News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by jdhn on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:38PM (#25171686)
I don't understand the opposition to this. These vehicles continue to use roads but don't pay any taxes that would help maintain roads if they were gas or diesel cars. How is that fair?
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by josephcsible on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:07PM (#25172398)
My opinion: The transition from ICE vehicles to EVs is a very large net benefit to society, so during this period when new ICE vehicles are still legal, we should be giving EVs special ("unfair") benefits to encourage people to switch. If this new tax results in people choosing to buy an ICE vehicle who would have bought an EV without it, that's a very bad outcome.

As for the loss of revenue from the gas tax, I think a two-phase solution would be best to solve that. In the first phase (now), make up the revenue by raising the gas tax. In the second phase (once ICE vehicles are almost gone), ban new ICE vehicles and then implement this tax. This way, the tax would never result in someone buying an ICE vehicle instead of an EV.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by octodog on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:36PM (#25173558)
Implementing the tax now makes sense because it brings ICE and EV into alignment now, while usage is relatively low, rather than suddenly introducing a tax down the proverbial road.

To incentive switching the government has other policy tools at their disposal, such as a one-off subsidy at purchase time.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by the8472 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:56PM (#25174240)
> Implementing the tax now makes sense because it brings ICE and EV into alignment now

It doesn't. ICE vehicles are effectively subsidized by not pricing in externalties. The playing field was never level, suddenly insisting that it ought to be is a selective demand for rigor.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by josephcsible on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:14PM (#25173729)
> it brings ICE and EV into alignment now

I know it does. My point is that bringing them into alignment now isn't a good thing.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by refurb on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:35PM (#25174745)
"we should be giving EVs special ("unfair") benefits to encourage people to switch"

Sure, but at least in the US, electric vehicles already get numerous other benefits include tax rebates, lower registration fees, HOV lane access, etc.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by josephcsible on Sunday November 22, 2020 @01:58AM (#25175556)
> tax rebates

Not Tesla or GM.

> lower registration fees, HOV lane access

Not in most states.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:08PM (#25171930)
Gas and diesel cars don't pay for the damage they cause to the climate, or for the local air pollution. How is that fair?
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by ajmurmann on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:15PM (#25171972)
That is the real problem. We need to properly price in the negative externality. However, that would mean that driving (and even more so flying) becomes almost prohibitively expensive for many. We already saw with the yellow jackets in France that this would lead to unrest.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:16PM (#25171989)
You know what else will lead to unrest? Unmitigated climate change. We need to drastically reduce driving. Making it more expensive is just one of the measures to take here. We also need to alternatives easier to use. Better city planning and better infrastructure need to go hand in hand with price signals.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Sabinus on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:02PM (#25173947)
>You know what else will lead to unrest? Unmitigated climate change.

Yeah in 10-50 years. Not now. People that aren't part of the intelligentsia don't see it a threat yet.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by tshaddox on Sunday November 22, 2020 @02:48AM (#25175776)
This piece of pie every day won’t cause obesity now. Maybe in a few months.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by bigbubba on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:16PM (#25172456)
> That is the real problem

A real problem. Both are real problems. The importance of road maintenance isn't diminished by the importance of environmental considerations. Roads are vital to the economy. Governments need to multitask; they need to handle many important matters at once , not focus on one issue at a time while letting others fall to the wayside.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:14PM (#25171971)
What's the cost of mining lithium for starters.. before talking about fair.

edit: down voted for stating facts.. I've noticed this place is becoming very ideological.. or maybe I'm getting old.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by matthewmacleod on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:25PM (#25173508)
You didn't state any facts though.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:17PM (#25171999)
What's the cost of oil spills? It's not like gas and diesel magically flow out of the pump either.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:24PM (#25172065)
I never said anything that implied gas wasn't an issue .. simply stating a truth bomb about EV's environmental and human costs; lithium mining being the biggest one.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by zemvpferreira on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:16PM (#25172449)
I didn't downvote you and I think you bring a useful point to the discussion, but I also think you'd be better-received if you completed your argument.

