News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by bzb6 on Saturday November 14, 2020 @12:18PM (#25093717)
I.e. you want this article to be clickbait and now you are unhappy that it is not.
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by kordlessagain on Saturday November 14, 2020 @12:41PM (#25093916)
Way to speak for another person's intentions AND feelings! That's where we are nowadays, I guess.

It's their article, I think it's fair they ask for the name of the post to be preserved. It has nothing to do with their intent (clickbait or not) that the audience here voted up their submission.

Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by cmroanirgo on Saturday November 14, 2020 @01:33PM (#25094400)
> I used Google's name in the title because that name elicits reaction from almost 100% of the audience,

And

>Changing the title from "Google" to "Third Party Auth" significantly softens the impact and urgency I want the reader to feel upon reading the title,

It sounds rather like parent was correct in calling it click bait. For me, any article that has aspirations to manipulating ones emotions in order to illicit a particular outcome is definitely selling some propagandist notion... Aka click bait.

That the article's content, HN submission and the parent comment is the same person @gurjeet, I would like to thank @dang for the modification.

Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by grayhatter on Saturday November 14, 2020 @05:01PM (#25096042)
But that's not what clickbait is. Clickbait is a title that quickly imposes the feeling of missing and important information. Especially to get people to click through so the link target can serve ads. That's clearly not OPs goal as he makes the title a call to action, omitting no critical information.

Propaganda has nothing to do with the definition of clickbait, so saying "[propaganda ...] Aka click bait." Is very misleading. And betrays your argument that everything should be exclusively logic, specifically omitting any appeal to emotion. That's exactly what you're trying to do by portraying op as using propaganda. And rhetorically speaking would be a disservice to both reader and article.

Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by grayhatter on Saturday November 14, 2020 @01:39PM (#25094456)
No, clickbait would be: This guy used Google to login, you'll never guess what happens next!!

He wants to us the name Google to personalize the message assuming that's what a lot of people use. Do you know how I figured that out? That's what OP said was his goal. It's rude to assert otherwise without evidence.

Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by texasbigdata on Saturday November 14, 2020 @02:33PM (#25094935)
“I opted out of a Yubi key, forgot my Yahoo password, didn’t have the authenticator set up, couldn’t text message myself, and wasted 3 days fixing it” could maybe fit as a title too.
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by gurjeet on Saturday November 14, 2020 @12:27PM (#25093798)
I want the title to reflect what prompted this article in the first place. Just as others are calling out, I noticed those Google login boxes on unrelated websites. I want the reader to also make that connection and then read the article to understand what’s at stake.
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by baby on Saturday November 14, 2020 @12:31PM (#25093842)
All titles are clickbait, researchers, bloggers, youtuber, conference speakers, and journalists who succeed are also ones who know how to choose good titles
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by kowlo on Saturday November 14, 2020 @12:56PM (#25094066)
Not all titles are clickbait, and even if the majority are, we should strive for better
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by patmorgan23 on Saturday November 14, 2020 @01:29PM (#25094364)
Clickbait is a spectrum not a binary. I think keeping google in the title doesn't detract from conveying what the article is about while at the same time making it more attractive.
Re:Don't use third party auth to sign in by gurjeet on Saturday November 14, 2020 @02:06PM (#25094702)
Definition of clickbait [1] (emphasis mine): something (such as a headline) designed to make readers want to click on a hyperlink especially when the link leads to content of dubious value or interest.

The title of the article matches the content, so, no, it wasn't a clickbait. Also, if the title was really a clickbait, someone would have surely called it out before my gripe about the title change. In fact, 2 others complained about the title change before I posted my top-level comment; those others' complaints and my responses are now buried under the "More" link at the end of this page.

I understand you, @baby, have good intentions, but I take offense to @bzb6's remarks. I guess that's what I get for responding to a recently created account (41 days ago) with no posts and all of whose comments are one-liners; mostly knee-jerk reactions, no insights, and not considering the nuances of the real-world implications.

[1]: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/clickbait