Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car...
by octodog on Saturday November 21, 2020 @06:36PM
(#25173558)
Implementing the tax now makes sense because it brings ICE and EV into alignment now, while usage is relatively low, rather than suddenly introducing a tax down the proverbial road.
To incentive switching the government has other policy tools at their disposal, such as a one-off subsidy at purchase time.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car...
by the8472 on Saturday November 21, 2020 @08:56PM
(#25174240)
> Implementing the tax now makes sense because it brings ICE and EV into alignment now
It doesn't. ICE vehicles are effectively subsidized by not pricing in externalties. The playing field was never level, suddenly insisting that it ought to be is a selective demand for rigor.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car...
by josephcsible on Saturday November 21, 2020 @07:14PM
(#25173729)
> it brings ICE and EV into alignment now
I know it does. My point is that bringing them into alignment now isn't a good thing.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car...
by refurb on Saturday November 21, 2020 @10:35PM
(#25174745)
"we should be giving EVs special ("unfair") benefits to encourage people to switch"
Sure, but at least in the US, electric vehicles already get numerous other benefits include tax rebates, lower registration fees, HOV lane access, etc.
Re:Victoria follows South Australia and imposes electric car...
by josephcsible on Sunday November 22, 2020 @01:58AM
(#25175556)
> tax rebates
Not Tesla or GM.
> lower registration fees, HOV lane access
Not in most states.
As for the loss of revenue from the gas tax, I think a two-phase solution would be best to solve that. In the first phase (now), make up the revenue by raising the gas tax. In the second phase (once ICE vehicles are almost gone), ban new ICE vehicles and then implement this tax. This way, the tax would never result in someone buying an ICE vehicle instead of an EV.