News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:10PM (#25114127)
The threat is not limited to politicians. Anyone (including you and your family members) could be blackmailed or otherwise publicly embarrassed.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:12PM (#25114165)
> The threat is not limited to politicians. Anyone (including you and your family members) could be blackmailed or otherwise publicly embarrassed.

... for what they actually did.

You think the solution is allowing people to be blackmailed or otherwise publicly embarrassed for things they didn't do, while removing their ability to verify that they didn't do them?

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by daveFNbuck on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:19PM (#25114271)
You're assuming no one has compromised the old keys. If that has happened, a blackmailer can forge old emails with proof of things you didn't do.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mschuster91 on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:36PM (#25114512)
> ... for what they actually did.

Being gay is not a crime, and yet people can be blackmailed with it. It is very easy to open yourself up to blackmail by perfectly legitimate activities.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by ivanhoe on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:16PM (#25115034)
True, there are things that might ruin someone's life even though there's nothing bad about them, but the list of actual crimes and bad things that people do is WAY longer, and being able to prove it is definitely useful...
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by avianlyric on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:33PM (#25115250)
The same argument can be used to build a police state. But I suspect that you’re not in favour that either.

We shouldn’t be building technical systems that “trap” people, just because they might be doing something bad and might want to prove that one day.

Additionally you’re also ignoring the whole “people have the right, to not have their emails stolen” argument. DKIM signatures are only useful if the emails are stolen, are you trying to suggest that it’s ok to steal emails from people if they’re bad?

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by ivanhoe on Monday November 16, 2020 @04:33PM (#25117243)
> Additionally you’re also ignoring the whole “people have the right, to not have their emails stolen” argument

No, just the opposite, that is an excellent argument and I think that the privacy should be the real focus when we discuss the freedom, and not the accountability. Because freedom is not to be able to get away for the lack of evidence, freedom is not to put innocent people in that kind of situation in the first place.

Police state doesn't come from the ability to track citizens, it comes from the lack of transparency and government's misuse of the information. Now, reality is that having more data collecting increases the chances of misuse, but I think we're attacking the problem from the wrong side. Rather than killing the option to track emails, there should be much more control and transparency on when and how that data can be collected and used.

[dead]
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Friday November 20, 2020 @12:18PM (#25162543)
Ok, that's enough and I think we have to ban you again. Pity.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:48PM (#25115419)
> Being gay is not a crime, and yet people can be blackmailed with it. It is very easy to open yourself up to blackmail by perfectly legitimate activities.

Option 1: DKIM keys stay private... "That email was just a joke, I'm not really gay" Option 2: DKIM keys go public... "That email was just someone else's joke, I'm not really gay"

Not really a difference, and with option 2 you can't prove you didn't send it (as far as you can prove someone didn't crack 2048 bit RSA and use that power to concern themselves with your sex life).

Being able to prove a fascist dictator who was killing people for being gay, was secretly engaging in gay acts themselves, might help your cause of protecting gay people.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by morelisp on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:25PM (#25115881)
> Being able to prove a fascist dictator who was killing people for being gay, was secretly engaging in gay acts themselves, might help your cause of protecting gay people.

How?

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:36PM (#25116003)
Because the DKIM keys were not made public, and a message sent from their account could be confirmed to be authentic.

If the keys were public, they could claim forgery. Regardless they could claim their account was hacked, but they couldn't deny the message was sent from their account.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by morelisp on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:44PM (#25116089)
I'm not asking how the technical mechanism proves the messages may be legitimate. I'm asking how you could use that knowledge in the specific situation you outlined to accomplish anything productive.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:00PM (#25118728)
I'm not the person who said outting people as gay was productive. The other person claimed it could be destructive.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by bee_rider on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:47PM (#25115409)
People change over time, and normal human communications have a natural sunset as most people don't remember every conversation in exacting detail. It is worth at least considering the fact that we've signed up to have basically all our communications preserved and cryptographically signed in perpetuity. Most people using these services didn't fully weigh the options.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by blendergeek on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:14PM (#25114200)
No. Once DKIM keys are published, one can simply deny all emails published "from their account". We currently have a way for an attacker to prove an email's origin years after the fact.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:30PM (#25115213)
Yes. We are saying the same thing.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:22PM (#25114301)
You're misunderstanding how this works.

