News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by akavlie on Thursday May 05, 2011 @01:50PM (#2518256)
TL;DR -- Mafiaafire redirects you to an alternative domain when the primary domain is moved or seized. So basically the DHS is trying to suppress a workaround to their domain seizures.

I'm not sure they have much of a legal argument here though, nor do they have a due process workaround... well, unless they seize mozilla.org.

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by ataggart on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:10PM (#2518331)
The validity of the "legal argument" is whatever a fellow government employee says it is. Some septuagenarian with an arts degree isn't likely to see this "computer stuff" as anything but a means to circumvent the law.

http://faculty.msb.edu/hasnasj/GTWebSite/MythWeb.htm

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by reedlaw on Thursday May 05, 2011 @05:23PM (#2518966)
The linked article is excellent. If it's not been submitted to HN before, I suggest the parent do so.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by ataggart on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:26PM (#2519150)
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by Natsu on Thursday May 05, 2011 @04:09PM (#2518740)
They might use MGM v. Grokster to make some kind of inducement claim, but one might think that this would be the sort of thing copyright holders would do, rather than the DHS. I don't know that they have in mind, but it's probably one of the few straws they could grasp at.

And there's that other test case Grellas posted the other day, suing C|Net for distributing Limewire. It obviously hasn't been decided yet, but it could create a dangerous precedent in the future. I strongly suspect they expected everyone to just cave. As things stand, I expect that copies of the extension will get hosted outside the USA, making any further action meaningless.

Even had they quietly allowed it to get taken down, someone almost certainly would have hosted a copy or created a new extension outside the US.

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:28PM (#2518401)
If the DHS had a legal leg to stand on they would have delivered their request via official channels.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by pavel_lishin on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:30PM (#2518410)
They didn't actually mention what channels they went through. What would an "official channel" look like, in this case?

Also, perhaps they didn't want to spend the $5k on a lawyer to draw up an official document, hoping that a simple request would suffice. Understandable, and laudable - as is Mozilla's refusal to comply with what is nothing more than a request.

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @03:25PM (#2518613)
What would an "official channel" look like, in this case?

Though nobody concerned is revealing the actual delivery method, it would look something like a process server and it wouldn't be called "asking."

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by gscott on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:21PM (#2519501)
They don't need official channels... they can just take the domain name for providing a plug-in that links to pirated content. The Mozilla domain might pull up a DHS graphic any day now! (it would be interesting if the DHS would go so far as to take down a site used by millions... but you never know as it appears DHS is above the law)
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by asadotzler on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:07PM (#2519732)
a site used by hundreds of millions, actually :-) and a site that helps ensure the security of every Firefox user across the globe.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by VladRussian on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:46PM (#2518475)
> Also, perhaps they didn't want to spend the $5k on a lawyer

a government bureaucrat letting pass a chance to send more work to his lawyer friend? Nope. They just do not risk yet to attack Mozilla on such a shaky ground as declaring such an add-on as a paraphernalia of copyright infringement. Yet, it is just a matter of time. They will start with somebody less popular than Mozilla.

Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by jarin on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:41PM (#2518460)
I would imagine DHS has their own lawyers on staff?
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by cellis on Thursday May 05, 2011 @03:15PM (#2518572)
Wouldn't that fall to the Department of Justice?
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by redthrowaway on Thursday May 05, 2011 @04:26PM (#2518784)
No, all government agencies have a legal staff. The DoJ's mandate doesn't include screening all government actions for legality.
Re:DHS asks Mozilla to take down MafiaaFire add-on by VladRussian on Thursday May 05, 2011 @02:35PM (#2518436)
>If the DHS had a legal leg to stand on

they would have raided the mozilla's offices and as GP mentioned seized the domain. When they can - they do.