Please tell us, what is a good estimate for the impact of producing and EV on the planet? And how does it compare to a gas vehicle? If that's too much work I'd be glad to learn more about battery production, since that's the point of difference.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by ohmaigad on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:50PM (#25174215)
Polestar published their transparency report which states that their fully electric Polestar 2 compared to a Volvo XC40 will break even in CO2 emissions after 112k km (Global energy mix), 78k km (European energy mix) and 50k km (wind energy).

https://www.polestar.com/nl/electric-sustainability/transpar...

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:22PM (#25172505)
Not an argument, just a point of view for which I'm open to any and all.

edit: but the cost of rare earth mining is huge and if you don't want to do your own research... that's your call.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Johnythree on Sunday November 22, 2020 @04:07AM (#25176070)
Never mind that Lithium is not a rare earth element, nor are cobalt, manganese, or any of the other key components of a lithium-ion battery.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by jdhn on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:39PM (#25172202)
That's a completely separate issue from what I brought up. The fact is that EV owners don't pay maintenance taxes that are captured through gas taxes, and are complaining when they have to pay additional fees at other times such as registration.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Dumblydorr on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:55PM (#25174235)
It's fair to incentivize EVs because they are far less damaging to the planet and local communities than gasoline vehicles. Gasoline vehicles get to pollute for free, why don't non-polluters get to use the road for free?

Either you're trying to minimize climate damage and disproportionate harms to vulnerable communities, or you're business as usual.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Zigurd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:56PM (#25171833)
While maintaining pavement is not all of road maintenance, it is the central aspect. Trucks wear out roads orders of magnitude more than cars. In the US trucks pay much less than cars, in total, for road maintenance. It is likely the same in Australia. Simply rebalancing the taxation to the amount of road wear would eliminate the need to tax EV road use without it being a significant subsidy of EVs.

Diesel trucks are also the dirtiest vehicles on the road. It makes absolutely no sense to subsidize trucking.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by AdrianB1 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:07PM (#25171918)
Actually Diesel engines are the most efficient ICE in mass production, modern engines respecting the latest emission standards (ex: EURO 6) are some of the least dirty vehicles on the road. If you compare fuel efficiency per ton per kilometer and what is the pollution caused, they become quite clean. Yes, older Diesel trucks are dirty and also the ones with improper maintenance, but hitting at all trucks because of some is not fair.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Zigurd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:17PM (#25171994)
In the real world, diesels should be taken off the road as quickly as possible due to the impracticality of controlling particulate emissions and the damage to human health caused by those emissions.

Also, euro 6 emission standards are for diesel passenger cars. Diesel cars, even with strict emission controls, still emit too much dangerous particulates.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by fogihujy on Sunday November 22, 2020 @12:14AM (#25175114)
It'll take generations to get rid of all current diesel engines. We need stuff like e-diesel as a stop-gap solution, because things like farming machinery are rarely replaced.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by brogrammer2018 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:15PM (#25174647)
I live in South Australia. Taxes here are already high for everything road related; we already pay taxes for roads as part of Vehicle Registration (excluding compulsory 3rd party insurance); pay council rates (goes to roads), income tax (goes to roads), capital gains tax, and have a 10% GST (which may be 15% soon) which all feeds into the roads. Other parts of the world are providing incentives to EVs; but not here.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Lammy on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:18PM (#25172004)
Probably a lot of Tesla owners on here upset at the thought of losing any of the privilege it brings.

Full EVs do more damage to the road than ICE vehicles since they’re a lot heavier. I’m totally pro-EV, but we should definitely pay some part of the tax necessary to maintain the roads we drive on.

Some quick searches show:

Mazda MX-5 Miata MY2020 base curb weight: 2403lbs

Toyota Prius MY2020 base curb weight: 3010lbs

Tesla model 3 base curb weight: 4072lbs

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by dmurray on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:28PM (#25172126)
That's an incredibly disingenuous comparison. The Miata is a two-passenger roadster, and one of the lightest cars on the road. The Model 3 is a 4-door sedan.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Lammy on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:35PM (#25172176)
I tried to think of a fun car that goes fast and a thicc hatchback that can carry stuff, because the Tesla is kinda both :D
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by oh_sigh on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:47PM (#25172260)
A 4 door luxury sedan would be a better comparison. For example, an Audi A4 has a 3700 lbs curb weight.

