Edit: Let me bring an analogy (GDPR applies to physical world too). Most cars have a visible VIN number like a phone has an IMEI (if you replace IDFA with IMEI mentally, which would be much worse if that was exposed to the apps). If you take a photo of the VIN and then track the car using this identifier in some way, you are [potentially] violating GDPR, not the car manufacturer.
A couple of years ago I realized that Spotify's recommendation algorithm provides me with a better selection of music than any other method ever has.
Lately I've found ads targeted using advanced ML implementation have been of great value to me as well.
I don't remember ever purchasing products from direct response marketing before, but this year I've purchased multiple high importance things that I would not otherwise been even aware of.
Personalized recommendations by an app based on your usage of that app are not what people mean by "targeted advertising." The privacy implications are completely different.
I looked it up after writing the last paragraph, and indeed "playlists are [...] based on the country you live in, genres you listen to and your age" (https://www.billboard.com/articles/columns/pop/9456319/spoti...).
Still I'm not sure if this information comes from tracking or my mistake of signing up to Spotify with my Facebook account.
Several years ago I saw a Facebook ad for an online coaching program for aspiring music producers.
It was exactly what I needed at the time, but I had no idea that someone had put something like this together, and I would never have independently thought of googling this. Instead, I relied on music production tutorials on the one hand, and generic productivity advice on the other hand, and assumed that was the best help available out there.
That is just my anecdote, but I'm sure everyone here has their "how could I possibly live without this before" product or service.
Advertising can be useful, and the more targeted, the less obnoxious.
>convincing you that you needed a product that you actually didn't
What if it's convincing him that he needs a product that is actually of benefit to him, that he didn't know existed?
I don't want crap pushed on me without consent. Once you have consent, (which is me doing a pull of what you're offering), then it's okay.
I'm surprised with all the controversy over consent in the last year or so that Tech and Ad companies still don't understand this. Then again, the wisdom of Upton Sinclair applies.
--It is difficult to get someone to understand what their paycheck is dependent on them not understanding
>The user on the other hand gets no benefits, the society gets no benefits, and those who benefit are random people whose motives are unclear.
This is blatantly false. In this thread alone there are multiple people who have stated they find benefit through targeted ads.
Then by all means, in the future, opt-in whenever you need to!
Your only foundation for this reasoning is that you've bought more things. What this definitely says is that the advertising is targeting you successfully, what it does not say is that you benefited from it. You clearly lived before you owned those things, presumably pretty well given your evident spending habits.
In conclusion, when looking at this post we can say just as easily that you were harmed greatly by targeted advertising.
For what it's worth, I have been involved with implementing the GDPR properly in a number of reasonably large companies. Sadly a number of people can say this and a vanishingly small amount of companies actually adhere to it properly, so I'd take it with a grain of salt.
> The consent MUST be received before storing cookies
I don't think we have any disagreement about that. We are discussing who is liable for failing to follow GDPR here.
Some people here seem to think it is available in the browser. Using the word ‘cookie’ furthers that false belief.
I otherwise agree with you.
Apple is severely limiting IDFA in the new iOS and shows a popup asking whether you want to allow apps to track you. So that's become opt-in.
https://mobiledevmemo.com/mobile-advertising-without-the-idf...
"I’d rather be a hypocrite than the same person forever."
The only way to get better is to change the things you did incorrectly in the past.
This doesn't mean it was illegal (or even unethical). Fifteen years ago few people anticipated the privacy implications of smartphones and many people didn't anticipate exactly how much this stuff would be abused. But in order to get better, they need to change their policy.
It's strange too that you go back to 2005, what with the iphone was out only by 2007 and the IDFA launched in 2013. Incidentally, IDFA was create as a way to limit the methods advertisers could use to track users, even as it expanded the pool of users tracked. And in 2013 the idea that digital tracking, as supplied by for example apple, could be bad was certainly not groundbreaking.
I’d argue that a ruling from the EU aids Apple in moving in a direction they already want to go.
What I’m sure Apple is opposed to is the implication that they are somehow violating GDPR themselves.
Prior to IDFA, advertisers used other unique on-device information (I believe they had access to the IMEA which was not changeable). With IDFA, users have the option of opting out or at one point resetting the IDFA on the device.
IDFA was fundamentally put in to give uses more control. It wasn't really enough, but it was an improvement over what was before it. Now Apple is improving it again by making it opt-in instead of opt-out.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/user-privacy-and-data-...
There’s a fair bit of documentation about IDFAs (disclaimer: I have never used them, so my experience is limited). Do a search for “IDFA”.
[NB Mainly because I do a lot browsing from my Apple devices - not because I want to use it!]
Think it through: you read this very article, and many cookies on that page you will have consented to will let many ad-tech companies know that you should probably be labeled "privacy conscious". Which, as any good AI will teach them, is closely related to the "extremist left" and "anti fascist" labels. Next, you start Youtube or Insta on your Apple device. Now you suddenly see promoted content from those bubbles because you probably want to click on it.
Ad-tech is dangerous.
What like 0.00001% of users would do. That option is useless in practice.
I'd disagree with that. It's like blaming the browser for storing the cookie which Facebook uses to track users across websites.
If Apple would use the IDFA in their own products, then it would be a different story.
IDFA's only purpose is tracking. I can't see any legitimate use for it. In this case Apple intentionally created a feature (which most people aren't even aware of) that only has malicious use-cases.
It is for tracking, but not all tracking is malicious. It is used for things like attributing an ad impression to an app install, to measure how effective an ad campaign is at getting people to install an app. This information doesn't really tell you anything about individual users, but is still useful when aggregated.
> This information doesn't really tell you anything about individual users
Except when you correlate it with other information that does identify individual users and suddenly you've deanonymized this "anonymous" ID.
Scum like Facebook, Google, data brokers and advertising companies base their entire business on this and that needs to stop.
Although the overwhelming majority of people distrust tracking, a significant minority >20% do not. Every time the discussion comes up here we see people who say they like targeted advertising.
Apple wants to exclude other mechanisms and have an opt-in mechanism to support this 20%. They are one step away from making it opt-in but were delayed by political pressure from Facebook.
If Ad Tracking companies improve their practices, perhaps they can persuade more people to opt-in.
Apple has reached this point by slowly eliminating other sources of fingerprinting from their apis, and adding rules insisting that IDFA be the only identifier used.
The only issue here is that IDFA is not yet opt-in. Otherwise, Apple is way ahead of the game. All other platforms allow some kind of fingerprinting.
So in order for it to work you'd need to also be the developer (vendor) of the initial app which displays the advertisement for your second ad? Otherwise how would it work if let's say your ad is displayed in app from vendor A (and they get their own IDFA), now when your (vendor B) app is installed you see a different IDFA. How would you associate the two?
If I understand correctly The IFDA is an identifier created by apple, which they let third parties access. The phone is not a channel, it is the creator of the ID so you're analogy doesn't hold.
And come on, the name of this is proof enough that the only use for this ID is tracking users.
Cookies are used to store anything, not necessarily specific for tracking.
What is it there for then?
If Apple doesn't access the IDFA, but provide the mechanism to do so for others, then clearly Apple is still violating the law.
Apple put the IDFA there. Others accessing it is similar to one website giving you a cookie without consent and other websites looking at that cookie. It's still a violation by the website that gave you the cookie without obtaining your consent.