News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by fastest963 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:12AM (#25289547)
Unfortunately, even if there was, they wouldn't have Thunderbolt so it would limit the external display options. Hopefully when USB4 starts rolling out it'll be a different story.
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by Matt3o12_ on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:38AM (#25289854)
This is not necessarily true. Apple sells their non Intel macs with Thunderbolt and there are some ryzen motherboards with thunderbolt support [1]. That being said, Thunderbolt is a lot less common on AMD boards probably because it is a lot more expensive then it would be on an Intel board. And Laptops so far have always received the budget treatment for ryzen chips (want a better screen? intel only, etc).

So I think lack of thunderbolt comes down to manufacturers not wanting to pay as much for their AMD R&D and keep costs down with simple, budget motherboards.

Or, if you needed Thunderbolt 3, you could just wait until USB 4 is commonplace, which is basically Thunderbolt 3 + some more.

[1]: https://www.asrock.com/mb/AMD/X570%20Phantom%20Gaming-ITXTB3... (there are more, and even ATX boards, first one I could find).

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by wlesieutre on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:37AM (#25289840)
What's the benefit of Thunderbolt displays? I think it's far more common to just do DisplayPort on USB-C alternate mode, or for slightly more specialized screens, the USB-C ones with power delivery. Thunderbolt screens are really unusual in my experience.

It's an understandable restriction if you already bought a Thunderbolt screen and need a new computer that's compatible with it, but requiring Thunderbolt case I might get a screen that needs it later is very far down my priority list of computer features.

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by fastest963 on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#25289967)
I have a dock with two 4k 60hz DisplayPort monitors that runs off TB3. Afaik that's not possible over USB.
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by wlesieutre on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:54AM (#25291011)
If you just want the displays, you can get that over vanilla USB-C:

https://www.cablematters.com/pc-1220-126-usb-c-triple-4k-dis...

If you want displays and all your other dock stuff combined under a single cable, that's where you're better off with Thunderbolt, yes. The USB-C docks can do some of this (I think with DisplayLink) but not quite as well.

A Thunderbolt dock doesn't limit your display choices like the comment I replied to was talking about though, you'd just use any normal DisplayPort screen. Worst case without it you're plugging in separate display cables in addition to a non-video USB hub.

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by kllrnohj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @11:39AM (#25290748)
TB3's display output is just displayport. Identical to displayport over USB-C.

You're only giving up the data part of TB3.

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by distances on Thursday December 03, 2020 @03:57PM (#25294796)
TB3 is 40Gbps, USB-C 3.2 10Gbps. 4K@60Hz is possible over USB-C but 4K@120+Hz only with TB3 AFAIK (or dedicated DP cable of course).
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by kllrnohj on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:15PM (#25295075)
The 40Gbps is for the data connection of TB3. The display part of TB3 is independent and is just DisplayPort. Both TB3 and USB-C alt-mode can do DisplayPort 1.4, assuming both sides support it of course. TB3 only actually requires DisplayPort 1.2.

There's actually no difference here whatsoever on the display-only side of things.

(side note, USB 3.2 achieves up to 20Gb/s, not 10Gb/s, and TB3 is also realistically only 20Gb/s as well unless you're sticking to the super short 0.5m cables)

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by distances on Thursday December 03, 2020 @04:34PM (#25295399)
Right, I was thinking of USB 3.1 Gen 2 which is 10Gpbs. Hooray for these naming schemes.

But good to know about the display connection being the same. I was under the assumption that the increased data rate of TB3 could be used for DisplayPort connection too.

Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by hackerfromthefu on Friday December 04, 2020 @10:41AM (#25303488)
USB-C 3.2 comes in 5Gbps, 10Gbs and 20Gbs variants, called Gen 1, Gen 2, and Gen 2x2 respectively
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by Grazester on Thursday December 03, 2020 @10:46AM (#25289953)
There is nothing stopping manufactures from including Thunderbolt.
Re:AMD CPU sales skyrocket with Ryzen 5000 launch, leaving I... by wmf on Thursday December 03, 2020 @12:38PM (#25291746)
Well, nothing besides a bunch of R&D since AMD doesn't provide any reference design with Thunderbolt.