Also, since road damage scales at something like axle weight ^ 4th, balance issues could completely override the 300 lbs difference in mass.

For example, if the Tesla 3 can have 2 axles each with 2036 lbs/axle (because there is no ICE weighing down the front), it could theoretically be less damaging to roads than an ICE that has one heavy axle and one light axle.

22036^4 = (x 3700)^4 + ((1-x) * 3700)^4. Solving for x = 63%, so if more than 63% of an Audi A4s weight is on the front axle, it will be approximately worse than a balanced Tesla 3 for road wear and tear.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by dschuler on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:11PM (#25173445)
ICE vehicles aren’t front-heavy like that, it would be terrible for braking performance.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by oh_sigh on Saturday November 21, 2020 @11:31PM (#25174936)
The Audi A4 from my example is apparently 55/45 front/rear weight, but I wouldn't be surprised if some trucks like a F150 or something was closer to 63/37. Of course, people who drive those things end up having to put artificial loads into the rear to make up for the weight distribution during inclement weather.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by guerby on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:31PM (#25172545)
Model 3 SR+ is 3627 lbs
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by tshaddox on Sunday November 22, 2020 @02:52AM (#25175788)
Why is it incumbent on the EV owners to somehow solve the blatantly and deliberately incorrect means of charging people to use roads?

This is like saying “the movie theater makes money by charging to park a car in the parking lot, but you walked to the theater, so how is it fair that you get to watch the movie for free?” Well, perhaps the movie theater should come up with some slightly less ridiculous way of charging for entrance.

Or if governments had decided to fund road maintenance using a tax on car paint, would it be unfair to buy a car that isn’t painted?

And what about people who use gasoline and diesel for things other than automobiles on public roads? That’s also unfair.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by rconti on Saturday November 21, 2020 @03:55PM (#25172694)
There's a huge gulf between not understanding opposition to a particular scheme, and thinking the existing scheme is unfair.

I didn't see anything in this article about how it's levied, for one. Are they doing vehicle tracking, as was proposed in places in the US? Certainly I can see opposition to that.

Maybe people driving a Renault Twizy don't think it's fair to pay the same tax per mile as an electric Hummer (whenever that comes out).

All kinds of reasons to be opposed to it.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by mtgx on Saturday November 21, 2020 @01:41PM (#25171706)
Trucks do...wait for it...1,400x more damage to roads than standard passenger vehicles do.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by blendo on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:44PM (#25172240)
We could put the tax on each tire. $1 per tire for a Miata, $100 per tire for an 18-wheeler. Just look at the tire load rating.

Also, tax based on tire speed rating, to capture the 0.5 m v^2 energy.

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by waiseristy on Saturday November 21, 2020 @05:47PM (#25173328)
This is the solution I ended up settling on. I can't think of any other use-indexed item for a vehicle that you can tax. It fixes the ridiculous registration pricing for people who rarely use their vehicles. Fixes the odd taxing of high capacity trailers. Fixes the indexing on damage caused to the roads as you mentioned. The only real downside I can see is it puts pressure on drivers to not replace old unsafe tires
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:17PM (#25171991)
Probably because they transport 1,400x more economic goods?
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by Sabinus on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:37PM (#25174140)
Then the cost of those goods should reflect the cost they put on the road transport system. It may make rail more competitive, or increase the incentive for local manufacture.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:20PM (#25172024)
No, because road damage is proportional to axle weight to the fourth power.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:25PM (#25172083)
And axle weight comes from the weight of the cargo be it human or goods...

edit: just looked up what you said, really interesting, but makes me wonder if the transport of goods in smaller lorries for instance would ultimately be beneficial when you factor in cost of fuel, maintenance etc

Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:28PM (#25172116)
Yes, but note the "to the fourth power".
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by 9HZZRfNlpR on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:27PM (#25172110)
But EVs themselves are very heavy compared to similar gas powered cars.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by adrianN on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:28PM (#25172128)
A truck still does orders of magnitude more damage. "To the fourth power" makes a big difference.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car... by xd on Saturday November 21, 2020 @02:34PM (#25172173)
What about EV trucks?