News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by pricechild on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:24AM (#25187656)
Probably best you don't look into the security of other manufacturer's keyless entry systems...

Many people refer to it as "relay theft" since historically it's often just a matter of relaying/repeating a signal - there may be no real authentication involved.

Around physical security, I'm often reminded that "locks are for honest thieves".

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by piyh on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:07AM (#25188195)
My car unlocks keyless, but needs a key and immobilizer chip to be present to drive.

Anyone can break a window to steal your stuff, getting a duplicate immobilizer chip is hard and usually requires an inside man in a dealer network.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by Nextgrid on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:58AM (#25188795)
> getting a duplicate immobilizer chip is hard and usually requires an inside man in a dealer network

Unless you talk to the car's ECUs over the diagnostic port and read out the secret values for creating a duplicate or outright patch out the immobilizer check in the firmware. There's usually no auth on this and it's just obscurity, which I expect to already be broken and exploited by tools available on the black market.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by gamblor956 on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:52PM (#25190174)
If you have access to the car's diagnostic port you already have the physical access required to steal the car...
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by Kirby64 on Monday November 23, 2020 @02:05PM (#25190362)
Which is the point. Getting inside the car does not require the immobilizer chip, so being able to get inside is really all that's required... assuming you can use the diag port to bypass the immobilizer. The immobilizer doesn't actually do much to a savvy criminal.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by cesis on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:00PM (#25188822)
Immobilizer chip is probably only required to start driving.

I can't imagine any car would stop if it lost signal with immobilizer chip- that would be a safety problem. That is how relay attacks work- signal is required only for a brief period.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by gray_-_wolf on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:34PM (#25189252)
Luckily my Toyota has an option to disable this remote proximity bullshit all together. I need to press button on the keys to unlock the car, and I need to put the keys on the start button to get it to start the engine.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by londons_explore on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:55PM (#25189493)
> the keys on the start button to get it to start the engine

So it's wireless... So someone can still use a relay attack to send the signal from the start button to the keys hanging up by your front door...

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by gray_-_wolf on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:03PM (#25189615)
It works only short-while after pressing the button. If I take too much time setting my stuff in the car I need to press the unlock button again to "wake up" the keys in order for it to work. So I believe it should be good enough against relay attack.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by iso1631 on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:10PM (#25189674)
Anyone remember the days when you used to put the key in the ignition?
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by yellowapple on Monday November 23, 2020 @04:42PM (#25192276)
Yeah, this is exactly why I'll be buying used pretty much forever. Don't trust self-driving anything, don't trust wireless/remote start, don't trust half-baked services like OnStar... if it gets to the point where ICEs are outright illegal, then I'd sooner convert an old beat-up Tacoma or 4Runner to an electric drivetrain than buy new.

The only exception is if I have full control over it, including the ability to lock it down. No OTA updates; if I want to install security patches, it'll be through Ethernet or USB or some other wired connection. But preferably, there wouldn't be a whole lot of software to update in the first place.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by z6 on Monday November 23, 2020 @10:25PM (#25194956)
Yep, and I also remember someone still managed to steal our car. Different times, different methods.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by iso1631 on Thursday November 26, 2020 @05:50AM (#25218776)
I had a 1997 Micra about a decade ago, lost the key. Had someone come out, they could get in easily enough, but couldn't get it started without the original key. Had to go to dealer to get one programmed.

That seems to me to be far more secure than a modern tesla.

There's far less chance of leaving your key in the car if you have to press the lock button on the fob after you get out -- done that on hire cars before. The key is always in the same place.

Conversely you can leave the key in the ignition if you're popping into the store to pay for the gas and leaving your passengers in the car. I had a keyless fob on another hire car in my pocket, alarm went off when I went into the store.

I don't get the appeal of keyless.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by brianwawok on Monday November 23, 2020 @06:39PM (#25193290)
Sounds like a lot of work
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by gray_-_wolf on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:24PM (#25189834)
I remember my father having a car like that :D
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by 8ytecoder on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:41AM (#25188583)
My car allows remote lock but has no feature to unlock via the app at all. And in addition the key has to be present inside the car to drive.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by egwor on Monday November 23, 2020 @12:47PM (#25189410)
If they can boost the signal of the key, then it would appear that the key is in the car. The car is unlikely to stop if the key signal is lost due to safety concerns.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by yellowapple on Monday November 23, 2020 @04:44PM (#25192303)
Would triangulation solve at least the signal boost part of the equation? A car thief would have a heck of a time trying to violate the laws of physics to trick that, no?
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by yencabulator on Wednesday November 25, 2020 @10:22AM (#25210120)
No need to triangulate, just measure round-trip time.
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by egwor on Friday November 27, 2020 @05:25AM (#25227332)
Ooh, interesting. Wouldn't that be an extremely short time to measure? It would need to compare <1m response time vs <10m? I would imagine that having an accurate time chip for that short duration would be quite expensive? I have no idea though. I'd be interested to know more
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by yencabulator on Saturday November 28, 2020 @10:38PM (#25242754)
You won't be driving a stolen car very far if you have to stay within 10 meters of the owner & their keyfob/phone. Accuracy of <200 meters would already eliminate the idea of being able to drive away with a stolen car by just boosting the keyfob signal.

And modern cars absolutely know how to switch safely to a "limp mode" that lets you pull over safely.

Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by egwor on Friday November 27, 2020 @12:03PM (#25230378)
(as in 1meter rather than 1min!)
Re:Bluetooth Attack Can Steal a Tesla Model X in Minutes by pwagland on Monday November 23, 2020 @11:41AM (#25188586)
Note that this is _not_ a relay attack. This actually updates the firmware on the Key Fob, which allows you to bypass (for example) the old workaround of disabling the "walk up unlocking" to defeat relay attacks.

Many manufacturers have actually worked to improve wireless key security. Including Tesla. But this is a new class of attack on the key fob.