News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by torbentorsten on Friday November 13, 2020 @03:33AM (#25080309)
Just to quickly help the Streisand effect, this is the private key, extracted from [1]:

-----BEGIN PRIVATE KEY----- MIIEvQIBADANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAASCBKcwggSjAgEAAoIBAQC10dxEGINZbF0nIoMtM8705Nqm6ZWdb72DqTdFJ+UzQIRIUS59lQkYLvdQp71767vz0dVlPTikHmiv dYHRc7Fo6JsmSUsGR3th+fU6d1Wt6cwpMTUXj/qODmubDK/ioVDW7wz9OFlSsCBvylOYp9v2+u/VXwACnBXNxCDezjx4RKcqMFT31WTxqU9OM9J86ChMOW4bFA41aLAJ ozB+02xis7OV175XdQ5vkVXM9ys6ZoRF/K6NXeHiwcZFtMKyphXAxqU7uGY2a16bC3TEG5/km6Jru3Wxy4nKlDyUjWISwH4llWjdSi99r2c1fSCXlMCrW0CHoznn+22l YCKtYe8JAgMBAAECggEAGOPDJvFCHd43PFG9qlTyylR/2CSWzigLRfhGsClfd24oDaxLVHav+YcIZRqpVkr1flGlyEeittjQ1OAdptoTGbzp7EpRQmlLqyRoHRpT+MxO Hf91+KVFk+fGdEG+3CPgKKQt34Y0uByTPCpy2i10b7F3Xnq0Sicq1vG33DhYT9A/DRIjYr8Y0AVovq0VDjWqA1FW5OO9p7vky6e+PDMjSHucQ+uaLzVZSc7vWOh0tH5M 0GVk17YpBiB/iTpw4zBUIcaneQX3eaIfSCDHK0SCD6IRF7kl+uORzvWqiWlGzpdG2B96uyP4hd3WoPcZntM79PKm4dAotdgmalbueFJfpwKBgQDUy0EyA9Fq0aPF4LID HqDPduIm4hEAZf6sQLd8Fe6ywM4p9KOEVx7YPaFxQHFSgIiWXswildPJl8Cg5cM2EyMU1tdn5xaR4VIDk8e2JEDfhPtaWskpJp2rU2wHvAXOeAES7UFMrkhKVqqVOdbo IhlLdcYp5KxiJ3mwINSSO94ShwKBgQDavJvF+c8AINfCaMocUX0knXz+xCwdP430GoPQCHa1rUj5bZ3qn3XMwSWa57J4x3pVhYmgJv4jpEK+LBULFezNLV5N4C7vH63a Zo4OF7IUedFBS5B508yAq7RiPhN2VOC8LRdDh5oqnFufjafF82y9d+/czCrVIG43D+KO2j4F7wKBgDg/HZWF0tYEYeDNGuCeOO19xBt5B/tt+lo3pQhkl7qiIhyO8KXr jVilOcZAvXOMTA5LMnQ13ExeE2m0MdxaRJyeiUOKnrmisFYHuvNXM9qhQPtKIgABmA2QOG728SX5LHd/RRJqwur7a42UQ00Krlr235F1Q2eSfaTjmKyqrHGDAoGAOTrd 2ueoZFUzfnciYlRj1L+r45B6JlDpmDOTx0tfm9sx26j1h1yfWqoyZ5w1kupGNLgSsSdimPqyR8WK3/KlmW1EXkXIoeH8/8aTZlaGzlqtCFN4ApgKyqOiN44cU3qTrkhx 7MY+7OUqB83tVpqBGfWWeYOltUud6qQqV8v8LFsCgYEAnOq+Ls83CaHIWCjpVfiWC+R7mqW+ql1OGtoaajtA4AzhXzX8HIXpYjupPBlXlQ1FFfPem6jwa1UTZf8CpIb8 pPULAN9ZRrxG8V+bvkZWVREPTZj7xPCwPaZHNKoAmi3Dbv7S5SEYDbBX/NyPCLE4sj/AgTPbUsUtaiw5TvrPsFE= -----END PRIVATE KEY-----

[1] https://archive.softwareheritage.org/browse/origin/content/?...

