploits. Although of course grey/black hat stuff is fun - look, mum, I have a cool exploit!
If VUPEN are sworn to secrecy by their Government customer, and cannot tell the vendor or help them fix the bug, maybe it's time to get a new Government and public service. Your Government (US arrogances with a captial G) is trying to pwn you and spy on you. Fuck that, the government should answer to the will of the people (and don't talk to me about the farce we call democratic election. Democracy is where (almost) all the people are deeply involved in determining policy, it's more like the ideal soviet system, really, which was not realized AFAIK.)
Anyway, isn't that why you're carting guns around all these years, in case your (US) Government turns nasty and starts pwning your ass up down right and left with a canoe? (Not that it wasn't already.) Yes indeed, guns!! However let it not be said that I am inciting violent revolution with this sarcastic post, as I don't believe in or wish to promote that or any violent act.
Poor Google, not enough money. LOL!
I both love and hate them. They are extremely talented and find absolutely awesome bugs that are hard to discover without a lot of work, and I hate them because they don't disclose their work unless it is for money. While I can understand that they have to make a living too, it just feels wrong to not protect everyone in the world when possible.