You can't be blackmailed by someone who has no plausible evidence.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by drdaeman on Monday November 16, 2020 @11:33PM (#25120286)
I'm afraid there's also a misunderstanding how the real world works. Cryptographic and real-world plausibility are two entirely different things.

People get blackmailed, shamed, hurt and even killed over mere rumors, speculations and suspicions. As long as people believe in something (because something merely look plausible), there's no need for a fancy crypto to prove some machine sent some email. I'd dare to say most people don't even understand what cryptography is and what digital signatures really are (who signs what and what exactly this means).

I'm yet to hear a story of, let's say, a brave dissident who got out of jail because of cryptographic plausible deniability property making their oppressors unable to prove authenticity of some leaked or intercepted correspondence.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @12:34PM (#25126646)
Read up on the Hunter Biden emails. After a DKIM signature was verified, the perception of a large number of people (including right here on HN) went from "this cache of email is probably total fiction" to "they likely do have access to at least some of his emails".
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:37PM (#25115292)
They don’t have plausible evidence anyway. Gmail has had bugs before with SPF/DKIM and will have some again for sure.

Some google employees have direct and indirect access to signing keys or writing emails. Not many, and they have good controls, but still many people with the ability to sign messages.

Not to mention a Trojan infiltration or account takeover, of which thousands (if not millions) a day occur.

The DKIM evidence is, for legal purposes, a good hint but far from proof.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:45PM (#25115392)
In the court of public opinion, the standard is not "100% proven beyond any reasonable doubt". Hence, blackmail can still be very effective if an accusation is highly plausible.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:01PM (#25115577)
Yes, but it’s not DKIM or not DKIM that will make it plausible in the court of public opinion.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:18PM (#25115799)
Current events prove otherwise. See Hunter Biden.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @05:04PM (#25117598)
I have not seen a single mention of DKIM w.r.t to Hunter Biden. Did you? Was any evidence presented? I couldn’t find any.

I fail to see how admissibility or lack of it, in a court of law or of public opinion, has anything to do with DKIM+Hunter Biden. Can you elaborate?

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by legolas2412 on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:18PM (#25118351)
I saw this news (https://www.washingtonexaminer.com/news/cybersecurity-expert...) a few days before the election. There is also a github repo.

I am not sure why the DKIM for all emails were not released, or why this did not catch more media coverage by other news organizations I consider more reliable (like NYT).

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:29PM (#25118438)
Thank you for this link, this did not come across my radar.

From your link:

> The only way the email could have been faked is if someone hacked into Google's servers, found the private key, and used it to reverse engineer the email's DKIM signature, Graham, said.

https://www.zdnet.com/article/google-fixes-major-gmail-bug-s... is from Aug 2020 and discusses an SPF/DMARC vulnerability that was in Google since forever (and though reported 4 months before public disclosure, was fixed only 7 hours after public disclosure). The last google DKIM bug I'm aware of was in 2012, so I can't counter the specific claim about DKIM with evidence, but the assertion that "the only way to spoof x is to hack and get the private key" is not any absolute truth.

(P.S: I have seen no denial nor confirmation about the authenticity of the Hunter Biden data - only claims of Russian involvement. Make of that what you will. The DKIM is circumstantial data until there is confirmation or denial - especially, as you say, it's not all released).

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by legolas2412 on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:42PM (#25118576)
Sure, you raise very important points. I just found it weird that NYPost was happy just releasing the emails and not the DKIM, and when one was validated, it received literally no coverage. I thought it might catch steam after the election, but the literal silence is surprising to me.

I am not insinuating any wrongdoing from anyone, just bringing it to your attention, as you claimed to not know about it.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:00PM (#25118726)
Thank you. I indeed did not know about it. I do try to read all sides, but this did not come on my radar (Though I did not, before you posted this, google DKIM+Biden, I did read tens of articles about those emails mostly from republican leaning outlets, and it wasn't mentioned in any of those I read).