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by qwerty456127 on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:29AM (#25081473)
I can hardly understand the motivation of the corporations keeping to invest in DRM and software activation bullshit tech despite it's obvious it is going to be cracked inevitably (and quickly).
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by seirl on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:33AM (#25081485)
The goal of DRM is and always have been to lock users inside a platform, not to prevent piracy. It gives companies market power because users cannot easily switch to a better alternative without losing their entire digital collection.

https://www.defectivebydesign.org/faq#copyright

> DRM is not about limiting copyright infringement. Such an argument attempts to make DRM appear beneficial to authors and is based entirely on a (very successfully advertised) misrepresentation of DRM's purpose. To illustrate the absurdity of the argument, consider the nature of file sharing: to obtain a copy of a file without permission, downloaders go to a friend or a file sharing network, not a DRM-encumbered distribution platform. If DRM existed only to prevent unauthorized sharing, every distribution method for that particular piece of media would have to be distributed by an uncrackable DRM-encumbered distribution platform, which is impossible on its own. So long as one copy becomes available without DRM, countless more are easily produced. Industry proponents of DRM are well aware that DRM is not a copyright enforcement mechanism. DRM is only marketed as a copyright enforcement mechanism to mislead authors into tolerating and even defending it.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by autoexec on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:07AM (#25081739)
> The goal of DRM is and always have been to lock users inside a platform,

In that case it fails to accomplish that goal for the same reason. It doesn't work and will be defeated. When you download a song, or movie, or ebook that has been stripped of its DRM you aren't tied to anything. Why introduce unnecessary annoyances for paying customers which often drives them to pirate copies that aren't crippled by DRM? As long as something works like they want it to, most people wont care what platform they use to get it.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by qwerty456127 on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:43AM (#25082022)
> As long as something works like they want it to, most people wont care what platform they use to get it.

For almost anything, there are (at least in big cities and in the Internet) many vendors offering nearly the same with nearly the same quality level at nearly the same prices.

But I can't say I don't care whom do I get the same service thing every particular time. I'm more likely to choose whoever feels more nice and offers even slightly more freedom and flexibility. Once I've chosen a vendor I'm much more likely to stick with them (and choose them every time I need something else they can offer) as long as I don't feel severely dissatisfied.

E.g. once I've got a GMail (GMail is and has always been the very best e-mail service anyway, you can hardly be dissatisfied with it) account I would use everything Google if only they didn't piss me off politically (with stiff like this particular discussion subject) and scare me by terminating other's peoples accounts. But I actually am migrating everything I can away from Google and Gmail because Google seems becoming more and more evil (I even suspect RIAA only attacked ytdl after Google told them to).

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by autoexec on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:58AM (#25082154)
That's fair, I think most people will stick with whatever easiest.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by theduder99 on Friday November 13, 2020 @09:19AM (#25082357)
Up until some line gets crossed (like Op). The definition of the line is subjective for each user.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by MKinley on Friday November 13, 2020 @09:54AM (#25082809)
Very good point, and I would add that line can be moved based on individual circumstances. I've seen people complain about issues with a service, but the moment I offer an alternative and a way to migrate (painlessly for me to do, and I typically offer to help them) suddenly all is good with their service and they're sticking with it. I've even pushed a little further in the past to say I will do ALL of the work for you, just sit back and relax and in a couple hours done. Most still refuse and I don't get why once all barriers have been removed.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jart on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:38AM (#25081526)
Maybe because it was a hush hush compromise intended to make it possible rather than impossible to watch netflix on linux at slightly reduced quality. Windows and Mac PCs with closed source browser would watch at full quality due to hardware drm. No one was motivated until now it seems to blow the lid off the weaker libre drm since a likely outcome is it just get turned off and services require hardware drm only going forward. We'll be lucky if we can still play videos on Linux or Chromium one year from now.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by vladvasiliu on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:10AM (#25081766)
I wonder whether the situation will improve now that Firefox has support for hardware decoding on Linux. After all, the DRM could be completely handled by the GPU without any help from the driver. Just feed it some binary stream and tell it where to put it.

Although the issue with your compromise theory is that not all browsers are supported for high definition even on MacOS or Windows, at least theoretically (don't have a Netflix account to check). In particular, Chrome isn't supported, although Chrome-based Edge is.

From the Netflix help page on watching UHD [0]:

    Netflix is available in Ultra HD on Windows and Mac computers with:
      Microsoft Edge for Windows
      Windows 10 App
      Safari for MacOS 11.0 or later
From the Netflix help page on watching on Windows [1]:

    Windows computers support streaming in the following browser resolutions:
      Google Chrome up to 720p
      Internet Explorer up to 1080p
      Microsoft Edge up to 4K*
      Mozilla Firefox up to 720p
      Opera up to 720p
      Windows 8 app up to 1080p
      Windows 10 app up to 4K*
The situation is similar on MacOS, where only Safari supports 1080p [2]

[0] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/13444 [1] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/23931 [2] https://help.netflix.com/en/node/55764

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by swiley on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:51AM (#25082080)
If I can't watch movies on Linux I'll just skip watching them or torrent them. I already hate dealing with running an OSX vm just to IM my parents, and without hardware acceleration I doubt video decoding would work anyway.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by DrBazza on Friday November 13, 2020 @09:03AM (#25082191)
Has that Cinavia nonsense been cracked though? It's the reason I haven't knowingly bought anything Sony in the last decade.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by vmp on Friday November 13, 2020 @06:13AM (#25081140)
If I made a facemask with that printed on it (as a QR code or whatever) would google stop trying to identify my face? Or would that paint a huge red target on my face?
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jlgaddis on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:16AM (#25081427)
Some HN'ers might be too young to remember the DeCSS [0] saga and, in particular, the t-shirts.

