News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by Udik on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @03:00AM (#25134212)
> starting with an NK thermonuclear weapon obliterating a major US city

That doesn't seem smart at all. I think that a nuclear explosion on the ocean, right in front of a major city (NY, LA) but at safe distance, would be a better start. It provides the same amount of threat with no victims and no pressing need for blind retaliation.

Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by jacobush on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @03:28AM (#25134384)
You may also loose your only chance to do damage that way. An incoming ICBM might get a response before it’s exact target is known.
Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by Udik on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @04:07AM (#25134641)
But why would you do damage? Since NK could never possibly win a "damage" war with the US- disabling the US ability to retaliate or defend itself- the purpose of an attack by a country like NK can only be that of preventing further attacks or retaliations. And inflicting serious damage on the first shot is ensuring that such retaliation will happen.

What NK needs is to make clear that the cost of attacking it can be unsustainably high, while provoking the least possible response.

Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by ohazi on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @04:56AM (#25134985)
ITT: everyone rediscovers mutually assured destruction

NK doesn't need to fire anywhere close to the US in order to do this. We're already watching them, and for the most part, they've already made it clear that attacking them might cost us a city or two.

Putting on a nuclear waterworks in front of Los Angeles would be psychotically risky, because the US would need to decide whether or not to return fire before the US target is known. "Vaguely near Los Angeles" might as well be Los Angeles because of measurement uncertainties, late-stage course corrections, and MIRVs.

As usual, the winning move is not to fire anything that might be construed as a nuke towards any of your enemies, unless you are prepared to die.

Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by Steve44 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @07:32AM (#25136048)
It doesn't need to be an ICBM, it could be in a shipping container or a fishing boat. They just sail right into position.
Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by ovi256 on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @10:51AM (#25138157)
Most probably the US riposte will be in the air (and there's not recall capability) before the US can be sure that the target is the sea 10km from the major city and not the major city.
Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by m4rtink on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @12:53PM (#25139920)
Something like this was actually proposed before the bombing of Hiroshima, but not carried out in the end.
Re:US Navy destroyer shoots down an ICBM in milestone test by 4gotunameagain on Wednesday November 18, 2020 @05:15AM (#25135103)
No immediate victims.