But it does support my thesis that DKIM or no DKIM is not what gives (or doesn't give) any credence to the authenticity (or lack of it) -- here we have a high profile case, with DKIM validation (which a lot of people on this thread cleim "is considered proof by people who don't understand it") and it seems to make no difference even in the court of public opinion - those who accepted it, accpeted it without DKIM, and those who rejected it as russian disinformation, rejected it even with DKIM.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @06:54PM (#25118666)
>I have not seen a single mention of DKIM w.r.t to Hunter Biden. Did you? Was any evidence presented? I couldn’t find any.

You really couldn't find any? Come on. Did you Google "DKIM Biden"?

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by beagle3 on Monday November 16, 2020 @07:06PM (#25118786)
I just did, and I have less than 15 related results in the first 4 pages, only two of which are sources I've ever heard of before (washingtonexaminer and nypost). I'm logged out of google, but it's been a while since I deleted my cookies.

I've read literally hundreds of pieces on the hunter biden laptop, about half of them from republican leaning outlets, (I try to keep a balanced diet....) and none of them mentioned DKIM validation.

(For the record: I don't live in the US, I don't watch television, but I do try to keep a balanced news diet)

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:41PM (#25115324)
You're misunderstanding how destruction of evidence works.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @01:50PM (#25115449)
Huh? No one (including yourself), have mentioned anything about "destruction of evidence" so far. If you care to enlighten me about how it's relevant I'm happy to listen.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:00PM (#25115573)
By making the DKIM keys public, you are converting solid evidence of something that was said into something that was either really said, or someone else pretended that they said.

Evidence was destroyed.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by Natanael_L on Tuesday November 17, 2020 @06:21AM (#25122445)
No, destruction of evidence involves things like making something impossible to analyze and evaluate. Publication of a key doesn't erase the original messages and does not make it impossible to look into their contents to try to establish authencity by external means. Causing ambiguity is not destruction of evidence.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:07AM (#25157729)
What do you call it when someone pees into someone else's pee sample?
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by Natanael_L on Friday November 20, 2020 @04:32PM (#25165250)
That would be an act of submitting false evidence, where you actively make a false claim regarding who the sample belongs to.

Which is very distinctly different from a passive act of not maintaining evidence of the origin of every single thing. Keep in mind that no data is altered - the equivalent of all collected samples remaining intact.

It's still just as possible to collect email logs, their contents do not magically dissappear. They would have to be actively manipulated by the party which holds the copy that would be provided to the police (either reported to them or confiscated, etc). That same party could already decide to delete the emails or strip signatures and then alter them.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:21PM (#25115834)
This describes all encrypted and short lived messages.

Edit: Removed the word "literally" because it was incorrect and caused distraction from the actual argument.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Monday November 16, 2020 @02:33PM (#25115985)
It doesn't at all. You're misunderstanding. Or, are you using the word "literally" in the modern sense of "not literally"?
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
[dead]
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Thursday November 19, 2020 @01:49PM (#25152917)
Yikes! Posting like this (and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25133743) will get you banned on HN. We're trying for the other end of the swimming pool here. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site to heart, we'd be grateful.

Edit: comments like https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25066116 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25118713 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25067189 also break the site guidelines quite badly.

Would you mind taking a look at this explanation I posted a couple days ago? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25130956 It is my attempt to explain why we don't want users to flame each other here, even when the other person is ignorant or wrong. The reason may be different than you think, in which case perhaps it will have some persuasive power for you. I hope so anyhow.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Thursday November 19, 2020 @03:41PM (#25154098)
You're absolutely right... the other person was ignorant and wrong.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Thursday November 19, 2020 @07:07PM (#25155959)
It's not a valid reason to break HN's rules.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Thursday November 19, 2020 @07:37PM (#25156153)
Still ignorant and wrong tho...
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Thursday November 19, 2020 @11:07PM (#25157217)
That could certainly be. But why not use HN in the intended spirit? It would be better for everyone, you included.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by mthoms on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:00PM (#25163019)
>even when the other person is ignorant or wrong

>It's not a valid reason to break HN's rules.