The EFF, who successfully represented two defendants accused of publishing the DeCSS source code in the two main cases, has the details [1]:

> In Bunner, the [ DVD Copy Control Association ] summarily dismissed its claims after the California Supreme Court ruled that computer programs could be preliminarily restrained from publication only in very narrow circumstances. The California Court of Appeals ruled that those circumstances were not met in Mr. Bunner's case because the program was not a trade secret at the time it was published, but instead was widely available around the world.

> In Pavlovich, the California Supreme Court ruled that Matthew Pavlovich, a Texas resident who published DeCSS on the Internet, could not be forced to stand trial in California. The landmark decision laid out clear jurisdiction rules for claims arising from publishing information on the Internet. DVD CCA's attempt to seek U.S. Supreme Court review of the decision was also rejected.

Additionally, the one known author of DeCSS was acquitted in a criminal trial in Norway.

Obligatory EFF donation link: https://supporters.eff.org/donate/

--

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DeCSS

[1]: https://www.eff.org/cases/dvdcca-v-bunner-and-dvdcca-v-pavlo...

--

EDIT: See also "AACS encryption key controversy" and the "free speech flag": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AACS_encryption_key_controvers...

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by justinclift on Friday November 13, 2020 @06:33AM (#25081240)
Probably a good idea to also incorporate that into some very-clearly-satire related artwork on the mask, to help with the legality. :)
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jeroenhd on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:43AM (#25082023)
WideVine has support for revoking private keys if they get leaked, which duped a bunch of smart TV customers before. I'm pretty sure the key is useless already, or will be very soon. Google can just roll new keys whenever the old ones get published through their Chrome update mechanisms.
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by pantalaimon on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:52AM (#25082095)
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by eecc on Friday November 13, 2020 @04:42AM (#25080688)
What would Google do if I emailed it to my own gmail account?

Delete the email? Ban me?

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by pas on Friday November 13, 2020 @04:52AM (#25080740)
Sure, why not both?

They deleted/locked accounts for less during the G+ real name frenzy.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by scott31 on Friday November 13, 2020 @04:52AM (#25080737)
I emailed you the key, please report if you are banned so we can all learn the answer
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by qwertox on Friday November 13, 2020 @05:17AM (#25080865)
"As per our phone conversation, ..."
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by kaszanka on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:52AM (#25082091)
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by djxfade on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:37AM (#25081517)
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jlgaddis on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:55AM (#25081643)
Geez, man! At least format it correctly so folks can copy and paste! :-)

