News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by tropdrop on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:19PM (#25242436)
The more productive conversation isn't around the tone of this particular "outrage piece," but the bombshell it references: The New York Times article about McKinsey's proposal of paying pharmacy companies rebates for OxyContin Overdoses [1]

1 - https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/27/business/mckinsey-purdue-...

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by remarkEon on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:33PM (#25242498)
I think the even more productive conversation is centered around how these consulting firms (Deloitte, BCG, Bain, etc etc) have become giant black holes, sucking in massive amounts of hyper talented and competent people.

And then they have them building spreadsheets about how to more “economically” provide a product that was/is literally killing Americans at scale.

It’s part of a larger conversation that’s difficult to have, but I think is largely true: managerial and financial capitalism has been a complete disaster.

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by whimsicalism on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:44PM (#25242555)
> hyper talented and competent people

Talented, but not hyper talented. At my school, consulting was sorta the career you did if you couldn't get a job doing something else (like tech or finance).

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by remarkEon on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:49PM (#25242568)
Probably highly dependent on which program you attend (assuming you’re talking about MBA programs). For some banking is the “high status” profession, for others it’s consulting, for still others it’s tech.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by whimsicalism on Saturday November 28, 2020 @10:17PM (#25242675)
No, just my Harvard undergrad experience
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by paulyy_y on Saturday November 28, 2020 @11:44PM (#25242965)
I went to state school and do consulting at a B4 - you're right on the money, consulting (especially at Big 4 level) isn't sexy. MBB is a league sexier though, but gets beat out by PE and some good spots at the FAANGs
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by creato on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:24PM (#25242455)
I don't doubt the proposal existed... But can someone explain why this is a good idea even assuming a lack of ethics? Would this really have changed the behavior of pharmacies somehow? Pharmacies don't have any influence over prescriptions, do they?
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by HillRat on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:36PM (#25242520)
It’s likely related to McKinsey’s recommendations to Purdue that they attempt to get major pharmacies to “loosen up” on efforts to stop illegal opioid scripts (which had resulted in an 18% reduction in OxyContin units sold by one major chain in particular). Paying kickbacks based on ODs would be a pretty blunt instrument that, I think, would have triggered alarm bells at those pharmacies’ leadership.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by cguess on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:31PM (#25242483)
Even considering such an idea is enough for it to get in writing or presented is such an egregious lapse of ethics that whomever does it should be fired immediately.

"Sorry we know you're going to lose customers if they die, what if we make up the difference for you so you keep selling our product?"

[dead]
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ahelwer on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:33PM (#25242495)
Individuals cannot "do something about" issues like this. Even a lone wolf gun attack against a corporate boardroom would see the victims swiftly replaced by ideological clones. Collective action is the only possible route to remedy, and that requires building a common understanding of what the problems are and what should be done about them. Hence the beating of the drum. Having two minutes of hate isn't the goal.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by troughway on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:38PM (#25242526)
>Collective action

Pray tell, what collective action? Are you going to boycott McKinsey? Write to the same congress representatives that companies like McKinsey personally finance and wine and dine and call in for favors?

Do share, we are all curious what is this collective action that will somehow lead to enlightenment of "building a common understanding of what the problems are and what should be done about them."

Billionaires are the untouchable class of people. They don't answer to anyone. They quite literally own and run the country. I don't know why it's difficult for the rational person to get this through their heads. The last thing you will see is them being in any kind of trouble about it. We can discuss the failing of a company like Enron another time. They really fucked the dog and in much the same way as Jeffrey Epstein hanging himself in a high security prison, pissed off other billionaires who are the only people who can get some sense of action out of the legal system on each other.

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by Shacklet0n on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:55PM (#25242587)
Pray tell, have you ever heard of the French Revolution?
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ahelwer on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:45PM (#25242560)
No, writing to congresspeople is useless. There are a few possibly viable strategies: one, fill as many elected positions as possible with leftist candidates. Two, build power of labor unions to achieve democratic control over the sources of profit. Three, well... revolution, if the above two fail. The ultimate backstop. Would be happy to hear any other suggestions.
[dead]
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ahelwer on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:59PM (#25242607)
Your solution seems to be somewhere between "lie down and rot" or "just let it happen", so not sure you have standing to criticize.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ardy42 on Saturday November 28, 2020 @10:22PM (#25242692)
> This is the pharma industry. It's been this way for decades. Don't pretend like you're woke and moralistic in light of this "bombshell" now please, it comes across as trite.

So, you're saying it's OK, then? Otherwise, you just seem unreasonably mad at people who don't dutifully accept the status quo without comment.

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by 93po on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:53PM (#25242580)
There are endless examples of bad press forcing change in laws and companies. This article is making something much more publicly visible. Spreading it is better than nothing, and again there's plenty of times when the populace becoming outraged results in change
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by troughway on Saturday November 28, 2020 @09:56PM (#25242591)
>bad press forcing change in laws and companies.

Big oil has entered the chat.

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ardy42 on Saturday November 28, 2020 @10:29PM (#25242722)
https://ohiohistorycentral.org/w/Cuyahoga_River_Fire

tl;dr: The Cuyahoga river caught on fire many, many times over the years. However, a fire in June 1969 spurred legislative action that finally solved the problem, even though that fire was not the most destructive nor the most deadly. The difference was society had changed, and that fire struck a nerve when the previous ones hadn't.

The moral of the story is: past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by throwanem on Sunday November 29, 2020 @01:57AM (#25243444)
True. Totally unrelated, the example you cite is now fifty years in the past, and occurred in a time when local news still existed.
Re:McKinsey: Friendly Neighborhood Spreadsheet Sociopaths Ar... by ardy42 on Sunday November 29, 2020 @05:56PM (#25248862)
> True. Totally unrelated, the example you cite is now fifty years in the past, and occurred in a time when local news still existed.

It's related because it's a nice clear example of "bad press [eventually] forcing change in laws and companies," on an issue that's settled enough that one would be hard-pressed to argue the end result was wrong. The swipe at local news isn't exactly relevant, given this recent is a national one that did get coverage and the river fire spurred a federal, not local, legislative solution.