>That could certainly be.

>But there are many different ways to stick up for the truth

Whoa. Dang, I have to say, I feel a little slighted. I'm neither ignorant, nor wrong, and I'm aghast that you would insinuate that.

I've contributed faithfully to this site for a decade. The other commenter has -15 karma because, as you noticed, his comments are largely childish, combative and unsubstantive. It's embarrassing that you are validating him.

His claim was that Google publishing DKIM keys as described in the article would be "destruction of evidence", but that's provably untrue since there would be neither intent or willfull neglect on anyones part.

Literally (yes, I mean literally) no-one else here on HN, or anywhere on the internet, has legitimately attempted to argue this. It just doesn't hold up to basic scrutiny. "Destruction of evidence" is a very specific legal term with very specific meaning [0][1][2]. He seems to be distorting it in a Guilianni-esque fashion - "It's fraud! ....But no, your honor, not in the legal sense. More like in my own made-up imaginary sense!".

I've been restrained and as courteous as possible (under the circumstances), but even after you tried to squash the thread, and I stopped commenting, he's continued to insult me. You seem to be tolerating it.

I would have appreciated it if you enforced sanctions against obviously bad actors and remained completely neutral. That is what you're known for, but I respectful think you've failed in this case. At any rate, I know you have just about the hardest job on the internet, so I'll go ahead and chalk this up to misunderstanding.

[0] https://definitions.uslegal.com/d/destruction-of-evidence/ [1] https://www.criminaldefenselawyer.com/crime-penalties/federa... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spoliation_of_evidence

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Sunday November 22, 2020 @01:36PM (#25179754)
None of those phrases imply that you were ignorant or wrong. They're simply saying that even if the other person is correct in their position, it doesn't justify breaking the site guidelines.

This is a way of pre-empting the objection "But the other person is wrong and I'm right", which otherwise is the most common reaction to getting moderated. Since the moderation issue is about how people treat each other rather than how right or wrong they are, it's helpful to take it off the table in this way. If you think about it, it's a way of raising the bar for behavior on HN and in that respect is a stronger moderation reaction, not a weaker one.

I am careful, when using such phrases, never to actually take a side on the issue of rightness or wrongness. Remember that in every argument, the other person considers that they are the one who is right; moderating like this is a way of temporarily standing beside them from that perspective and pointing out that nevertheless, they should not have broken the rules. (An exception might be if I happen to personally know the truth about the point under dispute. But I know nothing about DKIM; I barely remember what it is.)

If you skim through https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... you'll see that I use this approach all the time when trying to get people to follow the rules. It's true that I tried harder in this case than I usually do. That's for reasons which are out of scope of this thread, and had nothing to do with tolerating bad behavior (see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25162543).

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:11AM (#25157745)
I wouldn't want to be a part of anything that denied the truth in favor of civility.

Dang, I thought you would have understood that.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by dang on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:20AM (#25157774)
But there are many different ways to stick up for the truth, and some have positive side effects and some not—hammering people over the head, for example. The side effects are actually more important.

If you'd be willing to take a look at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25130956, I'd be curious to hear your reaction.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hashtagmarkup on Friday November 20, 2020 @01:30AM (#25157814)
After 5 replies, there isn't much room for logic. Trolls gonna troll... you should consider that.

I can help. Fly out, I got a guest room. I guarantee you won't regret it.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by cortesoft on Monday November 16, 2020 @09:22PM (#25119643)
> for what they actually did

All blackmail involves things a person actually did... otherwise it would be libel or slander.

You seem to be arguing that blackmail shouldn't be illegal.

Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by whimsicalism on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:25PM (#25114354)
I propose gouging out everyone's eyes, that way they can't see you do anything potentially embarrassing - thus making blackmail harder.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by hyperpape on Monday November 16, 2020 @12:30PM (#25114422)
This is a helpful comment because not having DKIM is in the same range of bad outcomes as having your eyes gouged out.
Re:Ok Google: please publish your DKIM secret keys by couchand on Monday November 16, 2020 @10:15PM (#25119929)
Except the proposal weakens legitimate use of DKIM not one whit.