  -----BEGIN PRIVATE KEY-----
  MIIEvQIBADANBgkqhkiG9w0BAQEFAASCBKcwggSjAgEAAoIBAQC10dxEGINZbF0nIoMtM870
  5Nqm6ZWdb72DqTdFJ+UzQIRIUS59lQkYLvdQp71767vz0dVlPTikHmivdYHRc7Fo6JsmSUsG
  R3th+fU6d1Wt6cwpMTUXj/qODmubDK/ioVDW7wz9OFlSsCBvylOYp9v2+u/VXwACnBXNxCDe
  zjx4RKcqMFT31WTxqU9OM9J86ChMOW4bFA41aLAJozB+02xis7OV175XdQ5vkVXM9ys6ZoRF
  /K6NXeHiwcZFtMKyphXAxqU7uGY2a16bC3TEG5/km6Jru3Wxy4nKlDyUjWISwH4llWjdSi99
  r2c1fSCXlMCrW0CHoznn+22lYCKtYe8JAgMBAAECggEAGOPDJvFCHd43PFG9qlTyylR/2CSW
  zigLRfhGsClfd24oDaxLVHav+YcIZRqpVkr1flGlyEeittjQ1OAdptoTGbzp7EpRQmlLqyRo
  HRpT+MxOHf91+KVFk+fGdEG+3CPgKKQt34Y0uByTPCpy2i10b7F3Xnq0Sicq1vG33DhYT9A/
  DRIjYr8Y0AVovq0VDjWqA1FW5OO9p7vky6e+PDMjSHucQ+uaLzVZSc7vWOh0tH5M0GVk17Yp
  BiB/iTpw4zBUIcaneQX3eaIfSCDHK0SCD6IRF7kl+uORzvWqiWlGzpdG2B96uyP4hd3WoPcZ
  ntM79PKm4dAotdgmalbueFJfpwKBgQDUy0EyA9Fq0aPF4LIDHqDPduIm4hEAZf6sQLd8Fe6y
  wM4p9KOEVx7YPaFxQHFSgIiWXswildPJl8Cg5cM2EyMU1tdn5xaR4VIDk8e2JEDfhPtaWskp
  Jp2rU2wHvAXOeAES7UFMrkhKVqqVOdboIhlLdcYp5KxiJ3mwINSSO94ShwKBgQDavJvF+c8A
  INfCaMocUX0knXz+xCwdP430GoPQCHa1rUj5bZ3qn3XMwSWa57J4x3pVhYmgJv4jpEK+LBUL
  FezNLV5N4C7vH63aZo4OF7IUedFBS5B508yAq7RiPhN2VOC8LRdDh5oqnFufjafF82y9d+/c
  zCrVIG43D+KO2j4F7wKBgDg/HZWF0tYEYeDNGuCeOO19xBt5B/tt+lo3pQhkl7qiIhyO8KXr
  jVilOcZAvXOMTA5LMnQ13ExeE2m0MdxaRJyeiUOKnrmisFYHuvNXM9qhQPtKIgABmA2QOG72
  8SX5LHd/RRJqwur7a42UQ00Krlr235F1Q2eSfaTjmKyqrHGDAoGAOTrd2ueoZFUzfnciYlRj
  1L+r45B6JlDpmDOTx0tfm9sx26j1h1yfWqoyZ5w1kupGNLgSsSdimPqyR8WK3/KlmW1EXkXI
  oeH8/8aTZlaGzlqtCFN4ApgKyqOiN44cU3qTrkhx7MY+7OUqB83tVpqBGfWWeYOltUud6qQq
  V8v8LFsCgYEAnOq+Ls83CaHIWCjpVfiWC+R7mqW+ql1OGtoaajtA4AzhXzX8HIXpYjupPBlX
  lQ1FFfPem6jwa1UTZf8CpIb8pPULAN9ZRrxG8V+bvkZWVREPTZj7xPCwPaZHNKoAmi3Dbv7S
  5SEYDbBX/NyPCLE4sj/AgTPbUsUtaiw5TvrPsFE=
  -----END PRIVATE KEY-----
Or, just provide the various components:

  p = 49429002897777261000839566786960900348661596779839481928152034285352681641807686782292757653824830822496391192085567895071852258385592280527115222429444042313542936301974046594875899181233742229945549738766655661560628018266563543784515148821370566306893780280151659623161213410927305309695027848755504091783

  q = 53602170802863928289500972217307025477290164757146419371852251620670300136901587204821451746991406880988053571342615187459978423766579984968561470104139545987787266751875098417999761783952366342302556060906681062460952347680147798276356366502237505269309185857430061068092584194979239221868593482021566547439

  n = 2952619226006031733278005132921693726100042011592660779869675820212138145939883834312253789060663461194528411412874982355146048292836507534000115353036163880492136645451564382009196182566124637478277389304691251397819894417106558057773147299342857185830516918343274468842497499522414750028740163342718036209925403503207235945059541974923084211147227388348091101183403929204074586611952779802158116643840147678791643283706927948872797793849591629882391903699724329001797545580009544763555067611040895630150211640906898700482769873702547829023169433411394249565049633221004211830736052381384491512655254513796679593737

  d = 142033101700003260678755863863267700134374886049156296238778043258513471417667391237505300342672722921505586813412391537592394712287451780540489111338082979901966887630936873112829448279475520471433931949082770983040743133849146064289054900225131501940560027662491217132619227565578893295128589581903273904124801461070363532834633728769178636552784294153467969250254358604276515140477045217505629092433114246051368410587618590542410950189868285511930901887132942539241081579465767831350539339965000260768249119651905050152151634478714116343168832447694793716937575319879226685046081583200335708696821445923072794535

  e = 65537
Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by m-p-3 on Friday November 13, 2020 @09:47AM (#25082719)
Thanks! Also shared on Aether (getaether.net) just in case

Disclaimer: I am not affiliated with the Aether software/platform.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by swiley on Friday November 13, 2020 @08:49AM (#25082069)
Wait why does it need a private key that's pushed to everyone's device? How does that actually secure anything?

I skimmed the code but I'm still not seeing it.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jagged-chisel on Friday November 13, 2020 @09:47AM (#25082718)
Technically: one must have the private key to perform decryption. There are many schemes that attempt to protect the original key and derive a decryption key, or do various other things to prevent disclosure of the private side of a key pair.

Practically: the point is not to "secure" anything, but to make it obvious that any infringement is due to "circumventing a protection device." Circumvention is also not allowed under DMCA, because it was obvious to the authors of the law that to view content one must indeed decrypt it.

Re:Google Widevine Content Decryption Module DMCA by jeffrallen on Friday November 13, 2020 @07:41AM (#25081550)